Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Westchester NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Westchester NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

711 Views

But of course, I have to taste the best of the best! So, out of the twelve pizza places I tried in Westchester NY, I think I can finally declare a clear winner.

This article takes an inside look into my experiences with each pizzeria and why one stands out among the rest in terms of flavor, quality and texture.

So if you’re looking for an amazing slice (or even just some cheesy bread sticks) in Westchester NY, this is your go-to guide! Join me as I dive deep into finding the most delicious pie in town!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Arthur Avenue

I was greeted by the warm and friendly staff, and couldn’t help but admire the delicious aromas that filled the room. I had heard about Arthur Avenue’s reputation for having some of the best pizza in Westchester NY, so I was really excited to try it!

The pizza itself was fantastic – it had a perfectly crispy crust that was full of flavor and the toppings were generous and flavorful. The flavors all blended together wonderfully, making this one of my most enjoyable pizza experiences to date.

The service at Arthur Avenue was top notch as well – everyone from the kitchen staff to the front-of-house team was friendly and accommodating. I never felt rushed or ignored, which really made me feel like a valued customer.

Overall, if you’re looking for an incredible meal with excellent service in Westchester NY, look no further than Arthur Avenue. Trust me when I say that you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in White Plains!

#2 Pizza Domo

I arrived at Pizza Domo in awe of its inviting atmosphere, and I knew I was in for a delicious meal. The staff was kind and helpful, and the wait time from arrival to consumption was surprisingly short.

When the pizza arrived, my taste buds were tingling! The pizza crust was thin and crispy, yet comforting and chewy. And the sauce! Oh dear lord, the sauce – it was so flavorful with hints of garlic, oregano, and tomatoes swimming together in harmony. All of this combined with melted cheese that just oozed out with every bite made me regret not coming here sooner.

I’m happy to report that Pizza Domo is living up to its reputation as one of the best places for pizza in Westchester NY. Whether you are looking for a quick bite or a sit down dinner, Pizza Domo will surely leave your tastebuds happy!

#3 Pizzarelli’s Pizza & Pasta

I arrived on a Saturday evening with high expectations and I can confidently say that Pizzarelli’s Pizza & Pasta exceeded them. The atmosphere was inviting, with a brick oven in the center of the restaurant and pictures of Italy adorning the walls.

The menu was quite impressive, boasting delicious hand tossed pies, calzones, and strombolis. After much deliberation, I decided on the classic Margherita pizza and it did not disappoint! The dough was light and airy with just enough crunch around the edges. The sauce was perfectly sweet and balanced by a generous helping of cheese that clung to every bite. The basil sprinkled on top added some nice herbal notes which made for a very tasty combination.

All in all, Pizzarelli’s Pizza & Pasta is worth every penny – and I highly recommend it as one of the best pizzas in Westchester NY! A big thumbs up from this food critic!

#4 Utica Pie Co.

The atmosphere is great – you feel like you are in a cozy little pizza joint, with the delicious smell of pizza in the air. The staff are friendly, knowledgeable and accommodating.

The menu has everything you could want in an Italian-inspired pizzeria – they have a wide selection of traditional and specialty pizzas that kept me coming back for more. I highly recommend the Buffalo Chicken Pizza with mozzarella, onion, garlic and a spicy buffalo sauce. It was so flavorful and just had the perfect amount of heat! If you like something a little more classic then go for the Margherita Pie with tomato sauce, fresh basil and shredded parmesan cheese.

I was also very impressed with how quickly the food arrives at your table. Everything was cooked to perfection and tasted just as good as it smelled.

Overall, Utica Pie Co. is truly one of the best pizza places I’ve ever been to – hands down! Their delicious food combined with their warm and inviting atmosphere makes this place worth every penny.

#5 Victor’s Pizza & Pasta

It was love at first bite. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy; the sauce had a nice kicked-up flavor with just the right amount of garlic; and the cheese melted like a dream. Plus, there were tons of amazing topping options, from spicy Italian sausage to zucchini spirals – my taste buds were in heaven!

Besides, the atmosphere at Victor’s Pizza & Pasta made the experience even better – it had this cozy, homey vibe with red checkered tablecloths and autographed celebrity photos on the walls. It really made me feel like part of the family.

To top it off, they serve beer and wine, so I can finally have a full meal and wash it all down with a cold one. That always makes everything more enjoyable! All in all, I highly recommend Victor’s Pizza & Pasta for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Westchester NY.

#6 Pizzeria La Rosa

The first thing that I noticed when I walked into Pizzeria La Rosa was the inviting atmosphere. The dining area was warm and cozy, and the staff was extremely friendly and accommodating.

When it came to the food, I wasn’t disappointed! The pizza crust was light yet crunchy and had a nice hint of garlic. Toppings were fresh and flavorful with just the right amount of cheese. Overall, this restaurant successfully perfected the art of pizza making!

But what really made this place stand out from other pizza places in Westchester NY were all the unique and interesting topping combinations that they offered. From my personal favorite – bacon & pineapple – to veggie-loaded options like mushroom & spinach, there was something for everyone!

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Westchester NY, look no further than Pizzeria La Rosa! With amazing food, friendly service, and creative toppings, you won’t be sorry you visited!

#7 Stagioni

The first thing that stands out about Stagioni is the atmosphere – it’s fun and lively, which makes for a great dining experience. The staff is friendly and helpful, and they serve up some seriously delicious pizza.

The crust here is thin but crunchy, cooked to perfection every time. Their specialty sauces are always flavorful and have just the right amount of kick. Toppings are creative, fresh, and abundant – like artichokes, olives, and mushrooms. Every slice I’ve had has been truly scrumptious!

I’ve tried their pizzas at lunchtime and dinner time – both are awesome experiences! The lunch special is a great deal: get two slices plus a soda or beer for only $10.00. Plus they have several vegetarian options if you’re looking for healthier choices.

Overall, I would highly recommend Stagioni to anyone looking for the best pizza in Westchester NY!

#8 Pelham Pizza

I had heard about this restaurant from a friend, but I was still skeptical. After all, how good could pizza be in a small town like Pelham? But boy, was I wrong!

As soon as I stepped into the place, I knew it felt different. The decor was welcoming and inviting—nothing like what you’d expect of a pizza joint.

Then, when my pie arrived at the table, my doubts were completely gone. This wasn’t just good pizza; it was amazing! The crust was perfection, with the perfect amount of crunch and flavor. On top of that, they had great toppings that really elevated each bite.

Finally, I have to mention the staff- everyone who worked there was so friendly and helpful. They made everyone feel welcome, which complemented the delicious pizza we were eating even more.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Westchester NY (or anyone for that matter), go check out Pelham Pizza. You won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Scarsdale!

#9 Gino’s Pizzeria

Upon entering Gino’s, I was instantly impressed by the atmosphere and decor. The exposed brick walls, checkered tablecloths and vintage chandeliers created a cozy atmosphere that I felt very welcome in.

The menu at Gino’s Pizzeria is impressive. With a wide variety of slices to choose from, there truly is something for everyone. After much deliberation, I decided on the “Gino’s Signature Supreme”, which came with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers and onions.

The pizza arrived piping hot and extremely flavorful! The dough was cooked to perfection; it was crispy on the outside and light and fluffy on the inside. The toppings were an abundance of deliciousness – juicy pepperoni, savory sausage, fresh mushrooms and crisp vegetables all balanced perfectly together with a generous helping of melted mozzarella cheese blanketed over the top. Needless to say, I left feeling completely satisfied!

In conclusion, my experience at Gino’s Pizzeria was nothing short of remarkable! This is undoubtedly some of the best pizza in Westchester NY and if you’re ever in town you must give it a try!

#10 Abatino’s

To kick off my experience, I sampled one of their delicious creations, the ‘Margherita Special’. It was a delight. The crust was thin and crisp with a slightly charred flavor from the brick ovens. The sauce was perfectly sweet and savory, and the cheese was deliciously melty with just the right amount of gooeyness.

For something a bit heartier, I tried their ‘Sausage and Pepperoni’ pizza topped with spicy pepperoni, crumbled Italian sausage and lots of mozzarella cheese. It had everything – spice, texture, flavor – you name it!

If that wasn’t enough to be impressed by, Abatino’s also offers an array of creative daily specials like Hawaiian BBQ pizzas and goat cheese-arugula masterpieces. The pies have all been cooked to perfection in the large wood-burning ovens they have on site.

Overall, if you’re looking for some true Neapolitan pizza in Westchester NY then Abatino’s is definitely your place to go! With attentive service and flavorful pies, there is no doubt that this place is sure to wow even the pickiest of eaters.

#11 Italia Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant

The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the smell of freshly baked pizza wafted through the air. I knew I was in for a treat before even taking my first bite!

What sets Italia Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant apart from other pizza restaurants is their commitment to using only top quality ingredients, as well as their brick ovens. The pies turn out perfectly cooked with a crispy crust every time. The toppings are always fresh and tasty too, making it hard to choose just one!

The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, and they are more than willing to offer suggestions or advice on what pizza would best suit your tastes. This shows that they really care about the experience of their customers.

I can honestly say that Italia Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant has some of the best pizza in Westchester NY! I highly recommend giving it a try – you won’t be disappointed.

#12 Sal’s Pizza Mamaroneck

From the moment I walked in, I was overwhelmed by the mouthwatering aromas that filled the restaurant. The owner himself, Sal, greeted me with a warm smile and offered me a slice of his signature pie. His passion for pizza was evident in every bite!

I tried everything on their menu and each dish was as delicious as the last. The crust was thin and crisp and the toppings were flavorful and fresh. My favorite was the classic margherita pizza – the perfect balance of tomatoes, basil, garlic, and mozzarella cheese.

The service was friendly and attentive throughout my meal. Sal took the time to explain each recipe to me and offered suggestions from his own years of experience making pizza. He even brought out some samples of new recipes he had been experimenting with!

Overall, I can honestly say that Sal’s Pizza Mamaroneck has some of the best pizza in Westchester NY – you won’t be disappointed if you visit!