Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Buffalo NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Buffalo NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

386 Views

I’ve tasted pizza all over the world, so you can trust me when I say there are some great pizzerias in Buffalo!

From Italian to wood-fired to deep dish, I sampled twelve different pizzas places throughout Buffalo with my trusty notepad and pen ready to take notes.

I kept my review process lighthearted but thorough and judged each pie on flavor, quality of ingredients, size and price. After hours of testing, it’s time to reveal which pizza place made it onto my list for the ‘Best Pizza in Buffalo NY’.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Slice of New York

When I walked in, the first thing that struck me was the delicious aroma of baking pizza. Then of course there was the mouthwatering selection of pizzas on display. From classic pepperoni pies to white pizza with artichokes and mushrooms, they had it all!

The slices were large and flavorful, with a thick but crispy crust and generous toppings. Each slice was perfection on its own – no sauce or cheese could make it any better!

I also enjoyed their unique side dishes. The garlic knots are particularly noteworthy – pillowy soft buns covered in garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan cheese. And their “spicy flower” chicken wings have just enough kick for those who like a little heat with their food.

The atmosphere at Slice of New York is laid-back yet festive. The walls are painted in bright colors, and the music is upbeat without being intrusive. The staff here is friendly and helpful, so you will always feel welcome here!

All in all, Slice of New York serves up some of the best pizza in Buffalo NY that I’ve ever tasted. Highly recommended by this professional food critic!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Amherst!

#2 Tuscan Pizza Crust

The first thing that struck me walking in was the incredibly warm and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant was decorated with a Tuscan theme that made me feel right at home.

The next thing I noticed was the smell in the air – mouth-watering aromas of freshly-baked pizza crust and spices.

One huge plus was watching the pizza chef stretch out the dough by hand in front of my eyes – it was kind of like a show! I must admit, I enjoyed watching him work his magic on each pie.

As for the pizza, it definitely did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunch to it. The sauce was flavorful but not overpowering and paired very well with all the toppings. My personal favorite combination was their classic margherita – which came with fresh basil and tomatoes for an added punch of flavor.

My overall experience at Tuscan Pizza Crust could only be described as delightful! From start to finish, this has got to be one of the best pizza experiences in Buffalo NY!

#3 Lovejoy Pizzeria

This family-owned Italian restaurant has been around for over 30 years and it’s easy to see why. The pizza here is so delicious it literally melts in your mouth! Everything from the thin and crispy crust to the savory sauce is spot on. In addition, they offer a variety of toppings – my favorite being homemade sausage infused with herbs, garlic and fennel seeds.

But that’s not all they have to offer. Lovejoy Pizzeria takes pride in their homemade calzones and stromboli, too. The ample portions of cheese and sauce inside the dough, combined with their expertly seasoned meats, makes these dishes a must-try!

Lovejoy also has an extensive selection of craft beers on tap – perfect for washing down all that pizza goodness! And lest I forget, if you still have room after your meal (which I doubt!) you won’t want to miss out on their homemade cannolis.

I’m always looking for the best pizza places when I travel and in Buffalo NY, you can be sure Lovejoy Pizzeria will make my list of top picks every time!

#4 Bailey N Doat Pizzeria

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately greeted by the inviting aromas of freshly baked dough and melted cheese. I took my seat at a cozy booth near the open kitchen where I could watch in awe as the pizza chefs expertly crafted each pie with care.

The menu is filled with creative pizza combinations such as BBQ Bacon Onion Pizza and Margarita Pesto Pizza. After much deliberation, I finally chose the Prosciutto & Roasted Pear Pizza. When it arrived to my table, I knew that this was going to be one delicious experience!

The crust was light and fluffy, which provided an ideal base for all of the amazing flavors that were coming together in every bite. The prosciutto and roasted pear were just heavenly when combined with gooey mozzarella and a light yet flavorful pesto sauce.

I finished off my meal with a dessert pizza because why not? The Nutella Dessert Pizza was utterly mouthwatering – chocolate hazelnut spread topped with juicy strawberries and drizzled with honey. It was truly an unforgettable experience!

If you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Buffalo NY then look no further than Bailey N Doat Pizzeria. From starters to desserts, they have something delicious for everyone!

#5 Brick Oven Bistro

The atmosphere here is perfect – it’s a great tourist spot and a nice place to watch sports while enjoying some of their delicious pizza. Plus, they serve alcohol, so that’s an added bonus if you’re looking to enjoy a beer or two with your meal!

What really makes this place stand out from other places in the area, though, is their insanely good dessert. Their desserts are truly unique, and I’ve yet to have a bad one!

Now for the downside: Brick Oven Bistro doesn’t offer delivery. But honestly, that’s only because their food tastes best when it’s fresh and hot from the oven. Plus, they offer a great kids menu so even the pickiest eaters are sure to find something they like.

So if you’re ever in Buffalo NY and looking for the best pizza around – look no further than Brick Oven Bistro!

#6 Joe’s New York Style Pizza

The pizza was delicious. The crust had that perfect crunch that only comes with a good New York style pizza. The sauce was bursting with flavor and the cheese melted in your mouth. Each slice had the perfect ratio of toppings, and flavors were exploding in each bite.

I’m also very impressed by Joe’s customer service. They were friendly and attentive, always there to answer any questions I had about their menu. Plus, they let me ask for my pizza exactly how I wanted it!

In conclusion, if you’re ever in Buffalo NY and want the best pizza around, head on over to Joe’s New York Style Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Imperial Pizza

The atmosphere of this place is just fantastic – it’s cozy and has a great vibe. The walls are painted with murals of Italian scenes, and wooden tables filled the room. Everyone was in a lively mood, chatting away and enjoying their meal.

The staff at Imperial Pizza were all friendly and attentive, which always helps to make the experience even better. They were also very knowledgeable when it came to recommending different pizza toppings and suggested some really unique combinations that I had never heard before.

Of course, the food is what really matters. I can confidently say that Imperial Pizza serves up some seriously delicious pizza! The crust was thin yet crunchy; they weren’t stingy with the cheese or toppings either! Every bite was packed with flavour from the rich tomato sauce to the tender vegetables.

I would definitely recommend Imperial Pizza for anyone looking for a great slice of pizza in Buffalo NY!

#8 Mineo’s South Pizzeria

I’ve had some phenomenal pizza in my time, from Italy to Thailand, but nothing compared to the deliciousness of Mineo’s. The crust is grilled perfectly and topped with a blend of fresh cheeses and the finest ingredients – the combination is truly delightful.

I particularly enjoyed their specialty pies like the Meat Lover’s Pie, Buffalo Chicken Pie and White Spinach Pie – all of which I highly recommend. All of the pizzas are made to order, so you never have to worry about anything drying out or getting cold! Perhaps most importantly though, there was no shortage of cheese on any of our pies – it was definitely not skimped on!

The atmosphere at Mineo’s was also top-notch, with friendly staff and an airy dining room with plenty of natural light filtering in through the windows. Overall, I could hardly ask for better pizza than what I found here in Buffalo. If you’re looking for great pizza in the area, Mineo’s South Pizzeria should be your first stop. Delicious food and a welcoming atmosphere make this place one of my favorite pizza stops ever!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Niagara Falls!

#9 Wise Guys Pizza

The atmosphere was great, with a lively and welcoming vibe that immediately put me at ease. I was met by an enthusiastic staff member who walked me through the menu and recommended some of their top-selling pizzas.

And let me tell you – they were delicious! All of Wise Guys Pizzas were cooked to perfection, with the perfect blend of cheese, sauce and crust. They use only the freshest ingredients, which really shines through in the flavor.

In addition to great pizza, Wise Guys also had some incredible sides. The garlic bread was my personal favorite; it was cooked just right so that it wasn’t greasy or oily but still had an amazing crispy texture. And the big salads were incredibly fresh too – definitely surprising for a pizza joint!

All in all, Wise Guys Pizza is hands down one of the best pizza places in Buffalo NY. Whether you’re looking for a slice or a full pie, wise guys will satisfy your craving!

#10 Gino’s NY Pizza ( University Plaza )

The atmosphere at Gino’s NY Pizza is like stepping into a little slice of Italian Heaven. The walls are adorned with Italian trinkets, the staff is friendly and attentive, and the pizza… well, it just might be the best I’ve ever tasted!

My pizza of choice was a classic Margherita with extra cheese. As soon as my order arrived, I knew I had chosen wisely. The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy, and the tomato sauce was packed full of flavor. Topped off with gooey mozzarella cheese and fresh basil leaves, this was by far one of the best pizzas I’d ever had!

What really made Gino’s stand out from other places around Buffalo was their commitment to using fresh ingredients in all their dishes. Everything from the dough to the toppings were top-notch; nothing seemed pre-packaged or over-processed.

I would highly recommend anyone visiting Buffalo to check out Gino’s NY Pizza; you won’t be disappointed! With delicious food, great atmosphere, and friendly staff, this place has definitely earned its title as home of the best pizza in Buffalo NY!

#11 Bonetti’s Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped into this place I knew it was special. The atmosphere is inviting and cozy, with a great selection of craft beers to accompany whatever delicious slice you order.

I started off with one of their legendary Sicilian slices. The crust was thin and crunchy, the cheese was melted like a dream, and the sauce had just enough sweetness to make my mouth water.

The real star however, comes out when you order one of their classic New York-style pizzas. They have perfected this style of pizza to a point where it’s almost impossible not to like it no matter what your taste buds are telling you. The crust is so airy and flavorful, while still maintaining that perfect chewy texture that I look for in an authentic New York-style pie. And don’t even get me started on the toppings! They were fresh, creative, and delicious in every bite!

All in all, if you’re looking for one of the best pies around town, look no further than Bonetti’s Pizzeria! You won’t regret it!

#12 Ricottas pizza Niagara

The staff are friendly and welcoming, making sure that each order is made quickly and correctly. The restaurant itself is clean and well kept.

When it comes to the food, Ricottas takes pizza very seriously. The crusts are thin yet slightly crunchy and the toppings are delicious! The marinara sauce is fragrant with herbs and the cheese melts perfectly every time.

Ricotta’s secret weapon is their house-made sausage which adds a blast of flavor to any pizza combination. One of my favorite pies from Ricotta’s is the Meat Lover’s Delight, which features pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, bacon bits, and red peppers. It’s definitely worth ordering!

To top it all off, I especially like that Ricotta’s serves beer on tap in addition to other tasty beverages.

If you’re in Buffalo for some great pizza then look no further than Ricottas Pizza Niagara–it will not disappoint!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – JJs Casa Di Pizza

Let’s start with the ambiance. As soon as I walked into JJs Casa Di Pizza, I felt like I had been transported to a pizza lover’s paradise. The walls are adorned with pictures of happy customers devouring their delicious, cheesy creations. There’s even a mural of a pizza tossing competition, because apparently, they take their craft seriously here.

Now let’s talk about the pizza itself. Oh boy, where do I begin? The crust is a perfect balance of crispy and doughy, like biting into a cloud made of pizza heaven. The cheese? Oh, don’t get me started! It’s so melted and gooey that it practically creates its own gravitational pull. I half-expected my slice to float away on a sea of cheesy goodness.

The toppings? Well, let’s just say they don’t skimp on those either. Whether you want traditional pepperoni or something wild like pineapple and jalapeños, JJs Casa Di Pizza has got you covered. I tried their Everything and the Kitchen Sink pizza, and let me tell you, they weren’t lying. I think I spotted a kitchen sink somewhere buried beneath the mountains of toppings.

But what truly sets JJs Casa Di Pizza apart is the service. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and clearly passionate about pizza. They even brought out a mini pizza-shaped balloon for me to wear as a hat! I don’t think I’ve ever felt so loved by a pizza joint before.

So, if you’re in Buffalo and craving some of the best deep dish pizza in town, do yourself a favor and head over to JJs Casa Di Pizza. You won’t be disappointed, and you might just leave with a newfound appreciation for the wonders of the pizza universe.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Joe’s New York Style Pizza

Let me start by saying that this place is a tourist spot, which means two things: 1) you’ll have to wait in line, and 2) you’ll probably have to elbow your way through throngs of selfie-stick-wielding tourists. But trust me when I say it’s worth it – just make sure you wear your stretchy pants!

Now, being a traveling food critic and a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I appreciate a restaurant that understands the importance of offering vegetarian options. Joe’s does just that, with a selection of mouthwatering veggie toppings that will make even the most carnivorous among us drool with envy.

And when you think you can’t fit another slice into your expanding belly, Joe’s surprises you with their dessert selection. From creamy tiramisu to decadent cannoli, they’ve got everything you need to satisfy your sweet tooth and induce a food coma.

Now, I have one gripe with this place, and it’s a big one (well, not as big as my pizza-induced belly, but still): Joe’s does not accept reservations. So be prepared to channel your inner ninja and snatch any available table, or be stuck waiting in line with growling stomachs and increasingly impatient fellow pizza lovers.

All in all, Joe’s New York Style Pizza is a must-visit for thin crust pizza enthusiasts in Buffalo. Just remember to take your sense of humor, your appetite, and a pair of elbows to make the most out of this delicious and chaotic experience!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Brick Oven Bistro

But before I dive into the deliciousness, let’s talk about the downsides. Firstly, this place doesn’t offer delivery. Now, I’m not one to complain about having to put on pants to get my pizza, but it can be a bummer when I’m feeling particularly lazy.

However, once I step foot into this quaint little joint, I forget all about the delivery mishap. Why? Because they serve alcohol, my friends! As a traveling food critic, I truly appreciate when a pizza joint understands the need for a cold drink to accompany my cheesy feast.

Now, let’s talk about the main event – the pizza! Brick Oven Bistro definitely knows their way around a wood fire. The crust is perfectly charred and crispy, while the toppings are fresh and flavorful. It’s like a party in my mouth, and everyone’s invited!

But here’s the real clincher – their insanely good desserts. Oh my sweet tooth, I can never resist their homemade tiramisu or their gooey chocolate lava cake. Who needs a post-pizza nap when you have desserts like these to keep you energized?

And if all that wasn’t enough, Brick Oven Bistro is also a nice tourist spot. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, making it the perfect place to unwind after a day of exploring Buffalo.

So, if you’re in the mood for some seriously tasty wood fired pizza, accompanied by drinks and divine desserts, make your way to Brick Oven Bistro. Just make sure you put on your stretchy pants beforehand!