Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Staten Island NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Staten Island NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

317 Views

I’ve sampled pizza all over the world and was pleasantly surprised when I landed back in Staten Island. With 12 pizza places to try, I’m on a mission to find the best slice in town!

This isn’t fine dining, but rather a lighthearted take on the top pizzas available. So grab your napkins and settle in for some serious pizza tasting!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern

When I first walked in the door, I was overwhelmed by the array of aromas emanating from the kitchen. The heavenly scent of melted cheese, fresh basil, and garlic wafting out into the dining area gave me a hint about what was to come.

I ordered their signature pie – a classic Margherita pizza with fresh mozzarella and basil. Let me tell you, my expectations were far exceeded! The thin, perfectly crisp crust was laden with gooey cheese and vibrant sauce that delivered an explosion of bold flavors to my taste buds. Each bite provided layers of flavor combined with just the right amount of grease.

But it’s not only the pizza that makes Denino’s stand out from other restaurants – their welcoming environment makes it an ideal spot for any night out. With its rustic decor and cozy atmosphere, I felt like I was part of an extended family as soon as I stepped through the door.

In conclusion, if you’re ever in Staten Island NY looking for some world-class pizza, head to Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern – it’s where you’ll find some of the best slices around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Bayonne!

#2 Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe

The pizza here is consistent and I’ve never had a bad experience. The restaurant itself has an inviting atmosphere, with the coal fire and brick oven burning brightly in view of the dining area. The menu features a wide range of classic pizzas, along with some unique creations that will truly tantalize your taste buds.

My personal favorite is their custom Coal Fired Pizza – loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers and onions. It’s cooked perfectly so that all the flavors meld together exquisitely for one amazing bite after another! And because this pizza joint is coal fired, it adds an extra smoky flavor to the pizza that you don’t get anywhere else.

I also have to give special props to the service staff at Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe. They are incredibly helpful and always more than happy to chat about their pizza creation process or answer questions. Plus they’re really friendly – I feel like they make me part of their own family whenever I’m there!

Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for great pizza in Staten Island NY – it’s by far the best option around!

#3 Lee’s Tavern

The place was great to visit. First, there’s the atmosphere: it’s got that authentic Staten Island vibe, with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable about the food they served, which tripled my satisfaction.

Being a traveling food critic, it’s important to find places that serve both good food and good drinks – and I’m happy to report that Lee’s Tavern has both! Along with their amazing pizza (which really is some of the best in all of Staten Island NY!), they offer many different alcoholic options, including hard liquor. That definitely adds to the experience!

Best of all, watching sports while you eat your pizza is possible at Lee’s Tavern too! Their TVs are always on the latest games, making it a great place to hang out with friends and enjoy some delicious pizza while rooting for your team.

My only complaint about Lee’s Tavern is that there is no delivery option for their pizza – you have to come into the bar in order to get the full experience. But if you’re from Statin Island NY or just passing through, it’s definitely worth checking out!

#4 Nonna’s Pizza Great Kills

The first thing I noticed when I walked into the restaurant was the wonderful aroma of freshly made pizza. The place had a lovely atmosphere, with a cozy brick-oven feel.

When it came time to order, I opted for a pepperoni and mushroom pizza; it was simply delicious! The crust was perfectly crispy and the sauce was flavorful without being too spicy. The toppings were cooked to perfection, with every bite truly packed with flavor.

I would definitely recommend Nonna’s Pizza Great Kills to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Staten Island NY! And don’t forget to try their famous garlic knots – they’re out of this world!

#5 Sal & Lloyd’s Pizza Place

The smell of the delicious pizza is delightful as soon as you walk in, and the locals always seem to be enjoying their food. The staff is friendly and helpful – they don’t mind answering all my questions about their delicious pies.

The pizza here is top notch – it has the perfect amount of crust, plenty of topping, and a delectable blend of flavors that keep me coming back time and time again. The pepperoni is especially good here – they must have some secret seasoning blends that add a unique kick to every bite!

If you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Staten Island NY, Sal & Lloyd’s Pizza Place should definitely be on your list. Their pies never fail to satisfy my craving for a slice of peppery goodness – I’m sure you’ll love it too!

#6 Original Giuseppes Pizza

The crust is cooked to perfection, with a nice crunch yet still soft enough to have that great texture. The sauce is delicious and full of flavor. The cheese is also top-notch, melty and gooey, but also not greasy like some pizza places can be.

And the toppings! Oh my! Every topping imaginable, from classics like pepperoni and sausage to more exotic choices like pineapple and jalapeños. Plus, for those looking for something a bit on the healthier side, they have lovely vegetable toppings too!

The staff are friendly and accommodating at Original Giuseppes Pizza. They really seem to care about the pizza they serve up and it shows in the quality of the food. I’m always greeted with a smile when I visit.

Overall, Original Giuseppes Pizza offers up some of the best pizza in Staten Island NY – high quality ingredients, tasty sauces and great customer service make this spot one worth visiting again and again!

#7 Reggiano’s Brick Oven Pizza

As soon as I stepped through the door, I could smell the distinct aroma of freshly baked dough. The atmosphere was warm and inviting and the staff friendly and attentive. After taking my seat, I eagerly perused the menu, quickly settling on the classic pepperoni pizza.

When my pizza arrived, it was a thing of beauty! The crisp thin crust, slightly charred from its time in Reggiano’s wood fire oven, had me salivating before I even took my first bite. The quality mozzarella cheese melted perfectly on top of the delicious tomato sauce and fragrant basil.

But what really made this pizza stand out were the toppings – perfectly cooked pepperoni slices complemented by a generous sprinkling of parmesan cheese. And if that wasn’t enough to make this one of the best pizzas in Staten Island NY, it also came with fresh garlic knots on the side – an unexpected but welcome addition!

At Reggiano’s Brick Oven Pizza you can expect great food at great prices – you won’t be disappointed!

#8 Goodfella’s

The pizza here is top-notch – the crust is thin and crispy, with the perfect ratio of dough to cheese. The flavors are well-balanced too, with a slight hint of garlic and oregano. While it isn’t the most adventurous pizza in the world (this is Staten Island after all), it hits exactly the right notes for a classic Italian style pizza that goes down easy.

Equally impressive was the atmosphere of Goodfella’s; it felt like I stepped back into an old-fashioned pizzeria from another era! The interior was retro in all the best ways, and there were framed pictures on the wall showing off some of the restaurant’s celebrity guests over the years.

I’m not sure if Goodfella’s makes THE best pizza in Staten Island NY, but it’s definitely up there. Whether you’re looking for a quick slice on your lunch break or you want to sit down and enjoy a full pie, I’d heartily recommend this spot as one of your go-to places for great food.

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Elizabeth!

#9 Seppe Pizza Bar

When I first walked into this restaurant, the warm and inviting atmosphere pulled me in straight away. The staff were friendly and even gave me a few pointers on what to order, which I really appreciated.

The pizza was incredible! The dough was crisp and light with a great balance of flavour, and the toppings were cooked just right. Even better, they offered many different kinds so you could always find something new to try.

I had heard rumours that Seppe Pizza Bar offers some of the best pizza in Staten Island NY – let me tell you, those rumours are true! I would highly recommend it for anyone wanting to experience an amazing pizza feast.

#10 Paesano’s Pizzeria

Since my first visit a few months ago, it has become my go-to for a truly delicious slice. The crust is perfectly cooked, crunchy and full of flavor. And the sauce? Absolutely exquisite. I don’t think I’ve ever had sauce that tastes so good before!

The selection of toppings is also top notch — you can find everything from classic pepperoni to more adventurous creations like pineapple and jalapeños. Every topping is fresh and flavorful, adding to the overall deliciousness of the pizza.

And the service at Paesano’s Pizzeria definitely adds to its charm; the staff are always friendly and helpful, making sure our visit was as pleasant as possible (and with all that delicious pizza around, it usually is!).

In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Staten Island NY, look no further than Paesano’s Pizzeria — you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Brother’s Pizzeria

The first time I tried their pizza, I was amazed at the quality and flavor of the pie. The crust was perfectly cooked, the sauce had just the right amount of sweetness, and the cheese was so flavorful it almost melted in my mouth.

When it comes to toppings, Brother’s Pizzeria has something for everyone. From pepperoni to mushrooms and sausage, they have it all! My favorite topping is their zesty buffalo chicken – packed with flavor and spice, it adds an amazing pop of flavor to any slice.

The service at Brother’s Pizzeria is top-notch as well. The staff is always friendly and accommodating and they make sure that your pizza is made just the way you want it. They also have a great selection of craft beers if you want to enjoy a cold one with your pizza!

If you’re ever in Staten Island NY looking for some great pizza, look no further than Brother’s Pizzeria – you’ll be glad you did!

#12 Round Pie Pizza Company

The ambiance of the place was welcoming, with a cozy atmosphere and vintage decor. The staff was friendly and professional; they made sure I had everything I needed for my dining experience.

My pizza arrived quickly and it was amazing – perfectly cooked with a crispy crust and delicious toppings. My favorite topping was the traditional pepperoni but they offer other more exotic choices like fresh pineapple & prosciutto or wild mushroom & truffle oil, so everyone’s sure to find something they love.

The service was great; the servers were attentive and always made sure that my glass of wine never ran dry! They also have an impressive selection of craft beers, too.

Overall, Round Pie Pizza Company is an excellent spot for pizza lovers in Staten Island NY – they serve up some of the best pies I’ve ever tasted!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Metro Pizza

But first, let’s address the downsides. Metro Pizza, I have to tell you, does not accept reservations. I mean, come on people, do they not know who I am? I am Edward, the great traveling food critic! I demand a VIP table at all times! But alas, I had to wait like a mere mortal. It was humbling, to say the least.

But boy, oh boy, was it worth the wait! Once I sunk my teeth into that cheesy, saucy goodness, all my grievances melted away. The crust was perfectly crisp yet doughy, with a satisfying crunch in every bite. The toppings were generous, and the combination of flavors was like a symphony in my mouth. I couldn’t help but do a little happy dance in my seat.

And as if the savory pizzas weren’t enough, Metro Pizza has the audacity to offer an array of delectable desserts! I indulged in their Nutella-filled calzone and let me tell you, it was like an explosion of happiness in my mouth. I’m pretty sure I heard angels sing. It was the perfect end to a pizza-filled feast.

So, while Metro Pizza may have some downsides, like not accepting reservations, their deep dish pizza is hands down the best in metro detroit. Trust me, dear readers, it’s worth the wait and the temporary humiliation of not being recognized as the world-famous critic that I am.