I’ve been searching the world for the best pizzas, from Naples to New York City, but it turns out that there’s something special cooking up in Niagara Falls. After sampling twelve different pizza places in this small city, I have found some real gems.
Let me tell you about my journey through Niagara Falls’ delicious pizza offerings and the final verdict on which pizzeria reigns supreme! I can assure you that this will be an entertaining adventure filled with cheesy goodness. So get ready to take a bite out of Niagara Falls – no passport required!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York
#1 Buck’s Pizzeria
The first thing I noticed was the incredibly inviting and friendly atmosphere. The staff was welcoming and the environment was cozy and inviting – it felt like home.
When it came time to order, I had a hard time deciding what to get! Their menu featured plenty of delicious options for me to choose from. In the end, I decided on their specialty pizza – The Big Buck! It arrived shortly after ordering and it was worth every penny! The crust was perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of crunchiness. On top, there was a generous layer of gooey cheese topped with a multitude of tasty toppings. The overall flavor profile is unique, yet still familiar enough that I craved more bites as soon as my pizza plate was empty!
Overall, my experience at Buck’s Pizzeria was nothing short of amazing. From start to finish they exceeded expectations and delivered some of the best pizza in Niagara Falls NY! Highly recommended!
If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Buffalo!
#2 Pizza Oven
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere here is both cozy and energetic, whether you’re dining in or getting takeout. The staff members are always polite and friendly, which adds to the charm of this pizza establishment.
The pizza itself is outstanding – from the perfectly crispy crust to the delicious toppings, it’s truly mouthwatering. I especially recommend their pepperoni pizza! It’s got that perfect balance of flavor and texture that you just don’t find anywhere else.
Not only does Pizza Oven make great pizzas, but their other menu items are all excellent too. Their pastas and salads are especially noteworthy – generous servings of fresh ingredients that will make your taste buds dance with joy!
All in all, Pizza Oven is definitely one of the best pizza places in Niagara Falls NY – a must-visit if you want an unforgettable Italian dinner experience!
#3 Ghada Have It! Mediterranean Home Cooking
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
This restaurant has something for everyone, whether you like thick crust or thin, traditional toppings or something more exotic. My personal favorite was the “Niagara Falls,” which had all the classic toppings (mozzarella, pepperoni and black olives) with a twist—it was topped off with cream cheese!
The atmosphere at this place is fantastic. It has an old-world charm that makes you feel like you’ve been transported to Italy. The staff are friendly and welcoming, too! They truly make you feel at home.
The prices are also reasonable, even for locals. I tried two of their pizzas—one cheese pizza and one specialty pie—and it only cost me around $30. That’s a steal!
If you’re ever in Niagara Falls NY, Ghada Have It! Mediterranean Home Cooking is definitely the place to go for delicious pizza. I highly recommend it—I’m confident you won’t be disappointed!
#4 Donatello’s
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
From the moment you enter the restaurant, it’s clear that the owners have gone all-out to provide a top-notch dining experience. The décor is elegant but relaxed, and the staff are attentive and friendly.
Most importantly though, the pizza is just outstanding. It’s made with fresh ingredients, sprinkled with just the right amount of cheese, and cooked to perfection. Every time I’ve visited Donatello’s, I’ve been thoroughly impressed by their pies.
I’m especially partial to their signature specialty pizza – which comes loaded with succulent mushrooms and sweet peppers – but they also have plenty of classic options like pepperoni that are sure to please. Plus, their weekly specials offer something new to try each time you visit!
Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Niagara Falls NY then you owe it to yourself to go to Donatello’s!
#5 Leon’s Italian Bistro & Pizza
- Serves alcohol
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The first thing I noticed when I stepped into Leon’s was the delicious aroma that hung in the air of fresh dough, cheese, and bubbling tomato sauce. After ordering a large pizza and taking my seat, I waited with anticipation.
When the pizza arrived, I could tell it was freshly made with incredible attention to detail – from the perfectly charred edges of the crust to the topping combinations that burst with flavor. Every bite was a delight!
What really sets Leon’s apart is their use of creative toppings – from roasted corn to crispy bacon and spinach – so you can be sure you won’t find anything ordinary here. They’ve put together some amazing concoctions that have won them awards for some of the best pizzas in Niagara Falls NY.
The staff at Leon’s are friendly and helpful too, so you know you’ll be well taken care of no matter what kind of pizza experience you’re looking for. All in all, if you’re after a fantastic pizza experience (and maybe an award-winning meal), Leon’s Italian Bistro & Pizza should definitely be your go-to choice!
#6 Brando’s Pizza & Wings – Niagara Falls
- Offers dessert
I didn’t think anything could top the pizza I had in Naples, Italy but this place comes pretty close. The crust was thin, perfectly charred and incredibly flavorful – just the way I like it. They offer an impressive selection of toppings and the quality is top notch. Everything from the classic pepperoni to some truly unique creations like truffle oil and porcini mushrooms – there’s something for everyone here.
The wings are also out of this world! The sauce is sticky and sweet with just a hint of heat that kicks you right in the taste buds. Plus, they’re served with a generous side of ranch – because why not? Even if you don’t like wings, you won’t be disappointed by the garlic knots or cheesy breadsticks.
And lastly, I have to mention the service — it was friendly, helpful and fast. The staff was always willing to answer any questions we had and make sure we left satisfied. Even their take-out orders come in an awesome box that’s sure to generate some Instagram likes!
Overall, Brando’s Pizza & Wings – Niagara Falls has earned its title as one of the best pizza places in Niagara Falls NY. If you’re ever in town, do yourself a favor and stop by for lunch or dinner – trust me, you won’t regret it!
#7 Michael’s Restaurant
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
- No delivery
The atmosphere was great and I felt right at home. Not only that, but they have a kid’s menu which is perfect if you’re bringing the little ones along! They also serve beer and wine, so it’s a great spot for adults to enjoy as well.
The pizza itself was simply delicious! It was cooked perfectly with just enough cheese and the toppings were fresh. There are plenty of options on the menu too, so there’s something for everyone. The downside is that there isn’t an option for pizza delivery unfortunately, but being able to visit this restaurant in person is a nice touch.
As if the pizza wasn’t enough, they also offer desserts! I got their chocolate cake which was absolutely divine.
Overall, I highly recommend Michael’s Restaurant for anyone looking for the best pizza in Niagara Falls NY!
#8 Joey’s Pizzeria
- Serves alcohol
On my visit to Joey’s, I was met with friendly service from the moment I stepped through the door. The servers were happy to explain their varied menu and offer me samples of their different creations.
The pizza itself was incredible, with a perfectly crunchy crust and all the toppings flawlessly balanced. Every bite was better than the last, with so much flavor exploding in my mouth that I couldn’t help but moan with pleasure.
But it wasn’t just about the pizza: Joey’s also had an impressive selection of salads, sandwiches, and sides to boot. The Italian sub I had was a nice contrast in texture and flavor compared to my pizza dinner.
What sets Joey’s apart is how they combine excellent service with top-notch ingredients. After tasting my way around Niagara Falls NY, there’s no doubt that Joey’s Pizzeria serves up some of the best pizza in town!
If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Amherst!
#9 Mr. Ventry’s Pizza on the Boulevard
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
I was amazed by their extensive menu of specialty pizzas and delicious toppings. They even offer vegan options for those who don’t eat meat.
The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, perfect for a night out with family or friends. The waiters and waitresses were friendly and helpful, making sure that our experience was enjoyable.
But the best part of my meal was definitely the pizza itself! It had just the right amount of crispy crust and cheesy goodness that made it simply irresistible. The tomato sauce was flavorful and fresh, and the toppings were cooked to perfection.
Overall, I’d highly recommend Mr. Ventry’s Pizza on the Boulevard if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Niagara Falls NY!
#10 The Original Ventry’s Pizza Shop
- Nice tourist spot
I’m not talking about one of those boring, run-of-the-mill pizza chains. The Original Ventry’s Pizza Shop is an independent restaurant that has been in the area for over 30 years and they know how to make delicious, classic pizzas.
As soon as I tasted their crusty New York Style pizza my taste buds sang with joy! It was perfectly crispy on the outside and light and airy on the inside. Topped with the freshest tomatoes, basil, and a drizzle of olive oil it made for a delightful slice! Not to mention their marinara sauce is to die for!
But if you aren’t a fan of traditional NY style pizza then don’t worry. The Original Ventry’s Pizza Shop offers so many other options like deep dish Sicilian or Southwestern themed pies featuring jalapenos and green peppers – yum! Their signature Quattro Formaggio pizza is also incredible – four cheeses topped off with roasted garlic – divine! And did I mention their dessert pizzas? Absolutely incredible.
The best part about this place though is not just the amazing food but also the atmosphere. The staff are friendly, courteous, and couldn’t be more willing to help you choose from the vast selection of pizzas.
If you are wondering where to find the best pizza in Niagara Falls NY then look no further than The Original Ventry’s Pizza Shop – you won’t regret it!
#11 716 supreme subs
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere is warm and inviting. I love the red-checkered tablecloths and the family-friendly vibe. The staff are always so friendly and welcoming, truly making it a great place to enjoy a good meal with friends and family.
The food, of course, is what makes 716 supreme subs stand out from the rest. The pizza is one of the best I’ve ever had – they use only top quality ingredients and it always comes out perfectly cooked! The crust is light yet crispy and the flavors of cheese and tomato blend together to perfection.
There’s also plenty of other options on the menu – from salads to subs – so there’s something for everyone at 716 supreme subs. As an added bonus, you can get some amazing homemade garlic knots – a must try!
Overall, I highly recommend 716 supreme subs for anyone looking for delicious pizza in Niagara Falls NY! You’ll definitely leave feeling fully satisfied.
#12 Mario’s Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
The pizza here is simply divine. The crust is thin, just the way I like it, and the cheese is a perfect blend of mozzarella and cheddar that melts in your mouth. The sauce is perfectly balanced between sweet and savory and complements the cheese wonderfully.
The toppings are likewise excellent – I had a pepperoni pizza this time which was delicious! They use fresh, flavorful ingredients that really allow the flavor to shine through.
I’ve passed through Niagara Falls several times on my travels, and each time I make an attempt to visit Mario’s Pizza for another taste of their amazing food! Not to mention that Mario’s Pizza always has friendly service that helps make the experience truly enjoyable.
To anyone looking for the best pizza in Niagara Falls NY, look no further than Mario’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!
