I’m no stranger to searching the world for the best pizzas, so this review of the seven pizza places in Mackinaw City comes with a certain credibility. I’m sure it’s quite obvious why Mackinaw City could be a great place for pizza, so let’s cut straight to it: what are the best options here?
My journey to test out the seven pizza places was one of enthusiasm and excitement – let’s face it, who doesn’t love a good slice of pizza? With high hopes but an open mind, I set out to find Mackinaw City’s tastiest creations.
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Michigan
#1 BC Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Has a kid’s menu
The crust is perfectly crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. The cheese is gooey and delicious, and the toppings are always fresh.
The atmosphere of BC Pizza is warm and inviting. The wait staff are friendly and helpful, willing to answer any questions you may have about their extensive menu.
But possibly my favorite thing about BC Pizza is that they allow you to customize your pizza with nearly any topping or combination of toppings imaginable. I’ve tried a few pretty wild topping combinations (think pineapple and prosciutto!) that all turned out delicious!
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Mackinaw City, look no further than BC Pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 36 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Petoskey!
#2 B.C. Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
It’s a quaint shop nestled on the main drag, but don’t let its humble appearance fool you—this place serves up delicious pies with thick, crunchy crusts. The selection of toppings is broad and varied and it’s clear that an attention to detail was given in selecting the best ingredients.
The star of B.C. Pizza is their signature sauce: smoky, tangy and packed with flavor! It really makes their pizzas stand out from the crowd.
I also have to give a shoutout to their friendly staff who are always willing to take the time to explain their various topping choices and answer any questions. It made me feel like I was more than just a customer; I felt like part of the family!
All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Mackinaw City, look no further than B.C. Pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 88 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Traverse City!
#3 Island Slice Pizzeria
- Nice tourist spot
From the moment I stepped in the door, I could tell this place was special. The atmosphere was inviting and warm, with rustic wood accents throughout the restaurant.
The menu was extensive, but I had my sights set on pizza. After ordering a large pepperoni and mushroom, I eagerly awaited for it to be cooked in their stainless steel ovens. When it emerged from the oven, I knew my search for great pizza had come to a close!
The crust was perfectly thin and crisp; the cheese was flavorful and blended with the sauce perfectly; and last but not least, the pepperoni and mushrooms were plentiful – exactly as they should be!
To top it all off, they have an excellent selection of craft beers that made a great accompaniment to their delicious pies. All in all, Island Slice Pizzeria is one of the best places for pizza in Mackinaw City – you won’t be disappointed!
If you’re willing to go an extra 128 miles, you can get to 15 more pizza places in Fish Creek!
#4 Duncan City Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
Upon arrival I noticed the restaurant had a great atmosphere. With its red and white checkered tablecloths, big windows that let in plenty of natural light, and plenty of pizza boxes scattered around, there was no mistaking this place for anything but an authentic Italian pizzeria.
The food was as good as the atmosphere! The dough was perfectly crispy on the outside, yet still tender and fresh. The sauce was tangy, with just the right amount of herbs. To top it all off, their cheese blend had a unique flavor that really made me appreciate the dish.
I also ordered some garlic bread sticks – they were absolutely delicious and one of the best I’ve ever had. They were crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside – a perfect combination!
I must say: Duncan City Pizza is hands down one of my favorite places to get pizza in Mackinaw City. If you’re looking for a delicious Italian meal with great service and a wonderful atmosphere, this is definitely worth checking out!
If you’re willing to go an extra 136 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Marquette!
#5 BC Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
When I visited, I was immediately impressed by their decor. The restaurant is decorated with pictures of downtown Mackinaw City and they have a great atmosphere.
The pizza itself is simply delicious. They have a great selection of pizzas, from classic cheese to more creative options such as Garden Vegetable and Supreme. All of their toppings are fresh and carefully chosen. Their crust is unique – it’s light and crunchy on the outside, but soft and chewy on the inside. Plus, they use a house-made sauce that really brings out the flavor of all the ingredients.
No matter what your preference is – whether you like thin crust or thick, veggie or meat lovers – BC Pizza has something for everyone! Plus, their prices are affordable so anyone can enjoy some of the best pizza in Mackinaw City.
If you’re ever in town, do yourself a favor and check out BC Pizza! You won’t regret it!
#6 Papa Zo’s Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere of the restaurant was great. The staff were all friendly, bubbly people that made me feel like part of the family. The interior was decorated in a traditional Italian style, with artwork, lamps and inviting furniture. I couldn’t wait to try one of their famous pizzas!
I decided to try the ‘Build Your Own’ pizza option, as I wanted to really create something special and unique. With my choice of cheeses and toppings I crafted a masterpiece that would have made Michelangelo proud! The crust was perfectly crispy and flavorful – not too thick or thin – just the way I like it.
The sauce was full of flavor – it had the perfect balance of saltiness and sweetness – something only a master chef could recreate. All of my chosen toppings also blended together perfectly and added an extra level of texture and flavor to the masterpiece before me.
So if you’re looking for some truly delicious pizza in Mackinaw City then stop by Papa Zo’s Pizza! You won’t regret it – unless maybe you eat too much!
#7 The Pizza Place
- Nice tourist spot
When I walked in, I was met with a warm, inviting atmosphere. The décor was simple yet tasteful and the staff was friendly and welcoming.
The menu is impressive and the pizza dough is made fresh daily with hand-tossed dough. The pizzas have delicious, flavor-packed toppings like pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers and more. Plus they have an array of specialty pizzas that are worth checking out.
I had their signature pie which was loaded with pepperoni and cheese and it really hit the spot! The crust was thin but not too crunchy; it was perfectly cooked to perfection. The sauce was rich with tangy tomato flavor that complemented the pepperoni and cheese flavors nicely. Overall, one of the best pies I’ve ever had!
If you’re ever in Mackinaw City on the hunt for great pizza then you definitely have got to stop by The Pizza Place – they truly make some of the best pizza in town!
