Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Goodyear AZ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Arizona

Best Pizza in Goodyear AZ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

171 Views

I’m sure the locals have their favorites, but I decided to embark on a mission to find the BEST pizza in Goodyear. After visiting twelve pizza places in town, I’ve got some thoughts about who has the tastiest pies.

My journey was an enjoyable one. I experienced some fantastic pies with chewy crusts and zesty sauces, all while meeting friendly local pizza makers along the way. Now that I’ve determined which pizzas reign supreme in Goodyear AZ, let’s get into it!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Arizona

#1 Taste of Italy

I was skeptical when I first walked in, but my doubts were quickly put to rest. The place smelled divine, with the aroma of fresh-baked pizza wafting through the air. The presentation of the pizzas was top-notch, adorned with colorful vegetables and cheese that made my mouth water just looking at it.

The crust was perfectly crisp, yet soft and flavorful. Each bite was like a heavenly symphony of flavors; the Italian sausage had a nice kick to it, while the mushrooms added an earthy taste. Lastly, the cheese was cooked to perfection – creamy and rich with plenty of flavor.

All in all, Taste of Italy is definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for some good pizza in Goodyear AZ. From the quality ingredients to the skillful preparation, this restaurant is sure to impress any pizza lover!

If you’re willing to go an extra 16 miles, you can get to 31 more pizza places in Surprise!

#2 MOD Pizza

My experience here started off with a warm welcome from the friendly staff that was more than happy to help me decide on my order. I ended up going for the classic pepperoni pizza, and boy oh boy, it did not disappoint!

The crust was light and crispy, but still had a nice chewiness to it. The generous amount of pepperoni complemented the flavorful tomato sauce wonderfully. To top it off, they use only the freshest ingredients to make their pizzas, which really brought out a unique flavor that I could only find at MOD Pizza.

The atmosphere at MOD Pizza is great too; they have plenty of seating as well as TVs playing various sports games. What truly sets this place apart is their commitment to creating customized pizza orders; you can add whatever toppings you would like and there’s no extra charge! It’s like being able to create your own dream pie without having to pay extra for any special ingredients.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Goodyear AZ then look no further than MOD Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!

#3 Taste of Italy

This was my first visit to the restaurant, and I couldn’t believe how delicious their pizza was. The crust was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunch. The sauce was flavorful yet not overpowering. And the toppings were truly top-notch!

The service at Taste of Italy was also quite impressive. The servers were friendly and attentive, making sure my glass stayed full throughout my meal.

Overall, I would highly recommend Taste of Italy for anyone craving some good pizza in Goodyear AZ! This place is definitely one of the best around and worth checking out if you’re ever in town. In fact, I’m already planning my next visit back here!

#4 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The deal at Papa Murphy’s is simple: they provide you with fresh ingredients, ready-made dough, sauce, and your choice of toppings so you can make it yourself. What separates them from the pack is that they don’t cook it for you – you take it home and throw it in the oven yourself.

It’s a win-win situation! You get to enjoy a freshly-made pizza that tastes like it just came out of the oven – right in your own home. Plus, with all the different ingredients to choose from, you can make your own unique creations.

I especially loved their “Create Your Own” option which lets you pick whatever topping combination you’d like. I chose bacon and pineapple (don’t judge me) and it was fantastic! The crust was perfectly crisp and flavorful and the ingredients were top-notch quality. And since their prices are so reasonable, I can afford to try something new every time I go.

No matter what kind of pizza you’re looking for, Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza has some of the best pizza in Goodyear AZ – hands down! All for a price that won’t break your budget – now that’s what I call a win-win situation!

#5 Papa Paul’s Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta

I was impressed right off the bat by their selection. They had all sorts of creative toppings – from roasted peppers to artichoke hearts. The crust was cooked to perfection and the sauce was just the right amount of sweetness.

The staff at Papa Paul’s made my experience top notch! They were attentive, knowledgeable and always eager to answer any questions I had.

When it comes to quality, I found the food at Papa Paul’s unparalleled! Every bite of their pizza was filled with flavor that kept me coming back for more. The pasta dishes were also delicious and some of the best I’ve ever had. Plus, they were generous with their toppings so there’s never a shortage on flavor.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Goodyear AZ then look no further than Papa Paul’s Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta! Delicious food backed by friendly service makes this place a must-try for anyone in the area who loves good Italian cuisine!

#6 NYPD Pizza

First off, the atmosphere of NYPD Pizza is excellent – a cozy Italian restaurant with checkered table cloths and a wait staff that are friendly and attentive. The aroma of fresh pizza dough wafting from the ovens can only be described as heavenly!

When it came to the pizza itself, I was thoroughly impressed. All of their pies come with a thin crust that was light and crispy on the outside yet still had a wonderful chewiness in the center. Every bite was loaded with flavor featuring topping combinations like pepperoni and sausage, mushrooms and olives, or for those looking for something even more interesting – eggplant and zucchini.

Their menu also has other traditional Italian dishes like pasta, calzones, subs, salads and more. But let’s be real: it’s all about the pizza here!

It’s easy to tell why NYPD Pizza is known best pizza in Goodyear AZ. Whether you’re visiting or live nearby – this place is an absolute must-try!

#7 Barro’s Pizza

I’m not one to talk lightly about my favorite food, but the pizza at Barro’s Pizza was seriously incredible. The crust was perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of crunch and flavor. And the sauce – oh man, such an amazing tomato-y flavor! I could tell it was made from scratch and had been simmering for hours.

The toppings all tasted as though they had been freshly chopped, with loads of veggies to choose from. My favorite was the pepperoni, which was just bursting with savory Italian spices in every bite.

The atmosphere of the restaurant really helped to add to the experience as well – it had a great vibe, and staff were welcoming and friendly as can be. It truly made me feel like I’d stepped into a pizza palace!

It’s no wonder that Barro’s Pizza is known for having some of the best pizza in Goodyear AZ – I’d definitely recommend giving it a try if you’re ever in the area!

#8 Oregano’s

The atmosphere was truly one of a kind. Sitting in the corner booth, I could feel the love and warmth of the local community that always radiates from this eatery! The staff were friendly and attentive, only adding to my experience.

When it came time for pizza, the choices were endless. Their specialty pies are delectable. Whether you pick their Italian classic or try something new like their Southwestern Chicken pie, your taste buds will be singing. And let’s not forget about their famous beer-infused pizzas! Who knew a pizza could taste so good with a hint of hops?

For those that are looking for traditional slices, Oregano has you covered there too. The secret is definitely in the sauce – it’s full of flavor without being too overpowering. The crust was also cooked to perfection – crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. The perfect combination!

Overall, I would give Oregano’s two enthusiastic thumbs up! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Goodyear AZ, then look no further than Oregano’s Pizza Café!

If you’re willing to go an extra 18 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Phoenix!

#9 Arizona Pizza Company

The first thing that struck me was the presentation – from the moment I opened the box, I knew this was going to be an incredible experience. The crust was crisp and flavorful, while still maintaining a light and fluffy texture. The topping selection was impressive – they had something for everyone! From their house-made sausage to vegan options, I felt like I could try something new every time.

The flavor of the pizza definitely lived up to the hype. It was savory and full of flavor without being overly salty or greasy. Each bite was as delicious as the last, making it hard to resist finishing off the whole pie in one sitting!

To top it all off, my wallet thanked me since Arizona Pizza Company is quite affordable. You get great quality pizza at prices that won’t break your bank – what more could you want?

All-in-all, if you’re in Goodyear AZ searching for great pizza, you must give Arizona Pizza Company a try! It’s undoubtedly some of the best pizza in town.

#10 N-Dub Pizza Pub

My trip kicked off with their house special, the N-Dub Pie. It had a deliciously thin crust and perfectly cooked toppings that included pepperoni, olives, mushrooms and onions. The cheese was sharp and savory, making it one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted.

For my next slice, I indulged in their White Pizza – a savory blend of rich cheeses and zesty herbs on a thick crust. It was an amazing combination of flavors, and I could easily see why this is one of their most popular dishes.

To finish the night off right, I opted for their signature dessert pizza. This sweet treat featured a generous amount of gooey melted chocolate and fresh fruit topped on a crispy golden crust. Heaven!

Overall, my experience at N-Dub Pizza Pub was nothing short of incredible. From the quality ingredients used to the skillful cooking techniques on display, this restaurant sets itself apart from the competition as serving some of the best pizza in Goodyear AZ!

#11 Fired Pie

I stepped into this unassuming little place, and my taste buds were in overload! From the moment I opened the door, I was hit with the smell of the most delicious pizza. Every time I come here I try something new, but no matter what combination of toppings I choose – their pizza always hits it out of the park.

My absolute favorite is the classic margherita with pepperoni and olives – it’s a combination that really packs a flavorful punch that you just don’t get anywhere else. Even their “weirdest” combinations like pickles and pineapple are surprisingly good! And their unique pasta dishes are always out-of-this-world delicious – definitely worth trying if you’re feeling adventurous.

I’m so thankful that Fired Pie has made Goodyear AZ an even tastier place to visit! Really, I’d even go so far as to say it’s probably some of the best pizza in all of Arizona!

#12 Garden Pizza

I stopped in after a long day of traveling and was greeted warmly by the staff. They had a great selection of pizzas, from classic cheese to creative combinations like BBQ chicken and sweet pineapple. I couldn’t resist and opted for the last one; it was delicious!

The crust was light and crunchy, with just the right amount of grainy cornmeal flavoring throughout. The toppings were smoky, sweet, and incredibly fresh. I appreciated the time taken to make sure each ingredient stood out in its own unique way.

But what really sealed the deal for me is Garden Pizza’s commitment to providing excellent customer service. Every employee I encountered made sure my experience was top notch — taking the time to answer questions about their menu, recommendations for other dishes, or even suggesting potential local attractions in Goodyear AZ.

All in all, Garden Pizza has definitely earned its spot as one of the best pizza restaurants in Goodyear AZ! I highly recommend it for anyone looking for a delicious pizza night out on the town!