Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Massapequa (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Massapequa (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

197 Views

I’ve tasted pizza from some far-flung places—from Chicago to Rome—so I know a good slice when I see one. This time around, I’m focusing on the best pizza spots in Massapequa. I’m about to review 12 places and let you in on my top picks.

My reviews can be a bit humorous and lighthearted at times, so don’t take them too seriously! All that matters is that you get a delicious slice of pizza and have a great time with your buddies, family, or significant other. So without further ado, let’s dive into the results of this pizza extravaganza!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Leonardo’s Pizza

The atmosphere of this Italian restaurant is warm and inviting, and their wood-fired crusts are to die for. They offer some unique toppings, like wild mushrooms and spicy sausage, as well as classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese.

The service at Leonardo’s Pizza was outstanding – they were polite, friendly, and incredibly attentive. I felt like I was an honored guest instead of just another customer! The staff even went out of their way to give me recommendations on what their most popular pizzas were.

I decided to go with their signature pizza: a thin-crust creation loaded with sauce, cheese, and the perfect balance of herbs and spices. It was truly amazing – definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

Overall, Leonardo’s Pizza is by far one of the best places to get pizza in Massapequa! If you’re looking for a delicious Italian meal that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds, then look no further than Leonardo’s Pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Babylon!

#2 Brick & Cork

The atmosphere is hip, trendy, and modern. The staff are all friendly and helpful, creating a unique and pleasant dining experience.

The pizza itself is so delicious that it’s hard to choose just one type. All of the ingredients are fresh and flavorful, making for an incredible taste that you won’t forget. Whether it’s their classic marinara or their more innovative creations such as bacon and blue cheese, Brick & Cork never fails to impress.

My personal favorite is the bacon and blue cheese pizza! It has just the right amount of richness from the bacon combined with the tangy flavor of blue cheese — I can’t get enough!

As far as pizza restaurants go, Brick & Cork definitely takes the cake as having some of the best pizza in Massapequa! If you’re ever in town, stop by and give them a try — your taste buds won’t regret it!

#3 Saverio’s Authentic Pizza Napoletana

My journey started with a warm welcome from the owner, Saverio himself. He showed me all of the ingredients that made his pizza special, from the traditional oven to the secret recipe for dough. His passion for great pizza was contagious!

But it’s not just the preparation that makes Saverio’s such a special place. The atmosphere is what really sets it apart. From the Italian music playing in the background to the friendly staff, you will always feel at home and welcome here.

The food was simply amazing and fresh. I had a taste of some of their signature pizzas, like Prosciutto and Mozzarella, Margherita and Bianca E Funghi. Each one was cooked to perfection with toppings that were vibrant and flavorful. So much so that I found myself going back for more!

All-in-all, Saverio’s has earned my seal of approval as having some of the best pizza in Massapequa. If you are looking for an authentic Neapolitan pie or just a great night out with friends or family, look no further than Saverio’s Authentic Pizza Napoletana!

#4 Rosario’s Pizzeria

The first thing I noticed when I walked in was the vibrantly decorated walls and the homemade tomato sauce aroma that filled the air. After taking a seat, I quickly realized this place had some character, but it didn’t take away from the quality of their pizza.

I decided to try their signature pie, and I’m glad I did! The crust was cooked perfectly and had just enough chewiness without being overcooked. The homemade tomato sauce was fresh and flavorful, while the cheese provided just the right amount of richness and gooeyness. To top it off, all of the toppings were high-quality and added an extra level of flavor to every bite.

Overall, Rosario’s Pizzeria is one of my favorite places for pizza in Massapequa—and perhaps even in all of New York State! Their pizzas are flavorful yet unpretentious with a perfect balance of ingredients. Highly recommended if you’re ever looking for some delicious pies!

#5 Carmela’s

The place is a cozy little joint with a few tables, and when you walk in, you immediately get the warm, inviting feeling that this is the kind of spot you want to hang out in. The pizza itself is nothing short of perfection – the crust is just right and the toppings are fresh and delicious. I tried out several different varieties while I was there, and they were all incredible!

The staff at Carmela’s are really what makes the experience special. They’re so friendly and welcoming – they make it feel like you’ve been part of their family for years! Even if this isn’t your first slice at Carmela’s, they still treat you like an honored guest. And, don’t forget about the owner – she knows how to make a mean pizza (just ask her!).

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Massapequa, look no further than Carmela’s! It’s definitely worth a visit!

#6 Fredo’s Pizza & Pasta

I could tell from the moment I stepped through the door that this place was going to be special; the smell of cooking pizza filled the air and everyone in there seemed to be having a great time.

The first bite of my cheese pizza was like nothing I had ever tasted before. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, while the sauce was flavorful and just spicy enough. The cheese complemented it all perfectly.

I moved on to the pasta menu and ordered an order of penne with garlic cream sauce. It was delicious! The pasta was cooked al dente, the sauce creamy yet light, and the garlic gave it a nice kick.

It’s also worth noting that Fredo’s is extremely affordable; prices are competitive compared to other pizzerias in town, and they offer plenty of discounts for large parties or bulk orders.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Massapequa – look no further than Fredo’s Pizza & Pasta!

#7 Lombardo’s of seaford pizzeria

My first bite was a delight. The pizza was cheesy and flavorful, with a perfectly crisp crust. I especially liked the generous amounts of their homemade tomato sauce that brightened up every slice. The toppings were incredibly fresh, too – from the pepperoni to the green peppers, every single topping was cooked perfectly.

The atmosphere at Lombardo’s is great, too! It’s casual yet cozy and always bustling with happy customers. I love how a pay-it-forward system has been implemented so you can buy pizzas for strangers in need! It shows how much this pizzeria cares about its customers and community.

I had a hard time deciding on dessert since everything sounded so delicious, but eventually, I decided to try out the mini cannolis. They weren’t what I expected; they were absolutely heavenly! These little treats were sweet but not overly so, with a delightful crunchy exterior that hid an even softer interior. I could definitely see myself coming back here just for these treats alone!

All in all, Lombardo’s of seaford pizzeria is my top pick for the best pizza in Massapequa. With its delicious food and warm atmosphere, this restaurant will keep you coming back time and time again!

#8 Mario’s

The first thing that drew me to Mario’s was the amazing aromas coming from inside. The smell of freshly-baked pizza dough and melted cheese filled the air and made my mouth water. Once I stepped inside, it was clear why this place is so popular: the decor was inviting and stylish, with no expense spared.

The menu was extensive and everything looked delicious, but I opted for a classic pepperoni pizza. I knew from the moment it arrived that this would be one of the best slices I’ve ever had! The crust was perfectly chewy—not too thin and not too thick—and the sauce had just enough zing to make it an incredibly flavorful experience. The pepperonis were cooked perfectly, adding a great amount of spice to each bite.

In conclusion, every element of Mario’s pizza experience was delightful! From its inviting atmosphere to its pipping hot pies, it’s no wonder they are known as having some of Massapequa’s best pizza. If you’re looking for a delicious slice that won’t break the bank, Mario’s is your spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Deer Park!

#9 Phils pizza 2

The first thing that struck me when I walked into the restaurant was the welcoming and friendly atmosphere. The staff was super helpful and really made me feel at home.

The pizza selection is fantastic, from classic cheese to more adventurous flavors like Hawaiian. Whatever toppings you could want are available, and each pie is cooked to perfection. The crust is always golden, crispy, and flavorful – just as pizza should be!

Also impressive is their selection of sides like garlic knot holders and big salads. And let’s talk about their desserts: wow! They have a great variety of sweet treats, but the star for me was their signature dessert pizza topped with fresh fruit, chocolate chips, and a rich cream cheese icing. It was so delicious!

My experience at Phils pizza 2 was amazing overall. It definitely lives up to its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Massapequa – maybe even world-class! I would highly recommend this spot to anyone looking for a great pizza experience.

#10 Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant

I recently had the chance to try some of the pizzas at this wonderful restaurant. From their signature thin crust pizza to their thick and surprisingly fluffy Sicilian-style slice, I was pleasantly surprised with the flavors and textures at Calda Pizzeria.

The classic margherita pie was a delight to have; tomatoes, cheese and fresh basil atop a perfect dough is always a classic combination that never fails to please! And then there was their unique white pizza featuring mushrooms, garlic butter and Romano cheese – an interesting twist that kept me wanting more.

The atmosphere of Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant also made for a fun dining experience. The staff were friendly and helpful in guiding us through the menu choices, but they didn’t hover nor did they take forever when we requested our order – something I appreciated!

Overall, I am now convinced that Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant has some of the best pizza in Massapequa, if not the world! Whether you are looking for traditional options or something more unusual, you’re sure to find it here. Highly recommend!

#11 Via Roma Pizza

The first time I visited this restaurant, I couldn’t help but be impressed. They have such a wide selection of pizzas – from the classic margherita to exotic topping combinations – that you’ll definitely find something to satisfy your craving. The crust is always perfectly crispy and the cheese is always freshly melted.

The best pizza in Massapequa can be found at Via Roma Pizza! They use a secret blend of spices and herbs to make their pizza stand out from the rest. The flavors are so unique and delicious that I’ve been coming back time and time again for my favorite slice.

On top of all that, they have friendly staff and a cozy atmosphere that makes it the perfect spot for a casual dinner with friends or family. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite on the go or a sit-down meal, this place has what you need!

If you’re looking for great pizza in Massapequa, look no further than Via Roma Pizza! You won’t regret it!

#12 Patrizia’s Of Massapequa Park

The atmosphere in this restaurant is inviting and cozy, and the staff are all incredibly friendly and helpful. From the moment I step inside, I’m welcomed with a warm smile and they give me plenty of time to decide what type of pizza I am going to have.

When it comes to the pizza itself, I can honestly say that Patrizia’s have mastered their craft. The crust is thin yet full of flavor and the dough has just the right amount of chewiness. Even better, they use only fresh ingredients that truly enhance the flavor of their pizzas.

One thing that makes Patrizia’s stand out from other pizzerias is their creative selection of toppings. Each pizza is unique in its own way as they offer everything from traditional Italian favorites like pepperoni and sausage to more exotic options like pineapple and jalapeño. Overall, there are ample topping choices for vegetarians, meat lovers, and everyone in between!

Finally, there’s no doubt that Patrizia’s Of Massapequa Park offers a great value for your money. Not only do they keep their prices competitively low but also provide generous portions that will satisfy even the hungriest customer.

So if you’re looking for some amazing pizza without breaking the bank – look no further than Patrizia’s! They definitely deserve recognition as one of Massapequa’s best!