Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Petoskey (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Michigan

Best Pizza in Petoskey (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

183 Views

I’ve had the opportunity to travel the world in search of the best pies, and now I’m putting my knowledge to use here in Michigan. Having tasted pizzas from 10 different places in Petoskey, I’m ready to share my findings with you!

This article is not just about giving a definitive list of the ‘best’ pizzas; instead, it’s more like a fun journey through Petoskey’s pizza scene. So put your stretchy pants on and get ready for an adventure as we explore delicious pies around town.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Michigan

#1 Full Moon Pizza

The experience starts as soon as you walk through the door – you can smell the aromatic combination of oregano, cheese, and fresh garlic. And then there’s the atmosphere – cozy booths lined with red and white checked tablecloths and a warm fireplace in the corner that gives it a homey feel.

The menu is full of delicious options for every type of pizza lover. They offer both classic Italian-style pizzas like margherita and pepperoni carbonara, as well as unique gourmet creations such as pumpkin sage and kale tomato. All their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients that really make their flavors stand out.

One thing I love about Full Moon Pizza is that they also have a bar serving beer, wine, and other alcoholic beverages! Now that’s something you don’t find in many pizza restaurants. Sadly, they don’t offer delivery services but it’s worth it to make the trip here just for their amazing pizza!

Bottom line: If you’re looking for the best pizza in Petoskey then look no further than Full Moon Pizza – it’s an experience that you definitely won’t forget anytime soon!

If you’re willing to go an extra 36 miles, you can get to 7 more pizza places in Mackinaw City!

#2 Mighty Fine Pizza

I first heard about Mighty Fine Pizza from a fellow traveling critic, and I just had to give it a try. From the moment I walked in, the staff were friendly and accommodating. The place reminded me of a classic Italian pizzeria – warm colors, vintage decor, and the smell of freshly baked pizza dough filled the air.

I ordered their signature pie – the Supreme. It was a generous helping of cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and green peppers – all atop an amazing hand-stretched crust with homemade sauce. As soon as I took my first bite, I knew I had found something special. The flavors burst in my mouth and all at once the age-old question of “who has the best pizza” was answered in one bite!

If you’re looking for truly great pizza that will delight your taste buds, look no further than Mighty Fine Pizza in Petoskey! They serve up some of the best pies around that will leave you wondering why this place isn’t more well known!

#3 Duffys Garage & Grille

As soon as I walked in, I was immediately impressed by the energetic atmosphere and the sizzling smell of fresh pizza. The decor is really awesome – they have old model cars throughout the restaurant that creates a cool and unique vibe.

The food was just as good as the decor! I ordered their classic pepperoni pizzas and it definitely lived up to my expectations. The dough was so light and fluffy, with just the right amount of crispiness. The sauce was flavorful and didn’t overpower the taste of the toppings, which were top-notch quality.

I also tried one of their specialty pizzas – a Hawaiian pizza with pineapple, bacon, and garlic crust – and it was outstanding! I’ve never had such an inventive blend of flavors on a pizza before. The bacon was cooked to perfection, not too greasy but still nice and crunchy. And that garlic crust – wow, it was amazing! All these flavors combined made to create an unforgettable pizza experience.

Overall, Duffys Garage & Grille has some of the best pizza in Petoskey – I’d highly recommend it for all your pizza needs! Whether you’re in the mood for something classic or crave something new and exciting, you’ll find exactly what you want here!

If you’re willing to go an extra 53 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Traverse City!

#4 Piper’s Mighty Good Pizza

First of all, the atmosphere is great. The interior is always warm and inviting, with a rustic and cozy feel. As soon as you walk in, you’re welcomed by friendly staff that are more than willing to answer any questions you have.

The pizza itself is definitely worthy of my prestigious food critic’s award. The crust is perfectly crunchy, but still soft enough to be easy to chew. Every bite has just the right amount of sauce and cheese – not too heavy, but still enough to make it flavourful. And their toppings are top notch! From classic pepperoni to unique combinations like basil pesto and artichoke hearts, there’s an option for everyone’s taste!

The quality doesn’t stop at the pizza – their garlic knots are just as delicious. The buttery garlic glaze on each knot melts in your mouth and will keep you coming back for more!

All in all, Piper’s Mighty Good Pizza truly lives up to its name – it really is mighty good! I would highly recommend anyone looking for the best pizza in Petoskey try this place out – you won’t be disappointed.

#5 Turkey’s

This bustling tourist spot offers more than just tasty pizza – they also serve up a few adult beverages, which is always a plus. And if you’re bringing the kiddos, don’t worry – there’s also a kid’s menu with something for everyone. If none of that takes your fancy, there are some vegetarian options too.

However, one bummer about Turkey’s is that they don’t offer any delivery options – so make sure you have wheels to make it over! But I can assure you that the trip will be worth it in the end; as soon as you take your first bite of that steaming hot pizza pie, you’ll know why I’m giving this place my seal of approval. It’s truly the best pizza in Petoskey!

If you’re willing to go an extra 109 miles, you can get to 15 more pizza places in Fish Creek!

#6 Mancino’s of Petoskey

From the moment I walked up to the restaurant, I knew I was in for something special. The aromas of freshly made dough, melted cheese and sizzling pepperoni filled the air. Inside, I was greeted with warm smiles from the friendly staff.

The atmosphere at Mancino’s is unique. Every corner of the restaurant has an inviting feel, complete with rustic wood furnishings and vintage Italian posters on the walls. It really helps create an authentic Italian pizza experience!

But let’s get to what really matters – the pizza! After reviewing countless pizzerias around the world it’s safe to say that Mancino’s stands out above them all. Their custom-made pizzas are crafted with fresh ingredients and flavorful spices that make for a delicious combination. Plus, they offer a range of unique topping options like grilled chicken and artichoke hearts that you won’t find anywhere else.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Petoskey then Mancino’s of Petoskey is your answer! This place has truly earned a spot at the top of my list when it comes to great restaurants serving up mouthwatering pizza.

#7 Jet’s Pizza

At first glance, it appears to just be a typical pizza restaurant. But appearances can be deceiving. The crust is thick, but also light and airy — the perfect blend of chewy and crunchy! And they don’t skimp on their toppings, either–they’re so generous you can barely fit all the ingredients in your mouth at once.

They have an extensive list of specialty pies that will tantalize your taste buds. My favorite is the Detroit Style Deep Dish with extra cheese—it’s out-of-this-world deliciousness! Plus, they offer gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

The ambience of Jet’s Pizza is nothing short of outstanding. With its vintage decor, it has a welcoming feel that I immediately connected with as soon as I walked in the door. The staff members are friendly and attentive too; they always strive to make sure your experience is topnotch from start to finish.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Petoskey, then look no further than Jet’s Pizza! They have something for everyone — whether you prefer a classic slice or something more exotic like their Breakfast Pizza (yes – breakfast pizza!). It never disappoints!

If you’re willing to go an extra 123 miles, you can get to 17 more pizza places in Mt Pleasant!

#8 Little Caesars Pizza

I was hesitant to try Little Caesars at first, but as soon as I took my first bite of their signature Crazy Bread, I knew I was onto something great. The cheesy garlic goodness of the bread was like none other!

The pizza itself was equally amazing – it’s made with the freshest ingredients, the most flavorful sauces, and is always served piping hot. No matter which topping combination you choose, you’ll be sure to enjoy your meal from Little Caesars!

This place is definitely worth a visit if you’re in Petoskey looking for some delicious pizza. It may not be the fanciest restaurant in town, but I guarantee that you won’t find a better pizza anywhere else. So grab a slice (or two!) and see for yourself why Little Caesars Pizza is definitely one of the best pizzas in Petoskey!

#9 B.C. Pizza Petoskey

First off, I was blown away by the quality of the crust. It was perfectly crispy on the outside, with a soft and chewy inside. Each bite was full of flavor and had a pleasant smell that made my mouth water.

The sauce was also fantastic! There was just enough to cover every slice without it becoming soggy or too sweet. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and truly brought out the best in each bite.

Overall, this restaurant is definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in town. Not only does B.C. Pizza Petoskey have some of the best pizza in Petoskey, but they also provide excellent customer service with friendly staff and fast delivery times. Highly recommended!

#10 Corktown Pizza

After tasting their pizza, I can definitely say that it’s worth the visit! The crust was perfectly crisp and flavorful, the sauce had a hint of sweetness, and the cheese was gooey and delicious. The toppings were also fresh and added incredible flavor. One of my favorites is their specialty pesto pizza – the balance of ingredients in this dish is amazing.

The atmosphere of Corktown Pizza is outstanding as well. They have a lively atmosphere with great music playing in the background – perfect for groups or families. The staff was very friendly and helpful as well, making sure everyone had a good experience.

At the end of the day, Corktown Pizza provides an unbeatable combination of great food, excellent atmosphere, and even better customer service – making it hands-down one of the best pizzas in Petoskey!