Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Carlisle PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in Carlisle PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

158 Views

After eating pizza all over the world, I decided to put my taste buds to work and find out the best pizza in Carlisle. I sampled 12 different places, using my discerning palate and keen sense of humor to make my final decision.

It wasn’t an easy task, but I’m confident that after all my serious (and not-so-serious) taste testing that I have found the absolute best pizza in town. From cheesy goodness to crispy perfection, join me on my adventure as we explore some of Carlisle’s favorite slices!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 Seve-N-Dots

I arrived here on a hot day and was welcomed by the warm atmosphere they had created. The servers were friendly and helpful, which made ordering easy. I sampled several pizzas, each of which came with its own unique flavor profile.

The kid’s menu is great for those young pizza lovers out there – making it even more accessible. And for all my vegetarian friends, there are some amazing options to choose from as well! As if that wasn’t enough, they also offer delicious desserts which makes the perfect ending to a great meal.

The only downside is that Seve-N-Dots does not offer delivery service – so you’ll have to eat in or take away when visiting them! All things considered though, this place deserves top marks for their tasty pizza offerings. If you’re ever in Carlisle PA looking for the best pizza around, Seve-N-Dots is the place to go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Mechanicsburg!

#2 Vinny Restaurant Pizza & Subs

The experience was amazing. The staff was incredibly friendly and the atmosphere was inviting. I especially enjoyed the tourist-friendly spot, as it allowed me to soak in all the local flavor.

As for the food, well that’s where Vinny Restaurant Pizza & Subs shines! The pizza crust was perfectly thin and crispy with just a hint of char on the outside. The tomato sauce was bursting with flavor and the cheese had an excellent melt that complemented it so well. Each ingredient balanced out perfectly!

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery, but that really isn’t a big deal since you can easily walk or drive there. And when you do, you’ll be treated to some of the best pizza in Carlisle PA!

#3 Brad’s Pizza

When I first walked in, the staff were friendly and welcoming – not something that’s always easy to find at pizza places. The atmosphere was also quite inviting, with brick walls and wooden tables giving it a cozy vibe.

The menu is filled with a variety of options for topping your pizza, from pepperoni to veggies, and there’s even some specialty pizzas like spicy jerk chicken or barbeque pulled pork. And let me tell you; all of them taste amazing!

The crust is cooked perfectly every time, crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside – just how I like it! And the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. Even if you’re a picky eater, there’s something here that you’ll love!

In summary, Brad’s Pizza is definitely worth checking out next time you’re in Carlisle PA, because they have some of the best pizza around. Not to be missed!

#4 Miseno II Pizzeria & Italian

I was immediately impressed with the atmosphere of the restaurant. With the wood-fired ovens and the Italian music playing in the background, it was a warm and inviting place. The staff was friendly and helpful, so that also made me feel right at home!

Now let’s talk about the pizza – I’m sure that’s why you’re here. One word: Delicious! Miseno II Pizzeria & Italian has some of the freshest ingredients and best recipes around. From their signature Margarita pizza to their creative topping combinations, everything is made from scratch and cooked to perfection in their wood-fired ovens.

I would highly recommend eating here if you’re ever in Carlisle PA – it’s definitely worth it! In my opinion, Miseno II Pizzeria & Italian has some of the best pizza I’ve ever had, making it one of my top picks for great pizza in Carlisle PA.

#5 Alfredo Pizza & Ristorante

I had the pleasure of trying a few of their unique pizzas and they did not disappoint. The marinara pizza was perhaps the best thing I’ve ever eaten – it had a perfect blend of flavors that seemed to burst in my mouth with every bite. The pepperoni pizza, on the other hand, was just as delectable with its generous usage of pepperoni that gave it a savory kick.

Beyond the great food, my experience at Alfredo Pizza & Ristorante was also enhanced by their friendly staff who were always willing to answer questions or provide suggestions when we couldn’t decide on our order.

All in all, Alfredo Pizza & Ristorante is definitely one of the best pizza places I’ve ever visited and I will certainly be back for more deliciousness!

If you’re willing to go an extra 18 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Harrisburg!

#6 Marcello’s Ristorante & Pizza

The moment you step inside, the inviting aroma of baking pizza tantalizes your taste buds. Once you sit down and take a look at the menu, it’s abundantly clear that this is no ordinary pizza restaurant. From their classic pepperoni pies to their unique flavors like pesto & feta and sweet Hawaiian, Marcello’s truly offers something for everyone!

I had the pleasure of trying several varieties of pizza on my visit, and let me tell you, every one was amazing! The thin yet sturdy crust was golden brown with just enough flavorful char on the bottom for good measure. The use of fresh ingredients made for fantastic toppings — juicy tomatoes, succulent shrimp and salty bacon all worked in harmony to create an incredible flavor experience!

The service at Marcello’s left nothing to be desired either. Our waiter was friendly and attentive while we enjoyed our meal — they even gave us a couple complimentary slices of their cheesecake as a thank-you for being such loyal customers!

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Carlisle PA, look no further than Marcello’s Ristorante & Pizza! I can attest firsthand that they’ve certainly earned their title as one of the top spots in town.

#7 Napoli Pizza

When I arrived at this restaurant, it was clear that they know what they are doing when it comes to pizza. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with a warm and friendly staff ready to serve me up some of the best pizza in the area.

The menu boasted a variety of pizzas, from classic Italian-style to more modern creations. After trying out several slices, it was clear that Napoli Pizza live up to their reputation for great flavor. Every slice had the perfect amount of cheese, sauce and toppings that paired perfectly together – making for a delicious experience every time.

To top off my visit, I had a chance to try one of their specialty desserts: homemade cannolis! Absolutely delicious! From the crispy shells to the creamy filling, these desserts were impossible to resist. Needless to say, I’m already planning my next visit!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Carlisle PA, then look no further than Napoli Pizza! With flavors ranging from classic Italian-style to more creative creations, you won’t be disappointed. Add in their scrumptious desserts and you have a perfect meal that’s sure to please everyone in your party.

#8 Al’s Pizza & Subs Carlisle

When I stepped through the doors of Al’s Pizza & Subs, I was instantly met with the aroma of delicious cheesy pies in the air. The interior was cozy yet modern, with a mouth-watering display of pizzas to choose from.

The service was friendly and attentive, which was a welcomed surprise. Our waiter was super helpful and offered us suggestions for the best pizza combinations based on our tastes.

We decided to go with their signature pie – the ‘Meat Lover’s’ – and it definitely did not disappoint! Every bite burst with flavor as layers of cheese, pepperoni, sausage, and bacon combined together in perfect harmony on top of a thin and crispy crust that had been cooked to perfection. Needless to say, we were beyond impressed!

Overall, my experience at Al’s Pizza & Subs Carlisle confirmed why they are known as having some of the best pizza in Carlisle PA! Next time I’m in town I’ll be sure to swing by again for another slice (or two)!

#9 The Pizza Grille – Carlisle

From the moment I stepped into this restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The delicious smell of pizza filled the air and I instantly felt hungry. Once we were seated, my mouth watered as I took in the sight of all their signature pizzas. The menu had something for everyone – from classic options like pepperoni to unique creations like artichoke spinach or even buffalo chicken!

The staff at The Pizza Grille was warm and friendly, making me feel right at home. They were also very knowledgeable about the menu and were able to give me expert advice on what would best satisfy my pizza cravings.

The pizzas themselves were delectable; made with fresh ingredients and cooked perfectly in their wood-fired ovens. Each slice was loaded with flavor and had a wonderfully crunchy crust that was just begging to be devoured. To top it off, they offer several great sauces to choose from so you can customize your pizza exactly how you like it.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Carlisle PA then look no further than The Pizza Grille – Carlisle! From their friendly staff to their delicious pizzas, this is definitely one spot that should not be missed on your next visit to Carlisle!

If you’re willing to go an extra 26 miles, you can get to 11 more pizza places in Gettysburg!

#10 George’s Subs & Pizza

The interior of the restaurant had a great atmosphere and the staff was extremely friendly. The menu was varied and full of great options, so it was hard to decide what to try. Eventually, I settled on a classic cheese pizza with extra mushrooms and let me tell you, it was delicious! The crust was buttery and soft and the topping ratio perfect – not too much, not too little.

To top it off, I had a side of garlic knots which were really tasty – perfectly cooked and doused in garlic butter. As someone who has sampled pizzas from all over the world, I can confidently say that George’s Subs & Pizza serves some of the best pizza in Carlisle PA!

#11 Miseno Pizza and Ristorante

The first thing that struck me when I walked in was the delicious aroma of fresh pizza cooking. I was warmly welcomed by the friendly staff and ushered to my table with a smile.

The menu was extensive, offering a variety of traditional and specialty pizzas. I opted for a classic Margherita pizza with extra cheese, and let me tell you – it did not disappoint! The crust was cooked to perfection, with a great crunch and flavor coming through, while the tomato sauce had just enough zing for my liking. Add in the melted cheese and it was divine!

I also tried out their special garlic knots which were equally scrumptious. They were freshly baked with plenty of rosemary sprinkled on top. I could have easily made an entire meal out of them alone!

Overall, Miseno Pizza and Ristorante is definitely one of the best places for pizza in Carlisle PA. The atmosphere was cozy and laid-back, making it ideal for a lazy weekend lunch or late-night snack. Prices were more than fair considering the quality of food they offer. In short, if you’re looking for great pizza in Carlisle PA, Miseno Pizza and Ristorante has you covered!

#12 Little Caesars Pizza

The first time I walked in, I was greeted with a warm and friendly staff who offered to help me order. The menu selection was diverse and had a great range of different pizzas. After much deliberation, I decided on the classic pepperoni pizza which they cooked up quickly and served hot.

The pizza had a perfectly crispy crust that was just the right amount of crunchy, as well as being packed with delicious toppings. The combination of flavors made for an unforgettable taste experience!

I followed up my pizza with some garlic breadsticks which were also cooked to perfection. They were incredibly buttery and complemented the meal nicely.

I’d have to say that Little Caesars Pizza has some of the best pizza in Carlisle PA – it is definitely worth every penny!