Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Medina OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Ohio

Best Pizza in Medina OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

283 Views

I’m on a mission to find the best pizza in this small town, reviewing twelve local pizza places. I come with an open palate and an appetite for adventure — it’s time to find out if Medina has anything special up its sleeve!

Along the way, I’m hoping to uncover some hidden gems and maybe even a few surprises. I’m sure there’ll be plenty of laughs too — discovering the best pizza isn’t always easy but can certainly be an enjoyable journey.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio

#1 Prehistoric Pizza

The first thing that struck me about the restaurant was the decor. Walking in, I immediately got a sense of nostalgia from the stone walls, dim lighting, and prehistoric paintings that adorn the walls. It really made me feel like I was back in time!

The menu also didn’t disappoint. From traditional pizza options to creative combinations, it was clear that Prehistoric Pizza was aiming to push boundaries with its flavor selection. After some deliberation, I opted for a slice of their dinosaur-shaped pizza topped with roasted peppers and onions. The ranch sauce and parmesan cheese rounded out the toppings nicely.

When my pizza arrived at the table it looked incredible! The oven-fresh crust was perfectly cooked and still had a nice sheen when it was served. All of the ingredients were fresh, flavorful, and arranged in what could only be described as a work of art! Each bite unleashed an explosion of mouthwatering flavors – I couldn’t get enough!

Overall, Prehistoric Pizza’s dinosaur shaped pizza is honestly one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had in Medina OH! The modern touches on classic recipes make this an absolutely delicious experience you won’t want to miss out on – highly recommended!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Strongsville!

#2 Lager Heads Brewing Company & Tap Room

The ingredients are always fresh, and their commitment to quality is evident in every bite. The pizzas are always perfectly cooked, with a delicious crisp crust. And don’t get me started on the toppings–they offer everything from classic pepperoni to more unusual options like pineapple and bacon.

What really sets this place apart, though, is their selection of beer and wine. With over 15 beers on tap and dozens of wines available by the glass, you can easily find something to pair with your meal. Plus, they have a great outdoor seating area so you can enjoy your pizza with a view!

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery–but honestly it’s worth driving out there and picking up some pizza for yourself! Don’t miss out on this amazing pizza experience–it really is some of the best pizza in Medina OH.

#3 Master Pizza

This place is full of surprises. I mean, the pizza was just so incredibly good, it felt like I had died and gone to pizza heaven. The crust was thin and crunchy, with the perfect balance of savory toppings and cheese melted to perfection. And for a food critic like myself, that’s always a plus.

The atmosphere at Master Pizza was great too; it felt like an old-timey pizzeria from days of yore. Everything from the cozy booths to the music playing in the background set the tone for what is truly one of Medina OH’s best pizza restaurants.

And let’s not forget about their customer service! The staff here are some of the friendliest people you’ll ever meet – they always greet their customers with a smile and go out of their way to ensure they have a great experience while dining at Master Pizza.

I don’t know why you’d want to go anywhere else when it comes to finding the best pizza in Medina OH; Master Pizza definitely delivers on its promise of providing delicious and freshly-made pies every single time!

#4 Courthouse Pizzeria

Their crust is perfectly thin and crunchy, with just the right amount of saltiness. Their sauce is made from a secret recipe, but I can tell you it’s definitely one of the best I’ve ever had. The cheese they use is always fresh and creamy, and their toppings are always top-notch!

The staff at Courthouse Pizzeria are also one of a kind. Everyone from the pizza makers to the cashiers is friendly and helpful – no matter what time it is or how busy the restaurant may be. They always have time for customers who need help deciding what to order or give recommendations about their menu choices.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Medina OH, look no further than Courthouse Pizzeria! You won’t be disappointed!

#5 Guys Pizza Co. Medina

I know what you’re thinking: How can a small town pizza joint compete with the big, world renowned pizzerias of Rome and Naples? Let me tell you: Guys Pizza Co. Medina knows their stuff! From the first bite of my pepperoni pizza, I knew this place was something special. The perfectly baked crust, with just enough crunch and chewiness in every bite; the tangy tomato sauce that had obviously been cooked to perfection; and the generous amounts of cheese and pepperoni that made each slice its own little work of art – all these components combined to create a truly unforgettable slice of pizza!

And if you’re looking for something a little more adventurous than your typical pepperoni slice, Guys Pizza Co. Medina offers an amazing range of specialty pizzas that will blow your taste buds away. Whether it’s their Firewalker with jalapeno peppers, pineapple chunks and Habanero-infused mozzarella topped with Cajun spiced sausage, or their Baked Omelet Pie featuring bacon, scrambled eggs and cheddar cheese – there’s something for everyone here!

From start to finish I enjoyed every single bite of pizza at Guys Pizza Co. Medina. From the friendly staff who took great care when crafting my order, to the hot (but never greasy!) slices that arrived promptly on my plate – everything was top-notch. If you’re ever in Medina OH looking for a delicious slice of ‘za, be sure to check out Guys Pizza Co., because it’ll definitely be the best pizza experience around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Fairlawn!

#6 Dominic’s Italian Restaurant

The pizza here is amazingly delicious and it’s all due to the perfect blend of dough, sauce, cheese, and toppings. The dough was light yet crisp; the sauce was the perfect balance of zesty and sweet; the cheese was gooey and flavorful; and the toppings were fresh, flavorful, and plentiful. Every bite of their pizza was a delight for my taste buds!

The atmosphere at Dominic’s Italian Restaurant also contributed to my overall experience. The restaurant has a cozy ambience that makes you feel right at home. Plus, their friendly staff is always around to give recommendations if you’re not sure what kind of pizza to get.

No matter if it’s a romantic dinner or group celebration, I can confidently say that Dominic’s Italian Restaurant is the place to go for some of the best pizza in Medina OH. Whether you’re looking for a unique specialty pizza or just want a classic cheese slice (or two!), you won’t be disappointed by what this amazing restaurant has to offer!

#7 Romeo’s O.T. Sports Grille

I mean, where else can you get delicious slices of pizza and a cold beer all under the same roof? It’s like the holy grail of pizza.

The atmosphere was also fantastic – there were huge TVs everywhere, making it a great place to watch sports. Plus, they even have hard liquor in case you want something extra to sip on while watching the game.

My only gripe is that they don’t do delivery, which really means I’m going to have to leave my comfy spot on the couch for this one. But hey, sometimes sacrifices have to be made for some truly great pizza!

All in all, Romeo’s O.T. Sports Grille had what I would call the perfect combination of delicious food and fantastic sports viewing experience – definitely one of the best places I’ve been in Medina OH!

#8 Johnny Malloy’s Irish Sports Pub

For starters, the atmosphere is great – lively and fun, with plenty of TVs playing sports on the walls. The restaurant has won awards for its outdoor seating, and there’s definitely something to be said for that!

As far as the pizza goes, it’s simply delicious! Every bite is oozing with cheesy goodness and the wide selection of toppings allows you to customize your pizza to perfection. My personal favorite is their ‘SPP’ (Sausage, Pepperoni and Pineapple) pizza – it takes a classic favorite and adds a tropical twist.

All in all, I would highly recommend Johnny Malloy’s Irish Sports Pub if you’re looking for some truly great pizza in Medina OH. It may not be the fanciest restaurant around, but they definitely have some of the best pizza in town!

#9 Marco’s Pizza

As soon as I walked in the door, I could smell the aroma of freshly baked pizza and it was a good sign. The interior of the place had a welcoming vibe that made me feel right at home.

The menu had all kinds of specialty pizzas to choose from, with something for everyone. Even though it was hard to choose, I finally decided on one that sounded like it would be a great combination: half-cheese, half-veggie.

Once my pizza arrived, I could see why this place is so highly rated. Everything about it–from the fresh dough to the flavorful vegetables–was top notch! It was nicely cooked through without being too greasy or overdone. On top of that, they make sure they get just the right amount of toppings so that every bite has its own flavor profile.

But what really sets Marco’s Pizza apart from other places is their service. The staff are friendly and welcoming and always make sure you’re getting just what you asked for in your order.

If you’re in Medina OH looking for your next pizza fix, be sure to check out Marco’s Pizza! I guarantee you won’t be disappointed with the quality of their food or their service!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Akron!

#10 Pizza Hut Express

Since I’m somewhat of a pizza connoisseur, I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of their pies. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the sauces used were flavorful, and all the toppings were fresh and delicious. Plus, they also offer a selection of desserts – a rare find in pizza restaurants!

However, the only downside is that you can’t get any delivery from Pizza Hut Express. Fortunately, it’s only a short drive away so it wasn’t an issue for me; but if you’re looking for delivery options then this might not be your best option.

Overall I’d say that Pizza Hut Express is one of the best pizzerias around Medina OH. If you’re looking for some great tasting pizza (and even dessert), then head over to this place today!

#11 East of Chicago Pizza

I had the pleasure of enjoying the classic pepperoni pizza, and all I can say is wow! The crust was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of crunch—not too hard, not too soft. Topped with an ample helping of tangy tomato sauce and a generous sprinkling of deliciously smoky pepperoni slices, it was a perfect balance of flavor and texture.

The interior of the restaurant was rustic and inviting, and all the staff were friendly and helpful. It really added to the experience!

Overall, I have to say that East of Chicago Pizza has truly earned its place as one of the best pizza places in Medina OH. Whether you’re looking for a delicious bite or simply somewhere with great atmosphere, East of Chicago Pizza is definitely worth a visit!

#12 Gionino’s Pizzeria

First off, their crust was absolutely delicious. It had the perfect crunch and flavor, making it hard to put down. I also found the sauce to be particularly noteworthy – just enough sweet and tanginess to perfectly balance out each bite.

Their toppings were also top-notch with a generous amount of cheese and great fresh vegetables. Every single bite melted in my mouth and tasted like heaven! Honestly, I can’t think of any pizza place in the world that could match up to Gionino’s Pizzeria when it comes to toppings.

Finally, Gionino’s offers an amazing selection of pizzas on their menu, which means there is something for everyone – from classic cheese pizzas to vegetarian pies. And best of all, they offer a variety of sizes so you can get what you need without wasting ingredients or money.

To conclude: I haven’t tasted a better pizza anywhere else in Medina OH – Gionino’s Pizzeria is undoubtedly the best pizza around!