Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Forest Hills (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Forest Hills (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

138 Views

My taste buds have had the pleasure of trying pizza around the world, but my search for the best pizza in Forest Hills was a particularly fun one. After all, it’s not every day that I get to try twelve different pizzerias in one area! As I sampled each offering, I paid attention to flavor, texture, and price point. My goal: find the perfect slice for everyone!

So which pizzeria will come out on top? Join me on this journey through Forest Hills as I hunt down the best pizza – with a lighthearted and humorous tone along the way.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Alfie’s Pizza

First of all, let me just say that the pizza is amazing. The crust is perfectly crispy and the sauce is incredibly flavorful. They use the freshest ingredients which really give this pizza its unique flavor.

The atmosphere at Alfie’s Pizza is also great – it’s cozy enough to make you feel welcome, but still modern and trendy enough to keep up with the times. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, so if you have any questions they are always ready to help.

But what stands out about Alfie’s Pizza is their attention to detail. They go above and beyond when it comes to creating their pizzas – from sauce recipes to toppings – each slice of Pizza perfection has been carefully crafted for your taste buds’ pleasure!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Forest Hills, look no further than Alfie’s Pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Queens!

#2 Dante’s Pizza

When I stepped inside, I noticed the charming décor and warm atmosphere immediately. The service was exceptional and the pizza smelled like a heavenly dream!

The taste of the pizza wasn’t far behind. It was cooked to perfection with a crust that had the perfect balance of crunchy and chewy. To top it off, there were plenty of zesty flavors in every bite.

I also have to say that their prices are unbeatable! After my meal at Dante’s Pizza, I paid less than half of what I usually pay for a decent slice of pizza elsewhere.

Overall, if you’re looking for some really good pizza without breaking the bank, then head over to Dante’s Pizza! You won’t be disappointed – trust me!

#3 Austin Street Pizza

I’m sure the locals here would argue that their pizza is even better than some of the other places I’ve visited, but you can’t deny the quality at Austin Street Pizza.

The downside to Austin Street Pizza is that they don’t offer delivery, but with great pizza like this, I don’t mind eating in. Plus it’s a great tourist spot being so close to all the attractions in Forest Hills.

Speaking of tourists, vegetarians will appreciate the fact that Austin Street Pizza has some great vegetarian options for those looking for a meat-free alternative.

In conclusion, I highly recommend anyone visiting Forest Hills to try out Austin Street Pizza and taste why it’s considered some of the best pizza in town!

#4 Pizza Classica

I’m so glad I made the trip to the restaurant. When I first arrived, I was immediately impressed by how clean and modern the decor was. Of course, what really mattered to me was the pizza.

The waitstaff were incredibly friendly and accommodating in helping me choose a pie that would suit my tastes, and they did not disappoint! The crust was thin, crisp, and perfectly seasoned with garlic and herbs. The tomato sauce had a perfect tanginess which complemented the generous helping of cheese that sat on top of it all.

I knew this was some of the best pizza in Forest Hills as soon as I took my first bite! The flavors blended together wonderfully, and each ingredient stood out on its own at the same time. Plus, the portion size was just right – not too small or too big.

Overall, Pizza Classica serves up an excellent example of authentic Italian pizza that’s sure to please everyone who visits. From their attentive waitstaff to their delicious pies, I can confidently say this is one of the best pizza spots in Forest Hills!

#5 Spolini’s

What can I say about Spolini’s that hasn’t already been said? From the second you walk in, you know you’re in for a treat. The aroma of their specialty pizzas envelops your senses and sets the tone for the rest of your meal.

The service is top-notch too – the wait staff is friendly and accommodating, which goes a long way in my book! Their menu has something for everyone, so no matter what kind of pizza you like, Spolini’s has it.

The food itself is magnificent, hands down! When it comes to their pizzas, they really hit it out of the park. Every bite is more delicious than the last – from classic pepperoni to more creative options like Hawaiian or Greek. My personal favorite was a white pizza with artichokes – it was truly divine!

I’d definitely recommend Spolini’s to any pizza aficionado looking for some of the best pizza in Forest Hills. They really have all the bases covered when it comes to great pizza: amazing ingredients, delicious recipes, and warm hospitality. So if your mouth is watering for some truly amazing pizza, head on over to Spolini’s as soon as possible!

#6 Lillian Pizzeria

As soon as I stepped foot in the door, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma of baking dough and fresh herbs wafted through the air. As I took my seat at the bar, I could already tell this place was something special.

The server greeted me with a smile and explained the menu options in detail. After hearing her descriptions of each specialty pizza, it was easy to decide what to order: an Italian-style thin-crust pie loaded with tangy tomato sauce, garlic, and mushrooms.

When my pizza arrived, it looked like a work of art – bubbly crust, just the right amount of cheese, and perfectly cooked toppings. Delicious! Eating it was even better than looking at it. In fact, this might be some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

I highly recommend Lillian Pizzeria for anyone who’s looking for the best pizza in Forest Hills – or anywhere else! Simply put: it’s hard to find a better slice than this one.

#7 Pizza & Pasta City

The atmosphere was incredibly inviting, with checkered table cloths and a warm wood oven putting out the most delicious smells. As soon as we sat down, we knew we were in for an exceptional meal.

The pizza was truly astounding- it was cooked to perfection with a golden crust and the most delightful toppings. The Margherita pizza had a fresh tomato-basil sauce that was wonderfully savory, while the Pepperoni had just the right amount of spice and tanginess.

What really stood out to me, though, were the homemade pastas. The Fettuccine Alfredo was so flavorful that I wanted to lick my plate clean! Plus, they used real parmesan cheese – none of that pre-shredded stuff here!

Overall, Pizza & Pasta City is undoubtedly one of the best pizzerias in Forest Hills. The friendly staff made us feel right at home and ensured that every dish was cooked with care and attention. From now on, this will be my go-to spot for Italian cuisine!

#8 La Rondine Pizza

I was overwhelmed by the variety of options on their menu. They had several different pizzas that I hadn’t seen before and a wide selection of toppings. It took me forever to decide what to get because there were so many great options!

The crust was perfectly crispy and thin, and the sauce was very flavorful. The cheese was gooey and melted perfectly. And the toppings were fresh and flavorful – it really made the pizza come alive in my mouth!

I also tried some of their specialty sides, like garlic knots and garlic bread, which both hit the spot. Their salads were also tasty, with lots of fresh produce, nuts, and cheeses.

And finally, for dessert, I got one of their delightful cannolis – just sweet enough without being overly sugary.

Overall, I would definitely recommend La Rondine Pizza if you’re looking for the best pizza in Forest Hills. There’s something here for everyone – long time locals will recognize many familiar flavors, while newcomers can explore new Italian dishes that they’ve never tasted before!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Queens!

#9 Nick’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Nick’s Pizza just screams authenticity. It looks like a classic pizza shop, with its checkered tablecloths, wood-burning oven, and a wisecracking pizza maker in the back. I immediately felt relaxed and at home.

The menu at Nick’s Pizza is simple yet sophisticated. You can choose from a variety of classic pizzas such as the margherita or classic cheese, or create your own masterpiece. The ingredients are all fresh, so you know you’re getting quality pizza every time.

As for the taste? Delicious! I had the pepperoni and extra cheese and it was absolutely scrumptious. The crust was thin yet crunchy and the toppings were juicy and flavorful – exactly how a good pizza should be! What’s more, the prices are very affordable so you don’t have to break the bank to enjoy some of the best pizza in Forest Hills.

In short, if you’re ever in Forest Hills and looking for some great pizza, look no further than Nick’s Pizza!

#10 Dee’s Wood Fired Pizza + Kitchen

The first thing that caught my eye when I walked in was the wood-fired oven, and the smell of freshly baked pizza. It gave me a sense that I was in for something special!

The menu was full of delicious options, so it took me awhile to make up my mind. I ended up deciding on the All-American Pie, which is a traditional take on cheese pizza but with an extra helping of mozzarella and bacon.

I’m glad I went with this option because it totally exceeded my expectations. The crust had that perfect combination of crunchy yet chewy texture and the toppings were cooked to perfection. The fresh herbs sprinkled over the top gave it that extra flavorful kick.

Overall, Dee’s Wood Fired Pizza + Kitchen delivers some of the best pizzas in Forest Hills. No matter what type you’re craving – traditional, vegetarian, or something more gourmet – they have something for everyone here. And don’t forget to get a side dish to go along with your pizza!

#11 Dani’s House of Pizza

From the moment I stepped through their doors, I knew I was in for a special experience. The aroma of quality ingredients and pizzas baking in the wood-fired ovens transported me to Italy!

The staff were very pleasant and friendly, which made my visit all the more enjoyable. Even though it was a busy day, they took their time to make sure my pizza was perfectly crafted.

I chose the signature pie, an incredible combination of homemade tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella cheese, and freshly cooked dough. The crust was light yet crunchy and the flavors melted together into an explosion of pizza perfection that I’m still dreaming about.

I can honestly say that Dani’s House of Pizza is one of the best places to get a slice in Forest Hills. Try it for yourself and you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Paul Michael’s Brick Oven Cafe Restaurant

The first time I stepped in, I was immediately taken aback by the atmosphere. The cozy outdoor seating area and brick oven with a view of the street gives it an inviting ambiance. It’s like you’re transported to a pizzeria in Italy!

The service is above and beyond what one could expect from a regular pizza joint. Everyone at Paul Michael’s is friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. They always make sure your experience is top notch.

The main reason that Paul Michael’s stands out among other pizzerias in the Forest Hills area is its pizza. To put it simply, it’s simply amazing! Crispy, cheesy crusts? Check. Flavorful toppings? Check. Perfectly cooked dough balls? Double check! Every single slice was delightfully delightful to say the least.

Above all else, Paul Michael’s Brick Oven Cafe Restaurant is definitely one of the best pizzerias in Forest Hills! Even after all my travels and tasting different kinds of pizza around the world – this place remains one of my favorites!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – UNO Pizzeria & Grill

Walking into UNO Pizzeria & Grill is like stepping into a parallel universe where pizza is revered and worshipped. The moment I entered, my senses were immediately assaulted by the tantalizing aroma of fresh dough and melted cheese. My taste buds couldn’t contain their excitement, and neither could my waistline!

As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I’ve had my fair share of deep dish, but UNO’s version left me weak at the knees (and not just because of the sheer caloric intake). The crust, oh the crust! It was like a buttery, flaky embrace from an Italian grandmother who wants nothing more than to make you forget your waistline woes.

And the cheese? It oozed with such reckless abandon that I couldn’t help but feel like I was committing a crime by devouring it. But like a true rebel, I shrugged off the guilt and continued my indulgence. The toppings were piled high, as if each slice was competing in a skyscraper-building contest. I found myself marveling at the engineering feat that was my plate of pizza.

The best part? The staff at UNO’s understood my pizza obsession. They didn’t judge when I ordered a second, or third, or fourth slice. They applauded my dedication to the art of pizza consumption and even cheered me on as I embarked on a personal pizza-eating challenge.

So, if you find yourself in Queens and craving a deep dish pizza that will make you question everything you thought you knew about pie, do yourself a favor and head straight to UNO Pizzeria & Grill. Prepare to be amazed, delighted, and thoroughly stuffed.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Lucia Pizza

Walking into Lucia Pizza is like entering a pizza lover’s paradise. I swear, the smell alone could make even the strictest dieter throw caution to the wind and dive headfirst into a gooey cheese-filled pie. And let me tell you, it’s worth every cheesy bite!

Now, let’s talk about the downside. Lucia Pizza has a no reservations policy. I mean, seriously? Do they not know who I am? (Just kidding, I’m not that big of a deal). So, instead of reserving a table like a civilized human being, you have to risk it and pray there’s an empty table when you arrive. I suggest going on a weekday if you don’t want to spend your evening pacing outside the restaurant like a peckish penguin.

But all jokes aside, Lucia Pizza is a hidden gem that deserves all the praise it gets. The thin crust is the stuff dreams are made of – crispy on the outside, yet still chewy on the inside, just like a perfectly toasted marshmallow. And the toppings? You can’t go wrong with any choice! Whether you’re a classic margherita lover or a wild mushroom aficionado, Lucia has got you covered.

So take my advice, folks. If you find yourself in queens ny and in need of some seriously stellar pizza, head on over to Lucia Pizza. Just make sure to bring your patience and an empty stomach because this place is worth the wait!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Tauro Wood Fired Pizza

As soon as I walked into Tauro Wood Fired Pizza, my senses were hit with the intoxicating smell of delicious pizza. I could practically hear my taste buds cheering in excitement. The ambiance of the restaurant was cozy and rustic, with a beautiful wood-fired oven as the centerpiece. It was love at first sight.

The menu was a delightful symphony of pizza creations. From classics like Margherita and Pepperoni, to more adventurous options like Truffle Mushroom and Prosciutto Fig, Tauro had something for everyone. As a food critic, I pride myself on being adventurous, so I decided to go for the Prosciutto Fig pizza. And boy, did it take my taste buds on a wild ride!

The first bite transported me to flavor heaven. The crispy, thin crust was the perfect canvas for the explosion of flavors. The sweet and salty combination of prosciutto and fresh figs was a match made in cheesy heaven. Each bite left me craving more. I couldn’t help but imagine how jealous my taste buds would be if they discovered I had been cheating on them with Tauro Wood Fired Pizza.

The service at Tauro was also top-notch. The staff was friendly, attentive, and had the perfect balance of professionalism and lightheartedness. They made me feel like I was dining with old friends, which is always a bonus when you’re traveling solo.

In conclusion, Tauro Wood Fired Pizza is not just another pizza joint. It is a slice of pizza paradise in San Francisco. So if you find yourself craving the best wood-fired pizza in town, stop by Tauro and let your taste buds embark on a magical pizza journey. Trust me, they’ll thank you for it!