Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Suffolk County (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Suffolk County (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

789 Views

I did some serious research and sampled 12 of the best pizza places in the area. After analyzing ingredients, crust texture, and flavor, I’ve determined which pizzas should top your list.

While I’m usually quite serious about my food reviews, this one was a bit more lighthearted. So get ready to find out which pizzas you need to try in Suffolk County!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Vincents_NYWF_Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant is a nice tourist spot, perfect for New York City visitors looking for a unique and delicious experience. The people behind the counter are always friendly, and my orders are always prepared quickly. Whenever I sit down in their dining room, the servers make sure to check on me often to make sure that my meal is enjoyable.

I have sampled several of their pies over the years, but one favorite is their Margherita pizza. The crust is thin and crispy with just the right amount of char to give it an extra layer of flavor. On top they layer freshly-grated mozzarella cheese, slices of ripe tomatoes, drizzles of extra virgin olive oil, and dabs of fragrant basil leaves. It’s heavenly!

Vincents_NYWF_Pizza has some other treats as well, like their delectable Pepperoni Salami pizza or their more adventurous Bacon & Egg Pizza. Whether you’re having an early morning snack or a late night indulgence (my personal favorite), Vincents_NYWF_Pizza has something special for everyone!

My only complaint about this establishment is that delivery is not available; however, it’s worth making a trip here to get some of the best pizza in Suffolk County!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Deer Park!

#2 Mozzafiato Pizzeria

My first visit to Mozzafiato Pizzeria was nothing short of delightful. I started off with a classic Margherita pizza, and the flavor combination of fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil was simply sublime. I was in pizza heaven!

The next time I visited the restaurant, I decided to get adventurous and try something new – a Sicilian-style pizza. It was made with homemade dough served thick and crunchy, bursting with olives, anchovies, capers, oregano and more. Wow!

I’ve also had the pleasure of trying their creamy ricotta calzones, which were stuffed to perfection with ricotta cheese and all kinds of tasty veggies. So yummy!

All in all, Mozzafiato Pizzeria has some of the best pizza around – definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in Suffolk County. With delicious antipasti plates to start the meal off right, plus fantastic desserts like tiramisu (for those who have room for it), you really can’t go wrong at this wonderful Italian eatery. Delicious!

#3 Angela’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere at Angela’s is warm and inviting, with a rustic charm that puts you in the mood for some Italian delicacies. The staff were incredibly friendly and eager to help me find just the right pizza.

The pizza itself was absolutely delicious! Perfectly cooked with a thin crust, not too greasy, and topping combinations that were out of this world. I tried the classic margarita as well as some speciality toppings like pineapple and chorizo, and both were cooked to perfection.

I have to say, I’m officially in love with Angela’s Pizzeria – it’s the closest thing there is to tasting the best pizza in Italy without actually having to go there! If you’re looking for a great place for pizza in Suffolk County, Angela’s is definitely worth checking out.

#4 Giovanni’s Pizza In Commack

The moment I stepped through the door of Giovanni’s, I was met with a warm, inviting atmosphere and the smell of freshly baked pies. The staff were friendly and made sure that I felt welcomed.

The pizzas here are simply amazing. From classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese to more creative options like Hawaiian, there’s something for everyone. All the toppings were fresh and perfectly balanced. The crust was thin and crispy, but still held up well to all the toppings; it had a nice crunch when you bit into it!

The presentation of each pizza was also beautiful – they look almost too good to eat! And best of all, the prices here are very reasonable so it makes for a great meal without breaking the bank.

Overall, if you’re in Suffolk County (or anywhere else) looking for delicious pizza, then Giovanni’s Pizza In Commack is definitely worth checking out!

#5 Gino’s Pizzeria

I recently visited Gino’s and was thoroughly impressed by the menu, which offers traditional pizzas like New York-style cheese and pepperoni, as well as some more innovative options like buffalo chicken with blue cheese and Mediterranean vegetable. Even though I’m usually one to opt for the classic choices, I was feeling adventurous and went for the latter – and it was exquisite! The flavors were bursting in my mouth with every bite.

The atmosphere at Gino’s is also quite charming. It’s a casual spot that has a cozy feel with its brick walls trimmed with strings of twinkling lights. And it doesn’t hurt that you get a view of the open kitchen while you dine.

But what really sets Gino’s apart from other pizza places is their fast service – they have a true commitment to customer satisfaction and always make sure your food arrives hot, fresh, and right on time.

To sum up my experience at Gino’s Pizzeria: it had the best pizza in Suffolk County, a unique atmosphere, great service, and an overall fantastic experience. Do yourself a favor and make sure to check it out!

#6 Ciro’s Pizza

What started out as a small family-owned pizzeria in the heart of Long Island has grown into an empire of deliciousness, with Ciro’s now serving up award-winning pies in multiple locations across the county.

I’ve had the pleasure of sampling pizza from their flagship location in Long Island, and let me tell you – it did not disappoint! From their classic Margherita to their unique gourmet creations like the ‘Truffle Delight’, every bite was sheer perfection. The crust was crispy while still retaining some chewiness, and the flavors were bold and undeniably delicious.

But what really sets Ciro’s apart is its commitment to making sure each customer leaves with a smile on their face. There’s always a friendly face behind the counter, ready to take your order or make recommendations based on your tastes. It’s clear they put a lot of effort into creating a pleasant dining experience for all sorts of customers.

All told, I can confidently say that Ciro’s is one of Suffolk County’s best pizza places – hands down! Whether you’re looking for something classic or creative, you won’t be disappointed by their mouthwatering selection.

#7 Colosseo Pizza

The first thing that struck me when walking into the restaurant was the aroma. It was as if a pizza had been baking in the oven all day just waiting for me to arrive. I could have stopped right there, but I decided to take a seat and sample some of their famous pies.

I opted for the classic pepperoni pizza, which arrived quickly due to their skilled and speedy kitchen staff. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, and the sauce was rich and flavorful. The cheese was gooey and melted just right, while the pepperoni added an unforgettable kick of flavor.

The pizza at Colosseo Pizza left my taste buds wanting more – so much so that I ordered an extra slice for the road! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Suffolk County, then look no further than Colosseo Pizza!

#8 Miseno Pizza

The crust on their pizzas is light and crispy, with just the perfect amount of bubbling cheese. Their toppings are always fresh, and they have an amazing selection of meats, vegetables, and herbs to choose from.

My favorite part about Miseno Pizza though is the atmosphere. There’s a laid-back vibe that I really appreciate – no fancy tablecloths or expensive wine lists here! Plus, they always have great music playing in the background and really friendly staff who are happy to answer any questions you might have.

I would highly recommend Miseno Pizza to anyone looking for the best pizza in Suffolk County (which, let’s face it, is pretty hard to find). If you’re looking for amazing pizza in a relaxed atmosphere then this is definitely the place for you!

If you’re willing to go an extra 18 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Huntington!

#9 The Pie at Salvatore’s

The environment of the restaurant is perfect for a nice pizza night out. The atmosphere is lively yet laidback and the waitstaff is always friendly and helpful. The decor has an old-school Italian vibe to it which only adds to the overall experience.

As far as the pizzas go, they are some of my favorites! The crusts are perfectly crisp on the outside and soft on the inside, giving each slice that amazing texture we all love so much. All of the toppings are fresh and flavorful and there’s something for everyone – from classic meats to unique veg options.

Now here comes the best part – The Pie at Salvatore’s also offers a variety of specialty pies that will make your mouth water! Whether you’re looking for a classic cheese or something more adventurous like their buffalo chicken pie, you’ll find something delicious here.

My favorite part about The Pie at Salvatore’s has to be the price; it’s very reasonable considering how high quality and delicious their pizza is!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Suffolk County, then look no further than The Pie at Salvatore’s. You won’t regret it!

#10 Pizza Rita

The experience was spectacular. From the moment I stepped into Pizza Rita, I was treated like royalty. The welcoming staff, who knew my name before I walked in, immediately took me to my seat and provided a delicious complementary appetizer platter.

The pizza? Incredible. This was honestly some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! The crust was light and crispy, the tomato sauce was flavorful and generously applied, and their selection of toppings is vast enough to satisfy even the pickiest of eaters.

My favorite part of the meal though has to be their unique pizzas. If you have a daring appetite like myself, you must try them! One in particular that stands out is their Chicken Bacon Waffle Pizza – it’s as delicious as it sounds!

All in all, Pizza Rita definitely lives up to its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Suffolk County. If you’re ever in the area, don’t miss this place – you won’t regret it!

#11 Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe

When I arrived at Donatina, the first thing that struck me was the incredible atmosphere – it felt like a real Italian countryside pizzeria. The walls were decorated with pictures from Naples and the staff was friendly and welcoming.

The pizza was out of this world! It had the perfect amount of crispness on the outside, and a silky smooth texture on the inside – just like a true Neapolitan pizza should be. Of course, I thoroughly enjoyed sampling all of their delicious topping combinations – my favorite being the classic Margherita pizza.

The service at Donatina was top notch as well. The waiters were attentive, efficient, and eager to make sure my experience there was perfect. And guess what? It totally was!

I have no doubt that Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe will continue to be one of the best places in Suffolk County for delicious Neapolitan-style pizza. Cin cin!

#12 Umberto’s of Sayville

I stopped in for lunch last week and let me say, it was the best pizza experience I’ve ever had. The atmosphere was warm and inviting as soon as I stepped through the doors. From the wood-paneled walls to the brick ovens, everything screamed “authentic Italian pizzeria”.

The menu was immense – from classic Margherita pies to pizzas topped with fresh clams or fancy gourmet ingredients – there was something for everyone. But I decided to stick with the house specialty: a thick-crust Sicilian pie loaded with tomatoes, garlic, and herbs. The pizza was cooked to perfection – it had a great crunchy crust on the outside and chewy center on the inside. The tomato sauce was bursting with flavor and complemented perfectly by the herbs and cheese.

All in all, this place makes some of the best pizza in Suffolk County and it’s definitely worth checking out!