Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Wayne NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Wayne NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

332 Views

I’m always on the lookout for great pizza, and I’ve eaten slices in many cities all around the world. But my recent search for the best pizza in Wayne NJ was a fun challenge, and I’d like to share my findings with you!

After visiting 12 different restaurants and tasting 112 individual slices of pizza, I can confidently say that I now know which places serve up the tastiest pies.

So if you’re looking for an amazing slice of pizza, read on to discover my top picks for Wayne NJ! The journey to find these tasty selections has been well-travelled and full of surprises.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Blaze Pizza

The atmosphere was inviting and warm, with a busy staff that seemed passionate about their craft: pizza. The crust was perfectly thin and flavorful, while the sauce was zesty and had just the right amount of garlic. And the toppings were spot on: pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions—each added to the flavor and texture of the pizza in their own way.

But it’s not just about what goes onto the pizza—it’s about how it all comes together. Thanks to Blaze Pizza’s unique approach to cooking pizzas, each one came out with an even crust and flavor throughout.

I’m telling you—if you have a craving for pizza in Wayne NJ, then Blaze Pizza is your go-to spot! I can honestly say it’s one of the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Highly recommended!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Paterson!

#2 Grandma’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped inside Grandma’s Pizza, I could smell the delicious scents of freshly-cooked Italian food. There was a charming atmosphere and an active kitchen that showed how much effort goes into making every dish special.

The menu offered plenty of options to choose from, and each pizza had its own unique flavor. And after trying them all, I can say with absolute certainty that Grandma’s Pizza is among the best in town. The dough was fluffy and golden brown with just the right amount of crunch; the toppings contained high-quality ingredients, handpicked for their flavor; and the cheese was ooey-gooey and tasted like it had been freshly cut from a block.

Overall, Grandma’s Pizza offers an amazing experience – one that you won’t soon forget! The customer service is also top notch as they truly go above and beyond to make sure everyone has a great time. So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Wayne NJ, come to Grandma’s Pizza – you won’t regret it!

#3 Pizza One

I had heard about Pizza One’s pies, so I decided to give it a try. From the moment I stepped in, I knew it was going to be an experience worth savoring. Everything from the cozy atmosphere to the friendly staff made me feel right at home.

The pizza is where Pizza One really shines, though. The variety of toppings available and their freshness were both impressive. They had all of the classics (pepperoni, sausage, etc) but also some creative options like kale, sundried tomatoes and feta cheese. No matter what topping you choose, every slice has a perfect crust that is both crunchy and light – exactly as it should be!

The portions are generous too – which you’ll appreciate if you’re a big eater like me! With all that said, I can honestly say that I’ve never had better pizza than at Pizza One. If you haven’t tried them yet, do yourself a favor and go for the best pizza in Wayne NJ – trust me, you won’t regret it!

#4 Primo Pizza

The pizzas here are delicious and the regular crust is one of the best I’ve ever had. The restaurant offers dozens of different toppings, which range from classic favorites like pepperoni to more exotic flavors like spicy artichoke. I’m a big fan of their speciality pizzas, especially the one with pulled pork and pineapple.

The atmosphere at Primo Pizza is great – it’s relaxing and family-friendly. The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful, always willing to answer any questions I have. Although they don’t offer delivery, you can call ahead to place an order – they usually have it ready within 15 minutes!

Overall, Primo Pizza is absolutely worth a visit if you’re in Wayne NJ looking for some seriously amazing pizza! It truly has some of the best pizza in the area, and it’s worth every penny.

#5 Buongusto Pizza Resturant & Catering

The first thing I noticed when walking in was how cozy the atmosphere was. The interior design was inviting and there was a great selection of Italian music playing in the background.

When it came to the pizza itself, I was blown away – from the freshly made dough to the perfect blend of cheese and toppings, they nailed it. Buongusto has perfected the classic Italian flavor with their pizzas. All of their ingredients were incredibly fresh and flavorful.

I also have to note that the service here is top-notch. Everyone working at Buongusto was friendly, knowledgeable and accommodating – which really added to my experience!

Overall, if you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Wayne NJ, look no further than Buongusto Pizza Resturant & Catering! In my opinion, they are one of the best around and something that you’ll definitely want to try!

#6 Bradlees Pizza

I’m usually a very critical pizza connoisseur, but I was impressed with the experience at Bradlees Pizza. The crust was perfectly crispy and had just the right amount of thickness- not too thick or too thin. My favorite topping combo, pepperoni and olives, was cooked to perfection. There’s no doubt in my mind that Bradlees takes their time to ensure every single pizza comes out perfect.

The atmosphere is relaxed yet lively, and everyone seems to have a great time while they’re enjoying their meal. My server was incredibly helpful and kept checking up on us during the entire meal. The service really set Bradlee’s apart from other pizza places that I’ve visited.

Overall, if you’re looking for a delicious slice of pizza in Wayne NJ, look no further than Bradlees Pizza! Their amazing pizzas paired with excellent service makes this restaurant one of my all-time favorites for ordering takeout.

#7 Anthony Franco’s Pizza – Wayne

Visiting this restaurant is a real treat – the aroma of homemade sauces and fresh-baked dough greets you as soon as you step in the door. The layout of the restaurant itself is polished, with bright colors and an atmosphere that encourages conversation.

The pizzas here are delicious. Every one’s made from scratch and baked to perfection in their wood-fired ovens. The crusts are perfectly thin and crispy, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. You can order anything from classic pepperoni to more exotic combinations like fig, artichoke, and balsamic glaze.

I must say, Anthony Franco’s Pizza – Wayne is truly the best pizza in Wayne NJ! From the welcoming atmosphere to delicious creations that put a modern twist on classic Italian recipes, there’s something here for everyone to enjoy. Whether you’re looking for a quick dinner option or a special date night with someone you love, this place won’t disappoint.

#8 Taste of Tuscany – Wayne NJ

On a recent visit, I was blown away by the high-quality ingredients, like the freshly made dough, unique cheeses and delicious sauces. The pizza crust was perfectly cooked – crispy on the outside, light and fluffy on the inside. Every bite was flavorful and left me wanting more!

The staff at Taste of Tuscany – Wayne NJ is friendly and attentive. No matter what questions I had or advice I needed, they were always happy to help steer me in the right direction.

I’m not sure if it was the atmosphere of Taste of Tuscany – Wayne NJ that made me feel so content or if it was just something about their pizza that hit all the right notes for me but either way, it’s by far one of my favorite pizza places in Wayne NJ. For anyone looking for some truly inspired Italian fare, this is definitely worth checking out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Clifton!

#9 Fratelli Pizza & Coffee

I’ve been to many places that boast the “best” pizza, but Fratelli’s is no joke. The crusts are thin and perfectly crispy. The sauce has a unique flavor that stands out from all the others. And of course, the toppings are always fresh – never soggy or over-cooked.

In addition to great pizza, Fratelli’s also offers an amazing selection of coffees that pairs perfectly with their pies. Whether you’re looking for a quick espresso shot or something more complex, they have it all.

But as if that weren’t enough, the atmosphere at Fratelli’s is always incredibly inviting and relaxed. You can come in your favorite sweatshirt and easily stay for hours without feeling uncomfortable or rushed.

If you haven’t been to Fratelli’s yet, then you don’t know what you’re missing! Trust me when I say it will quickly become your new favorite spot for pizza in Wayne NJ!

#10 V & J Pizza

The crust was perfectly cooked and golden brown, with just the right amount of crunch – not too hard, not too soft. The sauce was a flavorful blend of spices that tantalized my taste buds and kept me coming back for more. They didn’t skimp on the cheese either – it was generous in every bite, melty and gooey perfection!

My favorite part of the pizza though? The toppings! I could taste the freshly chopped vegetables distributed evenly throughout each slice and those delicious meats were so juicy and flavorful. From pepperoni to sausage to olives, V & J has something for everyone.

I definitely recommend checking out V & J Pizza if you’re ever in Wayne NJ looking for great pizza! Trust me, you won’t be disappointed.

#11 Hoboken’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere at Hoboken’s Pizzeria is truly unique. Upon arriving, you can smell the homemade pizza sauce wafting through the air. The place looks rustic and cozy, with brick walls and a large brick oven in the center of the room. I felt like I was back home in an old Italian pizzeria, but with a modern twist.

The menu offers a variety of pizzas made with fresh ingredients, such as their signature thin-crust cheese pizza with just the right amount of zesty flavor. I also had their pepperoni pizza which was tasty and had plenty of spice! Each order comes out quickly, just moments after it’s been placed in the oven.

What really sets Hoboken’s Pizzeria apart is its friendly staff. Everyone who works there is helpful and willing to answer any questions that you might have about their pizza. They even gave me insight into their processes for making dough each day and cooking their pies to perfection – it was fascinating to hear about all their efforts!

All in all, I’d have to say that Hoboken’s Pizzeria serves up some of the best pizza in Wayne NJ. Whether looking for a great meal or just a casual bite to eat, this place should be top on your list!

#12 Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

The atmosphere is lively, with a modern yet welcoming feel. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Plus, they have a great selection of coal-fired pizza options that are sure to please any palate.

Their signature pizzas really shine, with artfully crafted toppings that will tantalize your taste buds. For example, their Chicken Sausage & Ricotta Ardore had the perfect mix of smokiness and sweetness to really bring out the flavor in the dish. Even better were their wings which I found to be some of the best I’ve ever had! The sauces were tasty and nuanced – just enough to make them delicious without being overwhelming.

Overall, I’m convinced that Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings has some of the best pizza in Wayne NJ! Whether you’re looking for something on the lighter side or a full meal with all the fixins, this place has it all. If you haven’t tried it yet, do yourself a favor and pay this place a visit – you won’t regret it!