Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Garden City (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Garden City (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

142 Views

I’m excited to present my guide to the Best Pizza in Garden City, having tasted twelve different places. I’ve eaten pizza all over the world, and after careful consideration I’m ready to crown one as the very best!

Join me on this delicious journey as I share tips for each place, along with humorous observations and stories from my culinary adventures. This is sure to be a lighthearted yet informative guide that will have you craving some of Garden City’s finest pies.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Enzo’s Pizza Of Garden City

From the moment I walked into Enzo’s, I knew I was in for a real treat. The décor is cozy and warm, with the smell of fresh pizza wafting through the air.

I decided to try their signature “Pepperoni Supreme” pizza, and boy was it good! The dough was nice and crisp, with a perfect amount of melted cheese and spicy pepperoni on top. It tasted like it had just been pulled from the oven moments ago.

The service at Enzo’s Pizza Of Garden City is also top-notch. The waitstaff are friendly and helpful, always making sure that your drink cup is full and that you’re taken care of.

To cap off my meal, the dessert options at Enzo’s are simply amazing. They offer an array of Sicilian-style cannolis, a decadent chocolate lava cake, and more!

All in all, my experience at Enzo’s Pizza Of Garden City was one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had. If you’re ever looking for great pizza in Garden City, Enzo’s should be your first stop.

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Queens!

#2 Pizzeria G

I couldn’t believe my luck when I stumbled across this place. The smell and atmosphere of the place alone was enough to make me salivate in anticipation.

The menu was full of mouth-watering options, from classic favorites like margherita and pepperoni, to more exotic variations like cajun chicken and Mediterranean veggies. But ultimately, I opted for Pizzeria G’s special recipe – their signature blend that they claim is ‘the best pizza in Garden City.’

And let me tell you, it didn’t disappoint. The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside and soft and airy on the inside. The cheese was flavourful and melty, while the toppings were fresh and vibrant. Every bite was a burst of flavour!

As if that wasn’t enough, Pizzeria G also offers some tantalizing Italian sides, as well as cold beer or refreshing Italian sodas. Overall, I’d happily give Pizzeria G five stars for its delicious pizzas!

#3 Pizza Supreme

When I first arrived at the restaurant, I was struck by the inviting atmosphere. The place positively oozed with Italian charm. From the bright murals on the walls to the cheery music wafting from speakers, it’s clear that Pizza Supreme has gone above and beyond to create a stellar dining experience.

The food didn’t disappoint either! I tried their Supreme pizza, which boasts an amazing array of fresh ingredients. The sauce is flavorful and tangy, while the cheese is stretchy and delightful. The crust is thin, but not too thin – it’s just right for that classic pizza crunch.

But perhaps what impressed me most about Pizza Supreme was its service. Everyone from the hostess to our waiter was friendly and attentive. They’re clearly passionate about their craft and strive to offer excellent customer service each time you come in.

All in all, Pizza Supreme has earned my stamp of approval as one of Garden City’s best pizza spots! Highly recommended!

#4 Calogero’s

I recently visited this local pizza restaurant and I was delighted by how great the pizza was! The crust was perfectly crunchy on the outside while still being light and fluffy in the middle. And the sauce? Let’s just say that it had all of the flavor I’ve come to expect from an Italian-style pizza.

The toppings were also top notch – every ingredient was fresh, perfectly cooked, and perfectly balanced with one another. From classic favorites like pepperoni to more creative options like roasted red peppers and kalamata olives, Calogero’s has something for everyone.

And let’s not forget about their amazing selection of drinks. From craft beers to homemade Italian sodas, you can find something that pairs perfectly with your favorite slice of pizza.

Overall, my experience at Calogero’s was nothing short of wonderful and I highly recommend it for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Garden City!

#5 Taglio Pizza

From the moment I stepped into Taglio, I could tell that this place was the real deal. The smells of delicious homemade dough and cheese filled the air, and I was instantly salivating for a bite.

The pizza-making process at Taglio is an art form! Each gourmet pie is lovingly made by hand with only the freshest ingredients possible. Every slice has an amazingly thin crust that’s so crispy it practically melts in your mouth when you take a bite. And each topping bursts with flavor from sweet tomatoes to salty chunks of sausage.

Plus, there’s something for everyone on their extensive menu. Whether you like traditional pies or more unique creations like truffle mushroom pizza and Greek style, they have endless options to choose from.

Overall, my experience at Taglio Pizza was truly unforgettable and I can confidently call them the best pizza in Garden City! If you’re ever looking for a place to get some delicious pizza, look no further than Taglio Pizza!

#6 Mamma Gina’s Pizza

As soon as I stepped inside the restaurant, I was greeted with a warm, inviting atmosphere and scents that only pizza can bring. The staff was friendly and helpful in deciding what to order.

The pizza was simply delicious – from the freshly made dough to the zesty sauce, it all came together in perfect harmony. With ample topping options, I decided on a combination of proscuitto, spinach, mushrooms and artichoke hearts – it didn’t disappoint! The thin crust wasn’t soggy or greasy like some places tend to be.

I’m always looking for great dessert options when eating out and Mamma Gina’s certainly did not let me down! Their chocolate cannoli were filled with creamy goodness and served with a sprinkle of pistachios – what can I say? Yum!!

I’d definitely recommend a visit to Mamma Gina’s Pizza if you’re ever in Garden City – they have some of the best pizza around!

#7 Garden City Pizza and Catering

I was amazed by the amount of variety they offer. From the classic cheese and pepperoni pizzas to more creative toppings such as artichoke hearts and sausage, I had a hard time deciding which one to try first. After much deliberation, I settled on a bacon, mushroom, and black olive pizza that far surpassed my expectations. The crust was perfectly crispy and golden brown with just the right amount of charring and the ingredients were incredibly fresh.

The service at Garden City Pizza and Catering was excellent as well. The staff were friendly and accommodating to my every need – from providing extra napkins when needed to offering suggestions for sides to go with my order. I really appreciated their hospitality!

Overall, I highly recommend Garden City Pizza and Catering for anyone looking for an amazing pizza experience in Garden City. Whether you’re a fan of traditional pies like me or someone who loves trying something new, you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Queens!

#8 Rustica Brick Oven Cafe

I was in the mood for a taste of the classic Italian style pizza that I love, so I decided to give Rustica Brick Oven Cafe a try. And boy, am I glad that I did! When they say they make their pizzas with fresh ingredients and an old-world brick oven cooking technique, they mean it – this pizza was one of the best I’ve ever had.

The crust was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunchiness, while still being pillowy soft inside. The tomato sauce had nice bits of oregano and a hint of sweetness that really brought out the flavors of all the toppings on top. The cheese was perfectly melted, giving each slice just enough stringiness and creaminess.

Plus, everything about Rustica Brick Oven Cafe is made with passion. From the warm atmosphere to their friendly staff, you can tell that everyone loves what they do here and takes pride in their work.

If you’re ever in Garden City and are looking for an amazing slice of pizza, then look no further than Rustica Brick Oven Cafe – you won’t be disappointed!

#9 Louies Pizzeria

I arrived at their restaurant to find a warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly staff. The pizza was, in a word: delicious! The crust was perfectly thin and light, yet flavorful. The toppings were plentiful and of top-notch quality. All the ingredients blended together perfectly, creating an unforgettable taste experience that I’m sure I won’t forget soon.

And then there are the unique toppings! Louies Pizzeria offers some interesting combinations that are unlike anything I’ve ever had before. They offer toppings such as spicy giardiniera, smoky bacon bits, and garlicky mushrooms.

I also must mention the friendly service I received in this small establishment. The waitstaff always had a smile on their face, which made my whole experience even more enjoyable.

Without a doubt, Louies Pizzeria has some of the best pizza in Garden City. If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, then come pay them a visit—you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Novitá

The atmosphere is charming – the outdoor patio seating with garden views had me feeling like I was in Italy (or at least in a very upscale Italian-styled restaurant). But it was what came out of the kitchen that really made me appreciate Novitá. The pizza I ordered was perfection. The crust was crispy and light, with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. The toppings were top-notch, fresh and flavorful.

The service was also excellent – friendly and attentive. They made sure my drink stayed full and that I had all the napkins and plates I needed.

In short, Novitá is a great place to go for some truly amazing pizza! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Garden City, you can’t go wrong at Novitá!

#11 Luigi’s Pizzeria of Mineola

My first impression of Luigi’s Pizzeria was one of sheer delight. The menu had something for everyone, from classic favorites like pepperoni and sausage to gourmet creations like chorizo and feta cheese. The atmosphere was friendly, with staff that went out of their way to make sure I felt welcome.

And the pizza! Wow! It’s baked to perfection in a wood-fired oven, so it has that charred exterior with a soft center. Every topping is flavorful and fresh, with quality ingredients that’ll make your tastebuds sing. To top it off, Luigi’s pizzas are served hot and bubbling – talk about mouth-watering!

I honestly think Luigi’s Pizzeria is the best pizza in Garden City. But don’t take my word for it; go see for yourself! Just prepare to be blown away by the deliciousness waiting inside!

#12 Previti Pizza & Papazzio Dining

From the moment I walked in, I knew that I was not going to be disappointed. The aroma of fresh dough, herbs, and cheese filled the air and enticed my taste buds. But what truly set this place apart from other pizza places was their selection of toppings. All of their pizzas are made with high-quality ingredients, but what really set them apart was their unique creations. From dandelion pesto to wild mushrooms, they have a topping for everyone!

As for the pizza itself, it was nothing short of divine. The crust had a perfect balance of crunchiness and flakiness while still being light enough that it didn’t weigh down the toppings. The sauce had just the right amount of flavor – not too sweet or tangy. And then there were those delicious toppings! They added so much flavor and texture to the pizza; making each bite an unforgettable experience.

To top it all off, the service at Previti Pizza & Papazzio Dining is wonderful! Everyone from the waitstaff to the chefs was friendly and warm, ensuring that every customer feels welcomed and valued.

Overall, my experience at Previti Pizza & Papazzio Dining has earned them one very satisfied food critic! It’s definitely among one of Garden City’s best pizzas and I highly recommend giving it a try if you’re ever in town!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Grimaldi’s Pizzeria Garden City

From the moment you walk into this cozy little spot, you can’t help but feel like you’ve stumbled upon pizza heaven. The smell of freshly baked dough and melted cheese wafts through the air, instantly making your taste buds tingle with anticipation.

Now, let’s talk about the crust. Oh, the crust! It’s thin, crispy, and just the right amount of chewy. It’s like biting into a cloud made of pizza love. You won’t find any soggy, limp crusts here. Grimaldi’s knows how to make that crust sing, and boy does it hit all the right notes!

And the toppings? Let me tell you, they’re out of this world. Whether you’re a traditionalist and opt for the classic margherita or feeling a little adventurous and go for the prosciutto and arugula, each bite is bursting with flavor. And don’t even get me started on the cheese. It’s so gooey and melty that you’ll be wiping your chin with each heavenly bite.

But it’s not just the pizza that makes Grimaldi’s a standout. The service is top-notch, with a staff that’s quick with a smile and ready to fulfill your every pizza desire. Plus, the ambiance is cozy with dim lighting, making it the perfect place to cozy up with a slice (or five) and indulge in some serious pizza pleasure.

So, if you find yourself in nassau county and craving a thin crust pizza that will make your taste buds do a happy dance, head on over to Grimaldi’s Pizzeria Garden City. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed.