Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Philadelphia Barstool (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in Philadelphia Barstool (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

130 Views

I’m on a quest to find the best of the best when it comes to pizza. I’ve been all over the world, tasting different styles and combinations in order to bring you an honest opinion. After spending some quality time exploring Philadelphia Barstool, I found 12 places that made my mouth water! As someone who loves their pizza humorous and lighthearted, these were the most delicious options around. With a little bit of taste-testing and a dash of research, I’m here to present you with my top picks for the “Best Pizza in Philadelphia Barstool”.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 Gaeta’s Tomato Pies

For starters, the atmosphere is fantastic – cozy and bright with traditional Italian decor. The wait staff was friendly and attentive, making sure each diner had a great experience.

Next, the pizza. The crust is perfection – light, crispy, and just the right amount of char. The choice of toppings only added to the excellence. I tried their classic margherita and pepperoni pies which were so tasty I could almost taste the sun-ripened tomatoes used in every bite! And for those who like something hearty and spicy, Gaeta’s has an amazing sausage pie that will have you coming back for more!

Overall I would highly recommend Gaeta’s Tomato Pies as one of the best pizza places in Northeast Philadelphia! If you’re looking for a great meal at reasonable prices, this is definitely the place to go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Bensalem!

#2 Rione

I must say, the pizza at Rione is truly divine. It’s hard to believe that such delicious pizza can be made right in Philadelphia! The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, and the sauce has just the right amount of sweetness. But best of all are the toppings: there’s something for everyone! Whether you’re a fan of classic pepperoni or like to try something more experimental, you’ll find everything you need here.

The atmosphere at Rione is also noteworthy; it’s warm and cozy, with a bit of a retro vibe. The waitstaff are friendly and knowledgeable about their pizzas, so ordering is easy.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Phila, Rione is an absolute must-visit.

#3 PIZZATA PIZZERIA

It’s actually quite incredible: their pizza is truly something extraordinary. The crust is perfectly thin and crunchy, with a great balance of flavor. The sauce is delicious and the toppings are always fresh.

The atmosphere at PIZZATA PIZZERIA is amazing too – it’s cheerful and welcoming without being overly noisy. The staff are friendly and efficient, and they do a great job of making sure that each customer’s experience is top-notch. And best of all, the prices are very reasonable!

Overall, I give my highest recommendation to PIZZATA PIZZERIA – it really is the best pizza in Phila! Go try it out for yourself – you won’t be disappointed!

#4 Circles and Squares

First off, this place is totally worth the trip. I don’t usually drive to get pizza, but for Circles and Squares, it’s a must! The ambiance is inviting, the staff was friendly and knowledgeable, and the decor was cute.

Now on to the pizza: It didn’t disappoint! The crusts were perfect – crispy on the outside while still fluffy in the middle. And the flavors – wow! Toppings were fresh, vibrant and flavorful. Plus there were some interesting vegetarian options that weren’t just your typical veggie pizza.

The only downside of Circles and Squares is that there’s no delivery option. Overall though, if you’re looking for an amazing pie in Phila – this is it! And trust me- coming from a food critic that has traveled around the world in search of great pizza- this place is as close to perfection as you can get!

#5 Square Pie

As I walked in, the smell of freshly-baked pizza greeted me – and my mouth began to water. The restaurant had a cozy atmosphere and was beautifully decorated with art that gave it a nice eclectic flair.

The pizza was cooked to perfection! The crust was thin and crispy, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. The sauce was just spicy enough to pack a punch without being overpowering. Plus, they offer a variety of specialty pizzas, so you’re sure to find something for everyone.

I’m always excited when I get to try new food, but Square Pie really surprised me with how good their pizza is. My taste buds were delighted by the crunchy crust and savory toppings – I think this might be the best pizza in Phila!

#6 Pizza Jawn

I’ve been to a lot of pizza restaurants in my travels, but Pizza Jawn stands out from the crowd. From the moment I walked in, I felt like a king. The vibrant atmosphere made me feel like I was an honored guest, and the cheerful staff truly made me feel welcome.

Where this place really shines is its pizza! The crust was just the right thickness and had a wonderful crispy texture that really appealed to me. The sauce was also delicious – it was just a little tart but made for an amazing contrast with all of the other flavors on the pizza. And let’s not forget about their cheese – it was super ooey gooey and creamy!

But my favorite part of all? Pizza Jawn’s toppings! They have the best selection of topping options I’ve ever seen: everything from pepperoni to prosciutto to artichoke hearts! With so many delicious options available, it’s hard to pick just one favorite topping.

All in all, I would highly recommend Pizza Jawn for anyone looking for great pizza in Philadelphia. Whether you’re an adventurous eater or a traditionalist, there’s something on their menu for everyone – plus they have some seriously tasty beer and wine selections if you’re looking for something to pair with your meal!

#7 20th Street Pizza

I was greeted by the smell of fresh dough, cheese and sauce as I entered the restaurant. The interior was charming, with a classic Italian-American feel – red and white checkered tablecloths, brick walled pizzeria counter, and lively conversation among customers.

The staff at 20th Street Pizza were friendly and helpful, making sure that I had everything I needed to make my experience enjoyable. They weren’t just your typical pizza kids either! They were knowledgeable about their products and were able to answer any questions I had about the different toppings and combinations.

And then it came time to taste some of the best pizza in Phila. It was simply amazing! The crust was nice and crispy with a light cheesy flavor that made me keep coming back for more. The topping combinations weren’t too overwhelming either; they were flavorful yet delicate enough to allow all of the ingredients to shine through in each bite.

Overall, 20th Street Pizza is definitely worth a visit for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Phila! Being able to enjoy such high quality pizza without having to take a plane trip makes this place even better!

#8 The Angelo Pizza

The atmosphere of the place is cozy and comfortable, making it the perfect spot to sit down and enjoy a delicious meal with friends. The staff is friendly and helpful, always making sure that you’re satisfied with your order.

As for the pizza itself, it’s simply amazing. The crust has just the right amount of crunchiness and chewiness, while the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. I highly recommend ordering one of their specialty pizzas – they never fail to impress!

Overall, The Angelo Pizza easily earns its title as one of the best pizza joints in Philadelphia. If you’re looking for a great pizza experience, this is definitely the place to go!

#9 Momma Mia’s Pizzeria

I was a bit skeptical at first because I’m used to trying different types of pizza around the world, but upon walking into Momma Mia’s Pizzeria I was blown away and immediately knew that this place is something special.

The atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting and cozy, which made my meal even more enjoyable. The service was also top-notch and fast, which can sometimes be hard to come by.

And now for the food – it’s simply divine! The crust is crunchy and has a light yeasty flavor that’s not overpowering. The sauce has an amazing depth of flavor from their secret blend of spices that I’ve never tasted before. And the toppings are fresh, flavorful, and plentiful – you don’t have to worry about getting just cheese here.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Northeast Philadelphia, Momma Mia’s Pizzeria should definitely be your go-to spot!

#10 Café Carmela

When I walked into the restaurant, I was immediately struck by the vibrant atmosphere of good music, and bustling customers all enjoying a great meal. They must be doing something right to attract such a diverse clientele!

I was most impressed with their selection of pizzas. From classic Margheritas to creative toppings like roasted garlic and wild mushrooms, there’s a little something for everyone. The pizzas are cooked perfectly: crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Plus, the generous slices will keep you satisfied!

The staff at Café Carmela was another highlight for me – they were super friendly and went out of their way to make sure I had an enjoyable experience.

Overall, Café Carmela is one of my top picks for pizza in Northeast Philadelphia – they’ve earned my seal of approval!

#11 Pizzeria Stella

I’ve never tasted a pizza that was so perfectly cooked with just the right amount of cheese. The crust was exactly as it should be, slightly crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. The tomato sauce was rich and flavorful, and the toppings were all fresh and delicious.

The atmosphere at Pizzeria Stella really added to my experience as well. It’s a cozy little Italian eatery tucked away in Philly’s Italian Market. There’s an authentic brick oven which infuses every slice with that unmistakable flavor of wood-fired pizza – it’s simply amazing!

The service here is also top notch. Every staff member I encountered was friendly and attentive, from the chefs in the back of the house to their waitstaff out front. I felt like I was part of their family, which made for a truly special experience.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Phila, you can’t go wrong with Pizzeria Stella!

#12 Angelo’s Pizzeria

The decor is cozy, with a brick fireplace, inviting booths and table seating. Not to mention the smells of freshly made pizza all throughout the restaurant!

When I tasted their signature pepperoni pizza, it was like eating a little slice of heaven. The dough was crispy on the outside and deliciously soft and chewy inside. Every bite reveals layers of cheese, sauce and vegetables that were cooked to perfection.

The downside is that Angelo’s Pizzeria doesn’t offer delivery service which limits its reach. Nonetheless, if you’re in the city, it’s worth making the trip in for standing-room only experience. Believe me: It will be worth your while!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Joe’s Pizza Philly

But before I dive into the cheesy goodness, let me warn you about one downside of this place – they don’t accept reservations. I mean, come on Joe, it’s 2021! I had to stand in line for what felt like an eternity, watching pizza enthusiasts drool over slices while I anxiously waited for my turn. It was like a cruel joke, and I was the punchline.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza. Oh my, it was a slice of heaven! The crust was so thick and doughy, it was like biting into a cloud. And the cheese! It was like a molten, gooey lava flow of mozzarella. I’m pretty sure I heard angels sing when I took my first bite.

But the real star of the show? The toppings! They piled on every ingredient imaginable. I swear, they must have raided an entire grocery store to create these pies. Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers – you name it, they had it! It was like a mini pizza buffet on my plate.

And let’s not forget the location. Joe’s Pizza Philly is a great tourist spot. It’s right in the heart of the city, surrounded by bustling streets and historic landmarks. So, while waiting for your table, you can take in the sights and pretend to be cultured or something.

So, if you’re willing to endure the reservationless pain, prepare yourself for a deep dish delight at Joe’s Pizza Philly. Trust me, the deliciousness is worth the wait – just make sure to wear stretchy pants!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Pizzeria Vetri

As soon as I walked into Pizzeria Vetri, the smell of freshly-baked dough hit me like a carb-induced dream. The atmosphere was cozy, with dim lighting and a rustic decor that made me feel like I was dining in the heart of Naples.

I started off my pizza adventure with their Margherita pizza. As the waitress placed the piping-hot pie in front of me, I couldn’t help but admire the vibrant tomato sauce and the perfect balance of mozzarella and basil leaves. One bite and I was transported to pizza heaven. The thin crust was crispy, yet perfectly chewy, with just the right amount of char from the wood-fired oven. The flavors of the tomatoes and the fresh basil danced on my taste buds, and the gooey mozzarella brought it all together in a pizza symphony of cheesy delight.

Next, I couldn’t resist trying their Prosciutto pizza. The paper-thin slices of prosciutto delicately adorned the top, adding a salty and savory element to each bite. The combination of the prosciutto, arugula, and Parmesan cheese was a match made in pizza paradise.

To end my meal on a sweet note, I indulged in their Nutella pizza. This heavenly creation had a thin, crispy crust smothered in a generous layer of creamy Nutella. Each bite was a sinful delight, as the warm Nutella oozed out and mingled with the delicate dough.

In conclusion, if you’re in Philadelphia and want to experience some of the best thin crust pizza in town, Pizzeria Vetri is the place to go. Their pizzas are a work of art, and with each bite, you’ll be transported to a world where pizza reigns supreme.