Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Paducah KY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Kentucky

Best Pizza in Paducah KY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

157 Views

After trying 12 different pizza places in Paducah, I’m now qualified to tell you which one is the best. Gourmands beware – even if I’ve tasted great slabs of pizza all over the world, my standards are still high!

Join me on this humorous and lighthearted journey to determine the best pizza in Paducah. Buckle up – this is going to be one cheesy ride!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Kentucky

#1 J. Bella’s Pizzeria

When I first walked in, the pleasing aromas of fresh pizza cooking immediately filled my nose and made my mouth water. The seating area was clean, bright, and inviting.

I decided to order the classic pepperoni pizza and an extra-large drink. The restaurant staff were friendly and courteous throughout the entire ordering process.

When the pizza came out, I could tell it was going to be special–the dough was cooked perfectly with a crispy outer crust that gave way to a light and fluffy texture underneath. The toppings were superb: plenty of cheese, flavorful pepperoni slices, and a generous helping of delicious sauce throughout!

The flavor profile of this masterpiece exceeded all expectations! Every bite was bursting with flavor and left me wanting for more! It was truly some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted in my travels around the world.

If you’re looking for amazing pizza in Paducah KY, then J. Bella’s Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out. You won’t be disappointed by their delicious selection!

If you’re willing to go an extra 86 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Clarksville!

#2 J Bella’s Pizzeria – Lone Oak

The atmosphere was great, the staff was friendly and helpful, and the pizza…oh man. I’m still dreaming about it! The crust was cooked to perfection, the sauce was perfectly seasoned, and the toppings were fresh and delicious.

I particularly enjoyed the classic cheese pizza. It had just the right amount of cheese that wasn’t too much but still had a strong flavor that you can’t get anywhere else. The pepperoni slice packed plenty of flavor as well, with punchy basil leaves on top adding just the right amount of zest.

If you’re ever in Paducah KY looking for a great slice or pie then you should definitely check out J Bella’s Pizzeria – Lone Oak! They have some of the best pizza in town, making them one of my favorite spots for local eats.

#3 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

My first impression of the pizza was excellent. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, while still being able to hold all the delicious toppings! And wow, the toppings! They have all my favorites: meats, vegetables, and cheese. It’s obvious that this place takes their ingredients seriously – every topping was fresh and flavorful.

The best part about Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza is that you get to customize it however you’d like! No matter what combination of toppings I wanted, they were always ready to accommodate me. I also liked that I could choose different sizes and styles of crusts. This really allows for some creative combinations!

I must say that if you are ever in Paducah KY looking for great pizza, you can’t go wrong with Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza. This place has amazing quality food combined with unbeatable customer service–it truly is one of the best pizzas in Paducah KY!

#4 Pizza By the Pound

This fantastic pizzeria is located in the heart of downtown, and its cozy atmosphere allows you to really experience the full flavor of the pizza. As soon as I stepped through their doors, I knew that this place was something special!

The slices here are loaded with toppings, from savory meats to fresh veggies. Even better, they let you mix and match toppings so you can make your pizza just right! The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, and the sauce is just right.

What makes this pizza place extra special is their secret sauce. It’s a subtly flavored blend of herbs that adds a unique flavor to every bite. I’m sure it’s what makes Pizza By the Pound stand out amongst all the other pizza places in Paducah KY.

All in all, Pizza By the Pound offers an enjoyable dining experience. Their friendly service and delicious pies will keep me coming back time and time again! In my opinion, it’s definitely some of the best pizza in Paducah KY.

#5 Pizza Inn

Every pizza I’ve had here is delicious. The crust is perfectly crispy with a just the right amount of flavor and the toppings are always fresh and full of flavor. I especially love their pepperoni and cheese pizza – it’s heavenly!

The staff at Pizza Inn are really friendly and helpful too. They really care about making sure I have a great experience, which definitely adds to my enjoyment of their pizzas.

The atmosphere at Pizza Inn is also pleasant. They have a casual yet homey feel that makes me want to come back again and again! Plus, they have plenty of seating so you can bring your friends along for a great meal.

If you’re looking for amazing pizza in Paducah KY, look no further than Pizza Inn! Every bite is pure bliss and you won’t find better service anywhere else!

#6 Rocket Fired Pizza

The first thing that caught my eye was the wood-fired oven. Not only is it a visual treat, but it also adds an amazing layer of flavor to the pizza – something I haven’t experienced in any other place! The menu had all sorts of interesting options with classic and creative toppings, so I couldn’t resist getting one of each.

All of the pizzas were delicious, but my favorite was definitely the Paducah Porker (bbq pork, bacon, onion, peppers and mozzarella). The bbq sauce had just enough kick and sweetness to really amp up the flavors without overpowering them. The crust was perfectly cooked: crunchy on the outside and soft and chewy on the inside.

I also have to mention that their customer service is top-notch! Everyone was genuinely friendly and welcoming – it almost felt like I was eating pizza with family. Even though this spot isn’t well known yet, Rocket Fired Pizza should be your go-to for great pizza in Paducah KY!

#7 Michael’s New York Style Pizza

I visited Michael’s during a business trip and it was the best decision I could have made. From the moment I walked into the restaurant, it was clear that they were taking pizza seriously: there were multiple large ovens in one corner of the room, and even a barber chair to relax while you waited for your order.

The atmosphere was friendly and inviting—the staff greeted me warmly and seemed genuinely excited to serve up some tasty pies. And when my order of pepperoni arrived, all I can say is that it was absolutely delicious! The crust had an amazing crunch to it and the toppings were perfectly balanced.

Michael’s New York Style Pizza has definitely earned its reputation as some of the best pizza in Paducah KY. If you’re in town looking for great pizza, this is definitely the place to go.

If you’re willing to go an extra 90 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Evansville!

#8 Domino’s Pizza

From their signature pizzas like the Wisconsin 6 Cheese, to their specialties like the chicken and bacon Carbonara, you can’t go wrong at Domino’s.

The staff here are always friendly and helpful and they take the time to explain all of the options available. I haven’t had one bad experience with them in all my visits!

My favourite pizza here is easily the Brooklyn Style, with its thin and crispy crust, ooey-gooey cheese and tangy sauce. It really hits the spot every time!

Overall, if you’re looking for great pizza in Paducah KY, then look no further than Domino’s Pizza! Every slice is packed full of flavour, their prices are more than fair, and they always deliver on service. I’m a huge fan!

#9 Italian Village Pizza

The restaurant itself has an inviting atmosphere; it’s cozy and warm, making it a great place to hang out with friends. The staff is friendly, and they even gave me a free slice of pizza to sample before I ordered.

When it comes to the actual pizza, Italian Village Pizza definitely lives up to its reputation. The dough is light yet firm, the cheese is flavorful and gooey – everything you want in a great pizza. To top it off, their sauce has the perfect balance of sweetness and tanginess that really makes the flavors stand out.

In my opinion, Italian Village Pizza has some of the best pizza in Paducah KY! If you’re ever in town, make sure you stop by and give them a try – you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Mellow Mushroom

I arrived at the restaurant on a Saturday afternoon, and was immediately impressed by the quirky decor and fun atmosphere. The staff were incredibly friendly, which made me feel right at home – the perfect way to start off a pizza adventure!

The menu is packed full of unique pizzas that you won’t find anywhere else. I opted for their “Gourmet White” pizza with garlic, ricotta cheese, roasted tomatoes and spinach. It was absolutely delicious! The crust was wonderfully fluffy and light, yet still had a nice bite to it. The toppings were fresh and flavorful – exactly what I expect from a good pizza.

Of course, no visit to Mellow Mushroom would be complete without trying one of their signature craft beers. They have an impressive selection that perfectly complements their pizzas. I went for one of the house beers, which was surprisingly refreshing and flavorful.

In my opinion, Mellow Mushroom serves up some of the best pizza in Paducah KY – if you’re looking for great pizza with a side of fun atmosphere and tasty beer, you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Chuck E. Cheese

During my visit, I was greeted with a friendly smile and an inviting atmosphere. The pizzas were all cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of cheesy goodness. Plus, their unique selection of toppings made for some truly delicious creations!

I also loved their signature games and activities – what kid wouldn’t enjoy throwing a few rounds of skee ball or whacking moles in the Chuck E. Cheese game arena? It was a great way to spend an afternoon!

In addition to the entertainment and food, their service was top-notch. They were always willing to help me out when needed and went above and beyond to make sure our experience was perfect.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Paducah KY, look no further than Chuck E. Cheese – it’s hands down one of the best places around!

#12 Fazoli’s

As soon as I stepped into the restaurant, I was amazed by their extensive menu with all sorts of delicious goodies. But, most importantly, they have mouth-watering pizzas. The first time I had the pepperoni pizza, it made me feel like I had been transported to Italy! It was cheesy and tangy at the same time – a true delight.

And let’s talk about their crust…it is crunchy and buttery and just melts in your mouth. You really can’t go wrong with whatever pie you choose from Fazoli’s.

Plus, you don’t even have to leave home to enjoy their delicious pizza! They also offer delivery, so you can enjoy a piping hot pie anytime, anywhere.

Simply put – if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Paducah KY – Fazoli’s is definitely the place to go!