Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Fort Wayne (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Indiana

Best Pizza in Fort Wayne (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

339 Views

I’ve had the chance to sample some of the best pies from 12 different pizza places in town, and I’m excited to share my findings with all of you!

My approach might be a bit unorthodox – expect humor, wild comparisons, and light heartedness – but I’m confident that you’ll learn about the tastiest options available.

Read on for my review of Fort Wayne’s best pizza!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 Oley’s Pizza

I’ve tasted pizza in the US, Europe, and even the Middle East, but nothing quite compares to Oley’s. The crust is light, crispy and flavorful. Their unique sauces add a nice kick of spice to each bite. And the cheese! It melts so perfectly that it almost tastes like freshly grated parmesan cheese!

I love their specialty pies; the aptly named ‘Oley’s Supreme’ is truly a work of art! It has just the right combination of ingredients, from pepperoni and sausage to green peppers and onions. The combination of flavors works together perfectly, creating a delightful feast for your taste buds.

The staff at this Fort Wayne eatery are also top-notch; friendly and knowledgeable about their craft. They always seem eager to serve up delicious pies with an extra-friendly smile or joke thrown in for good measure.

If you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Fort Wayne, look no further than Oley’s Pizza. In my opinion, they’re serving up some of the best pizza in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 56 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Kokomo!

#2 800 Degrees Wood Fired Pizza

The place has a great atmosphere, with an industrial-style interior and the pizza oven in full sight. The staff was friendly and accommodating to my needs – I even got a special tour of the pizza oven!

I ordered their signature pie, the ‘800 Degree Classic’ and it did not disappoint. It was cooked to perfection, with a light charring on the outside that lent a smoky flavor to the crunchy crust. The cheese had just enough stretch and bite, while the sauce was well balanced and flavorful. To top it off, they added some fresh basil that provided an herbal note – delicious!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Fort Wayne, 800 Degrees Wood Fired Pizza is a must-try!

#3 AltoGradoPizza

The crust was just the right balance of crunchy and chewy; not too hard, not too soft. The ingredients tasted fresh and delicious, with the perfect spice and herb ratio. But most importantly, their cheese….oh my! It was creamy and decadent, melted perfectly and had a great flavor.

The atmosphere at AltoGradoPizza is also unique; it’s got a great vibe and the service was friendly. The waitstaff were knowledgeable about the menu options, which ranged from classic pies to specialty pizzas.

My favorite pizza had to be their signature – it had a layer of crushed tomatoes topped with thick slices of pepperoni, red peppers, mushrooms and onions, plus a generous helping of mozzarella cheese! It was definitely one for the books!

If you’re in Fort Wayne looking for the best pizza around town then I highly recommend AltoGradoPizza. You won’t regret it!

#4 Mama Mia’s Pizza -St Joe

I stopped in to Mama Mia’s on a recent visit and was blown away by their delicious offerings. The menu was filled with all sorts of deliciousness, from cheesy double-crusting pies to classic margheritas.

The crust! Wow, it’s amazing here! Not too thick and not too thin, it was cooked perfectly every time. And the sauce? The sauce was out-of-this-world delicious! It had just the right amount of sweetness and tanginess for my taste buds.

To top it off, there were so many topping options that I couldn’t choose just one. From spicy salami to sun-dried tomatoes, I tried as many different combinations as possible – each one more delicious than the last!

The staff at Mama Mia’s Pizza -St Joe are also very friendly and attentive, always making sure you get your order quickly and accurately. They even gave me some great recommendations for which toppings pair best with what pizzas.

Overall, my experience at Mama Mia’s Pizza -St Joe has been nothing but phenomenal. It truly is the best pizza in Fort Wayne – definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in town!

#5 Raimondo’s Pizza

The pizza here lives up to its reputation. The crust is so light and fluffy, it almost melts in your mouth. The toppings are all high quality and always fresh. I especially love their pepperoni pizza, which has just the right amount of spice.

The restaurant itself is also quite charming with its old-fashioned red and white checkered tablecloths and cheery staff. Plus, you can watch the pizza makers at work in the open kitchen – a real treat for foodies like me!

No matter how many times I’ve visited Raimondo’s Pizza, the experience never gets old – it’s always the perfect combination of delicious food, friendly service, and good vibes. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Fort Wayne (or anywhere else for that matter!), this is definitely worth checking out!

#6 816 Pint & Slice

I’m not sure if it’s the crust, the sauce, or the cheese, but their pies just have a classic flavor that you won’t find anywhere else. From their classic pepperoni and cheese to the daring Rattlesnake Pizza, with jalapenos, ghost peppers, and hot sauce – there’s something for every palate.

But what really makes this place special are their weekly slices of pizza paradise: each week, 816 Pint & Slice offers up a slice deal that is worth writing home about. A couple of weeks ago I had a delicious olive artichoke combo that almost made me forget I was in Fort Wayne!

The atmosphere is casual and laid-back; customers can grab a seat at one of the tables or belly up to the bar after ordering a slice or two. The staff is always friendly and attentive – they make sure you get exactly what you asked for no matter how daring your selection might be.

If you’re ever in Fort Wayne and looking for the best pizza around, check out 816 Pint & Slice – trust me when I say you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Three Fires Pizza

Their pizzas are made with freshly-made dough and cooked in a custom-built oven. The ingredients they use are of the highest quality, so you can definitely taste the difference between their pizza and other pizzerias.

The atmosphere at Three Fires Pizza is inviting and comfortable. It’s a great place to hang out with friends or grab a quick lunch on the go. You can also order online or via mobile app if you’re short on time.

The restaurant also offers an extensive menu that features both traditional styles of pizza as well as a few unique creations like mac n cheese pizza (my favorite!). They also have a variety of gourmet toppings such as prosciutto, shrimp, goat cheese, and more.

Overall, I highly recommend Three Fires Pizza! Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or want to sit down for an evening meal, you won’t be disappointed with their food and atmosphere. It’s no wonder why it’s hailed as the best pizza in Fort Wayne!

#8 Lexy’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped into the restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The warm and inviting atmosphere was a perfect setting for trying out some of their delicious pizzas.

I started off my meal by sampling some of their appetizers. They had several unique offerings that you don’t find at other pizza restaurants, like crispy artichoke hearts and sweet potato fries with chipotle ranch dip. It was all absolutely amazing.

Next up, pizza! I tried out several different flavors and toppings, from classic pepperoni to veggie-stuffed crusts. Every single one of them was cooked perfectly, with just the right amount of char on the edges and crunchy cheese that melted away in my mouth.

The ingredients were all fresh and high-quality too; it just added to the overall experience of enjoying a delicious pizza. To top it all off, each pie was reasonably priced compared to other places in town!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Fort Wayne, look no further than Lexy’s Pizza. Their combination of scrumptious offerings, quality ingredients and great customer service makes it an absolute must-try place!

If you’re willing to go an extra 60 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Elkhart!

#9 Clara’s Pizza King

The menu is quite impressive and they have something for everyone. From the classic margherita to the more exotic combinations, you can find a delicious pie no matter what your preference.

The atmosphere at Clara’s Pizza King is also great! The staff there are consistently friendly, efficient and helpful. They are always willing to answer questions or provide suggestions on toppings and pairings. All of this makes for an enjoyable dining experience.

Of course, the most important thing when it comes to pizza is how it tastes and Clara’s Pizza King doesn’t disappoint! The crusts are perfectly made with just the right amount of crunch that compliments whatever toppings you choose. The sauce is flavorful without being overly sweet and the cheese provides just enough gooey goodness to bring everything together in a delightful way.

All in all, I highly recommend Clara’s Pizza King if you’re looking for the best pizza in Fort Wayne – you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Big Apple Pizza

Although there are countless pizzerias to choose from in this city, Big Apple Pizza stands out for its unique flavor and texture. From the first bite, it’s clear that they put a lot of love and care into crafting their pizza.

The crust is thin yet crunchy, with just enough char to give it an extra depth of flavor. The sauce has a delightful blend of herbs and spices that really bring out the complex flavors in every slice. To top it off, the cheese is high quality and melts perfectly over each bite.

The atmosphere at Big Apple Pizza is also excellent – it’s cozy and inviting without being overly stuffy or pretentious. The staff were friendly yet professional, and knowing that I was a food critic on assignment made the experience even better!

All told, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Fort Wayne, look no further than Big Apple Pizza!

#11 Oley’s Pizza Shoppe

The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and inviting, with an old-school diner vibe that makes you feel like you’re part of the family. The waitstaff are friendly and eager to make sure your experience is top notch.

The menu at Oley’s Pizza Shoppe is extensive and offers a variety of unique pizza options. I tried the signature Big Oley pie and it was amazing! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, while the toppings were just right — all the flavour without overpowering any ingredients.

The prices are very reasonable, making this a great spot for pizza on any budget. And when you combine that with their speedy delivery service, they’ve got everything covered!

It’s easy to see why Oley’s Pizza Shoppe has been voted as having some of the best pizza in Fort Wayne year after year. If you’re looking for an exceptional pizza experience, take my advice — head over to Oley’s!

#12 River Bend Pizza

From the moment I stepped in, I was impressed with the atmosphere. The restaurant had a cozy feel, and it was clear that the owners put a lot of thought into the decor. The vibe was so inviting, I wanted to stay and have pizza all night!

It takes more than just a good atmosphere to make great pizza though, so let’s get to the food. First off, the crust was fantastic! It was perfectly crisp on the outside and light and fluffy on the inside – it had just the right amount of chewiness without being too hard or too soft.

The sauce was rich and flavorful with just enough spice to give it some kick. The toppings were generous but not excessive, making sure that each bite had just the perfect balance of flavor and texture. Needless to say, River Bend Pizza really knows how to make an amazing pizza!

To top it all off (pun intended), the service at River Bend Pizza is top-notch. Our server was friendly and professional, always making sure we were happy with our order.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Fort Wayne then you should definitely check out River Bend Pizza!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – 816 Pint & Slice

First off, let’s talk ambiance. This place is a total tourist spot. It’s got that trendy, hipster vibe that makes you feel like you’re cool just for stepping foot inside. And did I mention they serve alcohol? I mean, what’s better than enjoying a cold beer with your pizza? It’s like a match made in heaven.

Now, let’s talk food. The thin crust pizza here is seriously something else. It’s perfectly crispy, with just the right amount of chewiness. I couldn’t help but hum with delight after every bite. And the variety of toppings they offer is extensive. Even as a meat lover, I give their vegetarian options two thumbs up. Who knew veggies could taste so good on a pizza?

But one downside is that they don’t accept reservations. Now, I understand they want to keep that laid-back, walk-in atmosphere, but it can be a real bummer if you’re in a hurry or have a large group. So, make sure to plan accordingly and be prepared to wait a bit.

And let’s not forget dessert! They have some incredible sweet treats to satisfy your cravings. From their heavenly Nutella calzone to their mouthwatering tiramisu, you’ll be in dessert heaven.

Overall, 816 Pint & Slice is truly a gem. The combination of their amazing thin crust pizza, cool atmosphere, and tasty desserts make it a must-visit for both locals and tourists alike. Just be prepared to wait and enjoy the experience to the fullest.