After being in search of the best pizza pie in Pennsylvania, I’ve visited 12 different restaurants in Williamsport. I’m fired up to share with you the results of my exhaustive pizza journey!
I’m going to serve up my recommendations with a little humor and lightheartedness. But rest assured, I take every pizza place seriously and sample each pie with the same scrutiny.
The next step on this delicious mission is for me to describe all 12 pizza places and which one earned my highest rating – let’s get to it!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania
#1 Long Island Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The crust is surprisingly light and flaky. It’s the perfect base for the delicious, gooey cheese that adorns each of their pizzas. But it’s the quality of the toppings that make this place stand out. The pizza sauce is made from scratch with only the freshest ingredients, giving each slice a unique flavor profile. The sausage and pepperoni are hand-chopped daily, so you can taste the freshness in every bite.
The atmosphere at Long Island Pizza also makes it a great place to visit. There are several TVs around the restaurant, playing sports or classic movies – so it doesn’t matter if you’re there to watch a game or just hang out with friends. It’s definitely one of those places where people come together to have fun.
I’m obsessed with Long Island Pizza and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for the best pizza in Williamsport PA!
If you’re willing to go an extra 54 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in State College!
#2 Venice Pizza
The pizza dough was thin and crispy, with just the right hint of char. It was light yet flavorful with a slightly chewy texture. The sauce was sweet without being too sugary, and the cheese melted perfectly into each slice.
The toppings were fresh and plentiful, like freshly chopped vegetables, meatballs, and pepperoni. I could tell from the flavor and quality that Venice Pizza only uses the finest ingredients in their recipes.
The atmosphere is also great – it’s cozy but not cramped, with plenty of seating for groups or couples out on a date night. The staff are friendly as well – I had no trouble getting my order taken care of quickly.
Overall, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Williamsport PA, look no further than Venice Pizza! Their food is delicious and definitely worth a visit…trust me!
#3 The Crazy Tomato
The atmosphere of this restaurant is something to be admired. The decor is colorful and vibrant, with a great energy that pairs perfectly with the delicious pizza. You’re sure to get in a good mood just from being here!
The pizza itself is out of this world. It’s cooked perfectly – the crust isn’t too thick or too thin; it’s just right. Toppings are generous and flavorful, making for a truly enjoyable experience. The secret ingredient must be something special because it really makes the pizza stand out from the rest.
My favorite part about The Crazy Tomato has to be the staff – they are genuinely friendly and always willing to help you get whatever you need! They make sure your experience is top-notch every time you come in, and that’s why I keep coming back again and again.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Williamsport PA, then look no further than The Crazy Tomato!
#4 Joe’s Pizza (east end) Loyalsock
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
The flavor of the crust was just perfect, with a nice blend of herbs and spices. It had a great crunch on the outside that gave way to a soft, fluffy interior. On top of that, Joe’s uses only the finest cheese and sauces to really bring out the flavors of their toppings.
The toppings were also very flavorful. I especially enjoyed the pepperoni and sausage topping combination as they brought out a great spicy taste indicative of Italy. The pasta was also cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of al dente-ness to it.
But what made this place shine was its atmosphere. The staff were all friendly and welcoming, making sure you felt comfortable while enjoying your meal. And to top it all off, their prices are pretty competitive too!
All in all, I would highly recommend Joe’s Pizza (east end) Loyalsock for anyone looking for some good pizza in Williamsport PA
#5 The Stonehouse Wood Fired Pizza and Pasteria
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
From the moment I walked in, my mouth started to water. The smell of freshly cooked pizza dough and freshly grated cheese filled the air. I took a seat at one of their cozy booths, and was quickly presented with a plate filled with deliciousness.
The crust of their pizzas is made from scratch daily and is cooked to perfection – crisp on the outside with the perfect chewiness on the inside. It’s topped with fresh, flavorful ingredients that are sure to satisfy any pizza lover.
I sampled a few different kinds of pizza during my visit, and each one tasted better than the last! My favorite was their classic Margherita pizza – it was piping hot, had just the right amount of sauce and melted cheese, and was topped off with fresh basil for that extra burst of flavor.
What really sets The Stonehouse Wood Fired Pizza and Pasteria apart from other pizzerias is that they are truly passionate about what they do. All their ingredients are sourced locally and they make everything from scratch – meaning no shortcuts or frozen pre-made ingredients here!
If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Williamsport PA, then look no further than The Stonehouse Wood Fired Pizza and Pasteria – it really is out of this world good!
#6 Leo’s Pizzeria
On my visit, I was very impressed by the atmosphere of the restaurant. The owners and staff were incredibly welcoming, and the decor was both cozy and rustic.
The menu offerings at Leo’s were quite diverse. With options ranging from classic Italian recipes to unique specialties, I felt like I’d stumbled upon a magical pizza-making factory!
I’m glad that I decided to sample some of their signature pies. Every bite was absolute heaven! Their crispy, buttery crusts combined with fresh ingredients and flavorful sauces created a symphony of flavors that left me wanting more.
To top it all off, Leo’s Pizzeria also offers great prices for such delicious food. All in all, this is certainly one place you don’t want to miss!
#7 Bart’s Pizzeria
The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere and a friendly staff, which made the experience even better. The pizza here is simply sublime. The crust is thin and crispy, with just the right amount of char. The sauce also had the perfect balance of sweet and savory, while the cheese was perfectly melted and flavorful.
On top of all that, they also offer some great topping options that provide a unique flavor and texture profile. From the classic pepperoni to their very own special blend of vegetables, Bart’s Pizzeria really knows how to make amazing pizza.
All in all, I’d have to say that Bart’s Pizzeria is definitely my pick for the best pizza in Williamsport PA! This small town gem is not to be missed out on!
If you’re willing to go an extra 57 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Wilkes-Barre!
#8 Park Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
I recently dined at Park Pizza and was pleasantly surprised with the quality of their pizza. In particular, I loved the crust that had a good balance of crispiness and chewiness. The sauce was well-seasoned and flavorful, and the cheese melted just right!
Most importantly, the toppings were truly one of a kind. Park Pizza has an impressive variety to choose from—anything from green olives to mushrooms to Canadian bacon all make for great additions to any pizza.
What made this experience even better was the friendly service. My server greeted me warmly when I arrived and took extra time to explain each topping option available to help customize my pizza. He also made sure everything tasted fresh and hot when it came out of the oven, which is always appreciated!
All in all, if you’re looking for great pizza in Williamsport PA, look no further than Park Pizza! I had an exceptional experience here that makes it stand out as one of the best around.
#9 Vinnies’ Italian Eatery
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
The first thing that amazed me about Vinnie’s was the massive menu. It felt like there were about a hundred pizzas to choose from (don’t worry, I counted, it was only twenty-seven!). From traditional Italian-style pies to creative concoctions like “the Ultimate Gladiator” and the aptly named “Extravaganza,” I had no lack of options.
The crusts are thick and chewy without being too doughy or too crispy. The sauces range from zesty marinara to fragrant garlic olive oil. And the variety of toppings? Inspiring! So much so that I tried almost all of them!
Most importantly, the taste was top notch. Every bite of my creations seemed like a flavor explosion in my mouth — salty, sweet, creamy, spicy… everything melded into an intensely satisfying experience pastry for pastry. Even though I ate until I thought my stomach would burst, I could have easily kept going because it tasted SO good!
In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Williamsport PA, look no further than Vinnies’ Italian Eatery. You won’t be disappointed!
#10 The South Side Restaurant, Pizzeria, and Tavern
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
The décor is warm and inviting, with a unique Italian flair that can only be found in the area. The staff are friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere is definitely conducive to enjoying a great meal.
On to the pizza! I’d heard rumour of “the best pizza in Williamsport PA” and now I understand why. The selection of pizzas on offer is impressive, with every style imaginable catering to all types of tastes. Whether you’re looking for a classic Margherita or something more adventurous like a pepperoni and prosciutto combo, it’s all here. The crusts were just how they should be – thin and crisp while still managing to stay light and fluffy. Toppings are fresh, generous without being excessive, flavourful without being too heavy-handed.
To top it off (no pun intended), their prices are reasonable which make this an overall great value for money proposition. Not surprisingly, I definitely recommend you give The South Side Restaurant a try if you’re ever in town!
#11 Riverside Subs & Pizza
The crust was crispy yet chewy, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. My favorite pizza was the “Carne Asada” – with grilled steak, jalapenos, onion and cilantro. The flavors combined perfectly!
The service at Riverside Subs & Pizza was also top-notch. My order arrived quickly and the staff took their time to explain the menu in detail. They even offered suggestions for pairing my pizza with craft beer from local breweries – perfect for a night out.
All in all, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Williamsport PA – look no further than Riverdale Subs & Pizza. Their pizza is second to none!
#12 Pudgie’s of Williamsport
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- No delivery
The atmosphere is great, which makes it a great tourist spot. The restaurant itself is quite cozy and inviting, and the helpful staff helped make my experience that much better.
I ordered a large pepperoni slice and I must say, the pizza was one of the best I’ve ever had. The crust was crispy yet chewy, just like I liked it. And the sauce had a nice sweet flavor that complimented the cheese perfectly!
One thing that makes Pudgie’s stand out among other pizza places is their kid’s menu – there’s something for everyone! Plus they have delicious salads and sandwiches for those who don’t want pizza.
Unfortunately, Pudgie’s doesn’t deliver but thankfully they offer fast takeout so you can still enjoy their amazing pizza in the comfort of your own home.
If you’re looking for some great pizza then look no further than Pudgie’s of Williamsport to satisfy all your cravings!
