Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Toledo OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Ohio

Best Pizza in Toledo OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

289 Views

I recently traveled here to seek out the best of the best in this pizza-loving town. After an intense (and delicious) search, I’ve narrowed it down to the top 12 restaurants with the tastiest pies.

To determine which of these places take the cake for offering the best pizza in Toledo OH, I carefully inspected each one’s crust, toppings, cheese quality, and overall taste. Now comes the fun part: sharing my findings with all you hungry readers! So don your bibs and grab a slice of Toledo OH’s best pizza as I share my discoveries ahead.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio

#1 Mazzas stone baked pizza co.

The atmosphere is great and the staff is friendly. I couldn’t stop talking about how good their pizza was when I tried it. The atmosphere alone had me sold but one bite and I was hooked!

Their pizzas had just the right amount of crunchy crust that paired wonderfully with a soft inner cheesiness. The toppings were also spot on; all of them playing together in harmony to create a perfect flavor profile.

I sampled every pizza they had, from margherita to cheese, pepperoni, and veggie lovers – you name it, they most likely have it. Every single one was delicious and tasted like authentic Italian cooking!

My only complaint about Mazzas is that it’s not big enough because everyone else loves it as much as I do. It can get quite crowded at times! That said, don’t let that deter you from trying their delicious food – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Monroe!

#2 Gino’s Italian Delites

Their menu has something for everyone, from classic Italian staples to creative takes on pizza. The ingredients are all fresh and the dough is made in-house every day. That makes for a great, flavorful crust every single time.

The prices aren’t bad either, especially considering that you get to enjoy your pizza in an inviting atmosphere with pleasant staff. And if you have room for dessert, Gino’s even has sweet treats like cannoli and tiramisu!

Unfortunately there’s one downside – Gino’s doesn’t deliver. But if you’re looking for the best pizza in Toledo OH, then it’s worth making the trip over there to try out their delicious pies!

#3 Blaze Pizza

The crust was light and fluffy with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce had the perfect blend of herbs and spices that complemented the rich flavor of the cheese. And, of course, the toppings were plentiful and flavorful – a carnivore’s delight!

The atmosphere at Blaze Pizza is inviting and cozy, perfect for family dinners or romantic dates. The staff are friendly and informative, not to mention incredibly knowledgeable about pizza making! I even learned a few tricks from them during my visit!

The price was also very reasonable given the quality of ingredients used in their pizzas. You simply can’t beat their prices for such delicious flavors.

In conclusion, I must say that Blaze Pizza is indeed one of the best pizza places in Toledo OH – if not THE best. If you’re ever looking for great pizza in town, head on over to Blaze Pizza and treat yourself to some great tasting ‘za!

#4 Home Slice Pizza

As soon as I stepped in the door, I could tell this place was different. The inviting aroma of the hand-tossed dough and perfectly seasoned pizzas wafting throughout the restaurant had my mouth already watering.

The folks at Home Slice Pizza take great pride in their craft and it shows in every bite. The crust is freshly made and lightly charred, providing a perfect crunch with every bite. The toppings are fresh as can be—from succulent Italian sausage to fresh vegetables and gooey cheese.

The atmosphere of the restaurant is warm and welcoming but busy enough that you know you’re going to get your meal quickly if you’re pressed for time. Of course, there’s no need to rush if you don’t have to, because the staff creates such a friendly atmosphere that guests often hang out for dessert or another slice!

In short: If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Toledo OH, look no further than Home Slice Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!

#5 Pizza Cat

I must say, I was quite impressed when I walked up to the door and saw a smiling grinning cat painted on it. Who wouldn’t be at least a little curious right? Inside, it had a cozy atmosphere that almost made me feel like I was eating pizza in someone’s living room.

The menu offered several options—some cheesy, some with classic toppings, and others with more exotic ingredients. The prices also seemed reasonable—especially considering the quality of the pizza.

When it comes to taste, Pizza Cat didn’t disappoint! The crust was perfectly crunchy and had just enough char to give it great flavor. The tomato sauce had the perfect blend of sweetness and acidity that made each bite stand out. And the topping combinations were delicious!

All in all, Pizza Cat is simply one of the best pizza places in Toledo OH. So if you’re ever looking for excellent pizza in this area, make sure to stop by Pizza Cat! You won’t regret it!

#6 Dandino’s Pizza & More

My visit to Dandino’s began with a warm welcome from the friendly staff. The cozy ambiance of the restaurant only added to the experience.

As for the pizza, I was blown away. It had all of the classic flavors of traditional Italian pizza, but with a modern twist. The crust was crisp and light – not at all doughy like some places I’ve been to. My favorite topping combination was pepperoni and jalapeños – it just exploded in my mouth!

I also sampled their appetizers and desserts – both were delicious! The mozzarella sticks were cheesy and crunchy, while their s’mores calzone was hot and gooey; everything I wanted in a dessert pizza!

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Toledo OH, look no further than Dandino’s Pizza & More. You won’t be disappointed!

#7 Inky’s Italian Foods

My first impression of Inky’s was how inviting it was – the atmosphere is charming and cozy. I also noticed they serve alcohol, making it a great place for adult pizza-lovers. Plus, they offer some vegetarian options in case you have a picky eater with you.

The waitstaff at Inky’s are friendly and helpful – they made sure my table had the perfect view of the bustling kitchen. The pizzas were then served quickly along with some delicious desserts I couldn’t pass up.

I found the food to be just delicious –the pizza crust was flavorful and light and their selection of toppings tasty; however, outside delivery is not available, which is a bit of a bummer for those looking for takeout convenience.

Overall, Inky’s Italian Foods offers an enjoyable dining experience for both adults and kids – plus, it’s conveniently located near plenty of tourist attractions so you can make a day out of your visit! As far as my taste buds tell me, this is one of the best spots for grabbing a slice in Toledo OH.

#8 Guy’s Pizza

On my first visit, I was immediately impressed with the level of atmosphere. A unique combination of old-school charm and modern vibes created an inviting environment for a delicious meal. My server was friendly and helpful and gave me some great recommendations for toppings.

The pizza itself was out of this world! Crusts were hand tossed with just the right amount of crunch, deliciously topped with fresh ingredients that made each bite better than the last. The true standout, though, was the sauce. An explosion of zesty flavor paired perfectly with its cheesy topping creating a pizza that I simply couldn’t get enough of.

In summary, Guy’s Pizza is definitely one of the best pizza places in Toledo OH—if not in the entire world! If you’re ever in town and want to enjoy a truly great pizza experience then Guy’s Pizza is your must-stop destination!

If you’re willing to go an extra 25 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Bowling Green!

#9 PizzaPapalis

From the moment I walked into PizzaPapalis, the delicious aroma of freshly baked pizza surrounded me. The atmosphere was warm and inviting. The counter staff was friendly and helpful, pointing out all the different types of pizza available. I went for the classic pepperoni and it did not disappoint!

The crust was thin yet crispy, with just enough sauce to lend a hint of sweetness to the overall flavor. The pepperoni was spread evenly throughout and had a nice crispness around the edges. The cheese melted perfectly – not too greasy yet still creamy – which is always a good sign in my book!

I tried other menu items during my visit as well, like their famous chicken wings and signature garlic knots. Everything tasted heavenly and left me wanting more! Plus, they have several daily deals that are always worth checking out.

Overall, PizzaPapalis is one of the best places to get pizza in Toledo OH. If you’re ever in town, be sure to check them out; you won’t regret it!

#10 Jomaa Brothers Pizza

I’ll be honest – I had my doubts when I first heard about this place. After all, how good could a pizza joint in the Midwest truly be? Fortunately, I was wrong!

The pizza here is fresh and delicious, with just the right amount of crunchy char from the ovens. The dough is pillow-y soft and has a wonderful flavor that pairs perfectly with their delectable sauces. To top it off, the toppings are plentiful and flavorful – definitely not an afterthought!

Plus, Jomaa Brothers Pizza offers a variety of options for those who want something different. Try their amazing barbecue pizza topped with pulled pork and pineapple or their classic Margherita with housemade mozzarella – both are unbelievably delicious!

Overall, if you’re ever near Toledo OH, do yourself a favor and stop by Jomaa Brothers Pizza! You won’t regret it – this place serves up some of the best pizza around!

#11 Salute! Pizzeria

The atmosphere alone is enough to make any pizza-lover salivate. From the cozy, candlelit corner booths to the delicious aromas wafting from the kitchen, this restaurant has a warmth and charm that’s hard to find.

The menu at Salute! Pizzeria is extensive and varied. Every type of pizza imaginable is here – from the basic cheese to specialty pies loaded with fresh vegetables, meats, or seafood. No matter what your craving or preference might be, you’re sure to find something that hits the spot.

But don’t worry – while Salute! Pizzeria may have a variety of options on their menu, they don’t skimp on quality. All of their pizzas are made with only the freshest ingredients – no skimpy toppings here! The crusts are crunchy and just chewy enough and the sauce…oh man, you won’t believe it until you try it for yourself.

And if pizza isn’t your thing? Well never fear – Salute! Pizzeria also offers delicious appetizers like garlic bread and wings, salads, pasta dishes and more! So no matter what kind of meal you’re looking for, I’m confident that Salute! Pizzeria will have something for everyone.

At the end of the day, I can say without a doubt that Salute! Pizzeria serves up some seriously delicious eats worthy of being considered some of the best pizza in Toledo OH!.

#12 Jet’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed when I walked into the restaurant was the friendly and welcoming atmosphere. From the moment I stepped in, I could tell that the staff wanted to make sure my experience was nothing short of perfect.

Next, I sampled some of their pizzas. Wow! Every bite was better than the last, and their crusts were just absolutely delicious! They also have a wide variety of topping options, so everyone can find something to please their taste buds.

To top it off (pun intended), Jet’s Pizza has super reasonable prices, so you don’t have to break your budget to get great pizza.

If you’re looking for delicious pizza in Toledo Ohio, Jet’s Pizza is definitely worth a visit!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – PizzaPapalis

Picture this: I walked into the restaurant expecting a slice of heaven, and boy, did I get it! The aroma hit me like a punch to the face (in a good way, of course) as soon as I walked through the door. It was like a pizza-scented rollercoaster that I never wanted to get off.

Now, let’s talk about the deep dish pizza itself. Oh, dear reader, it was a masterpiece! It was like a mystical creature that had been crafted by pizza gods. The crust was thick and buttery, with just the right amount of crunch. I swear, biting into that slice was like biting into a cloud made of cheese.

The toppings were a perfect symphony of flavors. The salty, savory pepperoni danced beautifully with the tangy, zesty sauce. And the cheese, oh the cheese! It was so gooey and melty that I couldn’t help but make a mess. But who cares about table manners when you’re experiencing pure pizza bliss?

The staff was delightful and attentive, just the way I like it. They were quick to refill my drink, which was important because I needed something to cool down the fire in my mouth from all that deliciousness.

So, if you’re in Toledo and looking for the best deep dish pizza around, look no further than PizzaPapalis. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed. Just be prepared to enter a pizza-induced state of euphoria. Bon appétit, my pizza-loving friends!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – PizzaPapalis

Stepping into PizzaPapalis felt like entering a pizza paradise. The aroma of freshly baked dough and melted cheese hit me as soon as I walked through the door, instantly making my stomach growl in anticipation. The waitstaff, dressed like pizza superheroes, greeted me with enthusiasm, ready to guide me through their pizza wonderland.

I must confess, I was skeptical at first. I mean, how impressive could a thin crust pizza really be? Well, let me tell you, as soon as I sank my teeth into that crispy yet chewy crust, I was transported to a world of pizza delight. It was like the crust was made of angel whispers and unicorn dreams.

The toppings were generously distributed, with a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and whatever toppings my heart desired. And can we talk about their sauce for a moment? It was like a flavor explosion in my mouth, with just the right amount of tanginess and spice. I swear, it was so good that I momentarily contemplated quitting my job to become a full-time pizza sauce sommelier.

The atmosphere at PizzaPapalis added to the experience. With its colorful murals depicting pizza-loving aliens and its funky, retro vibe, I felt like I was dining in a pizza-themed museum. I half expected Michelangelo to jump out of the kitchen and start tossing pizzas with the skill of a ninja turtle.

So, all in all, if you’re in Toledo and craving the best thin crust pizza, PizzaPapalis is your haven. Trust me, I’ve eaten pizza all over the world, and this place deserves a standing ovation… or maybe just a round of applause with greasy hands.