Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Newington CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Connecticut

Best Pizza in Newington CT (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

120 Views

I’ve been around the world looking for delicious pizza, and I thought I’d give these Newington places a shot. After trying 12 different pizzerias in the city, here’s my pick for the best one.

The tone of this article is lighthearted and humorous. I’m no serious food critic grading restaurants on a curve; I simply want to find good pizza wherever I go! So Newington had better bring its A-game if it wants to stand up to some of Italy’s finest slices.

Let’s dive in and see which pizzeria comes out on top!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Connecticut

#1 Turnpike pizzeria

Let’s start with the crust. The crust was light and fluffy and had that classic pizza flavor that you expect from a top-notch pizzeria. It was cooked to perfection – not too crunchy and not too soft.

Next, let’s talk about the toppings. Turnpike has an impressive selection of toppings, including pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, olives, pineapple – you name it! All the toppings were fresh and had amazing flavor combinations that really made me smile.

The sauce was something special as well. It had just the right amount of spice without being too overpowering. And don’t forget about the cheese – ooey-gooey goodness all around!

All in all, there’s no denying that Turnpike is one of the best pizza places in Newington CT. I can confidently say that you won’t be disappointed if you choose them for your next pizza night out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in New Britain!

#2 Phoenix Pizzeria

The classic cheese pizza was simply delicious – a nice thin crust, perfectly melted cheese and just the right amount of tomato sauce. The veggies were super fresh and flavorful.

I’m also a fan of their specialty pies. My favorites so far are the Philly cheesesteak pizza, the buffalo chicken pizza and the garlic parmesan white pizza. All were cooked to perfection!

The atmosphere is inviting and cozy with a friendly atmosphere. The staff are always quick and helpful too which adds to the enjoyment of eating here.

Overall I would highly recommend Phoenix Pizzeria for anyone who wants a great slice of pizza in Newington CT – you will not be disappointed!

#3 Elm Hill Pizza

My experience at Elm Hill Pizza was certainly a memorable one. From the moment I stepped through the door, I knew that this place wasn’t your average pizzeria. The atmosphere was cheerful and inviting, and the staff went out of their way to ensure that my time there would be enjoyable.

The pizza itself was an absolute delight! The flavorful crust, fresh toppings and zesty sauce were a combination that could not be beat. Their menu offers a variety of classic pies as well as unique creations, so you can satisfy your craving for whatever kind of pizza you’re craving. Not to mention their secret ingredient – love! Whether it’s for lunch or dinner, you can’t go wrong with Elm Hill Pizza’s delicious pies.

I also had the pleasure of meeting some of the owners during my visit, who were more than happy to share stories and tips on how they make their amazing pizzas. They truly care about making sure each customer has a great experience.

If you’re in Newington CT and looking for the best pizza in town (or even in the world!), look no further than Elm Hill Pizza! You won’t regret it!

#4 Yannis Pizza Restaurant

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, with an old-school vibe that I absolutely love. From the vintage ovens to the handmade tables, it all adds a little something extra to the pizza experience.

The menu has a wide variety of options, from classic Italian-style pizzas to more adventurous recipes like their Feta & Spinach Grilled Pizza. Each and every pizza is freshly made with only the freshest ingredients. The crusts are crisp and flavorful, just like a good pizza should be!

The service was top notch as well. Our waiter was friendly and attentive, taking time to explain each item on the menu so we could make an informed decision. He even offered us some of his own favorite recommendations which turned out to be great!

All in all, I must say this is one of the best pizza restaurants I’ve visited in Newington CT! I highly recommend you check it out if you’re ever in the area looking for some delicious pizza!

#5 Town Line Pizza & Restaurant

The pizza is made with quality dough that’s cooked to perfection and topped with a delicious blend of toppings. From the pepperoni and sausage to the broccoli and mushrooms, all of the ingredients are top-notch. The cheese melts perfectly with each bite, adding a wonderful flavor to the pie.

I love the way they’re able to combine different flavors in each slice. Whether it’s a classic combination like pepperoni and mushroom or something more creative like pineapple and jalapeno, Town Line does an excellent job of creating new flavors that pair well together.

The staff at Town Line is super friendly too! They treat you like family from the moment you walk in until you leave. I had a great time chatting with them while waiting for my order, which was delivered quickly.

Finally, I have to mention how generous they are with their portion sizes – you can definitely get full off of one slice! I never leave feeling hungry when I come here.

Overall, Town Line Pizza & Restaurant has been my favorite pizza spot since visiting Newington CT! They offer delicious pies that are cooked perfectly every time and generous portions for an affordable price – it’s no wonder why this place is so popular!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Glastonbury!

#6 Bella Gourmet Pizzeria

When I walked into the restaurant, the manager greeted me with a big smile and immediately seated me at a cozy table for two. The atmosphere was warm and inviting – definitely the kind of place that I could spend hours in.

My order was a large pepperoni pizza, which arrived hot and fresh from the oven. From my first bite, I knew this pizza was special! The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy while the sauce had just the right amount of spice. It was truly delicious!

The toppings were also amazing – there were plenty of juicy pepperonis that added an extra level of flavor to every bite. Every ingredient seemed to be of top quality, making it one of the best pizzas I have ever tasted!

To top it all off, Bella Gourmet Pizzeria offered excellent service – my server was very friendly and attentive throughout my meal. All in all, it was a fantastic experience that left me wanting more. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Newington CT, then look no further than Bella Gourmet Pizzeria!

#7 Joey Garlics’ Newington

I must say that the staff at Joey Garlics’ was incredibly friendly and helpful. The restaurant is cozy and modern, with a nice atmosphere – perfect for grabbing a bite with friends or family after work.

The pizzas themselves were truly remarkable. The crust was perfectly cooked on the outside, but still had a fluffy bite on the inside. The sauce was like nothing I have ever tasted before – robust and rich in flavor, yet well balanced in taste. To top it all off, the toppings would make any foodie weak in the knees – fresh vegetables and herbs, thick cuts of meats and cheeses that melted perfectly together into one cohesive flavor medley.

As a food critic who has tried pizza from all over the world, I can confidently say that my experience at Joey Garlics’ Newington was one of my best pizza experiences to date! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Newington CT, look no further than Joey Garlics’!

#8 Newington Pizza Restaurant

Upon walking in, I felt like I was magically transported to the best pizzeria in Naples. The decor is simple but cozy, and it smells like a pizza oven heaven.

When it comes to the pizza itself, Newington Pizza Restaurant never fails to impress. They use the freshest ingredients, such as locally sourced tomatoes and mozzarella cheese, giving their pies an unparalleled flavor. Every bite is crispy yet still light on the stomach.

The staff at this establishment are always courteous and welcoming no matter how busy they are. They go out of their way to make customers feel at home, making sure that everyone leaves with their stomachs full and hearts happy.

Overall, Newington Pizza Restaurant lives up to its reputation for having some of the best pizza around! If you’re ever in Newington CT and have a hankering for good pie then look no further!

#9 TJ’s on Cedar

I stopped by one night, expecting to be disappointed, but I was pleasantly surprised. The restaurant looks humble on the outside, but inside it’s got a cozy atmosphere with friendly staff that really make you feel at home.

The pizza is really something special – the crust is thin and crispy, and the flavors are great. You can actually taste the quality of ingredients that go into each slice. They’ve got everything from classic pepperoni and cheese to more unique creations like feta and spinach.

I’m going to have to let everyone know about TJ’s – this place really does serve up some of the best pizza in Newington CT! If you’re ever in town, don’t hesitate to give them a try – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Hartford!

#10 Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

I was skeptical at first, but after one bite I was in pizza heaven. The crust was light and airy, the sauce had a perfect balance between sweet and tart and the cheese was oozing with flavor.

The service was great too! Our server was friendly and attentive. He even threw in a free sample of their trademark white clam pizza. It’s definitely worth ordering if you’re looking for something unique.

Overall, I can confidently say that Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana has some of the best pizza in Newington CT! If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, this is the place to be. Bon Appétit!

#11 Village Pizza & Halal Restaurant

I have tried a variety of pizzas over the years, but nothing can compare to the pizza I found here. The dough was perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of crunch. Additionally, they seemed to be able to capture the perfect balance between sweetness and saltiness when it came to their toppings. I could definitely taste the freshness in every bite!

Most importantly though, I loved their welcoming atmosphere. Everyone I met was so friendly and accommodating that it felt like being at home – except with much better pizza.

The service was also top-notch. My order came out quickly and there were no issues at all with my takeout order. The waitstaff was knowledgable about all their menu items and were able to recommend a great selection for me based on my tastes.

Overall, my experience at Village Pizza & Halal Restaurant was fantastic – from start to finish! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Newington CT, then this is definitely the place to go!

#12 Nicolas Pizza & Mexican Eatery

I love the fact that they offer both Mexican and pizza dishes, making it really convenient to satisfy my cravings for both in one spot. The pizza crust is perfectly crisp and thin, with ample amounts of flavorful tomato sauce and melted cheese that always hits the spot. They also offer a wide variety of toppings so I’m never limited when creating my perfect pizza.

The first time I visited this cozy little eatery, I chose their classic margarita pizza. It was simply delicious! But what really sets Nicolas Pizza & Mexican Eatery apart from all the other pizzerias out there is their unique spin on classic flavors; they offer more than just your usual pepperoni or mushroom pizzas. For instance, one of their signature pizzas includes roasted red peppers, goat cheese, pesto sauce, and spinach – an innovative combination that comes together flawlessly.

Not only does Nicolas Pizza & Mexican Eatery serve up some of the best pizza in Newington CT, but their customer service is second-to-none! Every time I’ve ordered from them, my food has been delivered quickly and warm to my door – which is always such a treat! The staff is genuinely friendly too; I can tell they take real pride in their delicious cooking.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Newington CT then Nicolas Pizza & Mexican Eatery should be at the top of your list! Trust me – you won’t be disappointed!