Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Pooler GA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Georgia

Best Pizza in Pooler GA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

108 Views

I’ve had some great pizza in my travels around the world, but nothing compares to that perfect combination of crunchy crust and melted cheese. I’m here to report on the best pizza places Pooler GA has to offer.

My team and I have tried out 12 different restaurants, all vying for the top spot. From traditional Italian recipes to new, unique combinations, we have tasted it all! We rated each pizza on its crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings before coming up with our final rankings.

Stay tuned as I take you on a journey through Pooler GA’s best pizzas!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Georgia

#1 Roma Pizza of Bloomingdale

The first thing that blew me away about this pizza-making establishment was their atmosphere. As soon as you walk in the door, you feel like family and are welcomed with open arms. Every staff member is so personable and pleasant – it’s hard to not be swept up in the infectious joy of being there!

The pizza itself is out of this world! Now I don’t say that lightly- I’ve been to nearly every pizza parlor under the sun and Roma Pizza has something truly special. The crust is light and crispy with a perfect balance of crunch and chewy deliciousness, while the tomato sauce is just acidic enough to make your palate tingle with delight. Toppings are nicely balanced and plentiful, ranging from classic favorites to unique recipes concocted by their own chefs.

But beyond the taste, what really impressed me about Roma was their commitment to quality ingredients. From locally sourced vegetables to premium Italian cheeses, it’s clear that no expense has been spared when it comes to creating a product that stands above the rest.

To sum up my experience at Roma Pizza: if you’re ever in Pooler looking for an amazing pizza experience, you must stop by Roma Pizza of Bloomingdale – because only then will you understand why it’s earned its title as the best pizza in Pooler GA!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Savannah!

#2 Holy Pie! Pizzeria – Dean Forest

Firstly, the atmosphere is really unique and inviting, unlike some of the other pizza places I’ve been to. It’s cozy, with a modern twist on traditional Italian decor. Secondly, the staff is friendly and attentive – they always make sure to bring out your order in record time.

As for the pizza itself, I can surely say it was worth the trip! All of their signature pizzas are handmade with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. It’s no wonder they’ve become known as one of the best pies around town! From their classic pepperoni to more exotic toppings like artichoke hearts and pineapple, there truly is something for everyone here. Plus, they even offer vegan and gluten-free options – amazing.

Overall, Holy Pie! Pizzeria – Dean Forest has quickly become my go-to spot for authentic Italian pizza in Pooler GA. Highly recommended!

#3 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

For starters, the selection of pizzas available is truly outstanding. From the classic pepperoni pizza to creative specialty pies like “The Works,” there’s something for everyone. Plus, with their buy-one-get-one free deal going on during some days of the week, I can get twice as much for my money!

The prices are also very reasonable. With such a variety of options and prices that fit any budget, it’s easy to see why Papa Murphy’s has become so popular in Pooler.

The taste is also top notch. Whether I’m ordering a plain cheese pizza or one of their signature pies, the flavor is always spot-on. The crust is perfectly cooked without being too thick or too thin, and it’s obviously made with quality ingredients.

On top of all this, the service at Papa Murphy’s is unbeatable. Even when I’m ordering online or over the phone, they’re always friendly and helpful. My orders are ready quickly and always hot when I come to pick them up—not to mention that take ‘n’ bake process ensures that my pizza will stay fresh until I’m ready to cook it myself!

Overall, if you’re in Pooler looking for a good pizza fix (or just looking for something interesting to try!), Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza should be at the top of your list! You won’t be disappointed!

#4 The Brother Pizza & Grill

I had a chance to stop by The Brother Pizza & Grill this week and sample some of their legendary 12-inch pies. From the moment I walked in, I could tell this place was going to be special. The bright and inviting décor instantly transports you to the Mediterranean coast.

The pizza itself is simply sensational! Each slice is so succulent that it melts in your mouth. The dough is light yet crunchy and the sauce is freshly made with a dual layer of savory meats, cheese and classic Italian herbs. Every bite sent me into an ecstasy of flavor that I won’t soon forget!

But what really sets The Brother Pizza & Grill apart from other restaurants is their commitment to excellence. The staff members are all passionate about their food and take pride in every dish they serve. They always make sure that their customers get delicious pizzas at affordable prices.

If you’re ever in Pooler GA, you owe it to yourself to try out The Brother Pizza & Grill for a truly world-class pizza experience! Trust me, it will be well worth the trip – best pizza in Pooler GA? Absolutely!

#5 LVL Up Pizza & Arcade

I was immediately impressed with the atmosphere of the restaurant. From the vintage arcade games to the enormous selection of craft beers, there’s something for everyone here. Every detail is carefully thought out and designed to make customers feel at home.

The pizza itself was delicious! The crust was perfectly cooked, with a nice balance between crunchy and chewy; it had just the right amount of char from the oven. All of their topping combinations are creative and unique. My personal favorite was their chipotle ranch chicken pizza – it had a kick that set it apart from anything I’ve had elsewhere.

Also, don’t forget about their arcade games! They have everything from old school classics to modern virtual reality options. It adds a fun element to your dining experience, making LVL Up Pizza & Arcade one of my favorite spots in Pooler GA!

If you’re willing to go an extra 26 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Bluffton!

#6 Your Pie Pizza

I stopped by this place on a whim, and I’m so glad I did. From the moment I walked in I could tell the staff took their pizza-making seriously. Everything about it was top-notch – from the fresh ingredients to the creative combos, you can really taste the care that goes into each pie.

Speaking of pies, their unique selection is what really sets them apart. Whether you’re in the mood for classic pepperoni or something more adventurous like their bacon cheeseburger pizza, there’s something for everyone here. My personal favorite is their spicy chicken with jalapeno – it’s absolutely packed with flavor!

But even more impressive than their pizza options are the prices – they aren’t shy about offering a great value! Not only do they have some of the best pizza in Pooler GA but they also offer deals and specials that make it an economically sound decision. On top of that, they are incredibly generous with their toppings – every single item on my pie was perfectly proportioned, which is something most places just don’t bother to do these days.

All in all, Your Pie Pizza has earned itself a permanent spot as one of my favorite pizzerias anywhere in the world. They’ve exceeded even my high standards for great pizza and are sure to become your go-to destination when you’re looking for delicious pies!

#7 Mellow Mushroom Pooler

The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, so it’s easy to settle in for a few slices of deliciousness. The staff was friendly and efficient, which helped to create an overall enjoyable experience.

As for the pizza, it did not disappoint. From their classic cheese to their gourmet specialty toppings, each slice was cooked just right and had a perfectly crispy crust. I especially enjoyed the BBQ Chicken—it had just the right ratio of sweet and smoky flavors that made my taste buds dance!

To top off my meal, I sampled a few sides that definitely lifted my spirits—the garlic parmesan fries were particularly tasty. As if that wasn’t enough, their huge selection of craft beers sealed the deal; I hardly needed anything else to cap off my visit!

All in all, Mellow Mushroom Pooler is a great place to go when you’re looking for some truly exceptional pizza. The best part? They even deliver so you don’t have to leave your cozy home if you don’t want to! If you’re ever in Pooler GA, be sure to give them a try—you won’t regret it!

#8 Rise Pies

From the first bite, I knew this was a different experience. The crust was perfectly crispy and flavorful, the sauce was the perfect balance of acidic and sweet and the cheese bubbled with gooey goodness. And of course, the toppings were fresh, vibrant and plentiful!

The atmosphere at Rise Pies is also excellent. Its fun, upbeat energy adds an extra level of enjoyment to dining there. The staff are friendly and accommodating, given their willingness to customize your order so you get exactly what you want. And it’s worth noting that they have a great selection of craft beers on tap which pairs perfectly with their slice options.

Overall, I can confidently say that Rise Pies is one of the best pizza restaurants in Pooler GA! If you’re looking for a delicious pizza experience filled with fresh ingredients and a vibrant atmosphere then look no further than Rise Pies!

#9 Lovezzola’s Pizza & Sub

To be honest, I wasn’t expecting much since it’s in Pooler and not some big city, but boy was I wrong! As soon as I stepped through the door, the amazing smells of herbs, spices and cheese had me drooling.

The menu at Lovezzola’s Pizza & Sub is full of delicious options––everything from their classic Italian-style pizzas to gourmet pies with toppings like artichoke hearts and goat cheese. There are also subs, salads and desserts if you’re feeling something different.

I ordered the pepperoni pizza which was cooked to perfection and loaded with ooey-gooey cheese. The crust was thin and crunchy while still being light enough to eat comfortably. Plus, the sauce was bursting with flavor. All in all, this pizza hit every note for me ––it had the perfect balance of sweet and salty flavors that made my taste buds sing!

In addition to having delicious food, Lovezzola’s Pizza & Sub has great service too. The staff were friendly throughout my visit and made sure that my glass of soda was always full. Plus, they offered helpful suggestions for creating unique custom pizzas.

If you’re ever in Pooler GA looking for some great pizza, make sure you check out Lovezzolla’s Pizza & Sub ––it’s definitely one of the best places in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 32 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Hilton Head Island!

#10 Green Fire Pizza & Sports Bar

I have to admit, I was somewhat skeptical of Green Fire Pizza’s claim that they had the best pizza in Pooler GA. But after tasting their pizza, I’m convinced it lives up to the hype!

The thin-crust pies are cooked to perfection in wood-fired ovens and served with a variety of delicious toppings. The crust has a slightly charred flavor that adds just the right touch of smokiness.

Their house specialty is the Fire Feta Pizza – made with feta cheese, olives, peppers, onions, and mushrooms. It was an amazing combination of flavors!

The atmosphere at Green Fire Pizza & Sports Bar is also quite inviting; it’s a great spot for lunch or dinner with friends or family. From cozy booths to big-screen TVs showing sports games and other events, there’s plenty of entertainment available. Plus the friendly staff always makes me feel right at home!

All in all, if you’re looking for some delicious pizza while in Pooler GA look no further than Green Fire Pizza & Sports Bar – it truly is some of the best pizza around!

#11 Little Caesars Pizza

The first time I stepped foot into this little restaurant, I knew great things were in store. Right away, the smell of freshly-baked dough and gooey mozzarella cheese hit me like a ton of bricks! After placing my order, it took no time at all for my pizza to arrive – perfect timing since I was starving!

The pizza was baked to perfection with a light and crispy crust. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, with just the right amount of sauce so there wasn’t too much or too little. Even better? It was reasonably priced compared to other establishments in the area.

If you’re ever in Pooler GA, do yourself a favor and stop by Little Caesars Pizza. You’ll be glad you did – it’s some of the best pizza around!

#12 Boston’s Restaurant & Sports Bar

My favorite thing about this place is the atmosphere; it’s really laid back and perfect for sports fans. The TVs are always tuned to the best games and there’s plenty of seating for everyone. The decor is vibrant and inviting, which only adds to the overall dining experience.

The pizzas are delicious! I tried half a dozen different pies while there, ranging from classic pepperoni to creative combinations like mac & cheese. And they do not skimp on the toppings either – every slice was abundant with flavor and texture. Plus, they offer an impressive range of gluten-free options as well.

But perhaps the best part is that all of their pizzas come with fresh ingredients straight from their garden! That means your pizza will always be made with an extra special touch that you won’t find anywhere else.

Overall, Boston’s Restaurant & Sports Bar offers some of the best pizza I’ve ever had in Pooler GA – if you’re looking for a great place to grab some slices with friends, this should be your go-to spot!