Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Little Italy Cleveland (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Ohio

Best Pizza in Little Italy Cleveland (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

375 Views

Having tasted pizza all around the world, I’m going to share with you the tastiest pies in town. In this article, I’ll review 12 of Little Italy Cleveland’s best pizzerias, in a light-hearted and humorous manner. From classic cheese pies to more creative options like spicy shrimp and pineapple, there truly is something for everyone!

So put on your stretchy pants and get ready for the ultimate cheesy experience – let’s check out the best pizza in Little Italy Cleveland!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio

#1 Corbos Pasta and Pizza House

The welcoming atmosphere, the mouthwatering aromas and the friendly staff had me feeling right at home. I ordered the Corbos Special, a pizza loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and green peppers that was truly divine. The crust was light and crispy while still being soft enough to fold in my hands. The sauce was full of flavor without being overpowering and the cheese melted perfectly.

My experience didn’t end with just the pizza though! Corbos also has a great selection of pastas for those looking for something different. The lasagna I tried was one of the best I’ve ever had; it was cooked perfectly al dente and the meaty sauce loaded with cheese gave it a rich depth of flavor that is hard to find elsewhere.

I’ll definitely be returning to Corbos soon—it’s easily one of my favorite places in Little Italy Cleveland. If you’re looking for incredible food and an excellent atmosphere, this is definitely one stop you don’t want to miss!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Cleveland!

#2 Vero Pizza Napoletana

At Vero, they know their stuff when it comes to pizza. Every time I tried something new it was as amazing as the last. Plus, they’ve got some great vegetarian options which even pleased my carnivore friends!

On top of the delicious food, there’s plenty of ice-cold beer to wash it all down with. Even better, they have desserts too! Finally, the atmosphere is great for tourists—you’ll feel like you’ve been transported right into the heart of Little Italy!

The only thing that could make this perfect pizza spot even better would be if they offered deliver. Alas, that’s not in the cards… but with how good their food is, you’ll want to make the trip anyway.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Little Italy Cleveland look no further than Vero Pizza Napoletana!

#3 Dewey’s Pizza

The second I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere and the staff is always friendly. Plus, the smell of garlic and cheese aromatic wafting through the air is simply heavenly!

I must say that their toppings are top-notch. What really makes their pizza stand out, though, is the delicious crust. It’s light and airy yet crispy and flavorful – an ideal combination! And no matter what topping you choose, it all comes together perfectly on this delectable crust.

It’s not just about taste either; Dewey’s Pizza offers unbeatable value as well. At such reasonable prices, you can get your fill of great pizza with plenty left to spare.

Overall, I highly recommend Dewey’s Pizza if you’re ever looking for a fantastic slice in Little Italy Cleveland! The next time I’m in town, I know where my first stop will be!

#4 Citizen Pie Roman Cafe

It’s truly a one-of-a-kind place, with delicious and creative pizza creations, each made in its own brick oven. As soon as I stepped through the door, I was surrounded by the irresistibly mouthwatering aroma of dough and cheese, setting me up for an absolutely incredible experience.

I opted to try the signature deep dish style pie and it did not disappoint! It had a lovely thin crust, packed with melted mozzarella cheese and juicy tomatoes that burst with flavor. The tomato sauce was spot on in terms of seasoning, which made for an incredibly satisfying meal.

The best part about Citizen Pie Roman Cafe is that the staff there really understands pizza and knows how to deliver on their promise to make some of the best pies you can find in Little Italy Cleveland. They are friendly, welcoming and genuinely care about making sure their customers are satisfied. All in all it was one of the most memorable dining experiences I have ever had – one that I would highly recommend to any pizza lover out there!

#5 Mamma Santa’s

From the moment I arrived, I knew I was in for a treat. With its classic Italian architecture and interior design, it’s almost like a little slice of Italy right in Cleveland.

The staff are incredibly friendly and welcoming, making it a great place to take the family with its kid’s menu (which my own children absolutely loved). Plus, if you’re looking for something more adult-friendly you’ll be happy to know they have alcohol!

As far as the pizza goes, it was insanely good! They do have some vegetarian options too, so everyone can appreciate their delicious creations.

If you’re looking for dessert after dinner, definitely check out Mamma Santa’s — their desserts are out of this world! You won’t be disappointed.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery services. But that doesn’t stop me from thinking this is one of the best pizzerias around!

#6 La Pizzeria Little Italy

I decided to try the classic Margherita pizza, thinking it would be a great test for any pizzeria. This was not just your average pizzeria – it was very different from anything I had ever tasted before. The dough was light, fluffy and full of flavor, and the San Marzano tomato sauce was perfectly balanced. Fresh mozzarella cheese was added on top and the whole pizza cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven.

I could taste all the flavors on my tongue – salty and sweet, herby and garlicky, with a hint of chili pepper kick at the end that really made everything stand out. It wasn’t just good – it was amazing!

Overall, La Pizzeria Little Italy has definitely earned its place as some of the best pizza in Little Italy Cleveland. If you’re looking for quality Italian flavors served up with a touch of humor, then this is the place for you!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Cleveland!

#7 Rascal House -University Circle Cleveland, OH

On this visit, I had some of their signature pepperoni pizza. The dough was perfectly cooked, slightly chewy on the outside and soft on the inside. The sauce was flavorful and the perfect accompaniment to the savory pepperoni slices covering it. It’s almost like they knew when to pull each slice from the oven so that it was cooked just right.

The warm atmosphere and friendly staff made for a pleasant experience as well. Everyone seemed very knowledgeable about their menu options and could recommend different combinations based off of my preferences. Everything felt like homemade with amazing attention to detail.

Overall, it’s safe to say that Rascal House -University Circle Cleveland, OH is one of the best places I’ve been to in Little Italy Cleveland for pizza. Highly recommended if you’re looking for delicious Italian food!

#8 Pizza Hut

The atmosphere is surprisingly pleasant, to the point that I almost forgot I was in Pizza Hut. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure you have everything you need. Plus, their pizza is freshly made by expert pizzamakers – the perfect combination of a crispy crust and deliciously flavorful toppings!

My favorite part about Pizza Hut is that they don’t skimp on quality ingredients – everything is always fresh and tasty. The prices are also reasonable – not cheap, but definitely worth it.

The one downside I noticed was that they don’t offer delivery service – but who needs it when you can experience the great atmosphere of this place?

Overall, Pizza Hut deserves a 9/10 rating for the best pizza in Little Italy Cleveland!

#9 Papa Johns Pizza

The first thing that impressed me was the friendly atmosphere. The staff are incredibly welcoming and always eager to answer any questions you may have. Once we sat down, it didn’t take long for them to bring us our delicious pizza.

The pizza itself was perfectly cooked, with a crispy thin crust and flavorful toppings. It was just like eating an authentic Italian pizza in Little Italy! We had some pepperoni and sausage, both of which were well-seasoned and cooked to perfection. Additionally, the cheese was soft but not too gooey, so it balanced out the flavors nicely.

We also got a side order of garlic knots, which I can only describe as heavenly! They were light, fluffy, and full of flavor.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Little Italy Cleveland, then Papa Johns Pizza is definitely the place to be; they won’t disappoint you!

#10 Guys Pizza

The great thing about Guys Pizza is that they offer a variety of options – from classic to innovative. On my most recent visit, I tried the special Garlic Parmesan Pizza, with Mozzarella and Cheddar cheese and the signature “Guy’s Sauce.” It was simply divine!

The crust was perfect: crispy on the outside yet soft and chewy on the inside. The cheeses were perfectly melted, creating a heavenly layer of flavor. And the sauce…oh, the sauce! It was rich, garlicky, and slightly sweet – a veritable symphony of flavors.

I also had some of their garlic knots which were equally delicious. They were enormous and wonderfully savory with lots of garlic and herbs. They also came with an herb butter dip which added even more flavor to each bite!

Overall, my experience at Guys Pizza was one for the books. If you’re ever near Little Italy Cleveland and in search of great pizza, I’d highly recommend paying this place a visit – they are truly serving up some of the best pizza in town!

#11 Rosso Gelato

As soon as I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The warm and inviting atmosphere immediately made me feel welcome and the friendly staff made sure that my experience there was a pleasant one. The pizza was cooked to perfection, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside – just how it should be.

The ingredients were all fresh and flavorful, resulting in pizza that tasted delicious. It was definitely worth the trip!

One downside of Rosso Gelato is that they don’t offer delivery service. However, this is a relatively small issue when you weigh it against the incredible taste of their pizza.

If you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Little Italy Cleveland, then look no further than Rosso Gelato – it’s certainly the best place for a slice!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 31 more pizza places in Parma!

#12 Valerio’s

Not only is the pizza incredibly delicious, but they also serve up a great selection of alcoholic beverages and hard alcohol too! I don’t know about you, but nothing pairs better with pizza than a good drink.

And if that isn’t enough, Valerio’s serves some truly insane desserts that really top it all off. As a food critic, I’m trying to remain professional here…but suffice it to say, these desserts are out of this world!

The only real downside here is that there’s no delivery option. But hey, this place is definitely worth going out of your way for! It’s the perfect tourist spot so make sure you bring a group and have fun while you’re there.

It’s safe to say that Valerio’s has earned its spot as one of the best pizzas in Little Italy Cleveland in my opinion!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Captain Tony’s Pizza

First of all, let me just say that Captain Tony’s truly understands the importance of dessert. As a self-proclaimed pizza enthusiast, I often find myself looking for the perfect sweet treat to round out my meal. And let me tell you, Captain Tony’s does not disappoint in this department. Their dessert options are out of this world! From the rich and creamy tiramisu to the indulgent chocolate lava cake, every bite is like a little piece of heaven. I have to admit, I’ve had dreams about their desserts. Yes, dreams!

Now, onto the atmosphere. Captain Tony’s is not just a pizza joint; it’s a tourist spot. The walls are adorned with nautical-themed decorations, and the waitstaff is dressed as pirates. Yes, you heard me right, pirates! They serve pizza with a side of swashbuckling charm. It’s hard not to get caught up in the whimsy of it all.

However, I must warn you, Captain Tony’s is not for the planners. They do not accept reservations. So if you’re the kind of person who likes to have everything scheduled down to the minute, you may want to reconsider. But if you’re willing to take a chance and trust in the pizza gods, it will be worth it.

Overall, Captain Tony’s Pizza is a must-visit for any pizza connoisseur. The combination of incredible deep dish pizza, divine desserts, and a quirky atmosphere make it a standout in Cleveland, Ohio. Just remember to leave your reservation books at home and prepare to embark on a pizza adventure like no other. Ahoy!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Il Rione

Let me start by saying, this place is a hidden gem. Located in the heart of the city, Il Rione is not only a pizza joint, but also a nice tourist spot. The moment you step into the restaurant, you can smell the heavenly aroma of melted cheese and freshly baked dough. It’s like being transported to pizza paradise.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself. Oh boy, the thin crust is perfection! It’s thin and crispy, yet somehow manages to hold all the toppings without collapsing. I have never seen such masterful pizza craftsmanship. Each bite is a delightful combination of flavors that will make your taste buds sing.

And guess what? Il Rione not only serves alcohol, but they have hard liquor too! Who would’ve thought you could enjoy a quality cocktail with your pizza? It’s like a match made in heaven. Plus, for my vegetarian friends, they offer some delicious meat-free options. So, everyone can find something to satisfy their pizza cravings.

However, it’s not all sunshine and pepperoni. Unfortunately, Il Rione doesn’t offer delivery. So, if you’re too lazy to step out of your house, you’ll have to find another way to satisfy your pizza cravings. But trust me, it’s worth the trip.

In conclusion, Il Rione is a must-visit for all pizza lovers. It’s the place where dreams come true, and where you can find some of the best thin crust pizza in cleveland ohio. Just make sure to bring your appetite and a sense of humor, because this place is as delightful as it is funny.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Pizza Whirl

First of all, let me just say that as a food critic, I take my pizza very seriously. And boy, did Pizza Whirl not disappoint! The moment I walked in, I was greeted by the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked dough. I knew I was in for a treat.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza toppings. They have options for everyone, including some vegetarian choices for those of us who prefer to keep our taste buds strictly herbivorous. The combination of their thin, crispy crust and the perfectly melted cheese is pure pizza heaven.

But wait, there’s more! Pizza Whirl also serves alcohol. Yes, you read that correctly. They have a fully stocked bar, so you can wash down that delicious slice with your favorite beverage. Cheers to that!

And if you have a sweet tooth like me, don’t worry. Pizza Whirl also offers a tantalizing array of desserts. My personal favorite? The Nutella pizza. Trust me, it’s like a little slice of chocolate paradise.

Now, I must mention one downside. Pizza Whirl does not accept reservations, which can be a bit inconvenient if you’re in a hurry or if you have a large group. But hey, good things come to those who wait, right?

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best wood fired pizza in cleveland with a side of laughter and a dash of adventure, look no further than Pizza Whirl. It’s the perfect tourist spot for indulging in a slice (or five) of deliciousness.