Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in West Lafayette (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Indiana

Best Pizza in West Lafayette (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

105 Views

I’ve tasted pizza all around the world and now I’m ready to share my findings about the best pizza in West Lafayette. After eating at 12 pizza places throughout the city, I know what’s worth trying and what isn’t.

It’s time to find out where your next slice of deliciousness should come from! Join me for an adventure into not only some of the most incredible food you’ll ever taste but also a humorous – and sometimes heated – exploration of which spots reign supreme.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 Pizza Uncommon

When I arrived at Pizza Uncommon, there was a certain excitement in the air – from the flavorful aroma of their pizza to the joyful chatter of their patrons. The pizzas here are crafted with love and attention to detail, using only the freshest ingredients. The presentation of each pie is almost artful, making it difficult not to take a few snaps with my phone before devouring it!

The first pizza I had was the Supreme Pie – and boy, let me tell you – this was one delicious slice! Every bite was full of flavor and texture, as it had been cooked perfectly with just the right amount of cheese and toppings. Another favorite (which I could hardly stop eating) was the Spinach & Ricotta Combo. Unlike many spinach pies I’ve tried elsewhere, this one actually tasted like something special. With plenty of ricotta cheese mixed into the spinach topping, it’s a unique combination that’s certainly worth trying!

The best part about Pizza Uncommon is that their crusts range from thin-crust to deep-dish – so you’ll definitely find something to fit your cravings. Their prices are also incredibly reasonable for what you get – making them an ideal spot for large groups or families on a budget.

In short – if you’re ever looking for great pizza in West Lafayette then Pizza Uncommon should be at the top of your list!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Lafayette!

#2 Snuggs Pizza

I was particularly impressed with the atmosphere at Snuggs Pizza. They had a great selection of beers on tap, as well as an impressive list of hard liquors. As a vegetarian, I was also pleased to see they had some creative vegetarian options.

The pies themselves were tasty and perfectly charred. The crust was crisp yet fluffy and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

Although there are many great things about this pizza joint, one thing that would be nice is if they offered delivery or takeout options. That being said, I highly recommend stopping by for some good ‘za! In my opinion, it’s the best pizza in West Lafayette!

#3 Azzip Pizza

To begin, the atmosphere is warm and inviting. The walls are decorated with vibrant murals that transport you to another world – or at least to a different zip code!

The menu has something for everyone. Classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese, as well as a selection of creative pies such as The Godfather (a white pizza topped with roasted red peppers, feta cheese, olives, garlic and basil). They even have gluten-free options!

But what really impressed me is the quality of their ingredients. From the thick hand-tossed crust to the fresh vegetables and perfectly melted cheese, it’s obvious that they take pride in making sure their pizza is always delicious.

Overall, Azzip Pizza is definitely the best place in West Lafayette to get your pizza fix. There’s something for everyone here – from classic toppings to the more adventurous – so don’t miss out on this slice of culinary heaven!

#4 Bruno’s Pizza and Big O’s Sports Room

I visited Bruno’s for a late lunch and found a great place to watch sports. I enjoyed the fanfare of the loud sports bar atmosphere while munching on my delicious pizza.

The menu had plenty of options for everyone including vegetarian-friendly offerings, and hard liquor drinks for those looking for something extra in their meal. But the highlight was definitely the dessert – it was insanely good! All in all, it was a great experience that made me feel like a kid again.

I only have one small complaint – there’s no delivery service. That’s probably not an issue if you’re in West Lafayette, but just be aware if you’re out of town and need to order some pizza.

If you’re visiting West Lafayette and looking for the best pizza around, make sure to pay Bruno’s Pizza and Big O’s Sports Room a visit soon!

#5 The Pickle

When I first walked in, I noticed that The Pickle had a kids menu, which is great for families. They also offer vegetarian options and dessert, so there’s something for everyone. The atmosphere was inviting and it made for a nice tourist spot.

The food is why most people come here though. Their signature pickle slices were delicious and unlike any pizza I’ve ever tried before! My only complaint was that they don’t offer delivery, so if you want the best pizza in West Lafayette, you’ll have to visit The Pickle yourself.

Overall, I highly recommend The Pickle — it’s worth the trip!

#6 Greek’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, with the bright red and blue walls taking me back to my childhood days. The staff was warm and welcoming, with smiles on their faces as they served up delicious slices of their signature pies.

Their menu offered a wide range of classic pizzas and unique specialty pies that all had something truly special about them. I opted for a classic pepperoni slice and let me tell you – it was divine! The crust was thin and crispy, yet chewy at the same time. It was topped with generous helpings of house-made sauce, rich mozzarella cheese, and salty pieces of pepperoni. Each bite tasted like pure perfection.

To top it off, I enjoyed some of Greek’s Pizzeria’s famous garlic knots. They were soft but crunchy on the outside and full of flavor on the inside. They were hands down some of the best garlic knots I’ve ever had!

Overall, Greek’s Pizzeria is a top class pizza establishment that definitely lives up to its name as having some of the best pizza in West Lafayette!

If you’re willing to go an extra 43 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Kokomo!

#7 Monical’s Pizza of West Lafayette

The traditional round pizzas are the highlight of the menu and they don’t disappoint. Thin crusts, rich tomato sauce and a generous amount of cheese make these pies stand out from anything else I’ve ever had. The toppings are fresh and flavorful, and even their veggie options have a great taste to them.

In addition to the classic pizzas, Monical’s also offers a variety of specialty pizzas that use an array of ingredients not found on your typical pizza menu. The Hawaiian Chicken Pizza is as delicious as any pizza I’ve ever eaten, with subtle sweetness from the pineapple balanced perfectly against savory bacon and chicken.

The atmosphere at Monical’s is also great. With its cozy booth seating, light music in the background, and friendly staff always ready to provide assistance, it’s easy to see why so many people come here for dinner. Plus, their prices are reasonable for such high-quality food!

Overall, I’m confident in saying that Monical’s Pizza of West Lafayette serves some of the best pizza around – if you’re looking for great pizza that won’t break your wallet, this is definitely a spot worth visiting!

#8 Arni’s Columbian Park

I was extremely impressed by the variety of menu items they offer. Not only do they have a standard pizza selection, but they also have a kid’s menu and desserts. It’s great to be able to bring my family along with me and still get something enjoyable for everybody.

The atmosphere at Arni’s is perfect for a tourist spot. The decor is fun and inviting, and I was immediately welcomed by the friendly staff.

The pizza itself was outstanding! The crust had the perfect amount of crunch, and the toppings all tasted very fresh. It definitely lived up to its reputation as some of the best pizza in West Lafayette.

The only downside I could find is that they don’t offer delivery; so if you’re feeling lazy, you’ll need to go pick your food up yourself! Other than that minor annoyance though, I’d highly recommend this place for anyone looking for delicious pizza.

#9 Parkway Pizza & Subs

When I arrived at the restaurant, it was clear that their pizzeria was well-loved – the walls were crowded with pictures of smiling customers and reviews from locals.

The atmosphere was inviting and cozy, but most importantly, the pizza was incredible. The crust was perfectly crispy yet still thick enough to bring out all of the flavors in every bite. The combination of tomato sauce and cheese had a remarkable depth of flavor, surely coming from all of the fresh ingredients they use!

I also tried a few of their subs, and they were just as amazing as the pizza. I especially liked the meatball sub – stuffed with gooey cheese and tangy sauce, it’s definitely something I could see myself eating again and again!

Overall, I would absolutely recommend Parkway Pizza & Subs to any pizza lover out there looking for an unforgettable meal. This is certainly one restaurant you won’t want to miss when you’re in West Lafayette!

#10 Pizza Hut

I’ve been to some amazing pizza places, but I have to say that Pizza Hut really knocked it out of the park.

The pizza was cooked to perfection and had a light, crispy crust. The cheese was gooey and flavorful, and the toppings were fresh and savory. But what really set Pizza Hut apart from other pizza places was its unique sauces. They had a range of flavors that really brought out the taste of the pizza – from sweet and savory to spicy and tangy.

The atmosphere at Pizza Hut is also top-notch. They have a comfortable, inviting ambiance that makes it easy to relax and enjoy your food. The staff are all friendly and knowledgeable about their menu items, so making an informed decision is never hard.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in West Lafayette then you need look no further than Pizza Hut! I highly recommend checking them out for your next pizza night – you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Mad Mushroom

The first thing that struck me about this restaurant was the atmosphere. Mad Mushroom has a fun, laid-back vibe and the walls are decorated with cool murals. The staff was friendly and accommodating, which is always a plus!

When it came to the pizza itself, Mad Mushroom definitely delivered. Their dough is just thick enough to hold all of their delicious toppings without getting soggy, and their wood-fired oven gives each pie an authentic flavor. What’s more, they offer a variety of specialty pizzas that you won’t find anywhere else in town.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in West Lafayette (or maybe even the world), then I highly recommend heading over to Mad Mushroom. You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 45 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Munster!

#12 HotBox Pizza

From the moment you walk in, you can smell the delicious aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, greeting each and every customer with a warm smile. Plus, they have this fun game called ‘HotBox Challenge’ which rewards customers who can eat an entire large pizza in one sitting!

When it comes to the food itself, HotBox Pizza really delivers. The crust is perfectly thin and crunchy while still being light and fluffy on the inside. It’s not overly greasy either which is a huge plus in my book. They then pile on generous helpings of their signature sauces and cheese before topping it all off with your choice of fresh ingredients. The flavor combinations are out of this world!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in West Lafayette, look no further than HotBox Pizza. Superb taste, friendly staff, and a great atmosphere make this place hard to beat!