Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Plymouth MA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Massachusetts

Best Pizza in Plymouth MA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

285 Views

I’ve traveled the world tasting pizza, so I like to think I have a pretty good idea of what makes a great pie. After studying the local scene in Plymouth MA, I’ve narrowed down the best 12 pizza places.

I know there’s nothing quite like a slice of hot pizza and plenty of debate about where to get the tastiest crust, sauce, and cheese combination. Hopefully, I’ll be able to help you decide on your next pizza order with this review!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Massachusetts

#1 The Artisan Pig

I’m a huge fan of their delicious pies. The toppings are always fresh and flavorful, and the crusts are crispy yet chewy – definitely something to write home about.

There’s also plenty of other options for your meal. They have a nice selection of vegetarian dishes, plus a great kids menu. And if you’re really in the mood for something special, they have several signature pizzas that’ll surely hit the spot!

Plus, they offer alcoholic beverages which is always a bonus in my book! My favorite: their hard liquor mixed drinks. The bartenders here can really make anything your heart desires.

The atmosphere is great too – it’s located right in the middle of town, making it an ideal tourist spot. I’ve actually taken several relatives here while they were visiting Plymouth MA and they loved it!

My only complaint with The Artisan Pig is that they don’t offer delivery service. That would be a nice addition in my opinion but otherwise no real negative thoughts here!

All in all, I’d highly recommend checking out The Artisan Pig for yourself if you’re ever in Plymouth MA looking for the best pizza around – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Brockton!

#2 Squinny’s Pizza

From the moment I walked in, the inviting atmosphere and friendly service instantly made me feel right at home. The restaurant has a classic ’50s vibe with red-and-white checkered tablecloths, pictures of celebrities on the wall, and old-fashioned jukebox playing tunes from a bygone era.

The biggest surprise was the pizza! I’ve been all over Italy, the US, and beyond trying different types of pizzas and I must say that Squinny’s Pizza definitely holds its own when it comes to quality pies. The crust was crunchy yet light, with just the right amount of sauce and cheese – not too much, not too little. And that’s just for starters! The toppings were fresh and flavorful, with plenty of options for everyone to customize their own pies.

To top it off (no pun intended), Squinny’s Pizza also offers an array of delightful sides like garlic breadsticks and chicken wings that really hit the spot.

If you’re ever in Plymouth MA looking for a truly authentic pizza experience – look no further than Squinny’s Pizza!

#3 Monte Christos Restaurant

The restaurant has plenty of options for all ages from a kid’s menu to a variety of desserts. And my favorite part? They serve alcohol, including hard liquor! So you can enjoy an ice-cold draft beer or a delicious cocktail while munching on your pizza.

The atmosphere in the restaurant was perfect—it seemed like it would be great for tourists and those looking to watch sports and grab some grub. The wait staff was friendly, the food looked and smelled amazing, and I could tell that it had been prepared with care.

Unfortunately, this place doesn’t offer delivery services so if you’re looking to have pizza delivered right to your doorstep then this isn’t the place for you. But believe me when I say it’s worth the trip!

Overall, Monte Christos Restaurant is definitely one of the best places around for pizza in Plymouth MA. Whether you’re looking for a great night out with friends or just want some quality Italian cuisine served up in a nice atmosphere – Monte Christos Restaurant has got you covered!

#4 Rose & Vicki’s in Manomet

I had the opportunity to try their unique and creative flavor combinations like the “Pepperoni & Pineapple” pizza, which is a surprisingly delicious combination. The crust was perfectly crisp, yet chewy in all the right spots. It’s topped with a generous helping of cheese and just the right amount of sauce.

The atmosphere at Rose & Vicki’s wasn’t too shabby either. It has an old-world charm that will take you back in time. The waitstaff was friendly and accommodating – they really made us feel welcome during our visit!

But, don’t take my word for it – go check them out yourself! Rose & Vicki’s is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Plymouth MA!

#5 Rose & Vicki’s in North Plymouth

From the moment I stepped foot in Rose & Vicki’s, I knew I was in for a special experience. The smell of freshly-baked pizzas and the bright, inviting décor created a welcoming atmosphere that made me feel right at home.

The pizza selection offered at Rose & Vicki’s is fantastic. From classic combinations like pepperoni and mushroom to their signature creations such as their famous “Rose’s Special,” there’s something for everyone! The pizza crust was nice and crispy on the outside while still being light and fluffy on the inside. And don’t forget about the generous portions of cheese – it was simply divine!

But what really sets Rose & Vicki’s apart from other pizza places is their commitment to fresh ingredients. Everything on their menu is made with locally sourced vegetables, meats, and cheeses that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. On top of that, they use a unique blend of spices that give each slice its own unique flavor profile. It’s truly remarkable!

I can honestly say Rose & Vicki’s serves some of the best pizza in Plymouth MA. They’ve got something for everyone – from picky eaters to those looking for something different – which makes them stand out from the competition. Plus, the friendly staff goes above and beyond to provide an unforgettable experience that will keep you coming back time and time again.

#6 Cappy’s Pizza

I was so excited to try their pizza that I drove almost two hours just for the opportunity. When I arrived, I wasn’t sure what to expect. Yet, the moment I opened up the door, I was hit with a wave of sweet and savory aromas that had my mouth watering in anticipation.

The inside of the restaurant was cozy and inviting, and it didn’t take long before our order was ready. The first bite was like heaven! Every ingredient blended together perfectly and tasted as if it were made from scratch. From the crisp crust to the tangy sauce and melted cheese on top – this pizza left me wanting more!

The staff at Cappy’s Pizza is also very friendly and knowledgeable about their menu items which makes the whole experience even better. Everything tastes so fresh, you can tell they take great pride in their craftsmanship.

If you ever find yourself in Plymouth MA looking for an amazing pizza experience, Cappy’s Pizza is definitely worth checking out! This place will leave your palate satisfied and your stomach filled with some of the best pizza in town!

#7 Mamma Mia’s of Plymouth Waterfront

The pizza here is mouth-wateringly delicious, with freshly made dough and loads of flavorful toppings. The crust is always thin and crispy and the toppings are always plentiful and fresh.

But it’s not just about the pizza – Mamma Mia’s also has some great advantages. They serve a full bar including hard liquor, so you can enjoy a cold beer or stiff drink with your meal. Plus, they have a kid’s menu which makes this place ideal for family dinners. Additionally, there are several vegetarian options available so everyone can find something to eat.

To top all that off, the dessert at Mamma Mia’s is out of this world! I’ve tried several items from their dessert menu and each one was better than the last. Trust me, you don’t want to miss out on this treat!

The only downside to Mamma Mia’s is that they don’t offer delivery options – but if you want to experience the best pizza in Plymouth MA then visiting Mamma Mia’s is definitely worth it. Not only do you get to enjoy an amazing meal in an amazing setting (the waterfront location makes for great scenery!), but you also get to explore what else Plymouth has to offer as a tourist spot.

If you’re looking for an awesome pizza dining experience, then look no further than Mamma Mia’s of Plymouth Waterfront – it really is the ultimate destination for good pizza and unbeatable service!

If you’re willing to go an extra 22 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Taunton!

#8 Boli’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Boli’s Pizza is cozy and inviting, and the staff are warm and welcoming. I was greeted with a warm smile and a wonderful slice of cheese pizza, which I quickly devoured.

The crust at Boli’s is really special – it’s perfectly thin and crunchy on the outside but still soft in the middle. It’s easy to tell that they take great care in making each pizza from scratch! Plus, the fresh ingredients used really elevate it to another level.

I also had a chance to sample their specialty pizzas, which are truly unique – like their Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza which combines all my favorite flavors into one convenient pizza pie! They even have vegan options available for those who don’t eat meat or dairy.

I would highly recommend trying Boli’s Pizza if you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Plymouth MA! Their combination of great atmosphere, excellent customer service, and delicious pizzas make them a must-try for any pizza lover out there.

#9 Rose & Vicki’s in Cedarville

As soon as I stepped into Rose & Vicki’s, I was immediately impressed by the atmosphere. It had a cozy vibe and the staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming! Plus, the décor was absolutely divine – modern yet comfortable.

The pizza at Rose & Vicki’s is truly something special. They offer a wide range of pizzas from classic Italian-style to their very own creative combinations – it’s truly something to behold! Their crust is thin and delicious, their toppings are always fresh, and their sauces are perfect every time. Plus, they have an extensive selection of specialty pizzas that’ll sure to please even the pickiest palette.

Overall, I’d have to say that Rose & Vicki’s definitely has some of the best pizza in Plymouth MA. Whether you’re looking for traditional favorites or something a bit more adventurous, this place will surely satisfy your craving! I’m so glad I made the trip out here – it definitely wasn’t a mistake!

#10 Tavern on the Wharf

I visited this restaurant during my travels and was pleasantly surprised by the atmosphere and service. The staff at Tavern on the Wharf were friendly, courteous, and knowledgeable about their menu. The restaurant had a pleasant vibe with its warm colors, cozy seating arrangements, and wooden accents.

When it came to pizza, I knew I absolutely had to try some! After looking over the expansive menu of pizza options, I went with a classic pepperoni pie. When it arrived at the table piping hot, it looked absolutely delicious – and let me tell you, that it tasted just as good as it looked! The thin crust was cooked perfectly in the wood-fired ovens. It had a crispy edge that gave way to an airy interior. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, while the cheese and pepperonis provided welcome texture contrasts. All in all, it was an amazing pizza experience for me!

My verdict? If you’re ever in Plymouth MA and looking for great pizza – look no further than Tavern on the Wharf!

#11 Family Pizza

The pizza itself is out of this world! The crust was thin and crispy, the sauce was flavorful, and the toppings were fresh. I especially enjoyed the pepperoni pizza – the perfect combination of spicy and savory flavors.

In addition to having a fantastic pizza, Family Pizza also offers an amazing atmosphere. The décor is cozy, with rustic wood tables and walls lined with colorful artwork. On top of that, the staff was friendly and welcoming – they made me feel right at home.

If you’re looking for a great place to get pizza in Plymouth MA, look no further than Family Pizza – it’s one of the best around!

#12 Southmeadow Pizza

Their crust is out of this world, with just the right amount of crispiness and delicious flavor. The toppings are always fresh and the portion sizes are always generous. Not to mention they are fast and efficient when it comes to delivery.

The atmosphere in the restaurant is great, too! It’s large and open, making it perfect for gatherings with friends or family. They also have an endless selection of beers and wines to pair with your meal – not that you’ll be left wanting more since their pizza is so delicious!

But don’t take my word for it – come on down and taste Southmeadow Pizza yourself to see why I say it’s some of the best pizza in Plymouth MA!