I’ve tasted pizza from a dozen different places in the area, all of which have something special to offer! I’m here to tell you my top picks for the best pizza in Westchester County.
It was no easy task — I tasted everything from thin-crust Neopolitan style to thick-crust Sicilian style pizzas. But after much taste testing, I narrowed it down to 12 spots that really stand out. So if you’re looking for delicious pizza, this article is perfect for you!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York
#1 Arthur Avenue
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere of the restaurant is friendly and charming, and the staff couldn’t be more accommodating. The pizza itself was mouth-watering! Each slice had just the right amount of melted cheese, flavorful sauce and a perfectly crispy crust. It’s impossible to not indulge in an extra slice or two.
For those looking to switch it up a bit, Arthur Avenue also offers several other Italian dishes that are worthy of trying. From lasagna to calzones and subs, they have something for everyone (and their bellies!)
I’m convinced that Arthur Avenue should win an award for having the best pizza in Westchester County. If you haven’t been there yet, take my word – it’s worth checking out!
If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in White Plains!
#2 Utica Pie Co.
- Serves alcohol
Their signature square pies, made with fresh and flavorful ingredients, should be experienced by everyone. The crust at Utica Pie Co. is unbeatable – thin and a bit crispy, yet still chewy inside. Every bite brings a burst of flavor that’s hard to match elsewhere.
The friendly staff create a warm atmosphere to enjoy your pizza in. They are passionate about their pizza and take great care when making it – they even hand roll their own dough!
Utica Pie Co.’s unique toppings add an extra layer of deliciousness to the meal. You can find unusual combinations like ground beef, roasted red peppers, onions, and mozzarella or brussels sprouts, garlic oil and parmigiano-reggiano cheese. Yum!
If you haven’t tried Utica Pie Co.’s delicious pizzas yet, you’re missing out on some of the best pizza in Westchester County. So what are you waiting for? Get over there and start eating!
#3 Pizza Domo
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere of the restaurant is warm and inviting, and the staff are always friendly and helpful. The menu offers a wide variety of pizzas – classic Neapolitan, deep-dish Chicago style, delicious Detroit square pies, flavorful New York-style slices, and more!
The pizzas are all carefully crafted with fresh ingredients. They use high-quality cheeses from Italy, homemade sauces from some of the best Italian chefs in town, and they bake the pizzas to perfection in their wood fired ovens.
I’m still getting over how delicious their signature Margherita pizza was – it was full of salty olives, juicy tomatoes and melted mozzarella. It tasted like I’d transported back across the pond to Naples.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Westchester County, Pizza Domo is definitely your place!
#4 Pizzarelli’s Pizza & Pasta
- Offers dessert
Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately blown away by the atmosphere. There’s an old-school charm about the place, complete with red and white checkered tablecloths and a large stone oven at the center of the restaurant.
The menu is full of delicious options, from classic Neapolitan pizzas to more creative pies like their famous charred eggplant and feta pizza. And of course, they also have lots of pasta dishes to choose from.
I decided to go for a classic pizza margherita, and it did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly crispy yet fluffy and the sauce had just a hint of sweetness that really made this pizza stand out. To top it off, they used only fresh ingredients that gave the pizza extraordinary flavor.
In addition to great food, Pizzarelli’s Pizza & Pasta has a great selection of wine and beer. Their waitstaff is friendly and attentive as well, so you can be sure your meal will be taken care of without any hassle whatsoever.
All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Westchester County (or really anywhere!), definitely check out Pizzarelli’s Pizza & Pasta. You won’t regret it!
#5 Victor’s Pizza & Pasta
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere at Victor’s is one of the best parts about the experience. It was like stepping into a home away from home: warm, cozy and inviting. The staff was friendly and welcoming, which made for a great dinning experience.
The pizza itself was heavenly! The artisan crust was perfectly thin, crisp and chewy – perfection! But it doesn’t end there – they had a wide selection of amazing toppings to choose from: fresh vegetables, succulent meats and savory cheeses. I especially loved the homemade sausage they use on their pies – it really takes their pizzas to the next level!
Overall, I would definitely recommend Victor’s Pizza & Pasta to all of my friends looking for a great evening out with truly world-class pizza. In my opinion, this is the best pizza in Westchester County–maybe even all of New York!
#6 Pizzeria La Rosa
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
On my most recent trip, I ordered their signature La Rosa Special pizza. It was a masterpiece. The cheese was perfectly browned, the crust was light and crisp, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. The presentation of this pizza alone was enough to make me come back for more!
The atmosphere of the restaurant is great as well – it’s decorated with classic Italian decor like red-and-white checkered tablecloths and old Italian movie posters. Even if you don’t speak Italian, the servers are friendly and helpful and make sure you have everything you need.
I highly recommend Pizzeria La Rosa for anyone looking for great pizza in Westchester County. Whether you’re traveling from far away or just around town, you won’t be disappointed – this pizza is definitely worth the trip!
#7 Stagioni
- Serves alcohol
- Offers dessert
From the moment I walked in, I was taken with the cozy atmosphere and warm service. The restaurant is decorated with photographs of old-world Italy, giving it a romantic and classic charm that’s perfect for date night. And the pizza? It’s some of the best I’ve ever had!
The crust is thin and crispy, just the way I like it. And the toppings are generous – they don’t skimp! Plus, they have a really delicious selection of specialty pies, so even regulars will never be bored.
And if you’re looking for something to drink, Stagioni has a great selection of Italian wines and craft beers.
In conclusion, this is not just one of the best pizzas in Westchester County – it’s one of the best pizzas in all of America. From its cozy atmosphere to its amazing food, Stagioni is definitely worth a visit!
#8 Pelham Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
The atmosphere is inviting and cozy, with a delicious smell of fresh pizza in the air. The staff was polite and friendly. It’s clear they take pride in their work – I could tell from the start that the pizzas were going to be top notch!
When I took my first bite, I knew I had found something special. The perfect crunch of the crust mixed with that unmistakable flavor of homemade Italian sauce was a heavenly combination. No ingredient was left out; it was evident from its perfectly balanced flavors that this pizza was made with care and skill.
The topping combinations were creative and incredibly flavorful; each bite seemed to bring out a new taste sensation. From the classic pepperoni to more unique options like roasted zucchini, eggplant, and smoked scamorza cheese, there’s something for everyone at Pelham Pizza – even the pickiest pizza connoisseur!
I’d say without a doubt that Pelham Pizza easily serves up some of the best pizza in Westchester County – if not beyond! If you’re ever looking for an amazing slice, look no further than Pelham Pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Scarsdale!
#9 Italia Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
I was truly blown away by the variety of options they have on their menu. From traditional pizzas to speciality pies, there’s something for everyone. My favorite was their legendary “Toscano”, with it’s perfectly cooked crust and perfectly balanced blend of flavors.
The atmosphere is also worth noting – it really does feel like you’re in Italy! The decor draws you in with classic Italian style and the staff are always friendly and helpful.
Overall, this place serves up some of Westchester County’s best pizza and I highly recommend stopping by if you’re ever in the area. From the tasty food to the wonderful service, Italia Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant is a real winner in my book!
#10 Abatino’s
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
I went to Abatino’s recently and was not disappointed. The pizza was perfectly cooked and the ingredients were fresh. The toppings had an amazing blend of flavors, making each bite as delicious as the last.
What really stood out to me, however, was the atmosphere. The casual dining space was filled with vibrant colors and great conversation, making it a truly enjoyable experience. It felt like I stepped into another world!
The friendly staff kept the place running smoothly while providing great service throughout the night. This made the meal even more enjoyable as my questions were answered quickly and efficiently.
Overall, if you are ever looking for some of the best pizza in Westchester County then look no further than Abatino’s! I highly recommend it for anyone looking for an amazing culinary experience combined with a fun atmosphere.
#11 Sal’s Pizza Mamaroneck
- Serves alcohol
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
I’ve had my fair share of pizza all over the world, but I was pleasantly surprised when I tried Sal’s Pizza Mamaroneck. The sauce is rich and perfectly seasoned, the cheese is just the right amount of creamy, and the crust is light and airy. It definitely hit all the right notes for me!
Besides serving up delicious pizzas, Sal’s also has a great atmosphere. The staff are friendly and helpful, always willing to help you figure out what kind of pizza would be best for you. Plus, they serve traditional Italian dishes like Calzones and Arancini that will make your mouth water.
To top it all off, Sal’s Pizza Mamaroneck also offers some pretty amazing cocktails – perfect for washing down one of their delicious pies! All in all, a visit to Sal’s Pizza Mamaroneck will guarantee you a positive experience with some of the best pizza in Westchester County.
#12 Venice Pizza & Trattoria
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Great place to watch sports
When I first stepped inside, I was taken aback by the atmosphere of the restaurant. The walls were adorned with pictures from Venice, Italy and the staff were friendly and welcoming. It was clear that they take pride in their work and wanted to provide me with a wonderful experience.
The menu had an impressive array of pizza flavors, but I decided to go with my favorite: pepperoni. The pizza was absolutely delicious; the crust was thin and crispy, while there just the right amount of toppings on top. I could tell that the kitchen team had put a lot of effort into creating this perfect pie. Every bite was more flavorful than the last!
Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Westchester County, look no further than Venice Pizza & Trattoria. The atmosphere is inviting and fun and the food is simply amazing!
