Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Springfield IL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Illinois

Best Pizza in Springfield IL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

406 Views

From thin-crusts to deep-dish, I’ve journeyed around the city testing out 12 different pizza places to determine who serves up the best ‘za.

I’m about to embark on a delicious and irreverent tour of Springfield’s pizza scene. But can any of them stack up against the best I’ve tried from around the world? Let’s find out!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Illinois

#1 Nancy’s Chicago Pizza

The first thing that struck me about Nancy’s was the incredible atmosphere. From the Chicago-style decor to the warm and friendly staff, it was clear I made the right choice for dinner.

The pizza itself was nothing short of amazing. The crust was perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crunch, and the toppings were cooked to perfection. The cheeses were gooey and melted in my mouth with each bite, and all of their special sauce combinations brought out flavors I hadn’t tasted before!

On top of it all, Nancy’s pizza is surprisingly affordable! With large pizzas costing under $15, you won’t have to break the bank to enjoy some great pizza.

If you haven’t already been there yet, what are you waiting for? Definitely check out Nancy’s Chicago Pizza for some of the best pizza in Springfield IL! You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 59 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Bloomington!

#2 Robert Reynolds’ Favorite Pizza Place

I was skeptical when I first arrived. It’s a tiny, unassuming place, and I wasn’t sure what to expect. But then I tasted their pizza and it was clear: this place really knows how to make a great pie!

The crust was perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crispiness, and the cheese was so flavorful. You could really taste the love that has been put into making each pie here. The toppings were fresh and vibrant, making for an unbeatable combination of taste and texture.

The best part about Robert Reynolds’ Favorite Pizza Place is that you can watch them make the pizza right in front of you. It almost feels like you are part of the process as they carefully craft each pie with care and attention to detail.

One downside is that they don’t offer delivery, so if you’re looking for takeout pizza then this might not be your spot – but trust me, it’s worth taking the trip out to Springfield IL to enjoy some of the best pizza around!

#3 La Piazza Cucina Italiana

The atmosphere inside is vibrant and inviting. The walls are adorned with blown-up photos of Italy, as well as some hilarious quotes about pizza. Plus, the dim lighting just sets the right mood.

When it comes to the food, La Piazza knows what they’re doing. The pizza crust is crispy and golden brown, like the perfect Italian grandmother’s recipe. And that about sums up its flavour—comforting and satisfying in every bite.

What impressed me most was the sheer variety of toppings available on their pizzas. From spinach and ricotta to smoked bacon and wild mushrooms, there’s something for everyone here! My personal favourite is the four-cheese pizza—the gooeyness of mozzarella and gorgonzola mixed with creamy provolone gives it a unique texture that I just can’t get enough of.

To top off my amazing experience at La Piazza Cucina Italiana, I was served an incredible tiramisu for dessert. It almost felt like I was back in Italy!

All in all, if you’re looking for some authentic Italian pizza in Springfield IL, La Piazza Cucina Italiana should be your first stop. Their delicious recipes, friendly service and great atmosphere make it one of the best places to enjoy a slice (or two!) in town!

#4 Dillon’s Pizza

I recently stopped by their restaurant for lunch, and I must say that it was one of the best pizza experiences I’ve had all year.

First of all, the atmosphere of the restaurant is fantastic—it has a fun, family-friendly vibe while still feeling upscale. The staff are friendly and attentive, making sure that I was comfortable throughout my experience.

But most importantly—the pizza! Oh wow! Dillon’s Pizza definitely lives up to its reputation as having some of the best pizza around. The dough is light and fluffy, and the toppings are always fresh and delicious. And the cheese! It’s so gooey and flavorful that it melts in your mouth with every bite.

If you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Springfield IL, then be sure to stop by Dillon’s Pizza. You won’t regret it!

#5 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

My first experience with Papa Murphy’s had me questioning my decision. It was late at night, and I’m sure the only person working was either half-asleep or still in the weeds, because it was a good 20 minutes before my order finally made it out. I almost fell asleep while waiting!

But all that changed once I opened that cheesy, gooey pizza. Much like a charm bracelet from a magical land, as soon as I tasted it, everything melted away and all of my worries were forgotten. The pizza was absolutely incredible!

The dough is always cooked to perfection and the sauce has just the right amount of sweetness to complement all the other flavors. The cheese is also incredibly delicious — an absolute revelation for someone who’s used to eating cardboard cheez whiz pizzas for most of his life.

Not only does Papa Murphy’s make one of the best pizzas in Springfield IL — they do it with great customer service too. Everyone there is always so nice and accommodating, no matter how long you wait or how picky your order might be. They really make you feel like family!

Overall, if you’re ever in Springfield looking for great pizza — don’t pass up on Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza! You won’t regret having some of the best pizza in town.

#6 Pie’s The Limit

The atmosphere of Pie’s The Limit is both casual and inviting, making it the perfect spot to grab a pizza with friends. The staff is friendly and helpful, always ready to answer questions or give suggestions – I’ve never had such great service! Plus, you can order online if you’re short on time.

As for the pizzas, they are out of this world! The crust is always perfectly cooked, just soft enough to be tender and crisp enough to hold up when loaded with toppings. The toppings are always fresh and tasty – definitely something for everyone. And the cheese – oh my goodness, the cheese! So creamy and delicious it will make your tastebuds do a dance!

Overall I highly recommend Pie’s The Limit for anyone looking for the best pizza in Springfield IL. Go give it a try – you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Gabatoni’s Restaurant

I had heard good things about Gabatoni’s, and I was not disappointed. From the moment I entered their cozy Italian-style dining room with its checkered tablecloths and warm lighting, I knew this was going to be an enjoyable experience.

The service was friendly and helpful, and the staff seemed genuinely excited for me to try their delicious pizza menu. Every single thing on the menu looked amazing – from the classic margarita to more unusual creations like the Mediterranean (featuring feta cheese and olives). Ultimately, I chose their specialty pie – the Napoli – which is topped with eggplant, mushrooms and mozzarella cheese.

The crust was perfect: not too thick or thin, just right! The toppings were all cooked just right as well – flavorful but not overpowering. It was definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had in my life.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Springfield IL then Gabatoni’s Restaurant should be your first stop! Delicious food, great atmosphere, friendly staff – what more could you ask for? Highly recommended!

#8 J.T. Costelloe’s Pizza Pub and Grill

You can tell the difference in quality from the moment you walk into the restaurant, with the smoky, inviting aroma of the wood-fired ovens. The menu is filled with all sorts of delicious options, from classic combinations to their signature pies.

Their pizzas are always cooked to perfection, with a crisp and chewy crust topped with fresh ingredients and savory sauces. The flavors are bold and distinct without being overpowering. And it’s all made in house with locally sourced ingredients!

I have to say that I was most impressed by their service—the staff here really goes above and beyond to make sure every customer gets top notch service. From helping you decide which pie is best for your tastes to offering advice on what side dishes pair perfectly, they’re always very friendly and helpful.

If you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Springfield IL, then look no further than J.T Costelloe’s Pizza Pub and Grill! It’s definitely one of the best pizza places I’ve been too—definitely tops my list!

If you’re willing to go an extra 64 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Peoria!

#9 Antonio’s Pizza

The traditional crust was thin and crispy, while the toppings were plentiful and just bursting with flavor. The service was truly top-notch – they welcomed me with a smile and went out of their way to make me feel like part of their family. I could tell right away these folks know what they’re doing when it comes to pizza!

My favorite was the classic pepperoni pizza. It had the perfect amount of cheese, meat, and aroma. And they didn’t skimp on the olives either – my mouth is watering just thinking about it.

I also got a chance to try some of their more unique offerings like the Hawaiian pizza and buffalo chicken pizza as well. Both were absolutely delicious! They even let me sample a bit before ordering so I could get an idea of what I liked most.

All in all, Antonio’s Pizza is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Springfield IL! Their prices are reasonable, their selection is huge, and the quality is simply unbeatable. If you’re ever looking for a tasty slice that won’t break your budget, definitely give them a try!

#10 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The first thing I noticed was the freshness of the ingredients. Every single topping on their pizzas was fresh and flavorful, from their signature marinara sauce to their real cheese. And let me tell you – nothing tops Papa Murphy’s crust! It’s never soggy or greasy, which is a huge plus in my book.

The prices are affordable too, so you can enjoy their delicious pizza without breaking the bank. Their online ordering system is also super simple and quick – perfect for when I’m on the go and don’t have time to wait around.

All in all, I’d definitely recommend Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza to anyone looking for the best pizza in Springfield IL. Fast service, great ingredients and decent prices make it a winning combination!

#11 Bernie & Betty’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Bernie & Betty’s Pizza is cozy and inviting, so it was the perfect place to grab a slice. The smell of freshly cooked dough with melted cheese wafted through the air, and I could not wait to dig in.

The pizza I ordered was delicious! Not too greasy or cheesy—just enough of each that it was the perfect balance. The crust had a light crispiness, while still being chewy. The pizza also had an incredibly fresh taste because Bernie & Betty use only top-quality ingredients. Every bite was better than the last and melted in my mouth!

To top it all off, the service was great as well. Everyone working there seemed to enjoy their job and were always smiling. They made me feel welcome and like I belonged there.

After eating at Bernie & Betty’s Pizza, I can gladly say that it offers some of the best pizza in Springfield IL!

#12 Joe’s Italian Pizza in Springfield (not Lincoln)

As soon as I stepped through the door, I felt the warmth of the ovens and smelt the delicious aroma of tomato sauce and cheese. The first thing that struck me was how cheerful the staff were – they really seemed to love what they do.

The pizza here is absolutely delicious! The crust was perfectly crisp, yet also slightly chewy. It was full of flavor and just a bit salty, but not too much – just enough to make it really tasty. The toppings were all freshly prepared and exceptionally flavorful – from meaty pepperoni to zesty mushrooms, there was something for everyone!

It’s clear that great care has gone into creating each dish here at Joe’s Italian Pizza. And let’s not forget about their amazing dessert pizzas – I’m still dreaming about that chocolate one with Oreo crumbs!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Springfield IL, Joe’s Italian Pizza should definitely be your go-to spot. They’ve certainly earned my five stars!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Nancy’s Pizza

Picture this: I walked into Nancy’s Pizza expecting just another average pie, but boy, was I in for a cheesy surprise! The moment I sunk my teeth into their deep dish creation, I was transported to a whole new dimension of saucy delight.

The first thing that caught my eye was the size of the slice. It was so big, I could use it as a makeshift frisbee if I ever needed to have a slice on the go! And when I say deep dish, I mean DEEP dish. The crust was as tall and proud as Mount Everest, and just as satisfying to conquer.

The cheese, oh the cheese! It stretched like a yoga instructor who’d been practicing for centuries. It was the kind of cheese that could solve any existential crisis – one bite and all my worries melted like mozzarella on a hot summer day.

And the toppings? Let me tell you, they were piled on with reckless abandon. Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, and more! It was like a pizza party exploded on my plate and I was here for it.

But let’s not forget the sauce. It had just the right amount of tanginess to cut through the richness of the cheese. It was like a harmonious symphony playing in my mouth, with each ingredient adding its own unique flavor note.

So, if you find yourself in Springfield, IL craving some deep dish perfection, look no further than Nancy’s Pizza. Your taste buds will thank you, and I guarantee you’ll leave with a smile on your face and a belly full of pizza-induced happiness.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Gabatoni’s Restaurant

Now, I’ve been to Italy, New York, and even tried pizza in the deepest corners of the Amazon rainforest (yeah, they have pizza there too), but nothing can compare to the sheer deliciousness that Gabatoni’s offers.

First off, the crust. It’s so thin, you could use it as a makeshift frisbee in case of a pizza emergency! But don’t worry, it’s not flimsy. It’s crispy, yet somehow manages to be chewy at the same time. It’s like the pizza gods themselves blessed this place with the perfect crust.

And let’s not forget about the toppings. Gabatoni’s has an extensive menu of unique and mouthwatering combinations. Where else in Springfield can you find a pizza topped with pickles, pineapple, and pancetta? It may sound odd, but trust me, it’s a flavor explosion in your mouth. I dare you to find another place that combines such unusual ingredients with such finesse.

Oh, and the cheese! It stretches like the elastic in your waistband after you’ve had one too many slices. It’s gooey, it’s melty, it’s everything you could ever want in a cheese topping. It’s like they have a direct hotline to the cheese gods themselves, ensuring that every slice is perfect.

So, if you’re in Springfield and craving some pizza, don’t waste your time on any other joint. Gabatoni’s is the place to be. Trust me, I’m a professional pizza connoisseur.