Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Hyde Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Illinois

Best Pizza in Hyde Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

69 Views

I recently set out on a mission to find the best pizza in Hyde Park, and after tasting over a dozen slices from several different places, I’m here to report back.

My journey was filled with laughs, heated debates, and (of course) lots of delicious pizza. Join me as I take you through my humorous and lighthearted evaluations of the 12 pizza places I visited.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Illinois

#1 Nella Pizza e Pasta

The atmosphere here is cozy, with a vintage vibe that brought back fond memories of my travels. I was immediately impressed and couldn’t wait to dig in!

My pizza was perfect – it had the perfect balance of cheese, tomato sauce, and dough. The crust was crisp and flavorful with pleasant hints of garlic and herbs. Every bite was like a little bite of pizza-flavored heaven!

The service at Nella Pizza e Pasta is always friendly, too. My waitress was friendly and helpful, suggesting just the right wine to pair with my pizza. She added to my overall experience!

My visit to Nella Pizza e Pasta has left me feeling satisfied beyond belief. Needless to say, this is definitely one of the best pizza spots in Hyde Park!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Chicago!

#2 The Sit Down Cafe & Sushi Bar

The first thing that caught my attention when I sat down was the unique atmosphere – its combination of Japanese and Italian flair was downright soothing. The walls were adorned with art, and it gave the restaurant a cozy yet hip vibe.

I was really looking forward to their pizza, and they did not disappoint. Their selections ranged from classic Margheritas to more creative pies like their Truffle Mushroom Pizza. The crust of each pie was light, crispy, and oh-so delicious! And the toppings – from fresh vegetables to artisan sausage – went perfectly with the homemade tomato sauce.

Of course, no meal would be complete without a couple of slices for dessert – and boy were they worth it! One of my favorites was their Nutella Surprise Pizza that had me licking my lips in delight.

So if you’re ever in town or just feel like treating yourself to a great slice of pizza, you should definitely visit The Sit Down Cafe & Sushi Bar! In my opinion, they have some of the best pizza in Hyde Park – it’s definitely worth checking out!

#3 Pizza Capri Hyde Park

The pizza dough is light and fluffy, with a perfect crunch that lets you know the crust was cooked to perfection. The toppings are bursting with flavor, from spicy pepperoni to sweet sausage; it’s all incredibly delicious. And let me not forget about their sauce – it has just the right amount of sweetness and spice!

As for atmosphere, Pizza Capri Hyde Park has a cozy feel inside that makes you want to sit down and enjoy a meal. Plus, the staff are super friendly and go out of their way to make sure your experience is nothing less than perfect.

All in all, my visit to Pizza Capri Hyde Park was an absolute delight! I can’t speak highly enough of this place and would definitely recommend it if you’re looking for the best pizza in Hyde Park. Trust me – it won’t disappoint!

#4 Jet’s Pizza

When I arrived at the restaurant, I was immediately taken by the inviting atmosphere and courteous staff. The pizza chef had an infectious enthusiasm for his craft that I knew would make for a great experience.

The first pizza to arrive at my table was Jet’s signature deep-dish square pie with extra cheese and pepperoni. It did not disappoint! Not only was it one of the biggest pizzas I’ve ever seen, but it tasted absolutely amazing! Every bite was full of flavor, it had just the right amount of grease, and the cheese melted perfectly.

For my second washroom, I decided to try something different – Jet’s classic thin crust with veggies. Again, I was not disappointed! All the toppings were fresh and flavorful and each one added a unique taste that blended so well with the thin crispy crust.

Overall, my experience at Jet’s Pizza was nothing short of amazing! The food was delicious and the service top notch. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hyde Park, this is definitely where you should go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Chicago!

#5 Cholies Pizza Hyde Park

When I first arrived, I was immediately impressed by the overwhelming smell of freshly cooked pizza! The decor inside was quaint yet inviting, and the staff was friendly and welcoming. Plus, they had a lively atmosphere which made me feel right at home.

The pizza itself was amazing! It truly was some of the best I’ve ever had. The crust was golden brown and crispy, while still being soft on the inside. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and there were plenty to choose from. I opted for their signature chorizo sausage pizza which really hit all the right notes!

Overall, if you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Hyde Park, Cholies Pizza Hyde Park is definitely worth your time and money!

#6 Ace Pizza

The moment I stepped into the restaurant, I could smell the delicious aroma of freshly made pizza. The menu had lots of options to choose from and it didn’t take long for me to find something I liked – an extra cheese and pepperoni pizza.

The moment it arrived, I was impressed. The crust was perfectly cooked and crunchy, with a delightful texture. The toppings were generous and flavorful, with a hint of oregano that really brought out the flavor profile. The cheese was melted to perfection and had that classic stringy texture when you pull up a slice.

In short, Ace Pizza is far above the rest in Hyde Park when it comes to pizza! It’s been my experience that great pizza requires some time and skill in order to get everything just right – and this place definitely delivers! If you’re ever in Hyde Park looking for a slice or two of authentic Italian-style pizza, look no further than Ace Pizza.

#7 Giordano’s

When I first stepped inside, the aroma of freshly made pizza wafted through the air and I soon found myself drooling! But it’s not just about smell and sight at Giordano’s—the taste is simply divine.

They offer a wide variety of toppings, from pepperoni to artichoke hearts and fresh basil. The crust is light and fluffy yet still substantial enough to support all your chosen toppings without getting soggy. The tomato sauce is made with diced tomatoes for a delicious, tangy flavor that will keep you coming back for more.

The staff at Giordano’s were friendly and attentive, making sure to check on our table every few minutes to make sure we had everything we needed. As an added bonus they offer free delivery if you don’t feel like making the trip!

All in all, Giordano’s has quickly become my favorite spot for pizza in Hyde Park. If you’re looking for delicious pizza that won’t break your budget, then Giordano’s is definitely the place to go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Chicago!

#8 Leona’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

When I arrived, I was greeted warmly and with a great selection of both traditional and specialty pies. From classic cheese to spicy pepperoni and beyond, Leona’s has something for everyone. The dough is made fresh daily and the ingredients are of the highest quality.

I sampled many of Leona’s creations, including their signature deep dish pie. To say it was extraordinary would be an understatement. It was truly one of the greatest things I’ve ever eaten! The crust was perfectly golden brown and had just the right amount of crunch on the outside while still being soft on the inside. The tomatoes were sweet and juicy, while the cheese melted into a gooey perfection.

To top it off, all of Leona’s recipes come with a side helping of charm and love that you’ll find nowhere else. Whether you pick up your order or dine in at the cozy restaurant, you can rest assured that you’ll get a delicious slice every time.

In my humble food critic opinion, Leona’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is one of Hyde Park’s best culinary secrets – definitely worth trying if you’re in search for good pizza!

#9 Domino’s Pizza

I visited the store off of 53rd Street, and the delicious smells of melted cheese and flavorful crust wafted through the air. The staff were friendly, efficient, and gave me an excellent dining experience.

The pizza itself was delightful! The sauce was flavorful and had just the right amount of tanginess. The dough was soft yet chewy with a dollop of garlic and herbs on top that really hit the spot. And oh, the cheese! A blend of mozzarella and provolone that melted in my mouth as I took each bite.

To top it all off, I decided to try their new Greek-style pizza with olives and artichoke hearts, which turned out to be a great decision! The flavors complemented each other perfectly for a delicious meal that I will be sure to come back for.

In conclusion, Domino’s Pizza has some of the best pizza in Hyde Park. From delectable crusts to savory ladles of sauce, this restaurant definitely deserves five stars from this food critic!

#10 Italian Fiesta Pizzeria – 47th St

I recently had the privilege of dining there and had a delightful experience. From the moment I stepped through the door, I was welcomed with a smile by the friendly and engaging staff. The restaurant itself is quite charming and cozy, and it didn’t take me long to feel at home.

The pizza selection is vast, offering something for everyone. From classic Margherita to creative pies like the Sausage, Asparagus and Ricotta White Pie, Italian Fiesta Pizzeria – 47th St has earned its reputation as one of Hyde Park’s best pizza restaurants.

My own meal consisted of the aforementioned white pie–a fantastic blend of sweet and savory flavors that left me wanting more! The thin crust was cooked perfectly, and each toppings layer added its own unique flavor to create an unforgettable taste experience.

To top off my meal, I ordered a cannoli for dessert and it was just delicious! The creamy ricotta filling paired perfectly with the crisp pastry shell.

All in all, Italian Fiesta Pizzeria – 47th St lived up to its reputation as one of Hyde Park’s best pizzerias! If you’re ever in the area, be sure to check them out–you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Chicago!

#11 Papa Johns Pizza

I was skeptical at first, but the moment I walked in the door and took my first bite, I knew this place was special. The crust is perfectly done – not too crunchy, not too soggy. The sauce is incredibly flavorful, almost tangy in a good way. And of course the toppings – there’s a great variety to choose from and they’re all excellent quality.

But the real star of Papa Johns Pizza is their customer service. They truly care about making your pizza experience enjoyable, whether it’s taking time to discuss recommendations with you or being proactive in making sure everything comes out right. Plus the staff are always cheerful which just adds to the whole dining experience for me!

All-in-all this is easily one of the best pizza joints in Hyde Park and definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in the area. Delicious food, great customer service and a welcoming atmosphere – what more could you ask for?

#12 Ascione Bistro

The atmosphere was just as good as the food. The owners, Tony and Nicky, made sure to give me a warm welcome and help me choose the perfect pizza! The restaurant’s decor was cozy yet modern with a great view of Hyde Park.

The pizza itself was out of this world! Starting with their homemade secret sauce, each ingredient was fresh and delicious. I’ve tried pizzas from all over the world but this one takes the crown. It was also cooked to perfection – not too crispy or too doughy.

I would recommend Ascione Bistro to anyone looking for an excellent pizza experience in Hyde Park!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Chicago’s Pizza

From the moment I walked into the restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma of bubbling cheese and perfectly baked crust filled the air, making my taste buds do a little happy dance. The decor was delightfully kitschy, with Chicago-themed memorabilia adorning the walls and even the waitstaff dressed as mini Chicagoan landmarks. I half expected to see a little pizza version of the Bean serving me my pie!

Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself. When they say deep dish, they really mean it. This thing was a monster! It’s like they took a normal pizza and pumped it full of cheesy steroids. And oh boy, the cheese! It was so melty and gooey, I felt like I should have brought a snorkel to dive into it. The crust was thick and buttery, with just the right amount of chewiness. It was like biting into a warm, fluffy cloud that happened to have a pizza on top.

The toppings were abundant and fresh. I tried their classic sausage and pepperoni combo, and each bite was a flavor explosion in my mouth. The sauce was tangy and zesty, and it paired perfectly with the rich, savory toppings. I couldn’t help but laugh with pleasure after every bite.

So, if you find yourself in Lakeview and craving a pizza experience that will make you belly laugh with delight, head on over to Chicago’s Pizza. You won’t be disappointed. Plus, where else can you have a slice of pizza and feel like you’re in the middle of the Windy City?

Best Thin Crust Pizza – La Crosta Woodfire Pizzeria Italiana

From the moment I stepped inside, I knew I was in for a treat. The rustic ambiance and the smell of smoky woodfire instantly transported me to pizza paradise. I practically floated to my seat, eager to sink my teeth into some cheesy goodness.

As I perused the menu, my taste buds danced in anticipation. The options were endless – from classic margherita to gourmet toppings like truffle oil and prosciutto. I felt like a kid in a candy store, but instead of candy, it was pizza. My excitement was palpable.

When the pizza finally arrived, I couldn’t help but gasp. The thin crust, perfectly cooked and oozing with cheese and toppings, was a work of art. It was like Michelangelo himself had sculpted it with his pizza-making hands.

I took my first bite and it was love at first chew. The crust was crispy, yet chewy, with just the right amount of char from the woodfire oven. The flavors exploded in my mouth, each ingredient complementing the other in perfect harmony. I couldn’t help but moan in delight, much to the amusement of the diners around me.

The staff at La Crosta were friendly and attentive, ensuring my pizza experience was nothing short of magnificent. They even accommodated my bizarre request for extra pineapple, which earned them extra points in my book.

So, if you find yourself in lincoln park and craving the best thin crust pizza around, look no further than La Crosta Woodfire Pizzeria Italiana. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you. And hey, even if they don’t, you’ll still leave with a satisfied stomach and a smile on your face.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Stix n Brix Pizza

As soon as I stepped into Stix n Brix Pizza, the tantalizing aroma of wood-fired dough hit me like a cheesy slap in the face. My taste buds were salivating like a pack of dogs at a butcher shop. I knew I was in for a treat.

The restaurant itself was a rustic paradise, with wooden beams and vintage pizza posters adorning the walls. It felt like I had stepped into a time machine and been transported to an era when pizza was a sacred art form.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza. Oh boy, where do I even begin? The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside, with just the right amount of chewiness on the inside. It was like biting into a cloud, if clouds were made of dough and cheese and dreams.

The toppings were a work of art. From the classic margherita to the inventive truffle mushroom and goat cheese, each pizza was bursting with flavor. I couldn’t resist but to close my eyes in pure bliss after each bite. It was like a symphony of flavors dancing on my taste buds, making me want to do a little jig right there in the restaurant.

The service was just as delightful as the pizza. The staff were friendly, attentive, and just as passionate about pizza as I am. They even recommended their homemade chili oil for an extra kick. Let me tell you, that stuff is like liquid gold. I drizzled it on every slice and felt like a true pizza connoisseur.

If you’re in Chicago and craving some of the best wood-fired pizza in the city, look no further than Stix n Brix Pizza. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.