After rigorous testing of twelve pizza places in the area, I’m confident that you can find some great choices here. Since I take my pizza seriously, but try to approach it with a sense of humor, I’m excited to share which pizzerias are the best of the best.
So roll up your sleeves and get ready to indulge in the deliciousness because I’m about to show you the Best Pizza in Wildwood Crest!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 JoJo’s Famous Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
I was first drawn to JoJo’s Famous Pizza by its old-timey vibe. The restaurant had a charming atmosphere, with décor of classic 1950s diner vibes.
I ordered the classic Pepperoni Pizza, and within minutes it was fresh out of the oven! The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, and their signature seasonings added a nice kick to each bite. The cheese was nicely melted and the pepperonis were salty and juicy.
The service here is top notch too–the wait staff is friendly and helpful, and my pizza appeared in less than 10 minutes! On top of that, prices are more than fair for such delicious food.
In conclusion, I highly recommend JoJo’s Famous Pizza for anyone looking for great pizza in Wildwood Crest–it’s definitely one of the best I’ve ever had!
If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Wildwood!
#2 Crazy Junky
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
The pizza crust is a work of art – it’s thin, but still manages to hold up the generous portion of toppings. The cheese is perfectly melted and goes perfectly with the flavorful spicy tomato sauce that adds a great kick to the pizza. My favorite pies at Crazy Junky are their specialty pizzas; the “Hawaiian” is an explosion of sweet and savory flavors.
The atmosphere of Crazy Junky is unmatched in Wildwood Crest. It’s a little bit wild, a lot of fun, and definitely brings out the crazy in everyone! The walls are adorned with artwork from local artists and there’s almost always lively music playing throughout the restaurant, no matter how busy it is.
When most people think about Wildwood Crest, they don’t think great pizza — but I’m here to tell you that Crazy Junky has some of the best pizza in town. If you’re looking for a fun night out or an amazing meal that will leave you wanting more, then look no further than Crazy Junky!
#3 Steak ‘Em-Up
- Nice tourist spot
To start off with, their crust is perfect. It’s light and crunchy, just like it should be and the flavor is spot-on every single time. Plus, they offer a range of toppings to choose from so you can always find something that fits your taste buds.
The sauce is savory and delicious without being overpowering. They use fresh ingredients throughout and the pizza comes out piping hot – never soggy or rubbery!
The staff at Steak ‘Em-Up are incredibly friendly too, which makes eating there even more enjoyable. The restaurant itself is cozy and inviting and creates a welcoming atmosphere.
All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Wildwood Crest, look no further than Steak ‘Em-Up!
#4 Poppi’s Brick Oven Pizza & Kitchen
- Serves alcohol
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
The atmosphere was inviting, the staff friendly and knowledgeable, and the pizza was out of this world — a perfect blend of fresh ingredients, homemade sauce, and bubbling cheese.
The selection of pizzas are something to marvel at — from classic margheritas, to outrageous toppings like pineapple and jalapeños. I’m sure you can find a pizza for any taste here.
But it’s not just about the toppings here. The crust was light and crispy yet held up to the delicious toppings! Plus, it wasn’t greasy or soggy…this is pizza done right!
If you’re looking for top-notch pizza in Wildwood Crest, Poppi’s Brick Oven Pizza & Kitchen is hands-down your best option!
#5 Piro’s Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
From the first bite of their delicious crust, I knew this place was something special. Their classic tomato sauce has a nice kick and the cheese provides a gooey finish to every slice that is really out of this world.
The toppings take the pizza to another level though. My favorite is their sausage, pepperoni and onion combo — it’s truly a work of art! The meat is cooked perfectly with just enough spices and sweetness to fill your taste buds with pleasure. The onions give it an extra crunch that really adds to the symphony of flavors in your mouth.
I would be remiss if I didn’t mention Piro’s secret ingredient: fresh basil on the top. It ties everything together perfectly and leaves a pleasant aroma in the air.
At the end of the day, I can honestly say that Piro’s Pizza makes some of the best pizza in Wildwood Crest. If you’re looking for great pizza, look no further than Piro’s!
#6 Italian Kitchen Express
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
I have a soft spot for Italian food, so I was delighted to find this place. The pizza is handcrafted and made with fresh ingredients, giving it a unique flavor. The crust is thin but still crispy, and the toppings are always generous and delicious. Plus, their combination of complimentary flavors – from the sauce to the cheese to the salami – really gave my tastebuds a treat!
The atmosphere at Italian Kitchen Express was also delightful. Not only does it have the feel of an authentic Italian restaurant, but it has a welcoming family-friendly vibe that makes everyone feel welcome. What’s more, the staff treated us like old friends instead of new customers – they even took our order in under two minutes!
All in all, I’d say that Italian Kitchen Express serves up some of the best pizzas around Wildwood Crest. If you’re looking for tasty pizza that’s worth every penny, be sure to check out this friendly little spot!
If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in West Cape May!
#7 Santucci’s Original Square Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
From the moment I stepped into their cozy Italian café, I knew my taste buds were in for a treat. As I looked around the room, it seemed like even the other diners couldn’t help but smile with anticipation for what was to come.
As soon as my pizza arrived, it was clear why everyone here was so excited – this stuff is delicious! The thin, crisp crust was perfectly cooked and had great flavor. The sauce was flavorful and just the right amount of sweetness. And of course, no pizza would be complete without lots of cheese — they use a generous helping here at Santucci’s.
I’ve tasted pizza all over the world and I can confidently say that this place serves up some of the best pizza in Wildwood Crest! If you get the chance to visit Santucci’s Original Square Pizza, don’t miss out on this delicious experience.
#8 Anthony’s Pizzeria & Ice Cream Parlor
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
My first visit to Anthony’s Pizzeria & Ice Cream Parlor was an experience I won’t soon forget. I mean, who else has the guts to combine pizza and ice cream into one establishment? Not only do they serve up delicious pizza pies, but they also have a wide assortment of homemade ice cream. I can see why locals swear by this place – it’s a one-stop shop for all your cravings!
But let’s talk about the pizza. The crust is thin, yet sufficiently crispy and chewy. Each pie is generously topped with fresh ingredients that are sure to please even the pickiest palate. And if you want something extra special, you can create your own custom-made pizza with whatever combination of toppings you’d like!
The staff at Anthony’s Pizzeria & Ice Cream Parlor is also top-notch – friendly and accommodating without fail. They provide great service no matter how busy it gets. Plus, they offer delivery on certain days which makes getting their delicious pies a breeze if you don’t feel like dining in.
Bottom line: Anthony’s Pizzeria & Ice Cream Parlor makes some of the best pizza in Wildwood Crest. Whether you dine in or order delivery, you’re sure to enjoy every bite!
#9 Little Nicky’s Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
I’m not sure how they do it but the slices at Little Nicky’s really hit the spot. The crust is perfect – crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside, and I’m always impressed with just how generous they are when it comes to topping each slice.
The atmosphere at Little Nicky’s is my favorite part. It truly feels like you’ve stepped into an Italian pizzeria with its red and white checkered tablecloths, traditional Italian music playing from speakers and a friendly staff that will make you feel right at home.
And lastly, the prices at Little Nicky’s Pizza are unbeatable! No matter what type of pizza you’re in the mood for, there’s a size, taste and price that will fit your budget.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Wildwood Crest, then look no further than Little Nicky’s Pizza!
#10 Dolce Italia
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has insanely good dessert
I was truly impressed with their crust – it was the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. The sauce had just the right amount of flavor and spice, and the cheese was freshly grated right in front of me.
The toppings were top notch as well. Everything that I tried was delicious – juicy peppers, flavorful sausage, and mushrooms so fresh they may as well have been picked from a nearby forest!
As if all that weren’t enough to make this restaurant stand out, their friendly staff made sure I felt at home the entire time. They went above and beyond to ensure my experience was enjoyable from start to finish – even packing me up a few slices for the road.
If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, look no further than Dolce Italia!
#11 Mr D’s Pizzeria Steaks & Subs
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
The crust is the perfect combination of crispy and chewy, and the sauce has a deep flavor that can only come from the freshest tomatoes. The cheese is bubbly, gooey, and melts in your mouth.
Their menu offers an extensive selection of authentic Italian pizzas as well as more unusual options like steak and shrimp pizzas. No matter your pizza preference, there’s something for everyone at Mr D’s!
What really sets this place apart is their special house pizza. It’s loaded with peppers, onions, mushrooms, sausage, and bacon. If you’re looking for a pizza that packs a flavorful punch, this should be your go-to choice!
To top it all off, the staff at Mr D’s are friendly and accommodating. They make sure to get your order right every time. And if you’re looking for something to wash down that perfect slice of pizza? They have an extensive selection of craft beer on tap! All in all, it truly is the best pizza in Wildwood Crest!
If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Avalon!
#12 Domino’s Pizza
My first experience at Domino’s Pizza was exceptional. From the moment I stepped inside, the atmosphere was warm and inviting. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable, and they seemed to love their job!
The pizza itself was delicious. It had a nice thin crust that was cooked perfectly, and all of the ingredients were fresh and flavorful. The toppings were plentiful and included items like cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers – you name it! My favorite part was the tangy tomato sauce that tied everything together perfectly. Yum!
I also enjoyed Domino’s menu options. They have a variety of specialty pizzas like Hawaiian, Buffalo Chicken, Meat Lover’s – something for everyone! Plus they offer salads, wings, desserts, milkshakes – you can really make a meal out of it.
What can I say? Domino’s Pizza is truly living up to its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Wildwood Crest! If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience with great food and friendly service at an affordable price – look no further than Domino’s Pizza.
