Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Modesto CA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in California

Best Pizza in Modesto CA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

137 Views

I’ve tasted pizza from all over the world, but I’m never one to turn down a slice of good ol’ American-style pizza. And what better place to find it than Modesto, CA? After trying out 12 different spots in town, I’m ready to share my top picks for the best pizza in Modesto.

It wasn’t an easy decision, but trust me: these places are worth writing home about. So gear up for some serious cheesy goodness and read on – you won’t want to miss out on the best pizza Modesto has to offer!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California

#1 Stonefire Pizza by MidiCi

The restaurant has a great atmosphere, with the smell of pizza in the air and its cozy decor. The staff was friendly and helpful, which added to my positive experience.

I had a chance to try several pizzas, and I must say that each one was delicious! The crusts were perfectly cooked and crispy, with just the right amount of toppings. The unique combinations of flavors were amazing, making this one of the most delicious meals I’ve ever had.

I especially enjoyed their creative approach when it comes to topping choices. From classic ingredients like pepperoni to innovative flavors like smoked salmon or truffle oil – there was something for everyone! Not only did it look amazing on the plate but it also tasted divine!

Overall, I’m really happy that I got to visit Stonefire Pizza by MidiCi. They have proved themselves time after time as having some of the best pizza in Modesto CA without fail. Highly recommended for all your pizza cravings!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Manteca!

#2 Donatello’s Take & Bake Pizza

I was impressed from the moment I walked in the door. The person behind the counter greeted me with a big smile, making me feel welcome and ready for an amazing pizza experience.

The first thing that caught my attention was their selection of pizzas. It seemed like they had every type of pizza imaginable! From classic margherita to Hawaiian to Mexican-style pies, there’s something for everyone at Donatello’s.

When it comes to taste, Donatello’s has it nailed down perfectly. The crust is thin and crispy, but still holds all the delicious toppings without getting soggy or falling apart. The sauce is flavorful and balanced perfectly with the cheese and other ingredients.

I also have to mention their selection of sides and drinks – they are equally as impressive! From chicken wings to garlic bread sticks, I was in pizza heaven!

If you’re ever in Modesto CA looking for a great pizza experience, look no further than Donatello’s Take & Bake Pizza – they’ve got some of the best ‘za this city has to offer!

#3 Jack’s Pizza & Wings

The first thing that struck me about Jack’s Pizza & Wings was the atmosphere. The restaurant is always filled with lively music, decorated with an old-school Italian feel, and the employees always greet customers with a smile.

The pizza is where Jack’s really stands out. They have so many delicious flavors to choose from, ranging from classic pepperoni to creative combinations like Mediterranean Veggie Supreme. Each pizza is made fresh with quality ingredients and cooked to perfection. To top it off, their wings are just as delectable – juicy and fried to crispy perfection!

But above all else, it’s the service at Jack’s Pizza & Wings that sets them apart from other restaurants: they’re accommodating, friendly and always make sure customers get exactly what they want. Whether you’re dining in or taking out your order, you can expect fast and efficient service every time.

In conclusion, I highly recommend Jack’s Pizza & Wings for anyone looking for the best pizza in Modesto CA!

#4 Pizzeria Halt

I first encountered Pizzeria Halt while on a cross-country road trip and decided to give it a try. I’m glad I did. As soon as I walked in, the inviting atmosphere and mouth-watering aromas of fresh ingredients made me feel right at home.

The staff were so friendly and helpful, walking me through all the options of pizza toppings available. The possibilities seemed endless! After much deliberation I settled on a classic combination of sausage, pepperoni, olives, onions, peppers and mushrooms.

My expectations for the pizza were quite high after hearing about how much locals love the place, and my expectations were more than met when my pizza arrived. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, yet still managed to hold together the generous amount of delicious toppings without getting soggy or falling apart.

I can honestly say that this is one of the best pizzas I’ve had anywhere! And with such reasonable prices too – it’s no wonder why Pizzeria Halt is quickly becoming one of Modesto’s favourite hot spots for Italian fare. Go check it out – you won’t be disappointed!

#5 Michael’s Pizza Bar and Grill

The restaurant is quaint, yet inviting. The moment you walk in the door, the aroma of deliciousness fills the air, and it’s hard not to salivate. I was immediately greeted by the friendly staff who were more than happy to help me choose from the extensive menu.

I had a few slices of their signature creation — a thin crust margherita pizza with mozzarella cheese, fresh basil, and parmesan. The flavors were out of this world! Each bite was packed with flavor; there was no skimping on ingredients or taste here. The thin crust gave it a light and crispy texture that would have made even Julius Caesar proud!

Overall, Michael’s Pizza Bar & Grill definitely lives up to its reputation as one of the best restaurants in Modesto CA. They take pride in their craftsmanship and attention to detail; it’s easy to see why they have so many loyal customers! If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, look no further than Michael’s Pizza Bar & Grill — you won’t be disappointed.

#6 Bobs Take n Bake Pizza

First, the atmosphere was unbeatable. Upon entering Bobs, I felt like I’d stepped into a 15th-century Italian pizzeria and that I was about to enjoy the best pizza of my life. The aroma of freshly baked dough and cheese wafted through the air, setting my mouth watering before I ever placed an order.

Next, there’s the taste – which, as any food critic can tell you, is paramount. Well, all I can say is wow! The crust was crunchy and flavorful with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. The toppings were cooked perfectly so they blended with the rest of the pizza without losing their flavor or texture. Bobs really knows how to put together a masterpiece of a pizza pie!

But beyond taste, Bobs Take n Bake Pizza has something else going for it – convenience! With their delivery services, you don’t have to worry about leaving home to pick up your order. Just place your order by phone or online and they’ll take care of the rest. How convenient is that?

All in all, I must say that Bobs Take n Bake Pizza is one top-notch destination if you want some truly amazing pizza in Modesto CA! If you’re looking for the best pizza around town (even if it’s not in town), make sure you don’t miss out on this place!

#7 Me n Ed’s Pizzera

From the moment you walk in, you can sense the passion for pizza – the delicious smell of tomatoes, herbs and cheese fills the air. Plus, the staff are all friendly and knowledgeable about the menu.

The pizza is simply outstanding. I had a meat lover’s pizza that was packed with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham and extra cheese. The crust was perfectly cooked between crunchy and chewy; not too thick or thin. The toppings were cooked to perfection with just enough sauce to complement without overpowering. It was exactly what I expected from an authentic Italian pizzeria!

For a change of pace, I also sampled Me n Ed’s speciality appetizer – their garlic knots! They were lightly fried to perfection and served with a side of marinara dip – absolutely delicious!

To top off this great experience, their selection of craft beers are second-to-none in Modesto CA. There’s something for everyone – from light lagers to high-gravity IPAs so there’s sure to be something that satisfies your taste buds.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Modesto CA then look no further than Me n Ed’s Pizzera – they serve up some delectable dishes with friendly service that will make you want to keep coming back for more!

#8 Nizario’s Pizza & Grill

The moment I stepped foot in Nizario’s, I knew I had stumbled upon a hidden gem. From the cozy atmosphere to the tantalizing smells coming from the kitchen, it was obvious why this place is so popular.

I ordered an Italian sausage pizza to start and was not disappointed. The combination of their unique crust, flavorful sauces, and delicious toppings made it one of the best pies I’ve ever had! The crust alone was worth returning for – perfectly crispy on the outside, light and airy on the inside – practically melting in my mouth.

But what really sets this pizza joint apart is the service. Both times I visited, the staff went out of their way to ensure that my experience was top-notch. My waitress even went so far as to recommend a few other dishes that weren’t on the menu but sounded too good to pass up!

If you love pizza like I do and are looking for something special in Modesto CA, then Nizario’s Pizza & Grill is definitely worth checking out. From their unbeatable pies to their remarkable service, it’s no surprise why they’re considered one of the best pizza places around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 29 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Stockton!

#9 Milano Pizza and Greek

The first time I went there, I was so impressed with their selection that I had to try a few slices. The Greek pizza was loaded with salty feta cheese and delicious olives, while the classic margherita featured a perfect combination of wholesome tomato sauce and freshly-grated mozzarella. But it was the pepperoni that really made me come back for more – each slice was bursting with flavor!

The atmosphere at Milano Pizza and Greek is also worth mentioning. The staff are friendly, the decor is cozy and inviting, and they even have live music performances on some nights… you can really feel a sense of warmth in the air.

I’m happy to say that after trying pizzas from all around the world, Milano Pizza and Greek is still one of my top picks for best pizza in Modesto CA. Each visit there makes me look forward to another opportunity to savor those wonderful flavors again!

#10 Luigi’s Pizza

When I first walked into Luigi’s, I was immediately greeted by the warm and inviting atmosphere. The red-checkered tablecloths added just the right amount of nostalgia to make me feel right at home.

I decided to order their signature pie, the ‘Luigi Special.’ It came loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, olives and peppers. The crust was cooked perfectly and had a nice crunch on the outside while still remaining tender in the middle. Every single topping was cooked to perfection – it truly was a masterpiece!

The sauce was absolutely amazing as well. It had a great balance between sweetness and acidity without being too overpowering. As a result, each bite felt like an explosion of flavor in my mouth!

Overall, my experience at Luigi’s Pizza has left me in awe. From start to finish, every element was executed flawlessly and I can honestly say that I felt like royalty when dining here! If you’re looking for the best pizza around Modesto CA, you absolutely must visit Luigi’s Pizza – it won’t disappoint!

#11 Pizza Guys

The first time I visited, I was truly surprised at the quality of the pizza. It had a nice thin crust with crispy edges, loaded with just the right amount of cheese and fresh toppings. The flavors were bold and incredibly delicious! As someone who has tried pizza all over the world, I can confidently say that Pizza Guys is on par with some of the best pizzerias out there!

The atmosphere at Pizza Guys is also top-notch. There’s a lively vibe in the air when you walk in and everyone seems to be having a good time. The staff is also extremely friendly, which makes for a pleasant dining experience.

To top it all off, their prices are very reasonable. You can get a large pizza for 4 people for around $20 or less, depending on the toppings you choose. Considering the quality of food you get at Pizza Guys, it’s definitely worth every penny.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for awesome pizza in Modesto CA, look no further than Pizza Guys! Go ahead and give it a try – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Pizza Guys

I’ve sampled pizza from Italy, Greece, New York City, Chicago, and elsewhere – yet nothing compares to the deliciousness of Pizza Guys. From their crusty Italian-style thin crust to their creamy white sauce, every bite is bursting with flavor. They also offer a variety of toppings so you can customize your pizza exactly how you want it.

But here is where Pizza Guys really shines: their gourmet creations. From the Mexican-inspired “Grande” to the Greek-style “Gyro”, there will never be a lack of variety when it comes to flavors. Not only are these pizzas incredibly flavorful, but they also have an aesthetically pleasing look that just adds to the experience.

The atmosphere at Pizza Guys rivals any five star restaurant I’ve had the pleasure of visiting – if they charged more than they did for pizza I would think it was a total bargain! The staff goes out of their way to make sure customers feel comfortable and welcomed in their establishment which always leaves me feeling right at home.

Overall, I highly recommend checking out Pizza Guys if you’re ever in Modesto CA looking for some great pizza!