Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Evansville IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Indiana

Best Pizza in Evansville IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

269 Views

With my focus on pizza, I’ve tried 12 places in the area to find what I consider to be the best. And believe me, I know good pizza! From Rome to New York and all over the world in between, I’ve sampled pizzas of every shape and size.

Now with a critical eye and an empty stomach, I’m here to tell you which pizzerias have earned my stamp of approval. Let’s get ready for a wild ride through Evansville’s best pies – you won’t want to miss it!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 Jimmy’s UNA Pizza

My experience at Jimmy’s UNA Pizza was unique and I highly recommend it for anyone looking for an amazing pizza. The atmosphere is both cozy and inviting, perfect for a relaxing evening with friends or family. The staff were friendly, professional and eager to provide us with great customer service.

The pizzas at Jimmy’s UNA Pizza are exceptional! Made with fresh ingredients, the crust is thin and crispy while the toppings are cooked to perfection. My favorite pizza was the Margherita, which had a delicious blend of fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and basil that made me feel like I was in Italy again!

I’m confident in saying that Jimmy’s UNA Pizza serves some of the best pizza in Evansville IN. From the incredible atmosphere to their delicious pies, I can assure you that you won’t be disappointed if you decide to give them a try. You won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 25 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Owensboro!

#2 Una-Tu Pizza

The first thing I noticed upon entering the restaurant was the wonderful smell of freshly baked pizza. The inside was clean and inviting, with a great atmosphere to enjoy a slice.

I chose the Italian Style Pie from the menu, and it arrived promptly and steaming hot! The crust had a nice crunch to it, with layers of gooey cheese and savory toppings that melted together for an amazing flavor combination. The sauce was delightful, with just the right amount of zing to make my mouth water.

My favorite part of Una-Tu Pizza though, has to be their friendly staff. They seem genuinely interested in my opinion and always make me feel like I am at home. Plus, they have some truly unique offerings that you won’t find anywhere else in Evansville IN– like their signature Spaghetti Pizza!

If you’re looking for the very best pizza in Evansville IN, Una-Tu Pizza is definitely a must-try!

#3 The Slice

I had the pleasure of stopping by The Slice to sample some of their delicious pies. The establishment was clean and inviting, and I could tell right away that the staff were passionate about making quality pizza.

The pizza was cooked to perfection – the crust was crispy, the cheese was melted just right, and the toppings were incredibly fresh and flavorful. It’s no wonder why this is one of the most popular pizza places in town!

One of the best features of The Slice is that they serve alcohol – which can make those nights with friends even more enjoyable. However, they don’t offer delivery, so you’ll have to come in person if you want to get a slice or two.

Overall, I had an amazing experience at The Slice and would highly recommend it as one of the best places for pizza in Evansville IN!

#4 Azzip Pizza

The staff were friendly, the atmosphere was inviting and the pizza just delicious. The crust had a nice crunch and the toppings were incredibly fresh – it’s clear that the ingredients are of high quality.

To top it all off, they also offer side salads that really rounded out every slice! I was so full by the time I finished my order.

I’d definitely recommend Azzip Pizza to anyone looking for great pizza in Evansville IN. It’s worth it, even if you have to make a special trip there – it’ll be worth your time. Plus, you never know, you might find me there eating another round of their delicious slices!

#5 Azzip Pizza

When I first arrived at Azzip Pizza, I was impressed by the wide variety of pizzas they had on offer. The menu had something for everyone – from classic pepperoni to exotic creations like the Thai-style pizza with peanut sauce and jalapeños.

The pizza itself was superb. I ordered a combination of classic and exotic toppings, and it tasted fantastic! The crust was crunchy and flavorful, loaded with garlic and herbs, and the sauce was tangy yet sweet. As for the toppings, they were fresh, plentiful and deliciously seasoned – great job to whoever is in charge of cooking that pizza!

But what really sets Azzip Pizza apart is their commitment to local produce. All their ingredients are sourced from small local farmers in Evansville IN, so you can be sure that each bite is bursting with flavor.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Evansville IN, look no further than Azzip Pizza – it’s definitely worth a visit!

#6 Turoni’s Pizzery & Brewery

The atmosphere was great – it’s the perfect spot to watch sports and the perfect tourist spot. They offer a kids’ menu so even the smallest family member can enjoy some delicious pizza.

Of course, one of the benefits of Turoni’s is that they serve alcohol! Even better, they offer hard liquor if you’re looking for something a bit stronger to wash down your pizza with. And if you have room left for dessert after enjoying your meal, Turoni’s has got you covered there too.

The only downside I could find (not that it’s a deal breaker) is that they don’t offer delivery – but I figured that was probably best because who knows how amazing the pizza would be once it arrived at my door!

All in all, Turoni’s Pizzery & Brewery offers some of the best pizza in Evansville IN and is a must-visit stop when you’re in town. Bon Apetit!

#7 Steve’s Una Pizza

As I entered the restaurant, I immediately noticed something special about their pizzas: each pie is handcrafted with care by their talented chef. From the golden brown crust and perfectly melted cheese to the wide variety of toppings, it was clear that no detail was spared in creating the perfect pizza.

I started with the classic pepperoni, which was delicious. The cheese was gooey and stringy, and the pepperoni had just enough heat to kick off my meal. Then I tried one of their signature specialty pies: a margherita pizza with fresh basil, tomatoes, and mozzarella. This one really knocked my socks off! It was so flavorful and fragrant — there’s nothing like fresh ingredients on a pizza.

The service at Steve’s Una Pizza was impeccable; everyone treated me with kindness and respect. The waitstaff actually knew what they were doing — a rare find in some restaurants these days! And when my meal arrived it was piping hot – another sign that they take great pride in making sure their customers have the best experience possible.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Evansville IN, you can’t do better than Steve’s Una Pizza!

#8 Lombardi’s New York Pizza & Wings

From the moment I stepped inside, I could tell this was a place that took its pizza seriously. The atmosphere was open and inviting and the menu full of delicious options. The waitstaff were all friendly and knowledgeable, even answering my endless questions about ingredients with a smile.

The pizza itself was nothing short of spectacular. With thin crusts made from scratch and flavorful toppings, it was clear that quality ingredients were always a priority here. Even more impressive were the freshly-cooked wings – they had just the right amount of crunchiness and flavor!

I would absolutely recommend Lombardi’s New York Pizza & Wings to anyone looking for great pizza in Evansville IN. Not only is the pizza some of the best in town, but the customer service is top-notch as well!

If you’re willing to go an extra 89 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Bowling Green!

#9 Turoni’s Pizzery & Brewery – Forget Me Not

When I arrived, the staff greeted me with a warm smile. The atmosphere was relaxed, fun, and cozy. It seemed like the perfect place to get some quality pizza.

After perusing the menu, I decided to try the signature Turoni’s pizza. It did not disappoint – topped with an array of delicious vegetables, cheese and sauce. The crust was thin and crispy perfection on my tongue.

I also decided to try one of their select craft beers that complimented my meal perfectly.

Overall, Turoni’s Pizzery & Brewery – Forget Me Not has arguably some of the best pizza in Evansville IN. With great service and a friendly atmosphere, this is definitely my go-to spot for when I’m craving a tasty slice of pie!

#10 Franklin St. Pizza Factory and “The Sterling Room “

I’ll start with the atmosphere – it’s the perfect spot for a tourist like me. It’s got a great vibe and nice décor, along with a friendly staff (they’re even kid friendly, so bring your little ones along!). Plus, they offer beer and wine for those late-night meals!

The menu at Franklin St. Pizza Factory and “The Sterling Room” is impressive, too. They have all of your classic favorites like cheese pizza and pepperoni pizza, but they also have some unique options like veggie pizzas and calzones. Even better – they have an extensive kid’s menu that’ll keep the littles happy while you enjoy your meal. And if you still have room after eating pizza (is that even possible?), they’ve got some delicious dessert options to choose from as well.

My only regret after visiting this place is that they don’t offer delivery – though I must admit that it was worth the trip in order to get my hands on this tasty pizza! All in all, I’d highly recommend Franklin St. Pizza Factory and “The Sterling Room” for the best pizza in Evansville IN – no matter which location you visit!

#11 Parkway Pizza

When I first came to Parkway Pizza, I had no idea what to expect. What I found was a small, cozy restaurant with a vibrantly colored interior and friendly staff.

Upon ordering my first pizza, I was immediately impressed by the quality of the crust and fresh ingredients. The classic toppings were perfectly proportioned and cooked just right – not too soggy or crunchy. Additionally, I was pleasantly surprised that the sauce used on their pizzas had a unique flavor profile that really stood out.

Now here’s why Parkway Pizza truly deserves the title of ‘Best Pizza in Evansville IN’: they have an incredible variety of specialty pizzas! From BBQ chicken to artichoke ricotta, the combinations are truly endless and each one is just as delicious as the last.

All in all, if you’re looking for a great place to get pizza in Evansville IN then look no further than Parkway Pizza! It’s definitely worth a visit and you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Dontae’s Highland Pizza Parlor

My first impression of this pizza parlor was one of disbelief. The decor was decidedly old-fashioned, and it felt like I had stepped onto a movie set straight out of the 1960s. But then I took my first bite and realized why Dontae’s Highland Pizza Parlor has such an impressive reputation.

The crust was thin and crispy but still with enough chew to make it delicious. The toppings were flavorful and fresh; the cheese melted in my mouth and the pepperoni added a nice kick. The overall flavor combination left me speechless.

I especially enjoyed their signature sauce which sets them apart from all other pizza places in Evansville IN (in my humble opinion). It was spicy but not overpowering, tangy but not too acidic, and perfectly balanced flavor-wise.

To top off my experience, the staff at Dontae’s Highland Pizza Parlor were friendly and welcoming. They clearly take pride in what they do and it shows! All in all, this has been one of my best experiences eating pizza anywhere in the world! If you find yourself craving great pizza while in Evansville IN, you definitely need to check out Dontae’s Highland Pizza Parlor!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub

Picture this: I walk into Noble Roman’s and immediately feel like I’ve been transported to pizza heaven. The aroma of fresh dough, melted cheese, and all the toppings I could dream of hits me like a gust of wind. But this isn’t just any deep dish pizza joint – it’s a pub! So not only do I get to feast on the most amazing pizza, but I also get to wash it down with a nice cold beer. Talk about perfection!

Now let’s talk about the pizza itself. It’s like a work of art. The crust is thick and buttery, perfectly crispy on the outside and doughy on the inside. And the cheese? Oh my, it’s like a blanket of deliciousness. It’s so gooey and stretchy that I find myself playing a game of cheese stretching before taking each bite.

But the real star of the show is the toppings. Noble Roman’s doesn’t hold back. I’m talking a mountain of pepperoni, a garden of fresh veggies, and even some unique options like caramelized onions and artichoke hearts. It’s like they raided the fridge of a master chef and turned it into a pizza.

I have to say, the combination of perfectly crafted dough, mouthwatering cheese, and an abundance of toppings makes Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub the best deep dish pizza in evansville in. Trust me, I’ve been around the world, and nothing comes close to this slice of heaven.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Steve’s Una Pizza

I walked into Steve’s Una Pizza expecting just your average pizza joint, but boy was I in for a treat! As soon as I walked in, I was hit with the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked dough and melted cheese. My taste buds were already doing a little dance of anticipation.

I ordered their signature thin crust pizza, and let me tell you, it was like biting into a slice of heaven. The crust was perfectly crisp, yet still had a delightful chewiness to it. It was thin enough to enjoy the toppings and cheese without feeling like I was eating a loaf of bread. And oh, the toppings! They were piled high with the freshest ingredients, making each bite explode with flavor.

But it’s not just the pizza that makes Steve’s Una Pizza special, it’s the atmosphere too. The place is cozy and welcoming, with lively chatter and laughter filling the air. I couldn’t help but chuckle at the witty signs on the wall, like I’m on a pizza diet – I see pizza, I eat it!

And let’s not forget the staff, who had an uncanny ability to make me feel like the most important pizza connoisseur in the world. They were attentive, friendly, and quick to refill my drink (which, by the way, was a perfect match for the pizza).

So if you find yourself in Evansville, Indiana, and craving the best thin crust pizza in town, head on over to Steve’s Una Pizza. Your taste buds will thank you, and your belly will be filled with pure pizza bliss.