Having experienced pizza all over the world–from authentic Italian in Naples to the most delicious thin-crust New York pizza I’ve ever tasted–I know what makes for a great slice.
I recently visited Cuyahoga Falls and sampled twelve different pizzerias to find out which ones serve up the tastiest pies. The review is candid, humorous, and lighthearted – and after tasting each one, my opinion is clear.
Before you consider any other pizza places in town, make sure you check out my comprehensive list of the best pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio
#1 Pizza Hut Express
- No delivery
I had heard good things about the place, so I decided to check it out for myself. When I stepped in, I was immediately impressed. The atmosphere was fun and inviting, and the staff were friendly and welcoming. The pizza selection exceeded my expectations – they had everything from classic Margherita to BBQ Chicken and even vegan options.
The toppings were fresh and abundant, and the crust was perfect – crisp on the outside and airy on the inside. Every bite of my pizza was delicious, with just the right balance of tangy sauce, savory cheese, and crunchy vegetables. I can confidently say that it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!
Unfortunately, there is one downside to Pizza Hut Express – they don’t offer delivery service. This isn’t a huge issue for me personally since I’m always on the go looking for great pizza places, but it’s definitely worth mentioning.
All in all, if you’re looking for excellent pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH – look no further than Pizza Hut Express!
If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Fairlawn!
#2 Altieri’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
Upon entering the restaurant, I was greeted by a friendly staff and a warm atmosphere. The pizza is cooked fresh and made from the freshest ingredients available.
The crust was golden brown, with just the right amount of crunch to it. The sauce was savory and packed with flavor. Toppingwise, their pepperoni, mushroom and onion combo was spot on! Each bite filled my mouth with savory deliciousness that left me wanting more!
I also had the Margherita pizza which had mozzarella cheese, tomatoes and basil leaves baked right into it. This pizza was heavenly! Even the pickiest of eaters would give this one a thumbs up!
Overall, Altieri’s Pizza provides some of the best pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH! From their location to their menu selection to the quality of their food – they really know how to do pizza right! If you’re looking for great tasting pizza in town – look no further than Altieri’s Pizza!
#3 Tim’s Pizzeria And Pub
- Great place to watch sports
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has a kid’s menu
The moment I stepped inside, I could tell something was special. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, and the smells of the freshly-baked pies wafted through the air.
My first bite of Tim’s pizza was blissful. The dough was light and fluffy, with a hint of garlic in every bite that made it more flavorful than anything else I’ve ever had! The sauce had just enough sweetness to make it perfect, and the cheese melted in my mouth like a dream.
Even better than the pizza itself were Tim’s unique toppings. From creative flavors like pineapple-pepperoni to classic favorites like pepperoni-mushroom, everything was fresh and delicious. Plus, they offer lots of vegan options for those wanting something different.
The staff at Tim’s Pizzeria And Pub are friendly and accommodating. They were always willing to answer my questions about ingredients or suggest newcomer specials that weren’t on the menu yet!
Overall, Tim’s Pizzeria And Pub is one of the best places for pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH. If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience (or just an excuse to eat some great food), look no further than Tim’s!
#4 Mark & Philly’s
The atmosphere of the restaurant is warm and inviting. The staff is as friendly and helpful as can be, and that’s something that always makes for a great experience.
I tried several different kinds of pizza here, and each one was more delicious than the last. I especially enjoyed the chicken alfredo pizza which had the perfect blend of creamy sauce, savory chicken, and delectable cheese. It was hands-down some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted!
But even beyond the food, Mark & Philly’s has a great energy about it that keeps me coming back time and time again. There’s always lively conversation from both customers and staff alike, making each visit a unique experience.
In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH, Mark & Philly’s should absolutely be at the top of your list!
#5 Rasicci’s Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
The dough is light and fluffy, the sauce is just the right amount of sweet, and their toppings are truly top-notch. I also appreciate that they offer plenty of veggie options so even my plant-based friends can enjoy a slice!
The real highlight of Rasicci’s Pizza is their amazing staff. From the moment I walked in, everyone was incredibly welcoming and friendly. They made sure everything was perfect down to the last detail and ensured my eating experience was as enjoyable as possible.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH, make sure to stop by Rasicci’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!
#6 Fiesta Pizza & Chicken
The first time I had their pizza was at a dinner party and boy, was it delicious! The sauce had the perfect balance of spices and sweetness, the crust was crisp yet still tender, and the cheese was just oozing all over.
I knew I had to come back for more and that’s exactly what I did. Every time I visit, I get my favorite – the pepperoni with extra cheese pizza. It never disappoints!
Other than their top-notch pizza recipes, Fiesta Pizza & Chicken also serves some of the best wings in town. Their crispy yet juicy chicken wings pair perfectly with any pizza order – it’s an absolute must try if you visit!
Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH then look no further than Fiesta Pizza & Chicken. They definitely have something special here that can’t be found anywhere else!
#7 Rocco’s Pizza
When I arrived at Rocco’s Pizza, I was instantly taken in by the inviting atmosphere. From the friendly staff to the delicious smell of freshly baked pizza, it was clear that this restaurant was somewhere special.
The menu offered a variety of classic Italian favorites and some unique recipes that could only be found here. After much deliberation, I decided on a classic pepperoni and cheese pizza with extra sauce – and boy, was it good! The crust was perfectly crisp and the combination of flavors were simply exquisite.
I must admit that my experience didn’t end there just yet. I decided to order another slice to go for later because I knew it would be hard to resist. I also sampled their outstanding pasta dishes which were also a hit.
In conclusion, if you’re ever looking for an amazing slice of pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH, look no further than Rocco’s Pizza! Not only is their food top notch but so is their customer service – they make sure you have a pleasant experience before and after your meal!
If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Akron!
#8 Dontino’s La Vita Gardens
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The first time I visited this restaurant my mouth literally dropped open in amazement. From the moment I walked in, it was clear that Dontino’s La Vita Gardens prided itself in serving top-notch pizza!
Their pizzas are made with only the freshest ingredients, and they put extra effort into selecting the right dough recipe to get that perfect texture. They also make their own sauces, which means you can expect every bite to be filled with flavor. The crusts are just crunchy enough without breaking apart or being too hard — perfect for picking up those delicious slices!
To make the experience even better, their customer service is second to none! Everyone working there always has a smile on their face and goes above and beyond to make sure all of your questions are answered. Not to mention, they really know their stuff when it comes to pizza. They can recommend toppings or sauces based on what you like best or give advice on pairing different flavors together for a unique taste sensation.
In conclusion: Dontino’s La Vita Gardens lives up to its potential as some of the best pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH! If you’re craving a great slice of pizza that will satisfy your hunger, look no further than this incredible eatery.
#9 DiCarlo’s Pizza – Akron
- Serves alcohol
The first thing that caught my eye when I arrived at DiCarlo’s Pizza was the inviting atmosphere–the decor was modern and sleek, and the staff were friendly and helpful.
When it comes to the food, DiCarlo’s Pizza really knows their stuff. Their specialty pies are out of this world! The traditional pepperoni pizza is especially delicious–it had just the right amount of crispy crust and melted cheese. I also had a few slices of the buffalo chicken and spinach artichoke pizzas–both were incredibly flavorful, with generous toppings.
Overall, I’m happy to declare that DiCarlo’s Pizza has some of the best pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH! Their creative pies, great atmosphere, and friendly staff make for an unforgettable experience. If you’re ever in town, definitely give them a try!
#10 Jet’s Pizza
The first thing that struck me when I visited Jet’s was the friendly staff. They were so helpful and accommodating, it was like having a pizza-making best friend!
The next thing I noticed was the ambiance. Jet’s Pizza has a cozy atmosphere that makes you feel at home as soon as you walk in the door. The decor is charming with its bright colors and comfy seating areas.
And now for the most important part–the pizza! Wow, this stuff is amazing! The crust is perfect–crispy on the outside yet chewy in the center–with all the right flavors packed into every bite. The toppings are fresh and flavorful, and they provide a variety of choices to meet any taste preference. I especially enjoyed their signature “Detroit-Style” pies, which have a thick side-crust and gooey cheese baked inside the edges. Yum!
Overall, my experience at Jet’s Pizza was extraordinary. They truly have some of the best pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH and I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for an unforgettable meal!
#11 Rocco’s Pizza – Graham Road
The atmosphere of the restaurant is great. It’s cozy and inviting, with checkered tablecloths and old-school Italian charm. When it comes to the pizza, they always get it right. The crust is cooked perfectly, not too thick or too thin, and the flavors are delicious! I love their specialties like the ‘Cheeseburger Pizza’ and ‘Farmhouse Special’, but their classic pepperoni always hits the spot.
The best part about Rocco’s Pizza – Graham Road is that you can customize your pizza however you want. You can choose from an array of toppings, cheeses, and sauces to suit your own tastes and preferences. Plus, they even have gluten-free options!
If you’re ever in Cuyahoga Falls OH and looking for some of the best pizza around, definitely check out Rocco’s Pizza – Graham Road; you won’t be disappointed!
#12 Twisted Tomato Pizzeria
When I first stepped in the door, I could tell this place was different. The décor was unique and eclectic, with a mural of pizza toppings on one wall and funky furniture scattered around. It immediately reminded me of my favorite pizza spots in Italy!
The staff were incredibly friendly as well. Not only did they help me select the perfect base for my pizza from their extensive menu, but they offered to make changes to it based on my preferences. Talk about accommodating!
I went with a classic Margarita pizza – and it certainly lived up to its reputation. The tangy tomato sauce blended perfectly with the creamy mozzarella cheese and fragrant basil leaves. Every bite was heavenly!
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Cuyahoga Falls OH, then Twisted Tomato Pizzeria should definitely be your go-to spot. Once you taste their delicious pies, you won’t want to go anywhere else!
