But with 12 different pizza places, how does one even begin to narrow down the options? Don’t worry, I’m here to help. Let me guide you on my quest to find the best pizza in this beloved beach town.
This review will provide a lighthearted and humorous look at all of the top picks, so strap yourselves in and get ready for an adventure!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 Lezama’s Restaurant & Pizzeria
The first thing I noticed when I arrived was the cozy atmosphere inside the restaurant. The decorations were inviting and the staff was friendly and knowledgeable. Having been to a lot of restaurants, I can tell they take great pride in providing a memorable experience to their guests.
Next, it was time for what mattered most: the pizza! Lezama’s pies are definitely up there with some of the best slices I’ve had around the world. The crust was light yet crisp, and it went wonderfully with their flavorful sauce. The toppings were fresh and cooked to perfection, making each bite more delicious than the last.
In short, Lezama’s Restaurant & Pizzeria is my go-to spot for pizza in Long Branch NJ! Whether you’re looking for a quick slice or planning a full-on pizza party, this place has everything you need for an amazing night out. You absolutely must try it if you’re in town—it’s guaranteed to be a tasty adventure!
If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Asbury Park!
#2 Nunzio’s Pizzeria
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
I have to admit, I was a bit hesitant to try pizza from a small New Jersey pizzeria. But after one bite into the gooey, cheesy goodness of Nunzio’s Pizzeria, my doubts were forgotten! The flavor combinations are truly unique and delicious — the perfect blend of traditional Italian flavors with modern pizzeria twists.
On top of that, the staff at Nunzio’s are friendly and welcoming. They make you feel right at home as soon as you walk in the door. And let’s not forget about the atmosphere — it’s laid-back and comfortable, allowing for some great conversations while you’re waiting for your pizza.
All in all, I’d highly recommend Nunzio’s Pizzeria if you’re looking for the best pizza in Long Branch NJ. From the fantastic flavor combinations to the cozy atmosphere, this is definitely a place worth checking out!
#3 Rockafellers Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
When I first stepped inside, I noticed the classic atmosphere of a family-friendly pizza place. The staff were extremely friendly and helpful, which certainly contributed to the great overall experience.
I decided to get their signature dish: a large pepperoni pizza. It was cooked to perfection – the crust was light and fluffy on the inside with a satisfying crunch on the outside. The flavor was spot-on; it wasn’t too greasy, nor too dry. The sauce was well-balanced, while the cheese melted easily and had a creamy texture. Of course, the pepperoni added just enough spice without being overwhelming. Needless to say, it was delicious!
My taste buds weren’t done yet though. Next up was dessert – an impeccable tiramisu cake with mocha latte ice cream. The presentation alone was enough to make my mouth water! And again, Rockafellers Pizza got everything just right – from its sweet taste to its creamy texture.
All in all, Rockafellers Pizza is definitely worth trying if you’re ever in Long Branch NJ looking for some good pizza or desserts! Definitely one of my top picks when it comes to great Italian food.
#4 Lupo Pizzeria West Long Branch
From the moment I arrived at Lupo’s, I was instantly drawn in. The smells of delectable toppings wafted through the air, and the inviting atmosphere of the restaurant made me feel right at home. I took a seat and quickly looked over their menu. Nothing could have prepared me for the sheer deliciousness of their pies!
The tomato sauce was savory and flavorful, with just the right amount of spices to not overpower the flavors of their other ingredients. The cheese was creamy and mouthwatering, while their selection of crusts provided a crunchy texture that contrasted nicely with each slice. Their selection of toppings were interesting yet delicious. From classic pepperoni to more adventurous selections like artichoke hearts and olives, there truly is something for everyone here at Lupo’s.
When it came time to take my first bite out of this masterpiece, all I can say is that words can’t do it justice! Every single component combined together to make one heck of a slice!
If you’re looking for some good pizza in Long Branch NJ then look no further than Lupo Pizzeria West Long Branch – they have some of the best pizza around!
#5 Federico’s Pizza On Main Oceanport
- Offers dessert
When I walked in, I was immediately impressed by the inviting atmosphere. The walls were lined with photos of happy customers enjoying their meals, and the staff was friendly and helpful.
I decided to try their signature dish: thin crust Neapolitan pizza with mozzarella, sausage, and basil. I must say, it lived up to the hype! The crust was perfectly cooked and had a nice crispiness that complemented the savory flavors of the toppings.
The experience simply doesn’t end with the food though! The restaurant also offers an extensive selection of local craft beers, wines, and cocktails that pair fantastically with their delicious pizzas.
Overall, I would absolutely recommend Federico’s Pizza On Main Oceanport to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Long Branch NJ. Whether you’re looking for something light or something filling, they have something for everyone!
#6 Scala’s Pizzeria
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
The unique thing about Scala’s is that they use a combination of traditional Italian recipes with a modern twist. You’ve got classics like pepperoni and cheese as well as unique creations like their Hawaiian pizza made with fresh pineapple and ham.
I have to say, not only was the pizza delicious but it was also huge! The individual slices were overflowing with toppings and you could really taste the quality ingredients they put into every bite.
But beyond the food, the atmosphere at Scala’s Pizzeria was amazing! The staff was friendly and welcoming, the tables were comfortable, and you could tell by looking around that everyone felt right at home. Plus I got to wash my food down with a nice glass of wine – now that’s something you don’t see at every pizzeria!
Overall, if you’re in Long Branch NJ, or even if you’re just passing through, I highly recommend stopping by Scala’s Pizzeria for some of the best pizza in town. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you later!
If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Red Bank!
#7 Bella’s Pizzeria
The first thing that caught my eye when I walked in was the menu. There were so many delicious choices, from classic cheese and pepperoni to unique creations with fresh vegetables and premium meats. It was a true pizza paradise!
When it came time for me to sample the food, I knew I was in for something special. The pizza dough was light and fluffy, not too thick yet still flavorful. The cheese was perfectly melted and had just the right amount of gooeyness. And the toppings were perfectly cooked – neither raw nor overcooked.
Overall, my experience at Bella’s Pizzeria was a delightfully delicious one! Not only did they have some of the best pizza in Long Branch NJ, but their staff were friendly and helpful throughout my visit as well. I would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for a great place to get pizza!
#8 John’s Pizza & Grill
From the moment I stepped in the door and smelled that tantalizing aroma of fresh-baked pizza, my taste buds were thanking me and begging for more.
The menu offered a wide variety of classic pizzas, plus some unique selections like a Thai Curry Chicken Pizza or a Vegetarian BBQ Ranch Pie. I opted to go with the classic Pepperoni and was definitely not disappointed! The crust was delicious and golden-brown, but not too thick or thin.
The toppings were generous and the sauce was just right – tangy and flavorful. And no pizza experience would be complete without tasting one of their homemade desserts, so I indulged in an order of Chocolate Lava Cake. It was scrumptious!
All-in-all, John’s Pizza & Grill offers an extraordinary pizza experience that everyone should try once. So if you’re ever in Long Branch NJ and looking for the best pizza around, John’s Pizza & Grill is definitely the place to go!
#9 Bom DMais Lanchonete e Pizzaria
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Has insanely good dessert
From the moment I walked in, I could tell they take their pizzas seriously – the décor is modern and inviting, and the aroma coming from the pizza ovens was heavenly!
The menu offers all sorts of combinations to choose from – classic cheese, pepperoni and sausage pizzas as well as interesting ones like Four Cheese Truffle. There’s also a great selection of calzones, strombolis, and salads.
But enough about the menu; let’s move on to what really matters – the taste! Honestly, this was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! The crust was perfectly crispy on top with a soft interior that melted in my mouth. The ingredients were fresh and flavorful – especially the truffle oil which gave it that extra depth of flavor.
Overall, Bom DMais is definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in Long Branch NJ. Best of all, their prices are fair so you don’t have to break your wallet for some world-class pizza!
#10 Long Branch Deli & Pizza
The first thing that stands out at Long Branch Deli & Pizza is their delicious sauce. It’s thick, rich, and has just the right amount of herbs and spices. The crust is always cooked to perfection and you can tell the dough has been carefully made with fresh ingredients.
My favorite item on their menu is the “Grandma Pie.” A delicious combination of a thin-crust pizza, loaded with cheese and tomatoes. Every bite explodes with flavor and it leaves me wanting more!
When it comes to toppings, Long Branch Deli & Pizza doesn’t skimp. From fresh vegetables to cured meats, every topping is of a high quality. Even better, when I asked for my pizza to be made extra spicy, they happily obliged! In addition to their pizzas, they also make some really tasty calzones and stromboli. Try them if you want something a little different!
In terms of atmosphere, Long Branch Deli & Pizza delivers an old school Italian vibe that will make you feel like you’re dining in Rome or Naples! The staff are friendly and attentive and make sure your food arrives quickly so you can enjoy it while still hot.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Long Branch NJ then look no further than Long Branch Deli & Pizza! Amazing flavors combined with excellent service makes this place an easy choice for a great night out with friends or a romantic dinner for two.
#11 La Scarpetta Italian Grill & Pizzeria
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
I kid you not – it’s every bit as delicious as the pizza I’ve had in Italy and around the world. The crust is thin, crisp, and golden-brown. Toppings are fresh and generous. Each slice was loaded with flavors that left my mouth watering (and let’s not even get started on their delicious homemade sauces!).
Plus, La Scarpetta goes the extra mile to make sure all their customers are satisfied. Their attentive staff makes you feel right at home, offering warm smiles and plenty of great recommendations for both pizza and Italian dishes.
Creating quality pizza isn’t something to take lightly – but La Scarpetta does. They put all their effort into every single pie they make which is why they can confidently proclaim themselves as having “the best pizza in Long Branch NJ”. And I’m more than happy to agree!
If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Red Bank!
#12 Joe’s Pizzeria and Cucina Italiana III
- Offers dessert
The first time I stepped foot into this establishment, I was immediately impressed. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with a cozy Italian vibe. The delicious smell of fresh tomato sauce further set the tone.
The pizza itself was out of this world! Every bite tasted like it had been made in the most authentic Italian pizzeria. From the thin and crunchy crust to the sweet and savory topping combinations, every pie truly hit the spot.
But what really clinched Joe’s Pizzeria as my favorite pizza joint in Long Branch NJ is their top-notch customer service. After ordering several pizzas for myself and my friends, the staff was friendly, attentive, and even gave us a few free slices as a welcome gesture!
Overall, Joe’s Pizzeria and Cucina Italiana III is truly an immaculate pizza experience from top to bottom. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Long Branch NJ, look no further than Joe’s Pizzeria!
