Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Woodbridge NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Woodbridge NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

152 Views

I’m sure they don’t rival the best of Italy, but if you’re in the area and looking for something close to authentic Italian pizza then you are in luck!

The pizza culture here is quite excellent, and I’ve had the pleasure of trying twelve different places. All were pretty good, but only a few have earned top honors on my list.

This article will share my thoughts on the best pizza in Woodbridge NJ, using my two decades of experience as a food critic to narrow down the options.

Come take a tasty trip with me through Woodbridge’s pizza scene – it’s sure to be delicious!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Milanos Pizzeria

Upon entering the restaurant, I was welcomed with a warm, inviting atmosphere. The staff were friendly and welcoming and the decor was modern yet rustic at the same time.

As for the pizza itself, it was nothing short of amazing! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, while the sauce had just enough zing to give it some extra flavor. The cheese melted just right, and they offered a wide variety of toppings that you could choose from.

But what really made this experience stand out was their attention to detail. They simply put in more effort than some other restaurants I’ve visited when it comes to presentation and plating. Everything about my meal looked like something out of a food magazine!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Woodbridge NJ then look no further than Milanos Pizzeria! It’s an experience that I’m sure you won’t soon forget!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Edison!

#2 Jersey Boys Kitchen

The atmosphere was perfect for a friendly gathering – with lively music in the background and the staff always eager to help. The pizza was so good that I didn’t want to leave! The restaurant was well-stocked with a variety of toppings and sauces, giving me plenty of options for creating my own custom slice. The crust was perfectly cooked and the cheese melted in my mouth like warm butter.

But what really impressed me were the unique toppings they had available! From bacon-wrapped shrimp to artichoke hearts and feta, there was something exciting on every slice. And not only that, but each piece was generously topped with quality ingredients that added just the right flavor. Plus, their signature pizzas boasted creative combinations – like their “Veggie Lover’s Delight” pie with eggplant, spinach, peppers and feta cheese!

I can confidently proclaim that Jersey Boys Kitchen serves up some of the best pizza in Woodbridge NJ! If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience with newfound flavors and classic favorites, this is definitely a place you should check out!

#3 Jersey Pizza Boys

On a recent trip, I decided to try out Jersey Pizza Boys’ delicious pies. Their menu included an array of options from classic Italian style pizzas to more inventive combinations like the Penne Alla Vodka Pie (which was my favorite!).

The crusts were crispy yet tender and full of flavor. The ingredients were fresh, flavorful and evenly distributed throughout. And their homemade sauces topped off every bite with a bold taste that really made the pizza stand out.

But what really set Jersey Pizza Boys apart wasn’t just the quality of their pizzas, but also the incredible service they provided. From the moment I arrived, I was welcomed by a friendly team who went out of their way to make sure I had everything I needed for a great experience.

Overall, Jersey Pizza Boys offers some of the best pizza in Woodbridge NJ! If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, look no further than Jersey Pizza Boys!

#4 Paone Pizzeria Restaurant

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately impressed with the wonderful atmosphere. The lights were dim and the tables were surrounded by brick walls, creating a cozy yet inviting atmosphere.

The menu at Paone Pizzeria Restaurant was extensive! There were so many options to choose from, it was difficult to decide which pizza to try first. After much deliberation, I opted for the classic pepperoni pizza.

When my pizza arrived at the table, I could tell it was going to be fantastic just by looking at it. The crust was cooked perfectly and the sauce had a delightful sweetness that balanced out the saltiness of the pepperoni. The cheese melted into a gooey deliciousness that made me want to eat every slice!

With each bite, I was surer than ever that Paone Pizzeria Restaurant has some of the best pizza in Woodbridge NJ. It’s definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in town and craving some great Italian food!

#5 Strawberry’s Pub & Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant was just as important to me as the quality of their food, and I must say that Strawberry’s Pub & Pizza did not disappoint! With its cozy, inviting feel and friendly staff, I felt right at home.

As for the pizza itself, I can honestly say it was some of the best I have ever tasted. The crust was crisp and perfectly cooked, with a great combination of flavors from the ingredients used. Topping wise, they had a great variety to choose from ranging from traditional toppings like pepperoni, mushrooms and olives to more unique toppings like pineapple and jalapeno. Every single slice was delicious and extremely satisfying.

Overall, I highly recommend Strawberry’s Pub & Pizza if you are looking for some truly exceptional pizza in Woodbridge NJ!

#6 Bennys Pizza

I’ve had a lot of pizza over my journey, and I’m not just saying that Bennys Pizza is the best; I have proof! When I placed my order for the cheese pizza, the owner, Benny himself, greeted me with a huge smile. He was passionate about his business and proud of the food he creates.

As soon as it arrived at my table, I could tell this was going to be good. The crust was perfectly crunchy yet doughy all at once. And the cheese! The cheese was an exquisite blend of provolone, mozzarella and white cheddar. It’s no wonder why Benny has so many loyal customers coming back every week!

On top of having some of Woodbridge’s best pizza, Bennys Pizza is also incredibly affordable. With prices cheaper than most fast-food joints in town, you get high-quality food at a fraction of the cost.

I can confidently say that Bennys Pizza is some of the best pizza in Woodbridge NJ and I highly recommend it to anyone passing through town looking for a delicious slice!

#7 Rocco’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere of Rocco’s Pizzeria is cozy and inviting. The large, wood-fired oven in the center of the restaurant is the centerpiece, and it’s a sight to behold!

The service at Rocco’s was great as well; everyone was friendly and eager to help. In addition to that, they make sure that every single pizza is cooked to perfection – if one isn’t up to their standards, they’ll remake it for you.

As for the pizza itself, it was absolutely amazing. All of their pizzas have flavorful sauces and a perfect ratio of cheese and toppings. I tasted some classic combinations like pepperoni and cheese, but their specialty pies are where they really shine. My personal favorite was the Four Seasons Pizza – layered with four different topping combinations, it’s definitely worth trying at least once!

All in all, Rocco’s Pizzeria serves some of the best pizza in Woodbridge NJ. If you’re looking for an outstanding pizza experience, look no further than Rocco’s!

#8 Ciro Pizza

The atmosphere is perfect: cozy, inviting and friendly. The staff greets everyone with a smile and excellent service.

On my first visit here, I ordered the classic pepperoni pizza. It was, quite simply, divine! The handmade dough had the perfect texture—crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside—and was complemented perfectly by the quality cheese and tasty pepperoni. And speaking of toppings, there are countless options to choose from. So if you’re feeling adventurous, give one of their unique specialty pizzas a try!

But Ciro Pizza isn’t just about great-tasting pizza; they also make some of the best garlic knots I’ve ever tasted. Soft and fluffy in texture with just enough garlic to give them a kick!

In conclusion, Ciro Pizza is hands-down one of the best places to get pizza in Woodbridge NJ. If you haven’t been yet, give it a try—you won’t be disappointed.

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Cranford!

#9 Menlo Pizzeria

On my first visit, I was totally blown away. The atmosphere was warm and inviting and the staff were friendly and helpful. The pizza itself was out of this world – the crust was thin and crisp, the sauce was rich and flavorful and the toppings were fresh and delicious. Every bite I took melted in my mouth!

The selection at Menlo Pizzeria is impressive too. From traditional pies to inventive creations topped with everything from bacon to pineapple, there’s something for everyone here. Plus, they have an amazing selection of calzones, strombolis, and hoagies that will make your taste buds dance!

The prices are also quite reasonable and you won’t have to break the bank to enjoy a memorable meal here.

All in all, I give Menlo Pizzeria a big thumbs up. It’s easily some of the best pizza in Woodbridge NJ that I’ve ever had – you definitely need to try it out!

#10 Dolce Pizzeria & Restaurant

Let me start by telling you about the decor. Though it’s not necessarily fancy and over-the-top, it definitely has a comfortable, inviting atmosphere that makes you feel like you’re right at home.

The menu is expansive and impressively varied, with plenty of options to choose from. I personally had the Spicy Chicken and Meat Lovers Special – a combination of creamy alfredo sauce, pepperoni, sausage, spicy chicken and mozzarella topped with parsley – and it was delicious! It’s clear that the dough is made freshly every day because it was light yet flavorful. Every bite was like a flavorful explosion in my mouth!

The service was also great. The staff were knowledgeable about their menu items and were able to quickly answer any questions I had about ingredients or cooking methods. Plus, they were incredibly friendly which made me feel even more at home in the restaurant.

Overall, Dolce Pizzeria & Restaurant has some of the best pizza that I’ve ever tasted – not just in Woodbridge NJ but around the world! If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience then this is definitely worth checking out.

#11 D’Italia Restaurant Pizzeria and Catering

The pizzas here have something special about them. The crust is always perfectly cooked, golden brown and crispy, the sauce is tangy but not too overpowering and the toppings are just right. It’s like visiting an Italian grandmother’s kitchen – you know it’s going to be good!

The atmosphere also adds to the experience. The restaurant has a cozy, rustic feel with red-checkered tablecloths, wood-panelled walls and classic Italian music playing in the background.

I must say I was particularly impressed by their service. Whether you’re dining in or ordering for delivery, the staff are friendly and prompt. They always make sure your order is exactly as you requested and that you’re getting the best pizza possible!

If you’re looking for some delicious, authentic Italian pizza in Woodbridge NJ then look no further than D’Italia Restaurant Pizzeria and Catering. In my opinion, it’s truly some of the best pizza around.

#12 Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

I recently had the pleasure of visiting this pizza restaurant and I must say, it was an experience like no other. From the moment I walked in, I could tell that this place was a cut above any other pizza joint around.

The restaurant itself has a cozy atmosphere; it’s warm and inviting and totally laid-back. The staff is friendly and helpful, which makes the entire experience even more enjoyable. Plus, the decor is simple yet impressive – all adding up to a great overall impression.

But what really set Anthony’s apart from the competition was their amazing pizza! Their coal-fired pies are cooked to perfection – with an authentically crisp crust that still manages to stay light and flaky inside. Additionally, their hand stretched dough was packed full of flavor and texture – nothing I’ve ever tasted before!

To top off my meal, I had one of their wings – smothered in garlic parmesan sauce with just the right amount of heat. Delicious!

So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Woodbridge NJ, look no further than Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings!