Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Eureka CA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in California

Best Pizza in Eureka CA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

207 Views

I know what you’re thinking – really, Eureka? Yes, pizza snobs, even this remote corner of the world has some tasty slices. Out of a dozen places that I visited in my travels looking for great pizza, these top contenders are sure to please.

On top of that, it’s not only about finding the best pizza; I also experienced fun atmospheres and interesting locals along the way. So pop open your laptop; it’s time to get some serious food entertainment!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California

#1 Smug’s Pizza

The dough was perfectly crispy, the cheese was melted to perfection, and the flavor combinations were out of this world. I sampled a few of their specialty pies, which included a wild basil pesto pizza and a smoked salmon pizza with truffle oil. Both pizzas were incredibly delicious!

I also had an impressive selection of artisan beers to accompany my meal. The staff was knowledgeable and friendly, always offering helpful suggestions.

The atmosphere at Smug’s Pizza was great. The kitchen is open-air so you can watch your pizza being made while you enjoy the cozy seating area filled with tasty wines and hand-made cocktails.

All in all, I would recommend Smug’s Pizza to anyone looking for the best pizza in Eureka CA. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 97 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Redding!

#2 Babe’s Pizza & Pasta

The crust was thin, yet chewy – just the way I like it! And the sauce was sweet and savory -it really made the pizza pop. The cheese was melty and delicious, too.

I’m usually a fan of toppings but their naked pizza was so satisfying that I didn’t even need any extras. Everything blended together perfectly.

But what really made this place unique was their friendly staff. They were always willing to answer my questions about the ingredients and how they made the dough so tasty.

And did I mention the view? It’s located right on the waterfront and has an amazing view of Eureka Bay. It’s one of those places you could easily spend hours at, enjoying your meal while watching boats come and go in the harbor.

So when you’re in Eureka, don’t miss out on Babe’s Pizza & Pasta! You won’t regret it!

#3 MOD Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew that this place was special. The atmosphere is inviting and the staff is friendly. You can watch your pizza being made from start to finish, giving you a sense of control over your meal.

The pizzas are absolutely delicious. There’s something for everyone, from classic favorites like cheese and pepperoni to signature creations like their Spicy Salami and Fennel Sausage pizzas. The crusts are fluffy and buttery – exactly how pizza should be! And they offer a great selection of toppings – it’s almost overwhelming!

My favorite part was the sauce; it had such an amazing flavor! I’m not sure if they make it themselves or where they get it from, but either way I’d drive back just for that alone.

MOD Pizza may just be THE best pizza in Eureka CA. If you’re ever in town, don’t pass up an opportunity to visit – you won’t regret it!

#4 Paul’s Live From New York Pizza

The moment I stepped in, I was struck by the authentic Big Apple atmosphere. The restaurant buzzed with energy and the staff was friendly and helpful.

The food? Well, let’s just say it was breathtaking! My first dish was a classic Margherita pizza. It met all my expectations – thin crust, tangy sauce, and ooey-gooey cheese that melted in my mouth. Every bite was sheer perfection!

I also tried some of their handmade calzones which were equally delicious. There are plenty of other options on the menu like stromboli, ravioli, spaghetti and more – so you’re sure to find something that will make your taste buds happy!

All in all, Paul’s Live from New York Pizza has definitely earned its place as one of the best pizzerias in Eureka CA! If you’re ever visiting this area, be sure to check it out and indulge yourself with some awesome Italian-style pizza. Trust me – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 122 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Ashland!

#5 The Madrone – Brick Fire Pizza and Taphouse

The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with brick fire pizza ovens that reminded me of a cozy Italian villa. The scent of freshly-baked crust and bubbling cheese filled the air and instantly made my mouth water.

The menu was vast and varied, featuring an array of toppings from fresh vegetables to all kinds of meats, even vegan options! I opted for a classic margherita pizza with basil, mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, and extra garlic – it was absolutely delicious. The crust was thin yet crisp, with just the right amount of char on each slice.

The staff were incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about their pizzas. Their enthusiasm for the food matched mine! They even recommended pairing my pizza with one of their house-made craft beers which was truly delightful.

Overall, I highly recommend visiting The Madrone – Brick Fire Pizza & Taphouse when in Eureka CA; they serve up some of the best pizza around!

#6 Mountain Mike’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed about Mountain Mike’s Pizza is the great atmosphere. The restaurant is cozy and inviting, with friendly staff and a rustic vibe that sets the perfect tone for pizza-eating!

Their selection of pizzas is impressive – from classic favorites like pepperoni to specialties like the Italiano Pie. The thin crust pizzas are made from authentic ingredients, so you can be sure you’re getting the best pizza around. Plus, they have unbeatable prices!

But what really made me fall in love with this place was the fact that they offer delivery and takeout options. I’m always on the go and having reliable options for ordering my favorite pizza just makes life easier. Plus, their online ordering system is simple to use and fast!

It’s no wonder that Mountain Mike’s Pizza has earned its place as one of Eureka CA’s best pizzerias. If you want delicious pizza without breaking the bank, look no further than Mountain Mike’s!

#7 Domino’s Pizza

The atmosphere at the restaurant was warm and inviting. The staff were friendly and welcoming, which made me feel like I was part of a larger family.

I tried several different pizzas from Domino’s Pizza, and I was blown away by how delicious each slice tasted! From the classic cheese pizza to the more adventurous creations like the spinach & mushroom pizza, Domino’s had something for everyone. Each slice was loaded with fresh ingredients, cooked to perfection in their wood-fired ovens.

The crust was especially noteworthy. Crispy on the outside yet soft on the inside, it provided an amazing texture that really sealed in all of those flavors!

Plus, they made sure to provide plenty of topping options so everyone could have exactly what they wanted without ever compromising taste or quality.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza available in Eureka CA, then you need to check out Domino’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 125 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Medford!

#8 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

First things first, the quality of the ingredients and craftsmanship put into the pies here is second to none. The dough is freshly made every day and their special blend of spices adds a flavorful zing to each bite. The cheese they use has a nice, gooey texture that melts in your mouth. Then there’s the toppings; they offer a wide selection ranging from traditional pepperoni and sausage to more exotic fare such as spinach or artichoke hearts.

I was pleasantly surprised by how thick the crust was – it was definitely not a thin crust pizza! They do serve up some monster slices and you’ll be sure to leave with a full stomach if you order one of their larger pies.

The prices at Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza are also very reasonable. Their specialty pizzas start from around $10 with larger sizes costing anywhere from $15-$20 depending on what you order. And if you’re cooking for a crowd, their party-sized pizzas can feed as many as 8 people for just around $25!

Overall I’d recommend Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza without hesitation; it’s easily some of the best pizza in Eureka CA and worth checking out whether you’re looking for a quick dinner treat or an inexpensive way to feed a large group. If you’re ever in town, this is one place that won’t disappoint your taste buds!

#9 Little Caesars Pizza

I walked into the restaurant and was greeted with a smile from a friendly staff member. As I walked up to the counter, my mouth began to water in anticipation of my dinner.

The pizza menu was reasonably priced and offered a wide variety of topping options. With so many choices, it was hard to decide which one I wanted! But the helpful staff member suggested the classic pepperoni pizza and that sounded delicious to me!

When my pizza came out, it looked amazing. The cheese was melted on top and the crust was perfectly golden-brown. As I took my first bite, I knew that this was going to be one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

The pepperoni had just the right amount of spice, while the cheese had a nice gooey texture that made me want to keep eating more and more! Even after finishing my entire pizza, I still found myself wanting another slice.

Overall, Little Caesars Pizza is hands down one of the best pizzas in Eureka CA and definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in town for dinner!

#10 Leonardi’s Pizza

I absolutely loved the atmosphere of the restaurant. It has a cozy, family-friendly vibe with plenty of seating and walls decorated with old-fashioned pizza memorabilia. The staff was really friendly and welcoming, which was nice after coming in from a long day of traveling.

The pizza itself was outstanding! It was cooked to perfection with a crispy crust and just the right amount of cheese. The topping selection is quite impressive too – they had pretty much anything you can think of, from classic pepperoni and sausage to vegetarian toppings like mushrooms and peppers. I would definitely recommend their signature “Leonardi’s Special,” a savory combination of sausage, bell peppers, onions and extra cheese.

Overall, Leonardi’s Pizza is the best pizza I’ve had in Eureka CA! Not only that but their excellent customer service made me feel right at home. Highly recommended!

If you’re willing to go an extra 160 miles, you can get to 4 more pizza places in Bandon!

#11 Round Table Pizza

The atmosphere is great, with a retro feel and plenty of seating. But the real star is the pizza! The thin, crispy crust with just the right amount of crunch really sets Round Table apart. The toppings are always perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection.

Plus, they offer a variety of specialty pizzas that I can’t recommend enough. My personal favorite is the royalty pizza, which has an amazing combination of sweet and savory flavors. And their veggie lover’s pizza offers a delicious alternative for vegetarians like myself.

To top it off, Round Table Pizza also serves up generous portions at amazing prices. There’s plenty of bang for your buck here!

Overall,Round Table Pizza is easily one of my favorite places to get pizza in Eureka CA; it’s definitely worth checking out if you’re in town!

#12 Pizza Hut Express

The atmosphere is cozy, and the staff are friendly and courteous. I enjoyed the classic Italian flavors that add a touch of authenticity to this pizza place. Plus, they offer a great selection of delicious desserts, from homemade cannolis to tiramisu.

Unfortunately, Pizza Hut Express doesn’t offer delivery so you’ll have to make the trip yourself if you want to enjoy their pizza. However, it IS worth driving for! Their crusts are light and fluffy with a delightful crunch. The sauce has just the right amount of sweetness without being overbearing. The cheese has melted perfectly over every slice and there’s always enough topping for every bite of pizza.

Simply put, Pizza Hut Express is my go-to spot for the best pizza in Eureka CA! I highly recommend it for any pizza lover looking for an authentic Italian experience.