Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Zanesville OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Ohio

Best Pizza in Zanesville OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

106 Views

I had the pleasure of visiting twelve pizza places in Zanesville to sample their specialties. I’m a pizza connoisseur and can tell you that these establishments take their craft seriously! My mission was to find the best slice of ‘za, so expect this article to be humorous and lighthearted as I share my thoughts on these delicious pies. So, let’s get started on my search for the best pizza in Zanesville OH!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio

#1 Jobo’s Pizza

I stopped by on a Wednesday night to see what all the fuss was about and boy, was I not disappointed! The pizza was top notch. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the cheese melted nicely over the top and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

The service was great too. Despite being quite busy they had everything running smoothly. The wait staff were friendly and helpful and made sure to check on us frequently to make sure we had everything we needed.

But what really stood out above all else? THE SAUCE! It’s probably some of the best sauce I’ve ever tasted! Rich, flavorful, with just a hint of sweetness that balanced out all the other flavors perfectly. If you’re ever in Zanesville OH, get yourself down to Jobo’s Pizza for some of the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 27 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Newark!

#2 Weasel Boy Brewing Company

I visited the restaurant with some friends, and I’m happy to report that their pies really exceeded expectations. The crust was light and fluffy and all of the toppings were fresh. Plus, they had more than enough options for everyone to find something they liked.

The service was great too! Our servers were very friendly and helpful. We asked plenty of questions about the menu, which they answered quickly and professionally.

Another plus is that Weasel Boy Brewing Company serves alcohol, so if you’re looking for a good time along with your pizza, then this is the place for you!

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery services. But considering how delicious their pizzas are, it’s worth the extra drive to get it!

All in all, I highly recommend Weasel Boy Brewing Company as a great pizza option in Zanesville OH – definitely one of the best places around!

#3 Russo’s Wood Fired Pizza

The crust was cooked to perfection, and you could taste the wood-fired flavor in every bite. The cheese was evenly distributed and melted perfectly. There was also just the right amount of sauce – not too much to make it soggy, but enough to give it a great flavor.

The toppings were fresh and flavorful, ranging from pepperoni and sausage to olives and mushrooms. All in all, this pizza had a great combination of flavors that made for an enjoyable eating experience.

I even enjoyed the atmosphere at Russo’s Wood Fired Pizza despite my demanding food critic job – their friendly staff helped me feel relaxed throughout my meal! I will definitely be heading back there soon for some more delicious pizza!

#4 Tat’s Pizzeria

I have to admit, I was a little skeptical when I first stepped into Tat’s Pizzeria. It was quite small, and the décor had seen better days. However, my doubts soon faded when I tasted their mouthwatering pizza!

Their pizzas are perfectly cooked every time and come with a variety of toppings. The crust is crisp and flavorful, which adds to the overall experience. The cheese is always fresh and delicious and melts in your mouth like butter.

The service at Tat’s Pizzeria is top-notch too, with friendly waiters that make sure your pizza arrives at your table hot and ready to eat! Their prices are also really great and they provide generous portions.

Overall, if you’re ever in Zanesville OH looking for an amazing pizza experience, look no further than Tat’s Pizzeria! They definitely have some of the best pizza around!

#5 Picnic Pizza Italian Eatery

I started with their classic pepperoni pizza, which was cooked to perfection. The crust was light and airy, the pepperonis were nicely crisped, and the cheese was just the right amount of gooey. It’s definitely one of my favorites!

Next, I sampled their speciality Sicilian pizza. The sweetness of the tomato sauce was balanced with tangy olives and salty anchovies – it was an absolute delight!

Finally, I couldn’t resist trying the prosciutto and arugula pie. It has a more delicate flavor profile that pairs perfectly with the earthiness of the arugula; it’s one of those combinations that you don’t come across often in your local pizzeria.

I have to admit – Picnic Pizza Italian Eatery really takes their pies seriously.The quality of ingredients used is top notch and it shows in each bite. If you’re looking for some seriously good pizza in Zanesville OH, this is absolutely your best bet!

#6 Adornetto’s Selected Italian

The pizza was so delicious! The crust was the perfect blend of crunchy and chewy and the toppings were top-notch. I had the special which included sausage, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers and extra cheese – it was amazing! The sauce was also very flavorful with a hint of oregano that complemented every bite.

The atmosphere at Adornetto’s Selected Italian is also worth mentioning. It has a cozy vibe with its brick walls, candlelit tables and rustic decorations. Not to mention the friendly staff who make sure you’re taken care of throughout your meal.

Overall, I would highly recommend Adornetto’s for anyone looking for some great pizza in Zanesville OH. In my opinion, it’s by far the best pizza in town. Be sure to check it out – you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Donatos Pizza

From the crunch of the crust to the gooey cheese, Donatos Pizza is perfection on a plate. The crust at Donatos is light and fluffy with just the right amount of crispiness, never too thick or thin. The sauce is just about as perfect as it gets for pizza sauce — savory yet slightly sweet and made from quality ingredients. To top it off, their cheese is always fresh, melted to perfection and full of flavor.

Of course, a good pizza isn’t complete without great toppings, and Donatos Pizza definitely delivers in that department too. The pepperoni was spicy yet mild enough to enjoy while still delivering a big punch of flavor, while the mushrooms were juicy and not too slimy. Plus, they offer a variety of fantastic specialty pizzas like their Chicago-style deep dish pizza which is one of my favorites!

Overall, if you’re ever looking for some amazing pizza in Zanesville OH then you have to check out Donatos Pizza! Their combination of delicious toppings and perfectly cooked dough make them one of the best around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 33 miles, you can get to 8 more pizza places in Logan!

#8 Pizza Cottage

The first thing I noticed when walking into the restaurant was the cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. The decor was warm and inviting, with a country charm.

When it came time to order, I knew that I had to get the classic Pizza Cottage cheese pizza. It arrived piping hot and tasted especially incredible! The thin crust really enhanced the flavors of the tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and basil.

I also sampled some of their other specialty pies, such as their Mediterranean pizza covered in feta cheese, sun-dried tomatoes and olives – yum! Another noteworthy favorite is their “Taco Pie”, filled with refried beans, ground beef, salsa and melted cheese – definitely not your average slice!

Pizza Cottage is truly a hidden gem in Zanesville OH. Anyone searching for the best pizza around shouldn’t miss out on this spot – they won’t be disappointed!

#9 Fazoli’s

It all starts with their delicious crust. Each time I’ve had the pleasure of enjoying Fazoli’s pizza, I have been rewarded with a crispy and golden crust that is sure to please even the most discerning pizza lover.

The toppings are where Fazoli’s really shines, though. Delicious pepperoni, savory sausage, and juicy mushrooms come together to create an experience that can only be described as heavenly. The combination of meats, vegetables, and cheeses will make your mouth water!

To top it all off, Fazoli’s offers some of the most delicious sauces in Zanesville OH. Whether you’re a fan of classic marinara or you like to kick up the heat with spicy buffalo sauce, they’ve got something for everyone!

If you’re ever in the area and looking for great pizza, look no further than Fazoli’s. In my opinion they make some of the best pizza in Zanesville OH—perhaps even the world!

#10 The Barn

From the moment I stepped in the door, I knew I was in for something special. The wood-fired ovens give off a heavenly smell that wafts throughout the restaurant, and the staff were incredibly friendly and helpful.

The pizza itself was nothing short of amazing. The fresh ingredients they use are top notch, and it shows in every bite you take. The crust was especially good — thin and crisp with just the right amount of crunchiness.

But there’s more to The Barn than just their delicious pies! They also offer a selection of side dishes like garlic knots, macaroni and cheese, and stuffed mushrooms. All of them are cooked perfectly and really add something special to your meal experience.

Overall, The Barn is a great place to get a hot slice or two of pizza (or three!). Their service is top notch, the prices are very reasonable given the quality of food they provide, and their pies rank among some of the best I’ve encountered. Highly recommended!

#11 Maxwell’s Drive-thru & Pizzeria | Zanesville, OH

First, the atmosphere was great. All the staff were friendly and welcoming, which made me feel right at home. They had a large menu with lots of options – from classic cheese to more gourmet creations.

The pizza itself was delicious! The crust was nice and crispy, yet still light and airy. I tried several different combinations of toppings and all were incredibly flavorful – from the classic pepperoni to some unique favorites like feta and garlicky shrimp. Plus the portion sizes were generous: two people can easily feed off of one large pie.

Overall, I’d happily recommend Maxwell’s Drive-thru & Pizzeria | Zanesville, OH for anyone looking for tasty pizza in Zanesville OH! It’s definitely one of the best places around for savoring delicious slices.

#12 Creno’s Pizza East

The ambiance is always welcoming, the staff is friendly, and the pizza is to die for! The doughs and sauces are prepared fresh in-house every day, making sure that each slice is loaded with flavor. No matter what your preferences are, there’s something on their menu that will satisfy every craving.

My personal favorite has to be their classic pepperoni pie – it’s just the right amount of savory and salty with a hint of tanginess from the sauce. The crust was cooked to perfection as well – crunchy on the outside, yet still soft and chewy on the inside. Yum!

I’m not surprised Creno’s Pizza East has been voted best pizza in Zanesville OH for many years now. I highly recommend giving them a try if you’re ever in town – you won’t be disappointed!