Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Portland ME (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Maine

Best Pizza in Portland ME (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

247 Views

The pizza scene here is varied; there are so many unique and delicious places to enjoy a slice. From old-school family-run spots to modern pizzerias, the city has something for everyone.

Having eaten my way through Portland’s 12 best pizza joints, I’m ready to tell you all about them. I’ve compared each place on its merits, from crust and cheese to toppings and seasoning, all with an eye toward offering a fun and lighthearted review of the best pizza in the area. So let’s get started!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Maine

#1 Radici

The atmosphere at Radici is perfect for tourists and locals alike. On my recent visit, their drink selection of local craft beers paired perfectly with the pizzas. And not only did they have some vegetarian options, but also some delicious desserts to top off a great meal.

Now I know what you’re thinking: “If it’s so good, why doesn’t Radici deliver?” Unfortunately, no delivery service is available – however, the restaurant has done such an amazing job compensating for that minor inconvenience that you won’t even notice its absence!

At the end of the day, I can confidently declare that Radici is one of the best pizza places in Portland ME. Make sure to pay them a visit when you’re in town – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Old Orchard Beach!

#2 Coals Bayside

The crust was perfect, the sauce was flavorful, and the toppings were spot-on. The cheese was melted to perfection and the pepperoni had a nice amount of spice. All I can say is that Coals Bayside should be given an award for their pizza-making skills!

In addition to their delicious pizza, Coals Bayside also offers a wide variety of sides and drinks. Their garlic knots were light yet full of flavor and their selection of craft beer was impressive.

The ambiance of Coals Bayside was great too. The walls are adorned with local art and there’s plenty of comfortable seating for large groups or small ones alike. Plus they have TVs playing sports games so you can enjoy your meal while staying up to date on your favorite teams!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Portland ME, look no further than Coals Bayside!

#3 Slab Sicilian Street Food

My first impression as I walked into Slab was one of delight. The restaurant is cozy, welcoming and exudes an undeniable energy that only comes from a true passion for pizza.

The menu here is surprisingly diverse, so it took me a while to make my decision. I finally settled on the classic Margherita pizza and I’m pleased to report that it lived up to all expectations. The crust was light and lightly charred with just the right balance of cheese, tomato sauce and fresh basil – definitely a winner in my book!

But the best part of dining at Slab has got to be their beautiful brick ovens. Located in the center of the restaurant these ovens are responsible for creating some absolutely delicious pizzas that can’t be found anywhere else in Portland ME.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Portland ME then look no further than Slab Sicilian Street Food – you won’t regret it!

#4 Flatbread Company

The aromas of the wood-fired ovens instantly made me feel like I had arrived at a true pizza paradise. The mouthwatering smell of tomatoes, oregano and garlic combined with the sound of crackling wood was almost enough to convince me that I was in Italy.

The menu has an impressively wide variety of pizzas to choose from, so it took me quite some time to decide which one to get. But finally, I decided on the Sausage & Pepperoni and it didn’t disappoint – each bite was oozing with melted cheese and the crust was just the right combination of thin and chewy.

The atmosphere is relaxed yet lively and all the staff are extremely friendly. Everyone seems genuinely excited about serving up excellent quality food, which you can tell they take great pride in preparing.

All things considered, this is truly one of the best places to get pizza in Portland ME and whether you’re just looking for a quick slice or an entire pie, Flatbread Company won’t disappoint!

#5 OTTO

I had their signature deep dish – and it was luxurious! The combination of the crisp crust, flavorful tomato sauce and gooey cheese was just divine.

The atmosphere at OTTO added to the experience. A big open kitchen and pizza oven further added to the flavor. I loved watching the chefs toss dough high into the air before baking it.

The staff here was also a blast to talk with. Everyone from the hostess to the servers were super friendly and seemed genuinely interested in making sure I had a great time.

Overall, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Portland ME, then OTTO is definitely worth checking out! If you can’t make it there, though, I’d settle for their frozen pies!

#6 OTTO

I stopped into OTTO for a quick bite, and I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the pizza. The crust was crispy and flavorful, the sauces were plentiful and flavorful, and the toppings were fresh. What’s more, they offer alcoholic beverages to wash it down!

As a vegetarian, I was also relieved to find some options that fit my lifestyle. Oh, and if you save room for dessert—try their mini cannoli!

The only downside is that they don’t deliver; you have to actually visit in person…which isn’t necessarily a bad thing since it’s become kind of a tourist hotspot these days! It makes for an enjoyable evening out with friends or family.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Portland ME, look no further than OTTO. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 30 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Wells!

#7 Lazzari

I’m not sure what it is exactly that makes this pizza special, but there is something magical about it. From the freshly made dough and the perfect blend of flavorful sauces, to the delicious toppings, every bite was an amazing experience.

The staff were also friendly and accommodating, which is always a plus. One thing I found particularly enjoyable was the casual atmosphere of Lazzari. It’s a great spot where you can relax in comfort while enjoying your meal.

All in all, I must say that my experience at Lazzari was one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had. The crust was flaky and light, and each topping added a unique flavor that complemented each other perfectly. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Portland ME, Lazzari should be your first stop!

#8 Pizza Villa

When I arrived at Pizza Villa, I was impressed with the charming atmosphere. The restaurant is located in a tourist spot and has outdoor seating, making it a great place to while away an evening with friends. And what’s more, they serve alcohol – including hard liquor!

The pizza itself was simply delicious. All of the pies were cooked to perfection with the perfect amount of cheese and toppings. My favorite was their Margherita pizza – it’s light and flavorful and really hit the spot.

My only complaint about Pizza Villa is that they don’t offer delivery service. But then again, half the fun of visiting this restaurant is being there in person to enjoy the atmosphere – so it’s all good!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Portland ME, look no further than Pizza Villa – you won’t be disappointed!

#9 Pizzaiolo

The first thing I noticed was the mouth-watering aroma of freshly made pizza. I knew that I was in for a treat!

When my pizza arrived, it was more delicious and appetizing than I had imagined. The crust was so thin, yet still crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. The cheese was melted to perfection, with loads of melted mozzarella providing an amazing base for each bite. And when it came to toppings, there was no shortage – they were piled high and full of flavor.

I also have to praise Pizzaiolo’s friendly staff. They always make sure you feel welcome and they go out of their way to accommodate any special requests or modifications you might have to your order.

Without a doubt, Pizzaiolo is the best pizza place in Portland ME, and definitely worth a try for any serious pizza connoisseur!

#10 Leonardo’s Pizza

My visit to Leonardo’s was certainly memorable. From the moment I walked in, I was met with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The staff were friendly and helpful, making sure that I had the best experience possible.

I started by ordering their signature, “Cheese-Lover’s Dream” pizza. As soon as it arrived at my table, I knew that it was going to be special. The sauce was wonderfully flavorful, the crust was perfectly baked and just chewy enough to keep me coming back for more. To top it all off, the cheese was melted to perfection – giving the pizza an extra layer of flavor and texture.

Overall, I have to say that Leonardo’s Pizza lived up to its reputation of being one of the best pizzerias in Portland ME! So if you’re ever in town and looking for an unforgettable slice of pizza, make sure you stop by Leonardo’s!

#11 Anthony’s Italian Kitchen

The friendly staff made us feel welcome from the start, even though I arrived with a rather pompous attitude. From the moment I stepped through the door, it was clear that Anthony’s Italian Kitchen had something special up their sleeve.

The pizza was hands-down one of the best I’ve ever tasted! The crust was light and fluffy, yet still had enough flavor to stand out. The sauce was tangy and flavorful – just enough to really bring out all of the toppings. And don’t even get me started on the cheese – it was gooey and melted in just the right way to pull everything together in a delicious bite.

To top it off, we were treated to an extra-large side of garlic knots! They were crispy on the outside and warm and pillowy on the inside – clearly a sign that these chefs know what they’re doing when it comes to Italian food.

All in all, Anthony’s Italian Kitchen has earned its title as one of Portland ME’s premier pizza restaurants. If you are in town and looking for some truly remarkable ‘za, look no further than Anthony’s!

If you’re willing to go an extra 41 miles, you can get to 15 more pizza places in Ogunquit!

#12 OTTO

There’s something special about the dough they use – it’s made with a special blend of locally sourced, organic flour, giving it the perfect amount of crispiness and chew. And then there are the toppings! They’ve got everything from classic pepperoni to unique creations like fig & gruyere. No matter what I try, it always comes out perfectly cooked and oh-so-tasty.

I can also attest to their commitment to using only high quality ingredients. The cheese is never greasy, the veggies are always fresh, and the meats are top notch. Plus, they offer vegan and gluten-free options so everyone can enjoy a great pizza!

The atmosphere at OTTO is relaxed yet lively – perfect for meeting up with friends or family for a night out. The staff is friendly and accommodating, making sure that your experience is enjoyable from start to finish.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Portland ME, look no further than OTTO – hands down one of the best pizza places in town!