I recently set out on a mission to find the best pizza in Wallingford, sampling 12 different pizzerias. I’ve had pizza all over the world—from New York to Rome and everything in between—so I’m confident I will be able to provide an informed opinion here.
Along the way, I found some disappointing pies and some that were simply okay. But I also found quite a few excellent slices. So follow me on this culinary journey through Wallingford to discover the best pizza around! My reviews are sure to provide you with lighthearted entertainment as well as serious advice when it comes to deciding where to get your next cheesy pie.
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Connecticut
#1 East Side Pizza Palace
The atmosphere at East Side Pizza Palace is cozy and inviting, with a warm and friendly staff. The restaurant is well-decorated with local memorabilia, giving it a hip vibe that’s perfect for grabbing a slice with friends.
When it comes to their pizza, I must say that I’m thoroughly impressed! They have an amazing selection of toppings and crusts to choose from. My personal favorite is their house special – The Wallingford Supreme. It has a thin crispy crust topped with flavorful sauce, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and bell peppers. Every bite is absolutely delicious!
Overall I highly recommend East Side Pizza Palace for anyone looking for the best pizza in Wallingford CT! Whether you’re grabbing lunch with coworkers or enjoying dinner with family and friends – this place will definitely satisfy your pizza craving.
If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Meriden!
#2 Trackside Brick Oven Pizzeria
- Serves alcohol
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
They serve up classic New York style pizza with a twist of delicious Italian flare. The ovens are brick, allowing for a crust that is the perfect combination of crunchy on the outside and chewy in the middle. And to top it off, all of their ingredients are fresh and locally sourced, providing an authentic flavor profile in each slice.
The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, so there’s no need to worry about ordering something you don’t like. They also offer a great selection of craft beer, imported from around the world, so you can pair your meal perfectly with your favorite libation.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Wallingford CT, then look no further than Trackside Brick Oven Pizzeria! From their amazing flavors to their welcoming atmosphere, it’s definitely worth checking out next time you’re in town.
#3 Fabi’s Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
From the moment I walked in, it was clear that Fabi’s Pizza was special. The warm and inviting atmosphere immediately made me feel at home and their fresh ingredients spoke to my pizza-lovin’ heart.
The dough is so light and fluffy – it melts in your mouth with every bite! And the sauce! It has just the right amount of sweetness that leaves you wanting more. As for toppings, well let’s just say they have a lot of options. From classic pepperoni to something more unique like prosciutto, each topping enhanced the flavor of the pizza.
The service at Fabi’s Pizza was also top notch. Everyone was friendly and accommodating – they really went out of their way to make sure I had a great experience.
Overall, if you’re looking for some great pizza in Wallingford CT then look no further than Fabi’s Pizza! They offer a cozy environment, delicious food and amazing customer service – making this one of my favorite pizza places in town!
#4 Hometown Pizza & Restaurant
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
When it comes to pizza, Hometown Pizza & Restaurant is no slouch. The crust is light and airy but still manages to hold up under the weight of all the toppings. Each topping was cooked to perfection and added an extra layer of flavor to each bite. My personal favorite was their classic margherita pizza – the tomatoes were so juicy!
The atmosphere at Hometown Pizza & Restaurant is also unforgettable. It’s like taking a step back in time with warm colors, vintage decor, and even a jukebox playing in the corner! The staff was friendly and attentive, which really put us at ease during our meal.
At the end of the day, I have to say that Hometown Pizza & Restaurant has some of the best pizza in Wallingford CT. If you’re in town and looking for a slice of deliciousness that won’t break your wallet, then make sure you visit Hometown Pizza & Restaurant!
#5 Napoli Pizza Restaurant
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Serves alcohol
- Has insanely good dessert
- No delivery
From the minute I walked in, I felt like family. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting – the kind of place where you can sit back and enjoy your meal with friends or family.
The best part, though, is the pizza! It’s freshly made with a wide variety of toppings. You can choose between traditional cheese and pepperoni pizzas, as well as vegetarian options like veggie-loaded pies. No matter what you order, it’s sure to be delicious.
Plus, they have a kid-friendly menu so families can come in and enjoy a meal together. And don’t forget the desserts – they’re out of this world! If you’re looking for a sweet treat after your meal, Napoli Pizza Restaurant has got you covered.
The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery service – but the restaurant itself is worth checking out regardless! It’s a great tourist spot too if you want to show off some Wallingford hospitality when visitors come to town.
If you’re looking for an experience unlike any other in Wallingford CT, then make sure to check out Napoli Pizza Restaurant! You won’t regret it – their pizza is some of the best around!
#6 Anthonys Pizzeria and Deli Wallingford
The pizzas here are simply divine, especially their signature cheese pizza. Toppings like pepperoni and sausage are juicy and flavorful, while the dough is light and airy. The freshly-grated parmesan cheese sprinkled on top of each slice is just the icing on the cake – it’s so good!
But that’s not all Anthonys Pizzeria has to offer. Their selection of deli sandwiches is equally delicious, with each sandwich artfully crafted to perfection. A personal favorite of mine is their steak & provolone sandwich – it’s teeming with flavor in every bite.
If you’re ever in Wallingford and looking for amazing pizza or satisfying deli sandwiches, I highly recommend Anthonys Pizzeria and Deli Wallingford. It truly is the best pizza in Wallingford CT!
If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Hamden!
#7 Old Colony Pizza
The sauce is full of flavor, the cheese is well-melted and the crust has just enough crunch. The toppings are fresh and delicious, and they always leave me feeling satisfied with every bite.
The staff at Old Colony Pizza is friendly and accommodating. I’ve never had a bad experience here! They even let me in to watch them make the pizza so I could take a few pictures of the process and post it online.
The atmosphere of Old Colony Pizza is also great. With a cozy, homey setting, it’s clear that this restaurant takes pride in its pizza making craft. The music is also always on point and helps to set the mood for an enjoyable meal.
I can confidently say that Old Colony Pizza offers some of the best pizza in Wallingford CT! If you’re ever in town looking for a delicious slice, be sure to stop by here!
#8 Oakdale Pizza
- Offers dessert
I was drawn in by the delicious smell of freshly-baked pizza when I walked through the door, and the friendly staff made me feel welcome from the get-go.
When it came time to choose a pizza, there were so many great options to choose from – all made with freshly-prepared toppings, homemade sauces, and freshly-made dough. I settled on a classic pepperoni pizza and boy am I glad I did! The perfect blend of sauce and cheese combined with the zesty pepperoni had my taste buds singing in delight.
My other favorite part of Oakdale Pizza is the atmosphere – it’s cozy and inviting without being too loud or busy. Plus, their selection of local craft beers makes for an even better experience. My friends and I had a great night out at Oakdale Pizza, laughing and enjoying each others’ company as we indulged in what can only be described as some of the best pizza in Wallingford CT.
If you’re looking for a reliable spot for great tasting pizza that won’t break the bank, look no further than Oakdale Pizza!
#9 Little Italy Gourmet Market & Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Has insanely good dessert
My experience here was nothing short of remarkable. From the moment I walked in the door, I was blown away by the aromas of delicious pizza and fresh ingredients. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable, and they made sure my order was perfect each time.
The pizzas themselves were amazing! My absolute favorite is the Margherita with its classic tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, basil, and extra-virgin olive oil. It’s like a slice of heaven on a plate! All their other pizzas are equally delectable, so you’re bound to find something you love no matter what your preferences may be.
Little Italy Gourmet Market & Pizza is truly a gem amongst pizza places in Wallingford CT. If you’re ever in town, make sure to give them a visit – you won’t be disappointed!
#10 Natalie’s Apizza
On my most recent visit to the pizza joint, I was thoroughly impressed with their impeccable hospitality and the out-of-this-world flavor of their pizza. The crust was light and crisp, while the toppings were fresh and flavorful. I particularly enjoyed their signature pepperoni pizza – they use the spiciest pepperonis around, which really brings out the flavors in the dish.
The atmosphere at Natalie’s Apizza was also top notch. It had a warm, inviting environment that made me feel right at home. The staff were incredibly friendly and attentive – every time I needed something, they popped up to serve me promptly. Not to mention, the restaurant was spotless!
All things considered, this is definitely one of the best pizzerias in Wallingford CT! If you’re ever in town and looking for amazing pizza, be sure to check out Natalie’s Apizza – you won’t be disappointed!
#11 Christo’s Restaurant & Bar
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
I decided to start with the Margherita – a classic. As soon as I bit into it, I was in pizza-heaven. The ingredients were fresh, the sauce was flavorful and the dough was perfectly cooked.
Next up was the pepperoni pizza – a personal favorite of mine. The combination of mozzarella, perfectly seasoned pepperoni, and a perfect thick crust created an amazing flavor experience that just kept getting better with each bite!
After finishing off both pies, I knew that Christo’s had earned my title for best pizza in Wallingford CT! For anyone looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, be sure to check out Christo’s Restaurant & Bar.
If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Southington!
#12 Minervini’s Pizzeria
- Offers dessert
I was blown away with the delicious selection of pies available. The classic margherita was one of the best I’ve ever tasted, and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a real Italian-style pizza experience. The Sicilian and Neapolitan pizzas were also top notch, both made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection in their wood-burning ovens.
The atmosphere at Minervini’s is also really great. It’s cozy yet vibrant, making it a great place to spend time with friends or family. The staff was so friendly and welcoming during my visit that I didn’t want to leave!
Overall, Minervini’s Pizzeria serves some of the best pizza in Wallingford CT, and I highly recommend it for anyone looking for a truly authentic Italian dining experience. Whether you’re a seasoned pizza connoisseur or just someone looking for a great dinner option, Minervini’s should be your go-to choice!
