Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Wesley Chapel (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Wesley Chapel (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

216 Views

I’ve traveled around the world tasting pizza, and I’m finally here to share my favorite picks for the best pizza in Wesley Chapel. After eating my way through 12 local places, I’m pleased to report that there is a plethora of delicious options in this area.

Along with my top picks, I’ll be giving you some additional thoughts on each spot so you can decide what type of pizza suits your taste buds. So grab your appetite and let’s get started on my guide to the best pizza in Wesley Chapel!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Pomodoro Pizza

The atmosphere here is lively and welcoming, and the staff are friendly and accommodating. The pizza itself is delicious with a perfectly crispy yet chewy crust that’s cooked to perfection. I tried both their classic cheese pizza as well as their olive and feta concoction, and they were both fantastic!

The best part of this place? Their unique toppings! They have some creative combinations that you can’t find elsewhere. My favorite was the spinach and caramelized onion pizza – so many flavors mixed together, it was absolute heaven!

If you’re looking for a place to get a great slice in Wesley Chapel, look no further – Pomodoro Pizza is the place to go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Tampa!

#2 Pasta di Guy

Sure, I’ve had my share of amazing wood-fired pizzas in Naples and Chicago deep-dish pies; but there’s something about the way the dough is perfectly spongy and chewy and the fresh toppings at Pasta di Guy that make it an absolute delight.

Here, you can find classic Italian favorites like sweet pepperoni or a hearty margarita pizza – or adventurous options like their fig and prosciutto pizza. All of them are made with slow rise dough that produces a light yet crunchy crust.

The friendly staff also adds to the experience – they seem to genuinely enjoy making your pizza exactly how you want it. That’s why this place is always so busy (and crowded). But don’t let that deter you – just hang in there and wait for your turn to come because it’s totally worth it!

In summary, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Wesley Chapel, then look no further than Pasta di Guy. Whether you prefer traditional Italian flavors or some wilder creations, this restaurant has something to satisfy any palate – plus top notch customer service thrown in for good measure.

#3 Blaze Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly and inviting staff, who assured me I’d get the best pizza around. The atmosphere of the restaurant was laid back and cozy – just the kind of place where I could find comfort while eating some delicious pizza.

When it came to the food, I was not disappointed. The crust was thin and crisp, yet still held its shape when topped with my favorite ingredients; and the sauce had just the right amount of spice without being too overwhelming. Each bite of my custom-made pizza was packed full of flavor and absolutely delicious!

Plus, Blaze Pizza also has an impressive selection of craft beers on tap. It’s rare to find such a great combination of quality pizza and craft beer in one location like this.

Overall, if you’re looking for some great tasting pizza in Wesley Chapel, Blaze Pizza is definitely worth checking out – it’s easily one of the best places for pizza in town!

#4 Amici Pizza (Wesley Chapel)

The crust was crispy and perfectly cooked. I’m talking about a pizza that would make even the most hardened New York pizza connoisseur jealous. The sauce was made from Amici’s own recipe which has just the right balance of herbs and spices, making every slice burst with flavor. The cheese was gooey and so rich; it just melted in my mouth!

The toppings were incredibly fresh, the vegetables lacked no flavor and added an extra layer to each bite. All-in-all, this is a restaurant that serves up some truly amazing pies.

I had a great time enjoying one of Amici Pizza’s pies, as well as their other offerings like sandwiches, salads, calzones and more. But let me tell you, the pizza was definitely worth the trip! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Wesley Chapel, look no further than Amici Pizza.

#5 Fratelli’s Pizza and Cafe

Their pizzas are truly something special. The crust is perfectly thin yet crispy, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. From classic pepperoni to unique combos like artichoke hearts with feta cheese, Fratelli’s Pizza and Cafe has it all!

The atmosphere is also truly remarkable. The staff is friendly and attentive, while the decor consists of a warm, Mediterranean-style motif complete with terra cotta tiles and Tuscan artistry. You really feel like you’ve been transported to a little slice of Italy!

And of course, no Italian-style meal would be complete without an extensive selection of wines to choose from. Whether you want a robust red or a crisp white, Fratelli’s Pizza and Cafe has something for everyone. Their expert sommeliers will even help you pick out the perfect accompaniment for your meal.

All in all, Fratelli’s Pizza and Cafe definitely lives up to its hype as being the best pizza in Wesley Chapel—well worth checking out!

#6 MOD Pizza

The atmosphere was inviting and the staff were super friendly and knowledgeable. The setup was great too, as I could customize my own pizza exactly how I wanted it. The fresh ingredients were of the highest quality – no skimping here!

As for the pizza itself… wow, just wow! It was cooked perfectly with a nice crunchy crust and plentiful toppings. The cheese was especially delicious – buttery, melty goodness. It seriously rivaled some of the best pizzas I’ve had in Italy!

I can’t recommend MOD Pizza enough to anyone looking for the best pizza in Wesley Chapel. Stop by on your next visit – you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Bosco’s Italian To Go

The first bite of the pizza was a bit of a surprise – it was unlike anything I had ever tasted before. The crust was crisp and delicious, and the tomato sauce that topped it off added just the right amount of flavor. The cheese was also very flavorful, with a nice balance between mozzarella and parmesan.

The toppings were nicely balanced as well, with generous amounts of pepperoni, salami, mushrooms, peppers and onions. Everything was cooked to perfection – no mushy vegetables or greasy meats here!

And let’s not forget about the customer service: everyone at Bosco’s Italian To Go is friendly and welcoming. Not only did they take my order quickly and efficiently, but they also made sure that everything we ordered was perfect.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Wesley Chapel, then look no further: Bosco’s Italian To Go is where it’s at!

#8 Mellow Mushroom Wesley Chapel

The atmosphere at Mellow Mushroom is always inviting and relaxed. From the friendly staff to the funky decor, you can’t help but feel at home here. I especially love their selection of beers on tap, which gives me an excuse to stay longer and enjoy more slices.

But what truly makes Mellow Mushroom stand out from all the other pizza places I’ve had the fortune of trying is their unique set of signature pizzas. With ingredients that range from pineapple to jalapeño peppers to bacon, they create a combination of flavors like no other. Not to mention their thin crust is perfectly cooked each and every time!

My favorite pie so far was their Mighty Meaty pizza, with sausage, pepperoni, ground beef, ham, applewood smoked bacon and mozzarella cheese. The combination of savory meats and creamy melty cheese was utter perfection.

To sum it up, if you’re looking for some great pizza in Wesley Chapel then look no further than Mellow Mushroom!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Tampa!

#9 Bubba’s 33

I was initially hesitant to try it since they don’t offer delivery, but after visiting I’m glad I made the journey. From the moment I stepped through the door I was taken aback by how incredible the atmosphere was. The staff is friendly, helpful, and accommodating.

The main attraction at Bubba’s 33 is, of course, their pizza! They have a great variety, from classic cheese to custom pies loaded with your favorite toppings. Their crust is thin and crispy yet still manages to maintain an airy fluffiness that leaves you wanting more.

But there’s more to love about Bubba’s 33 than just the pizza – they serve alcohol (and hard liquor!), have a kid’s menu for younger guests, and dessert options for those with a sweet tooth. It’s also a great tourist spot as well as a great place to watch sports on their huge HDTVs!

In conclusion, Bubba’s 33 has not only earned itself a place amongst some of the best pizza in Wesley Chapel but also my highest recommendation!

#10 New York New York Pizza

I knew as soon as I stepped foot in the restaurant that it was going to be a pizza-lover’s paradise. The smells were heavenly and the decor was inviting.

The wait staff was friendly and efficient, so we were able to get our food quickly without sacrificing quality.

When our pizzas arrived, they were nothing short of fantastic. The slices were sufficiently large and filled with a perfect combination of tomato sauce, cheese, and toppings. The crust was just right – not too thick or thin!

My favorite part of the experience was the atmosphere though. Our server was constantly checking on us with a smile and making sure we had everything we needed while the music in the background created an upbeat yet comfortable atmosphere.

You can’t beat New York New York Pizza for the best pizza in Wesley Chapel!

#11 Pizza Mania

My first impression of Pizza Mania was that it had a very inviting atmosphere. The restaurant was bright with lively decor and friendly staff. As I looked around, it seemed the other customers were just as content by the look on their faces!

I ordered the classic Margherita pizza and it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly cooked to a golden brown and had a light airy texture. Topping it off were slices of delicious, vine-ripened tomatoes swimming in melted mozzarella cheese. Delicious!

The experience at Pizza Mania would have been incomplete without tasting one of their signature creations – the “Pizza Mania Special”, which is loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and onions. I took my first bite into this masterpiece and was immediately taken away from the ordinary tastes of Wesley Chapel pizza places. It was like a flavor explosion in my mouth!

In conclusion, Pizza Mania has certainly earned its place among Wesley Chapel’s best pizza restaurants. It offers a great selection of pizzas, both classic and creative, all made with fresh ingredients. Don’t take my word for it; go ahead and try out Pizza Mania yourself – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Caprese Pizza House

I’m so glad I stopped here on my recent trip. The pizza was absolutely delicious – the perfect balance of flavor and texture. The thin, crispy crust was cooked to perfection, topped with fresh tomatoes and herbs, authentic mozzarella cheese, and a light drizzle of olive oil.

The service was outstanding as well – all of the staff were friendly and welcoming. They went out of their way to make sure my dining experience was enjoyable.

In addition to great pizza, Caprese Pizza House also has a wide selection of salads, sandwiches, pastas, and desserts that are sure to satisfy any craving. Not to mention the amazing outdoor patio area that is perfect for parties or just relaxing after enjoying your meal.

Overall, Caprese Pizza House has been one of my favorite pizza experiences yet. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for the best pizza in Wesley Chapel!