Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Punta Gorda (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Punta Gorda (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

184 Views

I’m always looking for the best pizza around the world – and after scouring Punta Gorda I’ve narrowed it down to 12 of my top choices. My pizza-filled travels have taken me from Italy, to France and even as far away as Australia, so I feel confident in my opinions.

The pizzas that made the cut are all unique in their own way – a variety of crusts, sauces, ingredients and more. Whether you’re looking for a traditional Italian-style pizza or something new and creative, this list has it all. Let’s find out which Punta Gorda pizzerias I’ve deemed to be the “Best Pizza in Punta Gorda!”

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Wildwood Pizza

From the first sip of beer to the last slice, every ounce of flavor was packed into my experience at Wildwood Pizza. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the staff was extremely friendly.

The pizza was out-of-this-world good! The crust was perfectly crisp with just the right amount of crunch, while the cheese melted perfectly in my mouth. Every bite oozed with flavor and I couldn’t help but savor every moment (even though I knew there were more pizzas waiting!).

The toppings were creative and delicious. From pineapple upside down pizza to bacon cheeseburger pizza, it’s clear that Wildwood Pizza isn’t afraid of trying new things. My favorite topping combo had to be their pepperoni and feta – a classic Italian combination with a unique twist!

Overall, this is definitely one of the best pizza places in Punta Gorda – if you’re ever in town, I highly recommend you give it a try. You won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Port Charlotte!

#2 Piccolo Italian Restaurant

I was blown away by the flavor and crust of the pizza – thin, crispy and oh-so-delicious. The vegetarian options are also worth trying, with loads of fresh veggies that are sure to satisfy.

And let’s talk about the desserts – they may be insane, but in a good way! Served hot and gooey, they made my evening a real treat.

On the downside, this restaurant doesn’t deliver. But if you can make it to Punta Gorda, no doubt it’s worth it! The atmosphere is perfect for tourists, with live music playing and plenty of alcohol to choose from.

In conclusion, I highly recommend Piccolo Italian Restaurant if you’re looking for some of the best pizza around Punta Gorda. You get an experience fit for a food critic!

#3 Pizza Gorda

The restaurant has a great atmosphere, with the perfect blend of tourist spot and local hangout. Plus, they serve alcohol and have some vegetarian options available.

The food was outstanding! Their crust is perfectly thin and crisp, while their sauce is bold and flavorful. The combinations of toppings are imaginative yet remain true to the classic pizza flavors we all know and love. If you’re feeling adventurous, try one of their specialty pies – you won’t regret it!

Their dessert options are heavenly as well (definitely save room for something sweet after your main course)! Even for someone who’s tried pizza all over the world, I can honestly say that Pizza Gorda stands out.

My only complaint would be that they don’t offer delivery – which can be a bummer when you just want to stay in for dinner and not make a night out of it. But other than that, this place really is the best pizza in Punta Gorda!

#4 Pioneers Pizza Port Charlotte

I was so excited when I stumbled upon Pioneers Pizza. The quaint, rustic dining room and friendly staff made me feel welcome from the moment I walked in.

The pizza itself was out of this world! It had a perfect thin crust and the unique selection of toppings made it unlike anything I’d ever tried before. The specialty ‘Pioneers Pizza’ not only had sausage, pepperoni, and mushrooms but also added a unique twist with bacon bits. The cheese was perfectly melted and the sauce balanced the flavors perfectly.

Aside from the food, there’s also a great selection of beer to choose from which is always a plus for me!

All-in-all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Punta Gorda then you have to visit Pioneers Pizza Port Charlotte at least once! You won’t regret it!

#5 Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza

I know what you’re thinking: “Punta Gorda, Florida? Is there even good pizza there?” But I’m here to tell you that Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza has truly outdone themselves.

The atmosphere is unlike any other pizza joint I’ve been to. The walls are covered with fun old-school decorations and the staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Plus, they offer a great selection of craft beers and wines to enjoy while you wait for your pizza.

But the real star of the show is the pizza! With fresh ingredients, expertly crafted doughs, and creative toppings, Brooklyn Joe’s has some of the best pizza in Punta Gorda–and possibly even in all of Florida! The slices are perfectly thin yet crispy on the edges, with just enough sauce and a generous amount of cheese that melts perfectly together.

If you’re ever in Punta Gorda looking for an amazing slice of pizza, look no further than Brooklyn Joe’s!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in North Port!

#6 Santa Lucia Pizzeria & Restaurant

It’s been a while since I tried pizza like this – with ingredients that were so fresh and flavorful. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with just the right amount of char on the edges. It’s light enough that you don’t feel weighed down after eating, but still fulfilling enough to satisfy a pizza craving.

The toppings were also as incredible as the crust. Everything from classic pepperoni to more exotic options like pineapples and artichoke hearts were available, and each one was cooked to perfection. Just be sure to get extra napkins… the pizzas are so delicious that they usually leave you with some sauce on your face!

Most importantly though, Santa Lucia Pizzeria & Restaurant provides a cozy atmosphere that makes it great for date night or grabbing a meal with friends. All in all, I’d have to give it five stars – best pizza in Punta Gorda!

#7 Pioneers Pizza Punta Gorda

The atmosphere at Pioneers Pizza is great. You can tell the staff takes immense pride in what they do and that makes for a special dining experience. Plus, the restaurant has a cool rustic vibe going on with the dim lighting and wooden decor.

Now onto the most important part: The pizza! I’ve tried all sorts of pies from around the globe but nothing comes close to Pioneers Pizza – it’s truly some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! The crust is so tasty, fluffy, and flavorful; it has just enough crunch to keep you wanting more. The toppings are fresh and cooked perfectly; you can definitely taste each individual ingredient used on pizza.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for an incredible pizza experience here in Punta Gorda then Pioneers Pizza should be your go-to spot. It certainly deserves its title as the best pizza in town!

#8 Dough Bar Pizza Pasta

I must say, I was quite impressed. The margherita pizza had a perfectly crisp yet chewy crust, with just the right toppings for a classic Italian pizza. And the flavor! Oh my, it was divine.

The pepperoni pizza was also amazing. The homemade sauce had a delightful sweetness to it that balanced out all of the spicy flavors from the pepperoni and cheeses perfectly. Plus, the dough was just so light and fluffy—it almost melted in my mouth!

And then there’s their traditional white pizza. Wow! This one really blew me away—the perfect balance between creamy ricotta, salty parmesan, and flavorful garlic made this pie a true winner. One bite and I was hooked!

It’s no wonder Dough Bar Pizza Pasta is known for having some of the best pizza in Punta Gorda. Their quality ingredients, tasty recipes, and dedication to creating delicious food make this place an absolute must-try for any pizza lover out there. Highly recommended!

#9 Ks Family Pizzeria & Restaurant

The service at Ks Family Pizzeria & Restaurant is top notch. From the moment I walked in the door, the staff were friendly and attentive, making sure that my experience was nothing short of amazing.

The menu at Ks Family Pizzeria & Restaurant is expansive, showcasing a variety of pizza options to suit whatever preference you have. I had the #1 house special, which was a delicious blend of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, olives and onions – it was truly divine! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, while still maintaining its structural integrity throughout eating. The flavors of the toppings worked together perfectly – nothing was overpowered or gone unnoticed.

I must also mention their salads and desserts because they are just as good as their pizzas! I had a classic caesar salad that was incredibly fresh, crunchy and flavorful. To top off my evening meal, I indulged in their hand-crafted tiramisu that melted in my mouth with every bite.

Ks Family Pizzeria & Restaurant has earned itself a spot in my heart for best pizza in Punta Gorda – you really must try it for yourself to truly understand why!

If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Englewood!

#10 Domino’s Pizza

This wasn’t an easy judgment to come to – I’ve experienced the delights of authentic Italian pizza and the best that New York City has to offer. But Domino’s Pizza truly impressed me.

First, let’s talk about the crust. It was perfectly thin and crispy with a hint of garlic – just enough to give it that extra special kick! Next, the sauce was sweet and savory at the same time; even though it was full of flavor, it didn’t overpower the toppings. Finally, Domino’s Pizza toppings were spot on. Every bite had something different in it – from juicy pepperoni to tangy mushrooms, there was something for everyone.

It goes without saying that their delivery time was prompt too (which is a huge plus!). All in all, if you’re looking for quality pizza in Punta Gorda then Domino’s Pizza should be your go-to place!

#11 Vic’s Primo Pizza and Restaurant

The pizza is made with only the freshest ingredients, so each bite is full of flavor and texture. The crust is perfectly crisp on the outside yet chewy in the middle, and the sauce has just the right amount of garlicky kick to it. And I’m always impressed with how generous they are with the cheese – it’s gooey, melted goodness as far as I can see!

But what really sets Vic’s Primo Pizza apart from other pizza places besides its heavenly taste? Well, their standout feature has to be their friendly atmosphere. It doesn’t matter if you come alone or with a group; everyone will be welcomed with a smile and all your needs will be taken care of promptly.

If you’re looking for some delicious slices in Punta Gorda to share with friends or family, then Vic’s Primo Pizza and Restaurant should definitely be your first choice! Try it out today –You won’t regret it!

#12 Manatees Pizza

As soon as I stepped through the door, it was clear that this was the place for the best pizza in town. The smells of fresh dough and delicious toppings filled the air and I knew my search was over.

The atmosphere at Manatees Pizza is nothing short of incredible – vibrant colors, classic music playing in the background, and friendly employees make for a memorable experience. But of course, the real star of the show is still to come: The pizza!

When it came time to choose my topping combination, I was delighted by the extensive selection they offer. From classic pepperoni to buffalo chicken sauces and creative veggie toppings – There’s something for everyone! At long last, after an exhaustive selection process (it truly took hours), I had finally made up my mind – Supreme with extra mushrooms and jalapeños.

And what a decision it was! Before too long my order arrived piping hot out of the oven. One bite into this cheesy masterpiece and I knew without a doubt why Manatees Pizza is considered one of Punta Gorda’s best pizzerias. The perfect blend of crunchy crust, savory sauce, ooey-gooey cheese, and zesty veggies was enough to make me want more!

So there you have it – my review says it all – Manatees Pizza has some of the best pizza in Punta Gorda. Whether you’re looking for a quick slice or a full meal with your friends, you won’t be disappointed visiting this great pizzeria!