Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Sedona AZ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Arizona

Best Pizza in Sedona AZ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

309 Views

In the past, I’ve been all over the world and tasted a wide variety of pizzas. So, when I decided to try out some of the best pizza Sedona had to offer, I thought it would be an easy feat. Boy, was I wrong! It took me 12 pizza places before I finally found something up to standard.

But don’t worry! After tasting each one and sampling their delicacies, I managed to find which ones should be on everyone’s must-eat list for the ultimate pizza experience in Sedona AZ. Even if you’re not a huge fan of ‘za, this lighthearted review will give you a break from the usual tourist traps.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Arizona

#1 Vespa Healthy Italian Café Sedona

I’ll admit, I was a bit skeptical when I saw the words “healthy” and “pizza” in the same sentence. But to my surprise, the pizza here is out of this world! They use simple ingredients and put a healthy twist on classic Italian flavors.

I had the opportunity to try a few of their delicious pizzas. The Margherita was one of my favorites – flavorful tomatoes, fragrant basil, mozzarella cheese, and a great crust. It was freshly prepared, with just enough char from the wood-fired oven that gave it an extra boost of flavor.

The Mushroom & Spinach pizza was also perfectly cooked with mushrooms that were incredibly flavorful and spinach that had been wilted to perfection.

My favorite pizza though was definitely the Zucchini & Prosciutto pizza. The combination of zucchini slices and small pieces of prosciutto make this arguably the best pizza in Sedona AZ. Plus they pile on lots of fresh mozzarella cheese – so yum!

Overall, Vespa Healthy Italian Café Sedona is a great spot for those looking to enjoy amazing pizza without sacrificing taste or quality. In fact it’s probably one of the best places you can get pizza in Sedona AZ!

If you’re willing to go an extra 24 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Flagstaff!

#2 Pisa Lisa

From the moment I stepped foot into Pisa Lisa, I knew it was going to be a great experience. Not only do they serve alcohol – and hard liquor! – but they have a fantastic kid’s menu for kids who want to eat there, too. On top of that, there are some great vegetarian options for those who abstain from eating meat.

At the end of the night, though, what really made me smile was the insanely good desserts offered by Pisa Lisa. At this point I’m convinced that they put their heart and soul into crafting each delicious slice of pizza.

The only downside to Pisa Lisa is that they don’t offer delivery services – you have to go there in person. But besides that, it’s a wonderful tourist spot with great food and drinks! I’d highly recommend making your way down to Pisa Lisa to experience some of the best pizza in Sedona AZ!

#3 Picazzo’s Healthy Italian Kitchen Sedona

At first glance, it’s easy to mistake this place for an ordinary Italian restaurant. But the truth is, there’s something special about Picazzo’s.

Their pizzas are made from fresh ingredients and cooked in a traditional wood-fired oven giving them an unmistakable flavor. The crust is thin and deliciously crunchy, perfect for a thin-crust enthusiast like myself. And the toppings are so flavorful you won’t believe it! I particularly enjoyed their speciality Pizza Bianca, topped with olive oil, garlic, arugula, shaved Parmesan and burrata cheese.

But the thing that makes Picazzo’s stand out above all other pizza places I have visited is that they offer healthy options too! Their whole wheat crust is just as delicious as their regular one and they have several vegetarian and vegan options available. This is great news for those of us who want to enjoy pizza without overindulging.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Sedona AZ then look no further than Picazzo’s Healthy Italian Kitchen Sedona. Everything here is top-notch – from the quality of the ingredients to the friendly staff – and you can rest assured that you’ll be getting a wholesome meal without breaking your diet!

#4 Hideaway House

The experience starts with the staff—they truly care about making sure you have an enjoyable time. They go out of their way to make sure you’re taken care of and that your pizza is just right.

Once your pizza arrives, you won’t be disappointed. The crust is a perfect combination of fluffy and crunchy, while the cheese is a delightful mix of sharpness and creaminess. And the toppings? Absolutely fresh—I tasted every one!

But probably my favorite thing about Hideaway House is how they don’t take themselves too seriously. When I asked for extra sauce on my pizza, they joked they’d throw bottles at me so I could put it on myself! How’s that for pizzeria humor?

All in all, Hideaway House gets five stars from me. If you’re looking for a good laugh and some of the best pizza in Sedona AZ, head over there tonight!

#5 Pago’s Pizzeria and Italian Cuisine

The atmosphere was welcoming and cozy, yet not lacking in modern amenities. As we entered, a friendly staff greeted us with a warm smile before leading us to our table.

The menu at Pago’s is surprisingly varied and interesting. Not only is there delicious pizza, but they also have an impressive selection of Italian dishes and appetizers that really hit the spot!

When our pizza arrived, I can honestly say that I have never had anything like it before – it was like nothing I’d ever tasted! The crust had just the right amount of crunch, with plenty of cheese mixed in for flavor. And when it came to toppings, you could choose from everything from classic pepperoni to pineapple and jalapeno — all cooked perfectly.

All in all, I think that Pago’s Pizzeria and Italian Cuisine is simply one of the best pizza places I’ve encountered during my travels! If you’re ever in Sedona AZ looking for the best pizza around, this is definitely a must-visit restaurant.

If you’re willing to go an extra 36 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Prescott Valley!

#6 Rotten Johnny’s Wood-Fired Pizza Pie

The crust is perfection and the ingredients are of the freshest quality. The atmosphere is cozy and the wood-fired oven in the corner gives the pizzeria an extra homey feel.

The owner, Johnny, knows how to craft a good pie. He adds just the right amount of herbs and spices and never skimp on ingredients. I have tried a few different types of pizza here, but my favorite has to be their signature “Rotten Johnny’s Special”. It’s absolutely delicious!

The service at Rotten Johnny’s Wood-Fired Pizza Pie is great too – always prompt and friendly. The employees seem to genuinely enjoy their jobs, as they serve up some of the best pizza in Sedona AZ with a great attitude!

Overall, I would definitely recommend this place for a great slice or for takeout. The best pizza in Sedona AZ can definitely be found at Rotten Johnny’s Wood-Fired Pizza Pie!

#7 Pisa Lisa

The pizza has a just-right thickness – not too thin and not too thick, which gives the perfect balance of delicious crust and cheesy goodness. The toppings are always fresh and flavorful, without being overly greasy or salty.

The atmosphere at Pisa Lisa is very inviting, with comfortable seating and a cozy Italian-inspired design. The staff is friendly and efficient, providing great service so you can enjoy your meal without having to worry about it taking forever to arrive.

I especially recommend trying the Supreme Pizza – it’s loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, olives… it’s like a party in my mouth! And the garlic knots are heavenly!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Sedona AZ, look no further than Pisa Lisa!

#8 Moondog’s Pizza & Dinner

The atmosphere of the place is homey and inviting with a rustic vibe. It’s the kind of place where you can relax and take your time enjoying your meal.

I opted for their signature chicken pesto pizza with artichokes, red onions, and roasted garlic. The first bite had me sold! The crunchy crust was thin and perfect, the toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the cheese melted to perfection. While this may not be traditional pizza, it matched the creative spirit of Moondog’s.

The service was top-notch as well. My server was cheerful and warm and my drink was never empty. They made sure I had everything I needed, even when I asked for extra parmesan.

I would highly recommend Moondog’s Pizza & Dinner to anyone looking for the best pizza in Sedona AZ. With its great atmosphere, amazing pizza, and attentive service – this is one restaurant that can’t be missed!

#9 Canyon Breeze Restaurant

In my experience, I’ve found that it’s often the small touches that make or break a pizza joint. Canyon Breeze has nailed them all! Their alcohol selection is great – not just beer and wine but hard liquor too! And if you’re visiting Sedona with kids, they have a kid’s menu so no one feels left out.

Their pizzas are amazing, too. No matter what your favorite toppings are they have something to satisfy everyone’s cravings. Plus, they offer dessert – which., let’s be honest, is always a great idea after stuffing yourself with a few slices of their signature pepperoni and garlic deliciousness.

It’s also worth noting that Canyon Breeze Restaurant is in a great tourist spot and provides an awesome atmosphere for sports fans thanks to the huge TVs in the corner. No other restaurant in town can match that!

The downside of course is that there’s no delivery option, but if you plan ahead and order from their website you won’t be disappointed. All in all, I highly recommend Canyon Breeze Restaurant to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Sedona AZ!

If you’re willing to go an extra 42 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Prescott!

#10 Sedona Pizza and Pasta Company

I was instantly impressed when I walked in the restaurant. The atmosphere was inviting and warm, with a cover band playing classic rock tunes in the background. They serve alcohol (and hard liquor!) which is always an added bonus for me. The menu had some great vegetarian options, as well as a kid’s menu, so I knew it was family-friendly.

I started off with their signature garlic knots – crunchy on the outside, soft inside and oh so garlicky – then moved onto their pizza selection. All of the pizzas were cooked to perfection and loaded with fresh ingredients like bell peppers, olives and mushrooms. My personal favorite was their Four Cheese Pizza (it’s like a party in your mouth!).

Besides pizza they also have plenty of other delicious items like pastas, salads and sandwiches to choose from as well. For dessert, they offered a lovely selection of crisp cannoli pastries that left me feeling satisfied.

My only complaint about Sedona Pizza and Pasta Company is that there’s no delivery option – if only they did delivery I could enjoy these delicious treats all night long! Overall though, it’s definitely one of the best pizza places in Sedona AZ!

#11 Famous Pizza & Beer – West Sedona

It’s not just the quality of the pizza that stands out, but also the atmosphere. The cheerful wait staff and warm, inviting environment made me feel right at home.

The pizza itself is out of this world! They use the freshest ingredients and you can tell by the flavor that they know their stuff. The crust was cooked perfectly and had a delicious crunch to it. The toppings were cooked to perfection – never too soggy or burnt.

The beer selection was great too! They had a huge variety of craft beers as well as some local favorites. I found a beer I hadn’t tried before, which was a nice surprise!

All in all, Famous Pizza & Beer – West Sedona is definitely worth checking out for anyone looking for the best pizza in Sedona AZ!

#12 Famous Pizza & Beer – Village of Oak Creek

I arrived at the restaurant hungry, and ready to devour some of their famous pies. I was pleasantly surprised at the variety of options – from traditional margaritas to creative creations.

The crust was perfectly cooked, with a light texture and golden color. The toppings were generous and artfully arranged. And the cheese – well let’s just say I’m now a believer in the superiority of freshly grated mozzarella!

The service was great too. The waitstaff were friendly and knowledgeable, able to describe each pizza option in detail without ever seeing a menu.

As for the beer selection – it’s no exaggeration when they say they have one of the best selections in Sedona AZ! From craft IPAs to crisp lagers, there truly is something for every palate.

So yes, the verdict is clear: Famous Pizza & Beer – Village of Oak Creek definitely has some of the best pizza in Sedona AZ! Whether you’re looking for a delicious slice or just want to relax with friends over an ice-cold beverage, this place has it all!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Famous Pizza & Beer – West Sedona

Now, I’ve been to Italy, New York City, and even Chicago, home of the deep-dish delight. But let me tell you, forget about those fancy pants pizzas, because this unassuming joint in West Sedona takes the doughy crown.

Walking into Famous Pizza & Beer is like stepping into a time machine. The decor screams 80s nostalgia with neon signs, vinyl booth seating, and posters of classic rock bands. It’s like a pizza place from my teenage dreams, complete with the smell of melting cheese and sizzling pepperoni.

Now let me get to the star of the show – the thin crust pizza. Oh mama mia, the crust is crispy, light, and has just the right amount of chewiness. It’s so thin that you could use it as a frisbee, but who would want to waste something so delicious?

The toppings are plentiful and high-quality. From classic Margherita to exotic combinations like BBQ chicken with pineapple, Famous Pizza & Beer knows how to keep things interesting. They even have a create your own option, so you can let your imagination run wild while the kitchen wizards work their magic.

And let’s not forget the beer! The selection is vast and varied, offering local brews as well as international favorites. The only thing better than a slice of pizza is a slice of pizza accompanied by a refreshing pint.

So if you’re in West Sedona and craving some thin-crust perfection, don’t waste your time wandering around. Just head straight to Famous Pizza & Beer. Your taste buds will thank you, and your waistline might curse you, but hey, life’s too short to count calories when the pizza is this good!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Sedona Pizza and Pasta Company

Now, I must admit, I was quite excited to find out that this place serves alcohol. And not just your run-of-the-mill beer and wine, but hard liquor too! Talk about adding some cheer to my pizza experience. Who doesn’t love a good piña colada with their slice of pepperoni?

Now, being a food critic who has dabbled in vegetarianism from time to time, I was pleased to find out that Sedona Pizza and Pasta Company offers some veggie options. Let’s face it, even the most carnivorous among us can appreciate a good Margherita or Veggie Delight once in a while. And trust me, their vegetarian pizzas are so good, they might even convert a few die-hard meat lovers.

And what’s a meal without dessert, right? Well, fear not, my sugar-loving comrades, because Sedona Pizza and Pasta Company has got you covered. They offer a variety of sweet treats to satisfy your sugar cravings, from tiramisu to cannoli. I wouldn’t blame you if you skipped right to dessert.

Now, onto the downsides. The only real downside I can come up with is that this place doesn’t offer delivery. I mean, seriously? I can’t just sit in my hotel room and have a delicious wood fired pizza brought to my door? I guess I’ll have to gather up the energy to walk a few steps to the restaurant. Oh, the struggles of being a pizza connoisseur!

All jokes aside, Sedona Pizza and Pasta Company is a must-visit for any pizza lover in Sedona. The combination of great pizza, drinks, vegetarian options, and sweet desserts make it a delightful spot for tourists and locals alike. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed.