Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Winter Garden (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Winter Garden (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

221 Views

I’ve sampled the offerings of twelve different pizza places in this Florida town, so you can trust me when I say I know the best of the best. Bring your appetite and your sense of adventure, because we’re about to embark on a delicious – and sometimes humorous – journey through Winter Garden’s pie paradise. The search for the most flavor-filled slice is on!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Bella Napoli Pizzeria

I can’t tell you how relieved I was to finally discover a pizza restaurant that lives up to my expectations. I’ve sampled some truly extraordinary pizzas during my travels, but Bella Napoli has created something even more remarkable.

First off, the atmosphere is fantastic – cozy, warm and inviting. The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful and the restaurant itself has an old-school charm about it that I simply adore. It almost feels like I’m eating in someone’s home!

The pizza is truly the star of the show here – the tomato sauce has just the right amount of sweetness and the crust is perfectly cooked with a crunchy yet tender texture. Every bite is bursting with flavor, from savory pepperoni to fresh basil, and they top it all off with a generous helping of mozzarella cheese!

I’d be hard-pressed to find better pizza in Winter Garden (or anywhere else for that matter!). Hands down, Bella Napoli Pizzeria deserves to be crowned king of the pizza places!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Clermont!

#2 SLIDDERS PIZZA

The place itself is unassuming and quaint, but the pizza is anything but. The menu is full of delicious options from classic Neapolitan-style to zesty white pizzas topped with arugula and feta. The crust always comes out perfectly bubbly and chewy, yet crunchy on the edges.

Service here is quick, and the staff are friendly. Though they don’t have a huge selection of beers or wine, what they do have pairs wonderfully with any pie you order.

But the best part has got to be their signature Sliders Pizza: a miniaturized version of a classic Italian pizza covered in fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and olives! It’s absolutely delightful!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Winter Garden, look no further than SLIDDERS PIZZA!

#3 MANGONI Italian Market Pizza

Having the opportunity to sit down in the restaurant, I can safely say that there’s something special about MANGONI. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it a great place for tourists to enjoy a meal. And if you’re looking for some liquid courage with your meal, they offer an array of alcoholic drinks as well!

The pizza was even better than expected. It was perfectly cooked with the perfect ratio of ingredients, so everything had its own unique flavor and worked wonderfully together. As someone who has had plenty of pizza in his lifetime, I must say that this one definitely stands out from the rest.

The only downside was that delivery isn’t available. If you want to get a slice of this incredible pizza, you have to find time to visit their restaurant in person. But trust me – it will be worth it! Your taste buds will thank you after trying some of their amazing creations.

For those looking for something sweet after dinner, they also have a great selection of desserts to finish off your evening on a sweet note.

If you’re seeking the best pizza in Winter Garden, MANGONI Italian Market Pizza has got you covered!

#4 Joe’s Pizza

From the moment I walked into Joe’s Pizza, I could tell there was something special about it. The aroma of freshly baked pizza wafted through the air, and the helpful staff were eager to answer my questions about their ingredients and cooking process.

The pizzas themselves were nothing short of amazing! Each one had perfectly melted cheese with just the right amount of sauce (not too much, not too little). The crust was crunchy, but fluffy on the inside – exactly how it should be. There’s a reason why all of Winter Garden knows that Joe’s Pizza is the spot for some of t he best pies around – they really know what they’re doing!

I tasted every topping combination available and couldn’t have been more pleased. From traditional margherita to white pizza with ham and mushrooms – each slice had its own flavor and texture profile. Every bite was sensational! Surely this place must make their dough from scratch every single day because it sure tasted like it.

If you’re ever in Winter Garden looking for a great slice of pizza, do yourself a favor and swing by Joe’s Pizza. It’s definitely one of the best spots around for an unforgettable pizza experience!

#5 I Love NY Pizza & Subs

My first impression was of the pleasant atmosphere, complete with Italian music playing in the background. I loved the decor and how warmly they treated me – it was like I was family!

When it came to the main event, the pizza did not disappoint. The crust had just the right amount of crunch and flavor, while the sauce was full of complex nuances that kept me coming back for more. As for toppings, they were generous in their portions, so much so that I ended up taking home leftovers!

The combination of flavors made this one of my favorite pizza experiences ever. I can honestly say that I Love NY Pizza & Subs has some of the best pizza in Winter Garden. Highly recommended!

#6 Winter Garden Pizza Company

The atmosphere in the restaurant is cozy and inviting, making it a great spot for a casual dinner. The wait staff are friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, so ordering is always an easy task.

The pizza itself is simply divine! The thin crust tastes like it was freshly made with the best ingredients available. The toppings are also top-notch, with creative and delicious combinations that make ordering a difficult decision. I particularly enjoyed the ‘Italian Gorgonzola’ which had Parmesan cheese, garlic, mushrooms and onions; all perfectly cooked to create an unforgettable flavor sensation.

I must say without hesitation that Winter Garden Pizza Company serves up some of the best pizza in Winter Garden! If you’re ever in the area, be sure to stop by – you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Italian Garden Pizzeria

The pizza here is so delectable that I was ready to move in and stay forever! The crust is perfectly thin and crunchy and the sauce is savory and full of flavor. Plus, they use the freshest ingredients that you can taste in every bite.

The service at Italian Garden Pizzeria is great too. The staff are very friendly, always offer a smile and take time to answer any questions about the menu or pizza ingredients. Overall, it’s clear that they love making their customers happy.

But what sets Italian Garden Pizzeria apart from all the other pizzerias? It’s their unique mix of flavors. They have a wide selection of toppings including unique cheese blends, roasted vegetables, and marinated meats. So no matter what kind of doughy craving you have, there’s a delicious pizza for everyone!

I’d highly recommend Italian Garden Pizzeria to anyone looking for the best pizza in Winter Garden – it certainly won’t disappoint!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Altamonte Springs!

#8 Domino’s Pizza

The crust was perfectly crisp, light and flavorful. The toppings were succulent and generous, and the sauce was just right—not too sweet and not too bland. As an added bonus, the cheese was melted to perfection, making it unbelievably gooey and delicious.

I quickly settled on a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese, but they have an amazing selection of other pizzas that I’m sure you’ll love. They have everything from classic pies like Philly Cheesesteak to specialties such as Hawaiian BBQ Chicken.

The atmosphere of Domino’s Pizza is also worth noting. It has a cozy, family-friendly vibe that made me feel right at home. The staff were all friendly and welcoming as well, which made for an even more enjoyable experience.

All in all, if you’re looking for great pizza in Winter Garden then Domino’s Pizza is definitely your best bet! Their pies are some of the tastiest around and I would highly recommend them for any pizza lover out there!

#9 Franco’s Pizzeria

I stopped by the quaint little pizzeria on a chilly winter evening and was greeted with a warm welcome from both the staff and oven. From the moment I walked through the door, it was clear that Franco’s had its priorities set in stone: quality before quantity.

The pizza is quite literally out of this world! The crust is thin and light, with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce has an intense flavor that makes you crave more with every bite. But what really made me say “wow” were the toppings – they’re freshly picked, organic and generously added ensuring each slice is like a flavor adventure.

It’s not just the food that’ll make sure you keep coming back for more though; Franco’s Pizzeria has some of the friendliest staff around who are always willing to go above and beyond for customers. They took a large amount of time when explaining each dish and even went out of their way to give me a few pizza-making tips!

Overall, Franco’s Pizzeria undoubtedly serves up some of the best pies around town and I definitely recommend them if you’re ever in Winter Garden looking for good pizza!

#10 Josie’s Pizza & Wings-Windermere

I was immediately impressed with how welcoming their staff were when I arrived. They offered me a cold glass of soda and some delicious garlic knots while I decided on which pizza to try. After much deliberation, I finally settled on the classic cheese pizza and boy was it good! The crust was light and airy with a nice chewy texture and the cheese melted perfectly along with the other flavors.

The wings were equally superb! Crispy exterior, juicy meat, and an intoxicating blend of spices that kept me coming back for more. Every bite had its own unique flavor experience that led me on a culinary journey to another world.

If you’re in Winter Garden looking for the best pizza around, look no further than Josie’s Pizza & Wings-Windermere! You won’t regret it!

#11 Domino’s Pizza

I was initially skeptical when I entered the restaurant, as I’d heard mixed reviews of their food. But after digging in, I can confidently say that Domino’s Pizza is the real deal.

Their crusts are perfectly crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside, and they’ve perfected the art of making a delicious sauce. Their toppings are generous, especially if you ask for extra cheese! From pepperoni pizza to their new Hawaiian specialty pizzas, there’s something for every palate.

I also have to give credit to Domino’s for their delivery options. It makes it easy for me to enjoy a slice or two without having to leave my hotel room! Plus, with their online ordering system, it’s easy to customize my pizza just how I like it with minimal hassle.

All in all, I’m glad that I finally got around to trying Domino’s Pizza in Winter Garden—it turns out it really is the best pizza in town!

#12 Michael’s Ali Coal Fired Pizza Winter Garden

I’ve tried a lot of pizza in my day, from Italy to New York City to the deep south, but Michael’s Ali Coal Fired Pizza Winter Garden has something special. The pizza crust is perfectly thin and crispy, with just the right amount of char from the coal-fired oven. And the toppings? Ahh, they are tantalizingly delicious. I may be biased, but I think their pepperoni and sausage combination is one of the best combinations I’ve ever tasted!

The service was friendly and attentive, so no complaints there either. The prices are also quite reasonable for what you get. Bottom line – if you’re in Winter Garden and looking for a great pizza place, Michael’s Ali Coal Fired Pizza Winter Garden is definitely worth checking out!