Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Upper West Side (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Upper West Side (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

472 Views

I’ve been all over the world to sample pizza, and now it’s time to share my expert opinion on the best places for slices in Upper West Side. After careful analysis of 12 different pizza joints in this area, I have come up with a list that will make an Italian foodie proud!

Upper West Side is home to some serious pizza-lovers and I am ready to order some slices and find out which pizzeria deserves the crown of best pizza. Follow me on this tasty journey of discovery as I determine one grand winner from the selection of delicious contenders.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Bosino

I’ve been to Bosino several times now, and each time I go the pizza is cooked to perfection. The crust is always crisp yet chewy, and the toppings are flavorful and savory. The service at Bosino is also top notch. Everyone I encountered during my visit was knowledgeable about their menu offerings and eager to answer any questions I had.

But what really sets Bosino apart is its atmosphere! This small pizza joint has a warm, inviting vibe that can’t be replicated anywhere else. Whether you’re enjoying an intimate dinner for two or celebrating with friends over a big pizza pie, everyone will have a great time at Bosino.

If you’re in Upper West Side and looking for some of the best pizza around, look no further than Bosino!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in New York!

#2 Made In New York Pizza

As soon as you walk in, you’re hit with the smell of fresh baked dough, oozing with melted cheese and your favorite toppings. The staff greets you like an old friend, and they know how to make a great pie.

The pizza itself is cooked perfectly every time. The crust is light and airy, while still being able to hold the weight of all the delicious toppings. The sauce is flavorful and the cheese…oh the cheese! It’s my favorite part! It’s both creamy and full-flavored.

I can honestly say I’ve never tasted better pizza in Upper West Side than at Made In New York Pizza. Sure, there are other places that claim to be the best, but none compare to this spot. So if you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza around town, look no further than Made In New York Pizza!

#3 Ortomare

I walked in the door of Ortomare expecting something decent, but when I saw the pizza ovens and smelled the delicious aroma emanating from them, I knew I was in for a treat. Upon ordering a margarita pizza, I was presented with one of the finest pizzas I have ever seen – perfect cheese coverage without being too greasy, fresh basil and just enough tomato sauce to not make it a soggy mess.

I thought my experience couldn’t get any better until the waiter brought out these tiny bottles of champagne! It turns out that Ortomare has an amazing selection of sparkling wines that pair perfectly with their pizza. After washing down my slice (or two) with bubbles, I can honestly say this place is my new favorite pizza joint in Upper West Side.

If you’re looking for some seriously good pizza, definitely check out Ortomare! You will not be disappointed.

#4 Fumo Upper West Side

The atmosphere of this restaurant is fantastic. It’s cozy and inviting, but also modern and trendy. The service was also top-notch. All the servers were extremely friendly and attentive, which made for a great dining experience.

But the real star of the show at Fumo Upper West Side is, of course, the food! Their pizza was absolutely delicious! Their dough is light and fluffy, with just enough char on the bottom to give it some crunch. The toppings were super flavorful and the cheese melted perfectly. And the portions were generous, so I never felt like I had to skimp on anything.

Overall, I would definitely recommend Fumo Upper West Side if you’re looking for great pizza in Upper West Side. The atmosphere, service and food make it an amazing spot to hang out with friends or family over a slice (or two!).

#5 Sal and Carmine Pizza

From the moment I stepped in, the warm and inviting atmosphere was undeniable. The sounds of happy customers enjoying some of the best pizza around filled the room with joy.

The menu had so many amazing options, it was hard to choose just one! Thankfully, Sal and Carmine sell by-the-slice which gave me the freedom to sample a few flavors that day.

First up was their classic Margherita slice. It was cooked to perfection – the crust light and crispy, while still being soft enough to easily bite into. The tomato sauce was sweet and tangy with just enough cheese between each layer of dough. It all came together perfectly!

Second, I tried their Spinach & Mushroom Pizza slice. The combination of these two flavors was stunning! As soon as I bit into it, my taste buds were in awe! This flavor combination is something I’ve never seen before and certainly something that won’t soon be forgotten!

To top it off, Sal and Carmine Pizza also offers unique desserts like fresh mini cannolis that are truly a treat for the tastebuds!

Overall, Sal and Carmine Pizza is definitely one of the best pizzerias in Upper West Side! If you’re looking for great tasting food at even better prices – this place is worth checking out. And if you can’t decide on a slice – go for both. You won’t regret it!

#6 Freddie & Pepper’s

I walked in, and the aromas of tomato sauce and melted cheese filled the air. I swear my mouth was watering even before I took a bite. The restaurant is decorated with colorful Italian memorabilia, giving it a cozy atmosphere.

The pizza menu is simple, featuring a few classic favorites like margherita and pepperoni. But here’s the fun part: you can customize your own pizza with a wide selection of toppings! I went for an unconventional combination – spinach, artichoke, olives, sun-dried tomatoes and feta cheese – and it was delicious! Their flavorful homemade sauces brought out all the robust flavors of my ‘special’ creation.

Every bite was fresh, cheesy, and packed with flavor – Freddie & Pepper’s knows how to make some seriously good pizza! And since they use premium ingredients like freshly picked herbs, quality mozzarella cheese and artisan sourdough crusts, there’s no doubt that this is truly the best pizza in Upper West Side.

If you’re ever craving an authentic Italian pizza experience without leaving Manhattan, look no further than Freddie & Pepper’s. Their pizzas will have you wanting more – guaranteed!

#7 Pizza Collective

When I first arrived at Pizza Collective, I was impressed by how elegant their restaurant is. The décor was warm and inviting, with rustic wooden tables and chairs that provided a cozy atmosphere. But the real showstopper here is the pizza!

I had a chance to sample several pizzas on my visit and every single one of them was delicious. The crust alone was enough to make me swoon – light and slightly crisp with just the right amount of chewiness underneath. And the toppings were out of this world – from classic cheese pizzas to creative white pies loaded with ricotta, kale, and even truffles!

But what really impressed me about Pizza Collective was their attention to detail. Each pizza they served came out looking like a work of art – perfectly topped with fresh ingredients, cooked just right so that each bite had the perfect balance between crunchy and chewy textures. It’s clear that Pizza Collective puts great care into each dish they create because everything is made from scratch in-house using only the freshest ingredients.

The service at Pizza Collective was top-notch as well. Our waitress greeted us with a friendly smile and was more than happy to answer any questions we had about menu items or wine pairing recommendations. Even when it got busy she made sure everyone’s tastes were taken care of in an efficient manner.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Upper West Side, then you have to try Pizza Collective – it won’t disappoint!

#8 Celeste

The pizza here is to die for—the crust is perfectly golden and crunchy, the cheese is gooey and flavorful, and the toppings are always varied and generous. I’ve been a frequent customer here for months now and I’m yet to be disappointed.

What really takes Celeste to the top of my list of favorite pizza places is the friendly staff. From the moment you walk in, you’re welcomed warmly like an old friend. The staff knows their stuff too; they can suggest amazing combinations of toppings that’ll make your taste buds dance in delight!

Also, Celeste has a great atmosphere with classic Italian pizza ovens as a backdrop. It’s really fun to watch them prepare your order right before your eyes as you wait in anticipation for your delicious meal. And once it’s ready, they call out your name so everyone knows who just got their slice of heaven!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Upper West Side then Celeste should definitely be at the top of your list!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in New York!

#9 Sforno Pizza

The way the pizza is cooked to perfection never fails to amaze me. Just the thought of Sforno’s wood-fired oven makes my mouth water! From their specialty pizzas, like their white truffle and wild mushroom pizza, to their classic margheritas – every single one is a work of art.

I was particularly impressed by how fresh all of the ingredients were. The mozzarella cheese is always just perfect, and you can taste the tantalizing burst of flavor coming from their home-grown tomatoes each time you bite into a slice.

The ambience and service are also top notch when you visit Sforno Pizza. The waitstaff is highly knowledgeable and can recommend great combinations to match your individual tastes. But what really makes this place stand out is the fact that they go above and beyond to ensure that everything they serve up is top notch – from the dough to the toppings.

If I had to sum up my experience at Sforno Pizza in one phrase, I’d say this: Best pizza in Upper West Side without a doubt!

#10 Patsy’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere of the pizzeria is the perfect combination of classic and modern. The walls are adorned with vintage posters, but there’s also a jukebox playing the latest hits. The staff all wear crisp uniforms, and they always have a smile on their faces.

The pizza at Patsy’s is truly special. All their pies are made from scratch with freshly-sliced ingredients. They make sure that each slice has that perfect chewy texture and crunchy crust we all know and love! Plus, there’s an endless array of toppings to choose from. Whether you’re in the mood for some spicy pepperoni or just want a few simple mushrooms, Patsy’s can do it all!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Upper West Side, look no further than Patsy’s Pizzeria!

#11 Motorino

From the moment I stepped into Motorino, I could tell that this place was something special. The atmosphere was incredibly inviting and the staff were incredibly friendly and knowledgeable.

The pizza here is simply delicious. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy and the ingredients are fresh and flavorful. Their menu includes a variety of unique toppings, from wild mushrooms to spicy soppressata, making it easy to find something for everyone’s taste buds.

I tried the famous margherita pizza with a side of garlic knots for an added treat and it did not disappoint! The dough was light and fluffy, providing a perfect base for all of the delicious flavors that lay on top.

Overall, Motorino’s pizzas are some of the best I’ve ever had in my life – no exaggeration! If you’re ever in the Upper West Side area looking for great pizza, don’t pass up on Motorino – you won’t regret it!

#12 Pizza Pete’s

From the moment I stepped into this cozy restaurant, I knew I made the right choice. As soon as I opened the door, a heavenly aroma greeted me and reminded me why pizza is one of my all-time favorite foods.

The atmosphere was great too – it had a fun and inviting vibe that could make anyone feel at home. I decided to sit at the bar so I could get an up close view of the delicious pizzas being prepared in the open kitchen.

When it came time to order, I couldn’t decide what to choose! The menu was filled with classic Italian recipes done to perfection. After much contemplation, I went with my gut and decided on the Pete’s original specialty – just like Mama used to make! My decision paid off – it was delicious! The crust was thin yet crispy, and smothered in fresh ingredients. The cheese was gooey and stringy – just the way it should be.

Pizza Pete’s definitely lived up its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Upper West Side! If you’re looking for a place that serves good food with a great atmosphere, then Pizza Pete’s is your spot!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Emmett’s

Stepping into Emmett’s is like stepping into a time machine that takes you back to the old-school pizzerias of yesteryear. The smell of melted cheese and freshly baked dough wafts through the air, causing my taste buds to dance in anticipation. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I take my job very seriously. So naturally, when I heard about the best deep dish pizza in downtown, I had to put it to the test.

Let me tell you, the moment that golden, cheesy heaven arrived at my table, it was love at first bite. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside but oh-so-soft on the inside, resembling a fluffy cloud of deliciousness. It held up to the mountain of toppings like a champ, without sacrificing its integrity. I mean, who needs a plate when you have a slice of Emmett’s pizza?!

The combination of gooey, melted cheese and tangy tomato sauce was like a symphony in my mouth. Each ingredient played its part and came together harmoniously. And don’t even get me started on the generous toppings! From juicy chunks of sausage to fresh vegetables, every bite was an explosion of flavor.

But be warned, this pizza is not for the faint of heart. It’s a commitment—a glorious, cheesy, and utterly satisfying commitment. So if you find yourself craving the epitome of deep dish pizza, head to Emmett’s and prepare to have your taste buds blown away. Your stomach may never be the same again, but trust me, it’s a risk worth taking.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The smell of fresh dough being rolled out filled the air, and my stomach growled in anticipation. The staff greeted me with a warm smile and a delightful introduction to their pizza creations.

As I perused the menu, I couldn’t help but chuckle at the variety of toppings they offered. From classic margherita to inventive combinations like prosciutto and figs, Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza takes pizza to a whole new level of deliciousness.

When my pizza arrived, I couldn’t believe my eyes (or my taste buds). The crust was thin and crispy, with the perfect amount of chewiness. It was like a symphony of flavors exploded in my mouth with each bite. I couldn’t help but do a little happy dance in my seat, much to the amusement of the neighboring tables.

To top it all off, the service was exceptional. The waitstaff was attentive and knowledgeable. They even recommended some locally brewed craft beers to pair with my pizza, and boy, did they hit the spot!

So, if you find yourself in midtown manhattan and craving some incredible thin crust pizza, Vezzo NYC is a must-visit. Just be prepared to have your taste buds blown away and your funny bone tickled. Trust me, this place is truly a slice of pizza heaven!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Arturo’s Coal Oven Pizza

First of all, let’s talk about the crust. Oh, the crust! It’s like biting into a cloud that’s been infused with the essence of a thousand Italian grandmothers. It’s crispy on the outside, yet delightfully chewy on the inside. I even contemplated stealing a few extra slices to use as pillows on my flight back home.

And the toppings! They are a work of art, hence the name Arturo’s. From the classic margherita to the wild and wacky combinations they come up with, each pizza is a masterpiece in its own right. I had a pizza topped with prosciutto, arugula, and balsamic glaze, and let me tell you, it was like a tastebud tango. The flavors danced and twirled on my tongue, leaving me in a state of pizza bliss.

The atmosphere at Arturo’s is like a cozy Italian trattoria, with red checkered tablecloths and charming, gesticulating waiters. You can almost hear the faint strains of an accordion playing in the background. It’s the perfect setting to enjoy a piping hot slice of pizza and imagine you’re sitting in a quaint little piazza in Naples.

So, if you find yourself in Buffalo, do yourself a favor and head straight to Arturo’s Coal Oven Pizza. It’s the kind of place that will make you want to throw all your travel plans out the window and stay in Buffalo forever, just so you can indulge in their wood-fired pizzas every day. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed. Bellissimo!