Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in New Britain CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Connecticut

Best Pizza in New Britain CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

176 Views

I’m here to present my findings after tasting twelve different pizza places in the city. With my broad (and often picky!) palate, I’ve sampled all kinds of pies to find the best ones around.

Don’t worry, I’m not taking this too seriously – with a lighthearted and humorous attitude, I’m ready to get this taste test started! So join me as I journey through New Britain CT’s pizza scene and share my unmissable picks for the absolute best pies around.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Connecticut

#1 Elm Hill Pizza

When I walked in, the aromas of fresh ingredients and the sounds of bubbling cheese made me feel right at home. The atmosphere is inviting yet casual and the staff was friendly and helpful.

The menu features classic pies as well as creative options that suit all tastes. I tried the classic Italian-style pie with a hint of garlic and oregano, which was delicious. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy and the sauce was flavorful yet not too spicy.

My favorite part of Elm Hill Pizza though is their unique toppings bar. They have everything from hot peppers to smoked sausage to bacon-onion jam! It’s a great way to add extra flavor without overpowering the pizza’s natural taste.

Overall, I definitely recommend Elm Hill Pizza for anyone looking for great pizza in New Britain CT – it’s some of the best pizza I’ve had anywhere!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Newington!

#2 New Britain House of Pizza

I sampled some of their regular thin crust pies and was blown away by the flavor. The pizzas have a delicious, garlicky taste and the crust is perfectly crisp but still has a soft, tender center. The toppings are also amazing – you can really taste the freshness.

The restaurant itself is cozy, with an inviting atmosphere and friendly staff. Plus, it’s conveniently located right in the heart of town!

If you’re looking for a great pizza experience that won’t break the bank, New Britain House of Pizza is definitely worth a visit. I highly recommend it – hands down one of the best pizzas in New Britain CT!

#3 Marathon Pizza

The atmosphere at Marathon Pizza is perfect for an enjoyable pizza experience. The staff are friendly and welcoming and make you feel right at home. The restaurant has a chill, laid-back vibe, with music playing in the background that adds to the cozy atmosphere.

The menu at Marathon Pizza is filled with all sorts of delicious creations. Whether you’re looking to try something new or stick to classic favorites, there’s something for everyone here! I tried their specialty margarita pizza, which had a light, crispy crust that was perfectly cooked and covered with tomatoes, basil & mozzarella cheese. It was simply divine! They also serve other Italian cuisine such as subs, calzones and salads.

Overall, Marathon Pizza is the perfect spot for a tasty pizza experience! I definitely recommend it as the best pizza in New Britain CT!

#4 Town Line Pizza & Restaurant

I had heard great things about this local joint, and I was not disappointed. The staff was friendly and welcoming, the atmosphere was comfortable and inviting, and the pizza – oh my goodness!

The pizza is made from scratch with a homemade crust that has an amazing texture. Each slice is just the right thickness, so you don’t end up with a soggy mess. It’s topped with high-quality ingredients that really bring out the flavor of each pie.

My favorite part of the experience was definitely the desserts. They make their own cannoli cream, which is truly out of this world delicious! It’s nice to know they still put in extra effort instead of using premade products like some other restaurants do.

Overall, Town Line Pizza & Restaurant deserves its reputation as one of the best pizzerias in New Britain CT. If you’re looking for a great meal, I’d highly recommend giving them a try!

#5 Brick Oven Pizza & Restaurant

The pizzas here are cooked to perfection with just the right crust and toppings. The menu has something for everyone, including vegetarian options, so there’s really no bad choice.

Another plus is that the restaurant offers dessert! The selection is small but delicious.

The only downside to Brick Oven is that they don’t offer delivery. That means if you want to partake in their delicious creations, you’ll have to go pick it up yourself. However, that’s probably a good thing when you consider how hard it would be to transport a pizza without it getting cold or soggy.

Overall, Brick Oven Pizza & Restaurant should be your first choice for pizza in New Britain CT!

#6 Adinas Pizzeria

I was so impressed with their signature pies that I wrote this review to share my experience.

The atmosphere at Adinas Pizzeria was warm and inviting, which is exactly what I needed after a long day of traveling. The staff were friendly and helpful, taking the time to answer all my questions about the menu.

The pizza slices were delicious! They had some unique topping combinations that really made each bite an enjoyable experience. The crust was thin and crispy while still retaining its structure after being cooked with all the toppings.

My favorite pie was their signature “Adinas Special” topped with pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, black olives, peppers and cheese. It was unlike anything I’ve had before – it had just the right amount of flavor without overwhelming your taste buds – and it made for one memorable meal!

If you’re ever in New Britain CT looking for some of the best pizza around then make sure to swing by Adinas Pizzeria – you won’t be disappointed!

#7 NTA Pizza & Grocery

The first thing that struck me when I arrived was the friendly staff and inviting atmosphere. From the moment I walked in, everyone was warm and welcoming, making me feel right at home. There’s something special about a place where you can feel like family before eating the pizza!

The pizza itself is superb. The crust is thin and crisp just how I like it, while the toppings are generously portioned so that each bite has just enough flavor without being overwhelming. The sauce is perfect – it has a nice balance of tomato sweetness with a hint of garlic that ties everything together nicely.

Without a doubt, NTA Pizza & Grocery deserves to be on my list of great pizzerias across the world! If you’re ever looking for some delicious pizza in New Britain CT, this is definitely the place to go – you won’t be disappointed!

#8 La Esquina del Sabor

This family-run restaurant is the kind of place you’d want to visit again and again. The atmosphere is fun and inviting, and the staff is always friendly and helpful.

The pizza itself is outstanding – a thin crust that’s perfectly baked with just the right amount of crunch. The toppings are generous and flavorful, and they add something special to every bite.

I had the pepperoni pizza, and it was simply delicious. The sauce was hearty but not too greasy, while the cheese was melted to perfection. I also added some mushrooms, which were cooked nicely in a mixture of garlic, herbs, and olive oil.

All in all, I highly recommend La Esquina del Sabor for anyone looking for some great pizza in New Britain CT. It’s definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Glastonbury!

#9 Bella Gourmet Pizzeria

I recently had the pleasure of checking out this local pizzeria, and let me tell you, it was an experience like no other. From the moment I stepped into Bella Gourmet Pizzeria, I knew I was in for a treat. The interior was cozy and inviting, with hints of Italian culture everywhere. The staff made sure to make my dining experience as pleasant as possible – from seating us promptly to giving great recommendations for what to order.

Then came the pizza: its thin-crust dough was cooked to perfection with just enough crispiness on the outside and it was topped with some mouthwatering ingredients! It literally melted in my mouth! This pizza place definitely knows how to make a pizza that’s flavorful without being overwhelmingly heavy.

I would highly recommend Bella Gourmet Pizzeria for anyone looking for the best pizza in New Britain CT. They really put a lot of heart and soul into making each pizza special and unique – it’s clear that they take their craft seriously! If you’re ever in the area looking for delicious food, be sure to stop by here!

#10 Pizza Pal Restaurant

The atmosphere is inviting and lively, making it a great place for groups or date nights. The staff are friendly and attentive, always happy to help with your order and answer any questions you may have.

I ordered one of the specialty pies, something called the ‘Crazy Carnivore’. It was loaded with all sorts of meats–salami, pepperoni, bacon–all atop a beautifully crafted thin crust. The flavors blended together perfectly and it has just the right amount of grease.

What really sets Pizza Pal Restaurant apart from other pizza places in New Britain CT is the quality of their ingredients. The cheese was freshly melted mozzarella and the sauce had an herby flavor to it that I’ve never experienced before. Every bite was a delicious adventure!

Overall, I would highly recommend Pizza Pal Restaurant if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in New Britain CT. Not only do they serve delicious food in an enjoyable atmosphere, but their superior ingredients will make sure you walk away satisfied every time!

#11 Town & Country Pizza Restaurant

From the moment I stepped through the doors of Town & Country Pizza Restaurant, I knew I would find something special. The staff was friendly and welcoming and the atmosphere was inviting.

I had heard rave reviews about their pizza, so naturally that’s what I decided to order. The pizza was cooked perfectly – thin crust with a hint of charring. It had just the right balance of tomatoes, cheese, and herbs, making it absolutely delicious!

Another great thing about Town & Country Pizza Restaurant is that they offer alcoholic beverages – perfect for those looking to enjoy a night out with friends or family. They also have some excellent vegetarian options and a kid’s menu, making it suitable for any kind of crowd. And if you’ve got a sweet tooth like me, you’re in luck as they offer dessert too.

The only downside I found was that they don’t offer delivery service; but after trying their pizza, it’s worth taking the time to go there in person anyway! All in all, it was an amazing experience and I’d definitely recommend Town & Country Pizza Restaurant to anyone looking for great pizza in New Britain CT.

#12 Peppino’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Peppino’s was wonderful. The cozy seating and Italian music playing in the background made me feel right at home. The staff was incredibly friendly, too; I felt like part of the family!

The pizza itself was out of this world- perfect crust, delicious toppings, and a generous helping of cheese! It really is the best pizza around. They don’t skimp on quality either; their ingredients are all top notch.

I tried a few of their specialty pizzas, such as their Meat Lovers and Veggie Delight. Both were amazing! I can honestly say that it was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life.

In conclusion, Peppino’s Pizza is THE spot to get the best pizza in New Britain CT. If you’re looking for a delicious meal that won’t break the bank, look no further than Peppino’s Pizza!