Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Steamboat Springs (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Colorado

Best Pizza in Steamboat Springs (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

227 Views

With over 12 pizza places in the town to sample, I was ready to dig into a veggie-loaded deep dish or a classic pepperoni pie.

I’m not one who takes my pizza tasting too seriously — otherwise, it wouldn’t be nearly as fun! So I approached the challenge with a humorous and lighthearted attitude. Plus, let’s face it: Could there really be such a thing as bad pizza?

After careful taste-testing, I’m ready to reveal Steamboat Springs’ best spots for grabbing a slice (or more!) of delicious pizza. Let the journey begin!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Colorado

#1 Y-Not Wagon

I was really impressed with the sauce, which had just the right balance of sweetness and spiciness. The cheese was so creamy that I couldn’t stop myself from reaching for more slices. With each bite, I could taste all the flavors coming together in a delicious harmony.

The crust was particularly good – thin, yet still sturdy enough to hold all of the toppings without getting soggy. Every variety of topping was fresh and flavorful and perfectly complemented every pizza I tried.

The staff at Y-Not Wagon were also very friendly and accommodating, making sure that my experience there was top-notch. There’s no doubt about it – Y-Not Wagon is easily one of the best places to get a delicious slice of pizza in Steamboat!

If you’re willing to go an extra 63 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Vail!

#2 Clyde’s Pies

I was skeptical at first, but after one bite my doubts were put to rest. The crust is that perfect balance of crunchy and chewy. It has a nice crunch on the outside and a soft, airy texture in the middle that’s just perfect for folding up as you eat it. The sauce is sweet with just enough garlic and herbs to give it complexity without overpowering the other flavors. And the cheese…oh man, the cheese! It’s stretchy and gooey like you’d expect from great pizza, but it also has an extra layer of flavor that really puts this pie over the top.

The atmosphere at Clyde’s Pies is great too – it’s a relaxed spot with a cozy vibe full of friendly folks who are passionate about their pizza and genuinely enjoy serving customers. Sure, they may be biased, but they definitely know good pizza when they make it!

I absolutely recommend Clyde’s Pies to anyone looking for the best pie in Steamboat – or anywhere else in the world!

#3 Mazzola’s Italian Restaurant

The atmosphere here is great – it has a cozy, old-school Italian pizzeria vibe to it. The wait staff were all friendly and helpful, making the experience that much better.

The pizza itself is out of this world! The crust is just perfect – crisp on the outside and soft on the inside – and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. We had their signature pepperoni pie which was filled with delicious cured meats, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese. Not to mention it was big enough for two people!

I’m not usually one for desserts but I couldn’t resist trying their signature cannoli. It was sweet, rich, and indulgent – the perfect end to an amazing meal.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Steamboat, look no further than Mazzola’s Italian Restaurant. Give it a try – you won’t be disappointed!

#4 How Ya Doin Pizza and Eatz

My experience at their restaurant began with the most hospitable staff. I felt like they’d known me forever! The atmosphere was warm and inviting, which made me feel right at home.

Their pizza is to die for. They have an extensive menu of gourmet pizzas that are made with only the freshest ingredients. Every slice was perfection! The crust on each slice is thin, flaky and deliciously crunchy. And the combination of toppings was absolutely delightful.

I’ve never tasted anything quite like it before. In fact, I’m already looking forward to my next visit just to try more of their unique flavor combinations!

When it comes to pizza in Steamboat, How Ya Doin Pizza and Eatz is a clear winner in my book. If you’re looking for an unforgettable dining experience and some of the best pizza around, this is definitely the place to go!

#5 Blue Sage Pizza

I’m honestly still in shock that this tiny shop out here in the Rockies has such a flavorful pie. The crust was perfectly cooked and had an amazing char from the stone oven. The cheese was creamy and stretchy, with a great flavor that held up to the quality of ingredients used for each topping. The sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions were all fresh and tasty. Plus, the sauce was sweet without being cloying or overwhelming.

The staff was also incredibly friendly and helpful. They made sure to check in with me throughout my meal to make sure everything was top-notch and gave me some great menu recommendations.

Overall, Blue Sage Pizza is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in Steamboat looking for some of the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 68 miles, you can get to 6 more pizza places in Winter Park!

#6 Otto PINT gastroteca

My first impression as I walked in was that the atmosphere of this place was special. It has a very unique Italian vibe with rustic brick walls and dark-wood tables. The lighting was cozy, but not too dim, which made it a great spot for friends or a romantic dinner.

When it comes to the pizza, Otto PINT gastroteca is fantastic! The dough is perfectly cooked every time and so flavorful – you can taste all the natural yeast! The ingredients are fresh, varied, and mixed together with passion to create an unforgettable flavor. I personally recommend the classic Margherita pizza where each bite delivers waves of tomato sauce and melted mozzarella goodness on top of the delicious dough.

The service is excellent! Everyone at Otto PINT gastroteca is warm and welcoming – they know their guests by name and always make sure their needs are met. They even offer a few surprises that involve complimentary desserts to top off your meal.

In conclusion, Otto PINT gastroteca definitely offers some of the best pizza in Steamboat without fail every time! If you’re looking for an amazing experience with great food, great service, and an awesome atmosphere then be sure to check it out!

#7 Mountain Tap Brewery

I love that it serves alcohol — that makes for a great dining experience, and I’m always looking for a good place to pair my favorite beer with pizza. The only downside is there’s no delivery, so you’ll have to visit in person!

The pizzas here are all handmade, using only the freshest ingredients. As soon as you bite into them, you can tell they’re made with love. The crust is thin and crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, giving it just the right texture. And topping-wise, there’s something for everybody: classic cheese; pepperoni; Hawaiian; veggie…the list goes on and on!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Steamboat, Mountain Tap Brewery should definitely be at the top of your list.

#8 Brick

I was really excited to check out Brick because it had so many things going for it. Not only does it serve alcohol (including hard liquor!), but it also offers a few vegetarian options and even dessert afterwards. It’s definitely a great tourist spot, too!

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery. I mean, who doesn’t love being able to order pizza without having to leave the house? But, of course, as long as you don’t mind getting off your couch, Brick’s pizza is worth the trip.

The pizzas here are huge and super delicious – the crust could be a little bit crispier – with enough different toppings to satisfy everyone’s cravings. And if that wasn’t enough – they even offer their own specialty pizzas!

So overall, in my opinion Brick has some of the best pizza in Steamboat and is worth checking out if you’re in town. Just remember that there’s no delivery option – so plan accordingly!

#9 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

Though it’s not a traditional pizza joint, I still find their pizzas to be top-notch. To start, the selection is great—from classic combination pizzas to unique creations, there’s something for everyone. The ingredients are always fresh and the prices are very reasonable.

In terms of quality, Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza certainly knows what they’re doing. All of their pizzas are made with premium ingredients and cooked perfectly in their special ovens. It’s no wonder why I always find myself coming back for more!

Another thing that sets Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza apart is its friendly staff. Everyone is so welcoming and knowledgeable when it comes to helping me pick out just the right pizza every time.

So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Steamboat (or anywhere!), then Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza is definitely the spot for you! I can guarantee that you won’t be disappointed with your next visit here!

If you’re willing to go an extra 71 miles, you can get to 8 more pizza places in Estes Park!

#10 The Corner Slice

The ingredients are top notch and the flavor is out of this world. The crust is perfectly cooked, with a nice crunch that melts in your mouth. The sauce is fresh and flavorful. And the cheese – mmm – it’s like my taste buds are on vacation!

The staff at The Corner Slice is also awesome. They serve up the pizzas quickly and have great attention to detail. Plus, they’re always ready to answer any questions about the menu or ingredients.

You can find plenty of other options on the menu too, such as wings, sandwiches, salads, etc., but I suggest sticking with the pizza. Trust me: you won’t be disappointed! It really is some of the best pizza in Steamboat!

#11 Slopeside Grill

As I walked in, the first thing that struck me was the warm and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant is cozy and inviting with a great view of the ski slopes outside.

The menu boasts some unique and delicious toppings, like bacon-wrapped jalapenos, smoked trout, and even applesauce! Of course, you can also choose from classic toppings like pepperoni, anchovies, and olives.

The pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven to give them the perfect flavor and texture. To my delight, each slice had a perfectly thin but crispy crust with just the right amount of sauce and cheese.

When it comes to taste, Slopeside Grill’s pies were simply out of this world! Each one was bursting with flavor – as if I could taste every ingredient on my tongue.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Steamboat, Slopeside Grill should be at the top of your list!

#12 Brooklynn’s Pizzeria

I can safely say that the moment I walked through the door of Brooklynn’s Pizzeria, I was transported straight to New York. The decor fit the bill perfectly – cozy booths, a brick-lined wall, and an open kitchen with a large oven in full view.

Right away I could smell freshly baked pizza dough, as well as cooked pepperoni and sausage. My mouth started watering!

My order of a classic pepperoni pizza didn’t disappoint either – it was simply divine. The crust was perfectly crisp yet fluffy and the marinara sauce had just enough tang to really bring out the flavor of the melted cheese and toppings.

The staff was also great – incredibly friendly and eager to suggest their favorite pies from the menu. They even offered me some extra sauces on the side so I could customize my experience even further!

Brooklynn’s Pizzeria is truly unique, providing some of the best pizza in Steamboat. Every bite is a little slice of heaven – highly recommended!