Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in West Seattle (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Washington

Best Pizza in West Seattle (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

203 Views

In my search for the best pizza in West Seattle, I visited 12 different restaurants. I’m here to tell you what I learned and which places serve up the most delicious slices!

If you’re looking for a light-hearted and humorous review of some of West Seattle’s finest pizza hotspots, then stick around. I promise to deliver an honest opinion of the places I visited – no matter how unpopular it might be!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Washington

#1 DUDE’Z woodfired pizza

The moment I walked into DUDE’Z, I could feel the warmth of the wood-fired oven and it was definitely inviting. The warm and friendly atmosphere made my dining experience even better.

I decided to try their classic Margherita pizza and let me tell you: it was delicious! Not only was the crust crispy and perfectly cooked, but the combination of tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, basil, and olive oil made for a perfect balance of flavor. It truly tasted like an Italian restaurant’s pizza.

To top it off, the service at DUDE’Z is extremely friendly – from the waitstaff to the cashiers – everyone was so hospitable!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in West Seattle, DUDE’Z Woodfired Pizza is definitely worth a visit!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Seattle!

#2 West of Chicago Pizza Company

I was delighted to find that this restaurant had a variety of vegetarian toppings available, and even a few speciality dishes. The wood-fired crust was thin and flavorful, not too thick and overly bready.

There’s no delivery option here though—which is a bit unfortunate—so be sure to plan ahead if you’re wanting to take pizza to-go!

The desserts are also worth mentioning: the house-made tiramisu was delicious!

All in all, West of Chicago Pizza Company is definitely worth checking out if you’re seeking the best pizza in West Seattle.

#3 MOTO

The atmosphere is lively, and the staff are eager to please. From the moment I stepped in line to order, everything was a pleasant experience. Even though there was a lot of people, I was waited on quickly and efficiently.

The pizzas here are truly one-of-a-kind! The crust is thin but crunchy with just the right amount of charring from the oven, which gives it that delightful rustic taste. Toppings are always fresh and flavorful – my personal favorite is their salami & pepperoni combo! Plus, their sauce has an absolutely amazing sweetness that really complements all of their flavors (just don’t ask me what’s in their special sauce – my lips are sealed!)

All in all, I’d give MOTO 5 stars for its delicious pizza and friendly service. If you’re looking for an excellent slice of pizza in West Seattle, this is definitely the place to go!

#4 Pizzeria Credo

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, with a romantic Italian vibe that’s perfect for date night. The food is nothing short of amazing. The crusts are perfectly thin and crispy while the toppings were flavorful and fresh. Plus they have just the right amount of cheese!

I was particularly impressed with the variety of toppings that Pizzeria Credo offers, ranging from classic favorites to some more unique offerings. I especially loved their signature sausage-pepperoni-mushroom pie. It was simply divine!

The service was also top-notch; my server was friendly and professional and really added to our experience at Pizzeria Credo.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience in West Seattle, look no further than Pizzeria Credo. Whether you’re out for an intimate dinner or just grabbing a slice with friends, I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#5 Mioposto Pizzeria

My first visit to Mioposto was a memorable one. From the moment I stepped through the door, I was awed by the décor and atmosphere – it had the feel of an old-school pizzeria and it smelled amazing!

I opted for the classic Margherita pizza and it did not disappoint. The crust was light, yet crispy, and each slice was loaded with fresh ingredients that were cooked to perfection. I’m confident that this is some of the best pizza in West Seattle.

The staff at Mioposto were wonderful too. There’s nothing quite like having a friendly face or two while enjoying great pizza, and they truly made me feel welcomed in their establishment.

If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, then you owe yourself a trip to Mioposto Pizzeria! It’s definitely one of my top choices when it comes to finding the best pizza in West Seattle.

#6 Breezy Town Pizza

What sets Breezy Town Pizza apart from the rest is its unique atmosphere. Not only does it serve alcohol, but it also has some great vegetarian options as well! In fact, I almost feel like I’m in a different country when I visit this place.

The downsides? Well, they don’t deliver. But if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in West Seattle and don’t mind taking the time to come down here, then you won’t be disappointed.

I highly recommend checking out Breezy Town Pizza!

#7 Talarico’s Pizzeria West Seattle

The first thing that struck me when I visited Talarico’s was the atmosphere. From the cozy booths to the fun, family-friendly vibe, it instantly felt comfortable and inviting – like being a part of an extended family.

But of course, the pizza itself is why I’m here. The dough is handmade in-house daily and has just the perfect amount of crunch and chew. As for toppings, I would have to say the classic pepperoni topped with fresh basil leaves is my favorite choice. The sauce is rich and tangy and oozes with flavor – definitely not your average pizza topping!

Since Talarico’s also offers a range of specialty pizzas, we decided to try one of those as well – an Italian-style pie with spicy salami and olives. It was delicious – the ingredients really complimented each other in creating a unique flavor unlike any other pizza I’ve had before.

Speaking of ingredients, Talarico’s takes its sustainability very seriously – all meat used in their pies is locally sourced, organic, and hormone-free. So you can rest assured that you’ll be getting tasty pie without worrying about where it came from!

All in all, if you’re looking for some truly delicious pizza in West Seattle then head on down to Talarico’s Pizzeria West Seattle – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Seattle!

#8 Peel & Press

First thing I noticed when I walked in was the incredibly inviting atmosphere. The staff were friendly, and the music playing was just the right type of vibes for a pizza joint.

The pizza… oh man! It’s hard to put into words how great it was. Perfectly thin crust with no soggy center and just the perfect amount of ingredients; so much that your taste buds will be singing with joy!

I had a few slices of their classic tomato and mozzarella pie and it was out of this world. For something more adventurous I tried the fig & prosciutto pizza which took my taste buds on a journey they won’t soon forget!

At Peel & Press they don’t skimp on any details. From the decor, to the music, to the pizza itself – everything is top-notch! If you’re ever in West Seattle my advice is to make a stop at Peel & Press and sample some of the best pizza you’ll find around here!

#9 A Pizza Mart

I went in there with an open mind, only to find out that they had some of the most delicious pizza I have ever tasted in my life. From the crunchy, brick-oven crust to the gooey cheese and savory toppings, I was blown away.

What made this pizza so special was its attention to detail. Every ingredient was perfectly balanced, not too greasy and not too dry. The toppings were hearty and flavorful without overpowering the taste of the rest of the ingredients. Plus, they offer a wide variety of options for those looking for something extra special.

The customer service at A Pizza Mart was top-notch as well! The staff were friendly and helpful, taking time to answer my questions and make sure I got exactly what I wanted.

Overall, from start to finish A Pizza Mart offers an amazing experience that truly stands out from all other pizzerias in West Seattle! Not only did I get some of the best pizza around but also fantastic customer service, making this restaurant my top pick for pizza lovers everywhere!

#10 MOD Pizza

I was impressed from the moment I walked in. The open kitchen was a refreshing change from the usual cramped spaces I’ve seen in other pizza places. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable – they even let me sample several different sauces before ordering.

The toppings were fresh and flavorful and the pizza itself was cooked to perfection – not too crispy, not too doughy. Even when I loaded up my pie with extra meat and vegetables, it still managed to be light and delicious without feeling heavy.

The key to MOD Pizza’s success is that they use quality ingredients and prepare each pizza with pride. The prices are also very reasonable considering the quality of their food.

Overall, MOD Pizza is definitely one of the best pizza places in West Seattle and makes for an amazing dining experience when you’re craving some good ol’ classic Italian-style pies!

#11 Proletariat Pizza

Let’s start with the basics: the crust. It’s soft and light, with just the right amount of texture. The toppings are always fresh and cooked to perfection, and their signature sauce is simply delicious.

But what sets Proletariat Pizza apart from other pizza places is its atmosphere. The decor is inviting and cozy, creating a fun and relaxing environment for friends to gather over great food. And the staff are some of the friendliest I’ve ever encountered in my travels – always eager to chat about their business or give recommendations.

Overall, Proletariat Pizza has definitely become my favorite spot for pizza in West Seattle. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or want to linger over dinner with friends, this place has something for everyone! I can’t recommend it highly enough – it’s definitely worth checking out!

#12 South Town Pie

When I visited, I was immediately won over by the cozy vibe of the restaurant. The décor evokes a sensory experience from the moment you enter, and it has really put South Town Pie on my map for great pizza.

The pizzas here are cooked up from scratch in an authentic brick oven with fresh, organic ingredients. To say their pies are delicious is an understatement! I had the Italian Specialty pizza with olives and mushrooms, and every bite was a new flavor experience. It’s honestly one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time.

The staff at South Town Pie is also very friendly and helpful. They always greet you with a smile and really care about making sure your visit is enjoyable.

If you’re looking for some truly amazing pizza, look no further than South Town Pie! The quality is top-notch, and I’d definitely recommend it to anyone who wants to enjoy some of the best pizza in West Seattle.

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Delfino’s Chicago Style Pizza

As a nomadic food critic, I have practically eaten my way through every corner of this planet in search of the perfect pie. And let me tell you, Delfino’s Chicago Style Pizza did not disappoint!

First off, let’s talk about the ambience. Delfino’s is not just a pizzeria, it’s a tourist destination! The walls are adorned with quirky Chicago memorabilia, making it feel like a mini trip to the Windy City. Plus, they serve alcohol! Who doesn’t enjoy a cold brew to wash down those cheesy delights?

Now, onto the main attraction – the pizza! The deep dish will blow your mind, and potentially your belt buckle. Each slice is a small treasure chest overflowing with cheese, fresh toppings, and a tomato sauce so rich it could make an opera singer blush. The crust is sturdy enough to support the weight of Mount Vesuvius, and the flavors are an explosion of deliciousness.

But here’s the kicker: Delfino’s also caters to vegetarians! You don’t have to be an herbivore to appreciate their delectable veggie options. Who knew you could have a deep dish pizza piled high with roasted veggies and still feel like you’ve been transported to pizza paradise?

However, there is one hiccup worth mentioning – Delfino’s does not accept reservations. So, if you’re a planner like me, be prepared to wait. But fear not, fellow pizza lovers, the wait is well worth it.

In conclusion, Delfino’s Chicago Style Pizza is not only a must-visit for pizza aficionados, but it’s also a prime spot for tourists seeking a slice of Chicago in the heart of Seattle. So grab your elastic-waist pants and get ready for a pizza experience like no other!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Serious Pie Downtown

As soon as I stepped foot into Serious Pie Downtown, my taste buds knew they were in for a treat. The aroma of fresh dough and melted cheese filled the air, making it impossible for me to resist ordering an entire pie for myself.

Now, let’s talk about the crust. Oh, that heavenly, crispy, thin crust! It had just the right amount of chewiness, allowing the toppings to shine without overwhelming the palate. I could tell this crust had been crafted with love and expertise, unlike the many lackluster imitations I’ve encountered on my pizza adventures.

And speaking of toppings, Serious Pie Downtown knows how to play with flavors. The combinations were out-of-this-world. From classic margherita to the more adventurous yukon gold potato with rosemary, each bite was a burst of happiness. They even dared to put Brussels sprouts on a pizza, and let me tell you, it was surprisingly delicious!

Now, let’s not forget the cheese. It was as if Serious Pie had tapped into some secret cheese vault because each slice was generously coated in a perfect, melty layer of pure cheesy joy. It was like a cheesy explosion in my mouth, and I couldn’t get enough.

To top it all off, the service was outstanding. The staff was knowledgeable, friendly, and had a great sense of humor. It was clear that they were as passionate about pizza as I am, and it was refreshing to see.

So, if you find yourself in Seattle craving the best thin crust pizza, look no further than Serious Pie Downtown. Trust me, it will take your taste buds on a joy ride that you won’t soon forget.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Serious Pie Downtown

From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with the smell of the heavenly wood burning oven that immediately transports you straight to pizza paradise. The crust is perfectly charred and just the right amount of crispy. I could spend all day just watching the skilled pizza makers effortlessly stretch and toss the dough – it’s like a mesmerizing pizza ballet!

Now, let’s talk toppings. Serious Pie Downtown doesn’t mess around when it comes to flavor combinations. They take their ingredients seriously (hence the name), but they also throw in a delightful twist. Who would have thought that Brussels sprouts and pancetta could be a match made in pizza heaven? Well, they did. And boy, does it work!

As a self-proclaimed cheese enthusiast, I must say that the selection at Serious Pie Downtown is drool-worthy. From the classic mozzarella to the rich and creamy fontina, they’ve got it all. And let’s not forget about the tangy goat cheese that adds that extra oomph to their white pizza creations. Each bite is a delightful surprise of cheese-induced happiness.

The staff at Serious Pie Downtown also has the perfect balance of friendliness and expertise. They’re always there to make recommendations and answer any pizza-related questions you may have. Plus, their jokes are cheesier than their pizzas – and I mean that in the best way possible!

So, if you find yourself in Seattle craving some seriously good wood fired pizza, look no further than Serious Pie Downtown. Your taste buds will thank you, and your pizza-loving soul will be forever grateful. Bon appétit!