Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in The Keys (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in The Keys (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

142 Views

I mean, how can you wrong with such a great climate and atmosphere for enjoying pizza? After tasting pizzas from twelve spots in The Keys, I’ve settled on the very best for you. It’s been a hilarious journey of trying over-the-top creations to more classic styles – sometimes all in the same pie!

So get ready for my humorous and lighthearted review as I take you through the best pizza options in The Keys. Bon appetit!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 KRUST pizza & pies

The pizzas are made with only the freshest, finest ingredients – from the crunchy crust to the sweet tomato sauce and cheesy toppings. The flavors explode in your mouth and leave you wanting more.

But there’s more than just pizza here – their pies are also some of the best I’ve had. They come in a variety of flavors, like apple and cherry, so there’s something for everyone.

The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, perfect for a casual evening out with friends or family. And they have friendly staff that makes sure all your needs are taken care of.

All in all, this place is one of my top picks for the best pizza in The Keys! If you’re looking for a unique experience and some delicious food, this is the spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Key Largo!

#2 Bayside Gourmet

The ingredients are fresh, and the crust is thin and crispy, yet still chewy. The delicious combinations of classic flavors like pepperoni and extra cheese, or specialty options like pesto and artichoke, are sure to please even the pickiest eaters.

And not only does Bayside Gourmet offer great pizza; they have an awesome selection of salads and sandwiches as well. I could not resist their heavenly fish sandwich with grilled banana peppers—it was out of this world!

Also noteworthy is the friendly staff that makes every visit special. They always have a smile on their faces and are willing to accommodate dietary concerns easily without batting an eye.

Overall, Bayside Gourmet has definitely earned its spot as one of the best pizza restaurants in The Keys—if you’re ever in town, you’ve got to try it!

#3 Clemente’s Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria

I was immediately drawn in by the warm and inviting atmosphere when I walked through the door. The ingredients are of the highest quality as evidenced by their thick, crusty base and flavorful, homemade sauce. The cheese melted perfectly and was full of flavor.

The toppings were incredible! The Italian sausage was cooked to perfection and had a bit of a kick to it; the pepperoni was equally delicious, crispy on top and gooey in the middle. On top of that, the trolley pizzas feature unique combinations like shrimp and spinach or prosciutto and pine nuts – definitely something for everyone!

I could taste why this is considered one of the best pizza places in The Keys: their ovens reach exceptionally high temperatures, allowing them to cook up an amazing pie with an unbeatable crust. It even had a hint of smokiness from the wood-fired ovens that really rounded out the flavor profile.

Overall, Clemente’s Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria lived up to its reputation as one of the best pizza places in The Keys. My experience there was truly unforgettable – between the cozy atmosphere, fresh ingredients, and wood-fired perfection you can’t go wrong here!.

#4 C&C wood fire eats

I’m always a fan of restaurants that offer some vegetarian options, and C&C does not disappoint. The choices are quite varied, and each has its own unique flavor.

The pizzas are cooked in an authentic wood fire oven which imparts delicious smoky flavors. I had the classic Margherita Pizza, which was outstanding! The crust was perfect and the cheese was so creamy and flavorful.

Of course, after enjoying your pizza it’s important to have dessert! They offer several incredible desserts – their cheesecake is out of this world! The combination of the creamy cheese filling, crunchy graham cracker crust, and strawberry topping make for a truly irreproducible experience.

My only complaint about C&C wood fire eats is that they don’t deliver. However, if you’re willing to take the time and visit them in person, it’s definitely worth it! This place serves some of the best pizza I’ve ever tried in The Keys – I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend it to anyone looking for great food!

#5 “Off The Hook” Grill

The restaurant is a great spot for tourists – its unique location and amazing view of the water make it an ideal spot to spend a relaxing evening. Plus, you can get alcoholic beverages here, including hard liquor!

I must say that the pizza at “Off The Hook” Grill is top notch. The toppings are fresh and the crust is cooked to perfection. They even offer some interesting specialty pizzas that you won’t find anywhere else.

Not only is the pizza incredible, but they also serve some of the most decadent desserts I’ve ever tasted. So even if you aren’t in the mood for pizza, “Off The Hook” Grill has something delicious to satisfy your sweet tooth!

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery service, so you have to dine in or carry out. But trust me – it’s well worth it!

Overall, I highly recommend checking out “Off The Hook” Grill if you’re looking for the best pizza in The Keys. It’s truly an experience that you won’t forget!

#6 Duetto Pizza and Gelato

Located in a quaint little strip mall, this restaurant had me hooked from the very first bite. The margherita pizza was delicious with just the right amount of tomato, cheese and basil. The crust was ideal – crispy on the outside, but still chewy on the inside.

The gelato was equally as amazing – it tasted like a scoop of heaven with its creamy texture and flavors that melt in your mouth. I tried all seven of their flavors, and each one was better than the last!

But the real star at Duetto Pizza and Gelato is definitely the staff. Everyone there is friendly, knowledgeable about their menu and always happy to provide a great experience for their customers. Plus, it’s always fun chatting with them about their favorite pizzas and gelato flavors!

If you’re ever in The Keys looking for a truly exceptional pizza experience, then look no further than Duetto Pizza and Gelato! It’s definitely one of the best places to get pizza in The Keys (and maybe even the world). Highly recommended!

#7 Mr. Z’s

I’m glad I made the trip just to try it! The place had a great vibe and the staff was very friendly. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted with a warm welcome and offered a seat right at the bar.

The menu had all sorts of different pizzas with lots of unique toppings. After much debating, I decided to go with their signature dish: the Mr. Z’s Special! It was loaded with delicious pepperoni, bacon, onions, mushrooms, and jalapenos. It was fantastic! The crust was thin and crispy while still being chewy like traditional New York-style pizza. The toppings were cooked to perfection and blended perfectly together.

To top it off, they also serve amazing craft beers from breweries around Florida that pair wonderfully with their pizza. All in all, it’s one of the best pizza places I’ve ever been too! If you’re looking for really good pizza in The Keys – this is definitely your spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 41 miles, you can get to 9 more pizza places in Marathon!

#8 Roostica

The benefit that really sealed the deal for me was their insanely good dessert—I mean, it was so great I literally couldn’t believe it. If you’re looking for a sweets fix after dinner then this is your place.

And if you have kids with you, they’re in luck too! Roostica has a kid’s menu so they can enjoy pizza while the adults indulge. Plus, they serve alcohol (including hard liquor!) which makes it a great tourist spot.

Although the only downside is that they don’t have delivery, that’s really the only bad thing I could think of. What’s even better is that they also have some vegetarian options so everyone can be happy.

So if you’re in The Keys and looking for the best pizza around, then look no further than Roostica!

#9 Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria

I was immediately taken aback by the pleasant atmosphere as I walked in. The wood accents and cozy booths made the atmosphere feel like a hidden gem, despite it being right on Main Street.

The staff were friendly and attentive and described each of the pizzas they had on offer in detail. I opted for their signature ‘Keys Margherita’ – a classic Neapolitan pizza with just tomato, mozzarella, some basil leaves and extra virgin olive oil. Let me tell you, it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted! The crust was crisp yet chewy and hearty and the topping was light yet flavoursome; definitely an expertly crafted pizza!

The ‘Keys Margherita’ wasn’t my only experience at Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria though; I also had their flagship ‘Grande Capricciosa’, a more indulgent pizza with tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, ham, mushrooms, artichokes, black olives and oregano. Again, this pizza lived up to its billing – a rich flavour profile that caused every bite to be savoured.

Simply put: If you’re looking for the best pizza in The Keys then look no further than Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria. You’d be hard-pressed to find a better place to get your Italian fix!

#10 Baypoint Market

It’s always a pleasure to walk into Baypoint Market and smell the delicious aromas of gourmet pizza. From the wood-burning ovens to the fresh ingredients, everything is top-notch. The pizzas come in classic styles, as well as some unique combinations that make for an unforgettable experience.

The staff at Baypoint Market is also outstanding. They are friendly, knowledgeable, and have great advice when it comes to choosing the best pies. Plus, they are more than happy to answer any questions you may have about the offerings.

The downside? Unfortunately, there is no delivery service at this time, so you’ll need to visit the restaurant in person if you want to enjoy their delectable pizzas. But trust me when I say it’s worth it!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in The Keys, look no further than Baypoint Market!

#11 Enrico’s Pizza

As soon as I stepped foot in the door, the quaint atmosphere was warm and inviting. And then there was the smell of the pizza baking in the oven – it was irresistible!

I ordered a classic marinara pie, and to my surprise, it tasted even better than it smelled. Every bite was filled with cheesy goodness and all sorts of delicious toppings that melted in my mouth.

The staff at Enrico’s are incredibly friendly, too. Everyone from the cashier to the busboy went out of their way to ensure that I had a great experience. They even let me sample some of their secret recipes!

If you’re ever near The Keys and want a truly amazing slice of pizza, head over to Enrico’s Pizza – it’s definitely worth it! The quality is outstanding, and you won’t be disappointed. In my opinion, they have some of the best pizza in The Keys!

#12 Stone Oven Pizzeria – The Whistle Stop

I arrived to this family-owned establishment, pleasantly surprised to find that it had a terrific atmosphere. The staff were friendly and welcoming, and the decor was warm and inviting.

But I was here for one thing – the pizza. And let me tell you, it didn’t disappoint! The crust was crisp yet chewy with just the right amount of charring on the edges. The toppings were vibrant and fresh — especially the local seafood varieties — and the tomato sauce was flavorful but not too overpowering.

The pizza at Stone Oven Pizzeria – The Whistle Stop is truly an experience worth having! It’s no wonder why they’re known as having some of the best pizza in The Keys; I certainly recommend it if you’re ever in the area!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria

Now, I’ve had my fair share of thin crust pizzas in my pizza-eating escapades, and let me tell you, this place knows what they’re doing. As soon as I walked in, I was hit with the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked dough and perfectly melted cheese. My taste buds were dancing with joy even before taking my first bite.

The menu at Onlywood is an open invitation to pizza heaven. They have a variety of unique toppings that will make your taste buds do a little happy dance. Who knew that truffle oil and arugula could be such a killer combo on a pizza? And let’s not forget about the oh-so-cheesy margherita pizza that practically melts in your mouth. It’s like a symphony of flavors that will make you weak at the knees.

The staff at Onlywood are equally as impressive as their pizza. They’re friendly, efficient, and they know their stuff. They even let me in on a little secret about their dough – it’s made with a special blend of flours imported directly from Italy. Talk about authenticity!

So, if you find yourself in Key West and craving the best thin crust pizza around, look no further than Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria. It’s a slice of pizza heaven that will have you coming back for more. Just make sure you bring your stretchy pants – you’re going to need them!