Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Waikiki (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Hawaii

Best Pizza in Waikiki (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

692 Views

I’m a crust critic in every sense of the word, so I’ve taken my time and traveled around to find the 12 best pizza places in Waikiki. My taste-testing journey has been far from a chore!

The locals may argue over which pizzeria is the top of their list, but after some serious snacking I can definitively say who takes the cake – or should I say, pie? My picks for the best pizza in Waikiki will have your mouth watering and stomach growling. So get ready for a fun and lighthearted tour through my favorite pizza spots.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Hawaii

#1 Little G Cafe

This little gem is tucked away in a shopping center, but their pizza is worth seeking out. From the moment I stepped inside, I knew it was going to be a great experience. The warm, inviting atmosphere and delicious smell of baking dough had me questioning whether or not I should have skipped dinner that night!

The crust on Little G Cafe’s pizzas definitely lives up to its reputation – it’s delightfully crispy and flavorful. The toppings were so fresh; they had an amazing depth of flavor that you don’t always get with pizza places. From classic cheese and pepperoni to gourmet chicken pesto and veggie supreme, the offerings are incredibly varied and interesting.

I would honestly give this place 5 stars if not for one slight problem: they don’t offer delivery service. So while the food here is beyond delicious (and definitely worth taking the time to sit down and enjoy), sometimes dining out just isn’t possible or convenient.

Even so, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Waikiki (or anywhere else for that matter!), I can confidently say that Little G Cafe is a surefire winner!

If you’re willing to go an extra 28 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Honolulu!

#2 Floralia

My first impression of the restaurant was positive: it’s a great tourist spot, with a nice atmosphere and friendly staff. The menu offered several vegetarian options, which I always appreciate.

But what really sealed the deal for me was the pizza. The thin crust was so perfectly crisp and the toppings were so fresh and flavorful. Every bite was an absolute delight! Plus, Floralia offers dessert pizzas, so it’s like having two meals in one.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery services. But considering how good the pizza is, it’s well worth the trip! I’d recommend that anyone who wants to find the best pizza in Waikiki head over to Floralia and enjoy some delicious Italian-style pies.

#3 ‘ili’ili Cash & Carry

I had the pleasure of dining at this one-of-a-kind pizza restaurant recently and I was blown away. The interior was beautiful, and the staff was incredibly friendly. They offered a wide selection of pizzas and other Italian favorites, all made fresh with locally sourced ingredients.

When it comes to their pizza, ‘ili’ili Cash & Carry really knows what they’re doing. The crust was crispy and light, the cheese perfectly melty and flavorful, and the topping combinations were creative yet still classic enough to appeal to traditionalists. My favorite was the Hawaiian BBQ Chicken – a unique take on Hawaiian pizza that added plenty of tangy flavor.

I’m convinced ‘ili’ili Cash & Carry is making some of the best pizza in Waikiki! I can’t wait for my next trip back so I can sample more dishes – if my experience is anything like it was last time, it won’t disappoint!

#4 Amina Pizzeria

I first heard of this place while staying at a hotel in Waikiki. I was so intrigued by their reputation that I decided to give it a try. Boy, am I glad I did!

When my food arrived, the aroma was heavenly. With each bite, I tasted all the fresh and high-quality ingredients. The crust was perfectly cooked and lightly seasoned with herbs and spices. The cheese melted in my mouth and blended harmoniously with the sweetness of the tomato sauce. Each topping added its own distinct flavor that combined for an unforgettable pizza experience!

The staff were also quite friendly and knowledgeable about their menu. They even managed to provide a great recommendation for me when I asked what the best pizza on their menu was!

Overall, Amina Pizzeria is definitely worth visiting if you’re ever in Waikiki and looking for some of the best pizza around. It’s been one of my favorite discoveries during my travels so far!

#5 Brick Fire Tavern

Their menu offers several gourmet pizzas that are sure to satisfy your cravings. My favorite was the brick-fired mushroom pizza with a balsamic glaze. The earthy mushrooms were complemented perfectly by the sweet glaze and the crust was crispy and flavorful.

The atmosphere at Brick Fire Tavern is very inviting, with rustic wood tables and exposed brick walls. The staff was extremely friendly and they make sure everyone has a great experience while they eat.

The drinks selection was fantastic as well. I enjoyed a refreshing craft beer while I waited for my pizza to be served, which came out quickly and piping hot.

Brick Fire Tavern really hit it out of the park for me! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Waikiki, definitely check this place out – you won’t regret it!

#6 La Pizza Rina

The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, and the staff were extremely friendly. Not to mention they offer some of the most delicious dough and crust I’ve ever had! My favorite is their Sicilian-style pizza with a thin but crispy crust, fresh tomato sauce and lots of mozzarella cheese!

Not only did I get to savor yummy pizza, but La Pizza Rina also offers a diverse selection of toppings. During my latest visit, I tried their four-cheese pizza with olives and mushrooms that was simply divine! Every bite was full of flavor and bursting with toppings.

If that wasn’t enough, La Pizza Rina has one of the best wine selections you can find in Waikiki. So if you’re feeling particularly fancy, you can pair your favorite pizza with your favorite bottle for an unforgettable evening.

If it’s quality pizza you’re in search of, then do yourself a favor and visit La Pizza Rina – it’s definitely one of the best spots for pizza in Waikiki!

#7 Appetito Craft Pizza & Wine Bar

The dough was cooked to perfection, with a crispy and chewy texture that was simply divine. The toppings were also top-notch; the spicy Italian sausage was the perfect addition to the classic margherita pizza I had.

One thing that really set Appetito apart from the rest of the competition was their selection of wines. As a food critic, I’m always looking for a place that offers both great food and drinks. With Appetito, they had an amazing selection of red and white wines from all over the world that perfectly complemented my meal.

To top it off, the service at Appetito Craft Pizza & Wine Bar was exceptional. Our server was friendly and took time to explain each option on the menu in detail so we could make an informed decision.

I highly recommend Appetito Craft Pizza & Wine Bar! From their scrumptious pizzas to their attentive service, you won’t be disappointed by selecting this restaurant for your next meal out in Waikiki!

If you’re willing to go an extra 80 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Lahaina!

#8 Arancino di Mare

From the first moment I stepped into the restaurant, I knew that this place was special. The staff were friendly and welcoming, creating an inviting atmosphere right off the bat.

I decided to order the Margherita pizza, and it did not disappoint! The mozzarella was light and creamy, the tomato sauce had a perfect balance of sweet and tangy flavours. And the crust – oh that crust! It was lightly charred with a slight crunch when you bit into it and wonderfully fluffy on the inside.

Overall, Arancino di Mare provided one of my most memorable gastronomic experiences, as well as one of my all-time favorite pizzas. If you’re looking for great pizza in Waikiki, this is definitely the place to go!

#9 Pieology Pizzeria

The pizza here is unlike anything I’ve ever tasted. Every single ingredient tasted fresher than anything else I’ve had before. From the crust to the sauce, it was all perfect. The toppings were varied and unique – they weren’t your usual pepperoni and cheese!

The atmosphere of Pieology Pizzeria also made my experience there even more enjoyable. The staff were all friendly, funny and attentive. They really know their stuff! Plus, the decor was modern and chic, giving off a relaxing vibe that made my meal here a pleasure from start to finish.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Waikiki then look no further than Pieology Pizzeria! I can guarantee you will not be disappointed with their delicious pies.

#10 Kings Pizza Cafe

I don’t know what kind of magic they use to make their pies, but they are always cooked perfectly. The crust is crispy on the outside and fantastically chewy on the inside – definitely worthy of its title as ‘the best pizza in Waikiki’.

The toppings are also incredibly fresh and delicious! I’ve tried all kinds of combinations over the years, from classic margherita to Hawaiian-style pineapple-and-ham – and every one has been a real treat for my taste buds.

What really sets this place apart from other pizzerias, though, is its incredible atmosphere. The staff are friendly and attentive, and really make you feel welcome when you come in. Plus, the decor is rustic but cozy – perfect for a night out with friends or family.

With all that said, it’s no wonder Kings Pizza Cafe has earned its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Waikiki! If you’re looking for a great slice that’ll fill your stomach and bring a smile to your face, then look no further than this truly magical pizzeria!

#11 Slice of Waikiki

My first impression of the restaurant was that it had a great atmosphere with plenty of space for large groups. The decor was colorful and inviting, making me feel right at home.

The menu had a variety of pizza options to choose from including classic favorites like pepperoni and margherita, as well as some more adventurous options like truffle-infused pizzas. I decided on the truffle-infused pizza with mushrooms and prosciutto – an amazing combination!

The pizza is made with fresh ingredients and cooked perfectly until it has a crisp, charred crust. It also had just the right amount of cheese and toppings so that each bite was full of flavor.

I would highly recommend Slice of Waikiki for anyone looking for great pizza in Waikiki. Trust me – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 California Pizza Kitchen at Ala Moana

I’ve had pizza from all corners of the world — Sicily, Rome, Naples, New York, even Tokyo! But I have to say that the pizza at California Pizza Kitchen really takes the cake.

The thin crust was cooked perfectly with a beautiful crispiness that held up against whatever toppings I decided to put on. The sauce was also very flavorful and went well with most of my choices of toppings. Whether it be classic Italian pepperoni or a more daring combination like smoked salmon and goat cheese, each bite was an absolute delight.

The atmosphere was also very pleasant; it was quiet enough for conversation but lively enough to be interesting. Plus, the staff were friendly and helpful in guiding me through their menu.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Waikiki, I would definitely recommend California Pizza Kitchen at Ala Moana!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – La Pizza Rina

Let me start by saying that I’ve eaten my fair share of pizza, from the tiny pizzerias in Italy to the famous New York pizza joints. And let me tell you, La Pizza Rina holds its own against them all.

First of all, the crust is delightfully thin and crispy. I’m talking so thin that you can almost see through it. It’s like eating a delicate piece of art, except it’s edible and absolutely delicious. The cheese-to-sauce ratio is perfectly balanced, and the toppings are aplenty.

Now, I must warn you about the danger of these pizzas. They are so good that you’ll find yourself eating slice after slice, unable to stop. It’s like a magical spell has been cast upon you, making you crave more and more. I’ve witnessed people lose control, their faces covered in sauce, cheese stuck to their cheeks. It’s a sight to behold, let me tell you.

The ambiance of the restaurant is nothing to write home about, but who needs fancy decor when you have pizza this good? The staff is friendly enough, but let’s be honest, I’m here for the pizza, not the small talk.

So, if you find yourself in Honolulu and craving some outstanding thin crust pizza, head straight to La Pizza Rina. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed. And if you do happen to lose yourself in a pizza-induced frenzy, just remember to wipe the sauce off your face before leaving.