Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Marathon FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Marathon FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

144 Views

My world travels have certainly led me to some great pizza. But Marathon, Florida? Who knew? After tasting nine different pizzerias in town, I’m happy to report back that the best pizza in Marathon FL is worth seeking out.

I’ll be guiding you through my hard-won findings, my expert opinion, and a few funny stories from my journey. So hold on tight—it’s time to go on a delicious culinary adventure!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Coast To Coast Pizza Company

The crust is perfectly crispy and fluffy while the pepperoni is a perfect mix of smoky and salty. The cheese is abundant and flavorful, just how I like it. Even the sauce tastes like it was freshly made this morning – really adding to the overall flavor profile.

Best of all, Coast To Coast Pizza Company offers great prices for their gourmet pizza without sacrificing quality! The staff are passionate and knowledgeable about what they do, which makes for an even more enjoyable experience.

Unfortunately, there’s no delivery option available, so you have to go in-store to get your slice – but that just adds to the fun. I highly recommend going in for dinner one night and experiencing the best pizza Marathon FL has to offer!

If you’re willing to go an extra 41 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Key West!

#2 Sparky’s Landing – Fish n Cocktails

This place definitely lives up to its name, combining the best of both worlds with fish, cocktails and some amazing pizza. With a kid’s menu too, the whole family can enjoy some great food and drinks. Although I was sad to find out there’s no delivery option, this is still your go-to spot for great pizza in Marathon FL!

The atmosphere at Sparky’s Landing – Fish n Cocktails is super relaxing; perfect for a night out or for when you just want to relax and watch the sunset over the harbor. On top of that, they also offer desserts – talk about hitting all the marks!

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Marathon FL then look no further – Sparky’s Landing – Fish n Cocktails has it all! From amazing pizza to yummy cocktails and even desserts, it’s one of my favorite spots around Marathon.

#3 Driftwood Pizza, Pasta, & Subs

I was skeptical when I first went in, but the atmosphere was warm, inviting, and full of delicious aromas. The staff was friendly and helpful as well.

When it came to the pizza itself, all I can say is wow! No matter what toppings you choose, it’s always cooked to perfection. The crust is golden and crispy on the outside with just a hint of caramelization, yet still soft and airy inside. And the sauce! It’s rich and complex with intense flavors that linger on your palate long after you’ve taken your last bite.

I’m not usually one for pasta dishes at pizza restaurants–but Driftwood totally changed my mind! The pasta dishes are made with quality ingredients like freshly grated cheese and homemade sauces. And let’s not forget their amazing subs! Their signature Italian Caprese Sub is simply divine – made with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, arugula, and balsamic vinaigrette on crusty focaccia bread. Divine!

In conclusion: if you’re looking for great pizza in Marathon FL, look no further than Driftwood Pizza, Pasta & Subs – it really is the best!

If you’re willing to go an extra 41 miles, you can get to 7 more pizza places in Islamorada!

#4 Upper Crust

From the minute I walked in, I was sure this was going to be a great experience. It’s a nice tourist spot, with plenty of alcohol available to help you enjoy your meal. Plus, they even have dessert after you’re done eating – what more could a food critic ask for?

The pizza itself is simply delicious. The crust is thin and crispy, the sauce is flavorful and not too sweet or salty, and the cheese is just cheesy enough. Everything about it makes for an amazing pizza experience!

Unfortunately, Upper Crust does not offer delivery, which can be a bit of a let-down if you’re in the mood for some takeout. But rest assured that if you make the trip to Marathon FL just for Upper Crust’s pizza, it’ll be worth it!

#5 Causeway Pizza

I’m not one to mince words, and I was thoroughly impressed with the impeccable crust on the pizzas that I sampled. The thin-crust style of the pizzas really brings out all the flavors and ensures there’s no one overpowering element.

The sauce here is also top-notch! It’s a mixture of sweetness and spice that makes for an unforgettable flavor experience. The toppings themselves were all quite fresh, providing a wonderful combination of textures when combined with the crust.

In addition to great pizza, Causeway Pizza has some fantastic sides as well, such as their garlic knots and fried cheese sticks. And if you’re looking for something a little bit sweeter, they have delicious desserts like cannoli and tiramisu too!

Overall, Causeway Pizza offers some of the best pizza in Marathon FL – it’s definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 47 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Key West!

#6 Papa John’s Pizza

I’m happy to report that this pizza joint lives up to the hype. The crust was just the right thickness, with a slightly crunchy texture that was both tasty and satisfying. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and each slice was loaded with cheese, making it extra cheesy goodness. The sauce was bold, tangy, and really brought out all the flavors in the topping combinations.

My favorite topping combination at Papa John’s is their Italian Sausage and Pepperoni with extra cheese. I love that they offer so many options for customizing your order as well with multiple sauces, additional cheeses, veggie toppings, etc.

The staff at Papa John’s are also friendly and helpful too! They always make sure my order is perfect before it goes out and let me know when my order is ready for pickup or delivery.

Overall I can confidently say that Papa John’s Pizza is definitely one of the best pizzerias in Marathon FL! While I may have sampled pizza from around the world this past year, nothing beats good old American-style pizza from Papa John’s!

#7 Frank’s Grill

My visit to Frank’s Grill was a delight. The atmosphere was casual and inviting, which made it the perfect spot for a family outing. And on top of that, they even served alcohol (and hard liquor!) so I could enjoy a cold beverage with my meal.

The pizzas here are mouth-watering. I had the classic pepperoni and cheese combo and boy did it hit the spot! Their kid’s menu also makes this place great for families with young ones.

And as if that wasn’t enough, the desserts at Frank’s Grill were insanely good! They have all of your favorite classic items like brownies, cookies, cakes and more; all of which are tasty treats everyone can enjoy.

Unfortunately, there is one downside to this restaurant: they don’t offer delivery services. This means if you’re craving their amazing pizza you’ll have to take a trip over in person—it’s worth it!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Marathon FL then look no further than Frank’s Grill. It’s an excellent spot to grab some grub with friends or family and enjoy some truly delicious food!

If you’re willing to go an extra 51 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Key Largo!

#8 7 Mile Grill

I’m a bit of a picky reviewer when it comes to pizza, so I was pleasantly surprised by the amount of flavor and variety that 7 Mile Grill offers. Whether you want classic pepperoni or something more exotic, like roasted garlic and sun-dried tomatoes, they have it all!

The crust was cooked to perfection! Not too thick and not too thin, with just the right crunch. What really sent me over the moon, though, was the variety of cheeses available. They’ve got mozzarella and provolone, but also a smoky gouda for those looking for something richer. And the sauce! So flavorful and creamy; it really made this pizza stand out from all the rest.

All in all, 7 Mile Grill is definitely one of my favorite pizza places in Marathon FL! Highly recommended!

#9 Triton Seafood Restaurant Italian Cuisine & Pizza

From the first bite, I was amazed. The crust was perfectly cooked with a delicious golden hue and that delightful aroma of fresh dough. The toppings were abundant, with flavorful combinations like pepperoni and olives or Italian sausage and onions that tantalize the taste buds with each mouthful.

The service at Triton Seafood is also top-notch. Everyone working here is friendly and knowledgeable about their pizza making skills. They will help you customize any order to your liking as well!

If you’re ever in Marathon FL make sure to head over to Triton Seafood for some of the best pizza around! Go now, because there’s no telling when this secret may get out!