Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Valparaiso (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Indiana

Best Pizza in Valparaiso (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

225 Views

After journeying around the world tasting pizza, I thought nothing could top Italy’s savory pies. But turns out, Valparaiso has some pretty amazing options! I recently visited 12 of its restaurants and am excited to share my favorite finds with you.

I’m not one to mince words, so I’ll get straight to it: Here are the best-tasting pizzas that Valparaiso has to offer. Join me as we venture through this journey of cheesy goodness and tantalizing flavors!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 The Rolling Stonebaker

I was blown away by their wide variety of options, including both vegetarian and non-vegetarian pies. I had the classic Margherita pizza, which was prepared to perfection. The dough was so light and airy that it practically melted in my mouth!

But perhaps even better than the fantastic food was the atmosphere. The Rolling Stonebaker is a great tourist spot as it offers more than just delicious pizza; they also have a full bar serving alcoholic beverages, plus desserts and other treats for those with a sweet tooth.

My one complaint about The Rolling Stonebaker is that they don’t offer delivery service, which would make it even easier to get great pizza on the go. But if you’re looking for the perfect place to enjoy the very best pizza in Valparaiso, The Rolling Stonebaker is sure to please!

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 15 more pizza places in Michigan City!

#2 Tomato Bar Pizza Bakery

This place has something for everyone. Whether you’re looking for a family friendly spot to take the kids, a nice tourist spot with drinks, or just an amazing slice of pizza, Tomato Bar Pizza Bakery deliveries on all fronts!

They have great veggie options for us vegetarians and even a kid’s menu with fun options. Plus, if you want to watch your favorite sports game while chowing down on delicious pizza, this is the spot for you.

The only downside of this place is that it doesn’t offer delivery. But it’s worth the trek out to experience their pizzas! I promise you won’t be disappointed.

#3 Amici Grill and Pizzeria

The atmosphere is friendly- with a menu that caters to everyone whether you’re looking for a full meal, just an appetizer, or a great drink. There are even options for the kids on the menu, along with some vegetarian dishes.

I visited them on a Saturday evening and they had quite a crowd! The bar was bustling with people ordering draft beers and cocktails while families occupied tables around us. It was easy to understand why this place was so popular – their pizza is delicious! They offer classic toppings like pepperoni, but also something special like prosciutto and gorgonzola or wild mushrooms.

The downside of Amici Grill and Pizzeria is that they don’t deliver – you’ll have to visit their lovely storefront in Valparaiso if you want your pizzeria fix from them. But it’s well worth the effort; plus you can finish your meal off with some homemade cannoli or tiramisu for dessert!

In my opinion, Amici Grill and Pizzeria is hands down one of the best places for pizza in Valparaiso. If you’re looking for some quality Italian food then I highly recommend giving this place a try!

#4 Uncle Menny’s Original Greek’s Pizzeria

I sampled their classic Margherita Pizza and it was amazing! The thin crust was perfectly crispy and the tomato sauce had just the right amount of sweetness. They used a delicious blend of mozzarella, parmesan, and romano cheeses, which added great depth to the flavor profile. And you can’t go wrong with fresh basil as garnish.

But it’s not all about the classic pizzas at Uncle Menny’s; they also make some truly unique creations! I was particularly taken by their Seafood Pizza which featured shrimp and calamari on a white garlic-infused sauce. The smokiness from the seafood balanced perfectly with the creamy white sauce and hint of garlic – trust me when I say that it’s a must try!

The atmosphere is inviting and cozy – with an exposed brick wall, wooden tables, and warm decor, you’ll feel like you’re part of the family. Plus, their friendly staff are always more than happy to answer any questions.

All in all, if you’re looking for quality pizza with top-notch ingredients in Valparaiso then look no further than Uncle Menny’s Original Greek’s Pizzeria. Trust me: it’ll be one of your best pizza experiences ever!

#5 Shoe’s Pizzeria Inc

The first thing that I noticed at this joint was the aroma – it’s like pizza heaven! The crusts were perfectly crisp and golden, and the toppings were generous and flavorful. Every bite was pure heaven!

The atmosphere here is amazing. Not only are there some awesome visuals for decoration, but the wait staff are so friendly and welcoming. They make you feel right at home, which makes the experience that much better.

To top it all off, their prices are reasonable; you don’t need to break the bank to get a great meal here. I would highly recommend Shoe’s Pizzeria Inc. to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Valparaiso – it certainly won’t disappoint!

#6 Verona Pizza

I was immediately drawn in by the classic atmosphere of Verona Pizza. The interior is adorned with old-fashioned Italian décor that reminded me of the pizzerias in Rome. I could smell the aroma of fresh pizza dough and spices in the air as soon as I walked through their door.

Their certified pizzaiolo put together some masterful pies that were just bursting with flavor. My Margherita pizza had a light, crisp crust and gooey mozzarella cheese that melted in my mouth. Their San Marzano tomato sauce was naturally sweet and had a distinct flavor that left me wanting more.

The customer service at Verona Pizza is also top-notch. They have an incredibly friendly staff who are always willing to answer questions or make recommendations about their menu items.

At the end of our meal, I was left feeling completely satisfied with my experience at Verona Pizza! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Valparaiso, look no further than Verona Pizza!

#7 Zao Pizza Bar

The pizza was cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of char on the crust. The tomato sauce tasted freshly made and was perfectly seasoned. The toppings were generous and flavor-packed, giving each slice a unique and delicious flavor combination.

The atmosphere is great too – chill music, good vibes, and friendly staff. Not to mention the outdoor seating area that looks out onto the street scene of Valparaiso!

My favorite part about Zao Pizza Bar is their signature “crunch” – it’s a kind of crunchy crust that you don’t get from other pizzas. It really takes the experience to a whole new level.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Valparaiso, then look no further than Zao Pizza Bar! Highly recommended!

If you’re willing to go an extra 25 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Hammond!

#8 Fazoli’s

From the moment I walked through the door, I could tell that this place was all about quality. As someone who has grown up eating pizza my whole life, I was really impressed with their ingredients. The crust is thin and crispy yet still light and fluffy, while the sauce is tangy and flavorful.

The toppings are incredibly fresh and full of flavor. My favorite is their signature Italian Cheese blend – it always adds just the right kick to any pizza! Plus, they always have great daily specials like half-priced cheese pizzas which just makes it even more value packed.

I’ve been to Fazoli’s multiple times now and each time I leave feeling satisfied with my meal. The staff is friendly, attentive, and always willing to go out of their way to make sure you have a great experience dining with them.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Valparaiso, Fazoli’s is definitely your spot!

#9 Santini’s Pizza And Wings

The pizza itself is delightful – the crust is crispy, yet chewy, and the red sauce is flavorful and not too spicy. I’ve sampled multiple types of pizza here and each one was cooked to perfection. The toppings have been fresh, generous, and well-balanced.

Plus, Santini’s Pizza And Wings offers a variety of wings to nosh on in between slices. The wings are spicy enough to satisfy my palate but still maintain their juiciness.

Although I highly recommend trying out the food at Santini’s Pizza And Wings, the atmosphere at this restaurant takes it up a notch. The decor has a nostalgic feel with kitschy art adorning the walls. The waitstaff is friendly and attentive too!

Overall, if you’re looking for an enjoyable dining experience in Valparaiso that boasts some of the best pizza around then look no further than Santini’s Pizza And Wings!

#10 Gelsosomo’s Pizzeria Valparaiso

The pizza here is simply divine. From the classic Margherita to the unique Hawaiian varieties, their pizzas never fail to impress. I especially loved their signature Gelsosomo’s Special – a smoky combination of cheese, pepperoni, and sausage that was out of this world!

The atmosphere at Gelsosomo’s is also great; it’s cozy and inviting, with bright lights and colorful decorations. The servers are friendly and attentive, always making sure that my experience was perfect.

As for the prices – they’re more than reasonable for what you get. And, on top of all that, Gelsosomo’s offers one of the widest selections of beer in town; it’s clear why they’ve become so popular with locals and tourists alike!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Valparaiso, then look no further than Gelsosomo’s Pizzeria Valparaiso. Don’t take my word for it though – see for yourself!

#11 Tony’s Place

I was so impressed with the sheer variety of pizzas available at Tony’s. From their awesome Thin and Crispy Pizza to their more classic Hand-Tossed Crust, there’s something here for everyone. The crusts were cooked to perfection and there’s no shortage of toppings to choose from.

But it doesn’t stop there—the ingredients too were top-notch! I tried a few different combinations, but the one that really won me over was their Margherita pizza with extra fresh mozzarella—it was absolute perfection.

The atmosphere of Tony’s Place is also fantastic—it’s spacious, cozy, and has a great buzz about it. It always seems like the place is packed, which goes to show how popular it is among locals and tourists alike.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Valparaiso, Tony’s Place should be your first stop! They’ve got a great selection of pizzas, fantastic quality ingredients, and an inviting atmosphere—what more could you ask for?

#12 Rosati’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped in the door of Rosati’s Pizza, I knew I was in for a treat. The open kitchen design really allowed me to get an up-close look at all the delicious ingredients they were preparing. There are so many options on the menu to choose from, it almost felt overwhelming. But after talking to the friendly staff, I decided to give their signature big cheese pizza a try and boy was that a great decision!

The crust was perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crunch and flavor. And then there were those delicious layers of cheese – oh man, it was like my taste buds were in heaven! I even chose some extra toppings (pepperoni and sausage) just to make my pizza experience even more enjoyable, and it worked – wow!

I’ve been very lucky to have tasted some of the best pizzas in the world over my travels but I truly believe that Rosati’s Pizza is making some of the best pizza in Valparaiso. They really know what they’re doing here; if you’re ever in town, do yourself a favor and stop by Rosati’s Pizza – you won’t regret it!