Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Brick NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Brick NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

154 Views

After sampling pizza from twelve different establishments, I’m here to deliver my verdict on the best pizza that Brick NJ has to offer. It’s a tough job, but someone’s got to do it – and I’m the perfect person for the task.

So whether you’re a resident looking for something new or just passing through town, sit back and take notes as I humorously guide you through my top picks for the best Brick NJ has to offer. Bon appetit!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Mike’s Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped in the door, I knew this place was something special. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with red and white checkered tablecloths on each table and a fireplace in the corner that always made me feel right at home. The staff were friendly, knowledgeable and passionate about their pizza, yet also welcoming to people like myself who weren’t as familiar with their menu.

The highlight of this restaurant was definitely the pizza! With so many delicious combinations to choose from, it wasn’t hard to find something (or several somethings!) that suited my taste buds. They offer classic varieties like pepperoni and sausage, as well as more creative options like BBQ chicken or even a breakfast pizza! Each one was cooked to perfection – the crust was crispy but not too thick, the sauce zesty without being overpowering, and topping generous without drowning out all other ingredients.

Of course no meal would be complete without dessert- and Mike’s Pizzeria did not disappoint! I especially enjoyed their homemade cannolis stuffed with creamy ricotta cheese filling.

In summary, if you’re looking for an unforgettable culinary experience in Brick NJ then Mike’s Pizzeria is a must! Not only can you enjoy some of the best pizza in town but also a variety of other Italian treats like calzones, stromboli, sandwiches – and even delicious desserts!.

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Point Pleasant!

#2 Serpico’s Pizza

From the moment I walked into Serpico’s Pizza, I knew I was in for something special. The atmosphere was inviting and friendly – somehow they made me feel like I was a regular even on my first visit!

I started with their signature pizza – the Serpico Special. It was loaded with toppings and cheese, and it tasted like a little slice of heaven! The crust was light and fluffy, yet still had a flavorful crunch to it. The sauce melted in my mouth and the combination of flavors were exquisite.

Next up was their famous brick oven pizza. This one had an extra crispy crust that was as thin as paper but still held its own against all the toppings. The sauce oozed out when cut into slices and the combination of flavors left me in absolute bliss.

And last but certainly not least – we tried their amazing deep dish pizza! This one was cooked to perfection, with a flaky crust that still managed to hold all of its juicy toppings inside. It was filled with piles of cheese that seemed to go on forever and the taste simply blew me away. After tasting this pizza, I can honestly say it’s one of the best pizzas I’ve ever eaten – anywhere in the world!

I cannot recommend Serpico’s Pizza enough – if you’re ever in Brick NJ, this is definitely your spot for some of the best pizza around.

#3 LG’s Pizza & Pasta

From the moment I walked in, I could tell that this was a place that really took their pizza seriously. The pizza ovens were roaring at high temperatures, and the smell of delicious dough filled the air. The staff greeted me with smiles, ready to serve up a piping hot pie.

I ordered one of LG’s iconic specialty pies – the “Grandma Pizza” – and it certainly did not disappoint! The freshly made dough was thin and crispy with just the right amount of crunch when I bit into it. On top, LG had loaded on plenty of cheese, mushrooms, peppers and sausage that all added up to a delicious combination.

No matter what kind of pizza you’re looking for, LG’s has something to satisfy your craving. They have regular options like pepperoni or Hawaiian as well as creative choices such as BBQ Chicken or Cheeseburger Pizza. And don’t forget about their pasta dishes either; they’re equally delicious!

Overall, I’d easily say that LG’s Pizza & Pasta is some of the best pizza in Brick NJ and should be on everyone’s list when it comes time for pizza night!

#4 Victory Pizza

As soon as I walked in, I was pleasantly surprised by the restaurant’s modern yet old-world feel. The decor combined rustic brick walls with bold and vibrant artwork, creating an atmosphere that was inviting and fun.

The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful throughout my visit, going out of their way to make me feel welcome. They even offered me samples of some of their best pizza before I made a decision on what to order.

When it came time to order my pizza, I chose one of their unique creations and have no regrets! The crust was perfectly crispy with just the right amount of crunchiness. The sauce was flavorful without being overly acidic, while the toppings were both generous and well-seasoned. To top it all off, the cheese melted evenly over everything for that classic cheesy flavor we all know and love about pizza.

All in all, Victory Pizza is a great option for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Brick NJ! Their delicious creations are sure to tantalize your taste buds while their warm hospitality will make you feel right at home. Highly recommended!

#5 Brick Oven

The atmosphere in the restaurant is great. The pizza cooks are always friendly and welcoming, and they really know their stuff when it comes to making a good pie.

The pizzas here are made using traditional methods, which give them an amazing rich flavor. The crust has the perfect crunchy bite and is cooked to perfection every time. The toppings are always fresh and flavorful, with plenty of cheese, meats, vegetables and spices to choose from.

The prices at Brick Oven are also very reasonable considering the high quality of the food. They even offer specials from time to time so you can get even more bang for your buck!

Overall, I would highly recommend Brick Oven for anyone looking for a top-notch pizza experience in Brick NJ. It’s definitely one of my go-to places whenever I’m craving a delicious slice of pizza!

#6 Nickolas Pizza Restaurant

Upon entering Nickolas Pizza Restaurant, I was met with a warm welcome and great service. The decor was homely and inviting, a stark contrast to the more modern pizzerias I have visited in my travels.

The first thing that caught my eye upon perusing the menu was the sheer variety of pizzas they offered. With options such as classic Italian margherita to unique creations like Hawaiian barbecue, it’s easy to see why Nickolas Pizza restaurant is one of the top pizzerias in Brick NJ.

After placing my order for a specialty pizza (garlic chicken with roasted red peppers), I took some time to observe the pizza-making process. What I saw astounded me; it appeared that every effort had been made to ensure that every pizza delivered was cooked perfectly, right down to the last detail.

When my garlic chicken and roasted red pepper pizza arrived at my table, I can say without exaggeration that it was one of the most delicious pizzas I’ve ever tasted. The crust was crispy and flavorful, while the toppings were cooked just right – not too soggy or overcooked.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Brick NJ, then look no further than Nickolas Pizza Restaurant!

#7 Saturn Pizza

I was particularly impressed with the variety of menu offerings – from classic Italian pizzas to creative signature pies. The crust had just the right amount of crunchiness, and each pizza was perfectly cooked.

The ingredients were fresh, plentiful and flavorful. From the generous portions of cheese to the juicy slices of pepperoni, everything tasted great. I especially liked that they offer vegan pizza options as well.

I was also pleasantly surprised by the prices – they offer fair prices for the quality that you receive.

The atmosphere was welcoming and fun – perfect for getting together with friends or family for a pizza night! To top it all off, the service was excellent – friendly and attentive without being too intrusive or pushy.

Overall, if you’re looking for an enjoyable evening out paired with delicious pizza in Brick NJ, then Saturn Pizza is your place!

#8 Denino’s South Pizzeria

I have been to Italy, Greece, and all throughout the United States tasting pizza, and Denino’s South is by far one of my favorites. What sets this pizza apart from the rest is the unique taste of their crust. It has a fantastic flavor that goes perfectly with every topping they offer.

The toppings are also top notch! Whether you’re looking for something classic like pepperoni or something more out there like pineapple and bacon, Denino’s South has it all. They really put some thought into their menu.

The atmosphere at Denino’s South Pizzeria was great as well! The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, the restaurant was clean, and I truly felt at home while enjoying my slice of pizza perfection.

If you want to experience some of the best pizza in Brick NJ (or frankly anywhere else) then Denino’s South Pizzeria is definitely your spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Toms River!

#9 Federico’s Pizza

The atmosphere alone is worth the trip. It’s got a classic Italian charm that really helps to set the mood. The rustic decor and warm, welcoming staff make you feel right at home.

I ordered their special, the Chicken Alfredo Pizza –– wow! It was loaded with delicious cheese and toppings, plus it had a wonderful garlic cream sauce that all came together perfectly. The crust was just crunchy enough to hold all of those delicious flavors in balance, making for an unforgettable experience.

The best part though might have been the freshly made dough. They don’t skimp on quality or flavor. This pizza was light and fluffy but had enough substance to stand up to any other pies I’ve ever tasted. And trust me when I say that I know what good pizza tastes like!

Finally, the service was top-notch –– they really go out of their way to ensure your satisfaction. Whether you’re a guest or a frequent visitor, you can depend on this place to deliver excellent quality every time.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Brick NJ then look no further than Federico’s Pizza –– it’s simply unbeatable!

#10 Papa V’s

First, the atmosphere is really upbeat and inviting, with bright lights, vivid colors, and lively music. The staff are all extremely friendly, which makes the experience even more enjoyable.

The pizza itself? Delicious! The crust comes out perfectly thin and crispy with that slight char that I love so much. It’s not too greasy or heavy. The sauce is fantastic – rich, flavorful and just slightly sweet. And the toppings – oh my goodness! From savory cured meats to flavorful roasted peppers to creamy tangy cheeses – each topping adds something unique and delicious to the mix.

I would highly recommend this place for anyone who wants the best pizza in Brick NJ!

#11 La Fontana Pizzeria

I was skeptical at first since Brick NJ doesn’t usually come to mind when you think about great places for pizza, but boy was I wrong.

The fresh ingredients and traditional wood-fired oven really set the pizzas from La Fontana Pizzeria apart. The crust is cooked to perfection with a slightly charred flavor that really helps bring out the other flavors of the pizza. The sauces are flavorful and vibrant and every topping on the pies I’ve had have been spot on!

The atmosphere at La Fontana Pizzeria is relaxed and laid-back, which is perfect for just kicking back and enjoying a slice or two of their delicious pies. They also offer takeout and delivery for those days when you don’t feel like going out.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Brick NJ then look no further than La Fontana Pizzeria! They’ll definitely satisfy your cravings!

#12 Oscar’s Pizza & Restaurant

My first experience at Oscar’s was delightful, and it certainly set the bar high for all the other pizza places in Brick. Upon arrival, I was immediately overwhelmed by the delicious smell of fresh pizzas cooking in their wood-burning oven, as well as the friendly staff behind the counter.

As I took my seat, I could barely contain my excitement to dig into a slice of their famous pepperoni pizza! From the first bite, I knew that I had found something special. The dough was light and airy with just enough crunchiness from the char on the crust. On top of that, they weren’t stingy with their toppings – each slice had a generous helping of melted cheese and slices of flavorful pepperoni.

The atmosphere at Oscar’s is also great – it has a cozy family feel that’s perfect for a casual night out or even an intimate dinner gathering. Plus, they have a decent selection of beers to choose from so you can really make your meal complete!

Overall, I’m so glad to have experienced Oscar’s Pizza & Restaurant while in Brick NJ. They definitely serve up some of the best pizza in town!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Urban CoalHouse Pizza + Bar

Walking into Urban CoalHouse is like stepping into a pizza lover’s dream. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, with the alluring aroma of freshly baked dough wafting through the air. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I thought I had seen it all, but this place truly surprised me.

Let’s talk about the main attraction – the thin crust pizza. Oh boy, where do I even begin? The crust is so thin and crispy that it practically melts in your mouth. It’s like biting into a cloud, if clouds were made of perfectly baked dough and topped with deliciousness. Each bite is a harmonious symphony of textures and flavors.

The toppings at Urban CoalHouse are a work of art. From classic pepperoni to mouthwatering combinations like prosciutto and arugula, they have something to satisfy every palate. And let’s not forget about the cheese! It’s like a velvet blanket covering the entire pizza, oozing with gooey goodness.

The servers at Urban CoalHouse are as charming as the pizza is delicious. They’re knowledgeable about the menu and always ready to offer recommendations. I couldn’t help but chuckle at their playful banter and witty remarks. It added an extra layer of enjoyment to an already delightful dining experience.

So, if you find yourself in Brick, New Jersey, and craving the best thin crust pizza around, look no further than Urban CoalHouse Pizza + Bar. It’s a pizza paradise hiding in plain sight. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed – just make sure to come with an empty stomach and a sense of humor!